Skeptical criticism on Buddhist beliefs and observances.

I believe that we should be as skeptical of philosophies as we are of religions.

My point in the philosophical Buddhism / religious Buddhism distinction was merely to point out that there are Buddhists who are not religious.

Since religions involve belief in a supernatural, they are easy to deal with as a group - they are not correct.

Philosophies need to be analyzed individually.
 
"Buddhism is a scientific religion" -- allegedly.

I entered this phrase "scientific religion" +Buddhism" into the search engine of Google, and it returned the following report (please try the same search with Google):
Web Results 1 - 100 of about 644 for "scientific religion" +buddhism. (0.64 seconds)

[First find in the listing]
Buddhism
dd15 Buddhism very tempting. The only scientific religion as highly developed with respect to the mental world as is our science with respect to the ...
www.mith.demon.co.uk/Buddhism.htm - 40k - Cached - Similar pages
............
............
............

​

Here is what I read from just the first find of Google:
(Bolding by Yrreg)

dd15 Buddhism very tempting. The only scientific religion as highly developed with respect to the mental world as is our science with respect to the physical. Our science cannot refute, it fits human aspiration and purpose in a way which makes almost any western developed philosophy of life look hopelessly primitive.

--------------

ff55& Excellence of Buddhism, the most brilliantly conceived of religions. Buddhist culture descending magnificently from superb philosophical insights, an aristocratic religion and therefore capable of expressing the deepest philosophical insights. Our esoteric tradition lost in the 18th Century...... Alan Bennett should be honoured. B logical extension of the love of nature and art...in our civilisation the only equivalent of B is esoteric & neoplatonic Christianity, founded on nothing so rational....religious equivalent of modern science.

(From the blog-site of John Stewart Moore. born 1948. BA hons in Philosophy from King's College London, 1969, lives Islington in north London, UK. 2 sons, Simon, born 1969, and Alistair, born 1978.)

http://www.mith.demon.co.uk/Buddhism.htm

The author waxes eloquent in praise of Buddhism, not mindful of the distinction between beliefs and facts, speculation and information, dwelling in beliefs-speculations but on a psychology of feeling that the beliefs are facts.


Yrreg
 
As far as I can see, the one making the claim is not a Buddhist, but someone with a degree in philosophy.

How you can claim that Buddhists say their religion is scientific just because some English bloke is of that opinion is beyond me.
 
Looking for card-carrying Buddhists?

Dear good friend and brother, Ryokan, let's not be disingenuous, what I am referring to are Buddhist enthusiasts, not certifiable Buddhists who might have documentary evidence of their Buddhist affiliation or have gone through some kind of ordination or initiation or public profession of an auto de fe.

Yrreg said:
#106 Why do I suspect that Buddhism is a pseudoscience? Because from my reading about Buddhism from Buddhist enthusiasts I have come across their assertion that Buddhism is a scientific religion. What is the experience of others who read accounts of Buddhism published in the web by Buddhist enthusiasts? have you come across such an assertion?

-----------

I can't find anything scientific in Buddhism, understanding scientific as referring to science in 2005. So, I think Buddhist enthusiasts who tell us that Buddhism is a scientific religion is making of Buddhism a pseudoscience.

-----------

Of course Buddhists here might ask me to produce instances in the web, of such an assertion that Buddhism is a scientific religion from Buddhist enthusiasts; in which event I have to back off.

If they have never come across such an assertion, and I am not inclined to invest time and labor to look up such instances in the web; then I will just take back that statement that I encountered such an assertion in my reading about Buddhism in the web from Buddhist enthusiasts.

-------------

#113 I said that in my reading of Buddhism from Buddhist enthusiasts in the web I have the impression among other impressions, that they or some of them make the assertion that Buddhism is a scientific religion.

-------------

What is the third kind of Buddhists? What about the scientific Buddhists, which I seem to meet in my reading in the web of writings from Buddhist enthusiasts extolling the scientific grounds of Buddhism.

About who are Buddhists in your book, what are the credentials for one to call oneself a Buddhist?

You label yourself a Resident Buddhist here in JREF Forum, are you representing people whom you recognize to be Buddhists like yourself.

I know from the start that 'Resident Buddhist' is just a gimmick from you, because JREF cannot possibly house a resident Buddhist in the manner that I have come across resident philosopher in a prison establishment and resident writer in a public library; these are people with an office in the respective institutions.

But there might be readers who think that you are a resident Buddhist designated as such by the owners/managers of JREF Forum. It seems like the title of moderator of administrator after the names of users who do perform the task of moderator and administrator in a message board.

Anyway, may I suggest that such a label should be changed into something less misleading, like for example, Buddhist Enthusiast.

Just the same, tell me what credentials you hold and from what Buddhist groups entitling you to call yourself a Buddhist, and even sport the title even though only a gimmick, Resident Buddhist here in JREF Forum.


Shall we have a Buddhist hahaha together, as certainly Buddha himself would approve of most heartily, in his role as the fat Buddha with kids crawling all over him.

Yrreg
 
Dear good friend and brother, Ryokan, let's not be disingenuous, what I am referring to are Buddhist enthusiasts, not certifiable Buddhists who might have documentary evidence of their Buddhist affiliation or have gone through some kind of ordination or initiation or public profession of an auto de fe.

But I can't speak for those people.



About who are Buddhists in your book, what are the credentials for one to call oneself a Buddhist?

If you call youself a Buddhist, chances are you are one.

You label yourself a Resident Buddhist here in JREF Forum, are you representing people whom you recognize to be Buddhists like yourself.

I am a member of several Buddhist organizations, but represent only myself.

I know from the start that 'Resident Buddhist' is just a gimmick from you, because JREF cannot possibly house a resident Buddhist in the manner that I have come across resident philosopher in a prison establishment and resident writer in a public library; these are people with an office in the respective institutions.

But there might be readers who think that you are a resident Buddhist designated as such by the owners/managers of JREF Forum. It seems like the title of moderator of administrator after the names of users who do perform the task of moderator and administrator in a message board.

The JREF forum allows you to set whatever custom title you want (within reason). I thought Resident Buddhist would be a fun title. I'm sorry if you, or anyone else, got confused.

Now I sure hope they don't go around believing fowlsound is really a titanium superhero! Or that geni really is an anti-homeopathy illuminati member!

Btw, the 'I knew from the start' is a lie.

Anyway, may I suggest that such a label should be changed into something less misleading, like for example, Buddhist Enthusiast.

Not a bad idea, really. I'll think about it.

Just the same, tell me what credentials you hold and from what Buddhist groups entitling you to call yourself a Buddhist, and even sport the title even though only a gimmick, Resident Buddhist here in JREF Forum.

By what credentials I call myself a Buddhist? Why, I'm a follower of the middle path shown to us by Siddharta Gautama.

I will give out my 'serious' credentials if you do the same. Who is Yrreg?

Shall we have a Buddhist hahaha together, as certainly Buddha himself would approve of most heartily, in his role as the fat Buddha with kids crawling all over him.

Yrreg

Hotei is not Siddhartha Gautama, known as the Buddha. Gautama Buddha is always depicted as rather slim.

But that's okay, it's a very common mistake.
 
Let's do an experimen, ala skeptics.

I am excited with this idea.

I will write after this post, to the owners/managers of the JREF Forum, asking them to remove or to require you to sport another label less misleading to readers of the JREF Forum, namely, your self-conferred title of 'Resident Buddhist'.

Then we will sit back and see what happens.


Yrreg
 
There, the experiment has been launched, in the best tradition of skepticism.

This is the best way to find out how things will turn out, do an experiment.

Yrrey said:
I am Yrreg but using the report bad post button of Resident Buddhist. And this is my report or request:

Yrreg said:
I am excited with this idea.

I will write after this post, to the owners/managers of the JREF Forum, asking them to remove or to require you to sport another label less misleading to readers of the JREF Forum, namely, your self-conferred title of 'Resident Buddhist'.

Then we will sit back and see what happens.


Yrreg

So, what is the reaction of the owners/managers of this board?


Yrreg


So, let's sit back and wait for the results.

Yrreg
 
Since all custom user titles have to be put in place by a mod, they are, in effect, approved by the mod team (more specifically, Upchurch). I do not see that "Resident Buddhist" is in any way misleading. The definition of resident is:

Dwelling in a particular place; residing

So a Resident Buddhist is merely a Buddhist dwelling in a particular place. In this case, Ryokan is "dwelling" in the JREF.
 
Yrreg said:
But there might be readers who think that you are a resident Buddhist designated as such by the owners/managers of JREF Forum. It seems like the title of moderator of administrator after the names of users who do perform the task of moderator and administrator in a message board.
My title used to be "Resident Greek." No one appeared to think that I was the Official JREF Greek Person.

[pmod=Paul C. Anagnostopoulos]Ryokan's title "Resident Buddhist" is perfectly fine.[/pmod]
 
Dear good friend and brother, Ryokan, let's not be disingenuous, what I am referring to are Buddhist enthusiasts, not certifiable Buddhists who might have documentary evidence of their Buddhist affiliation or have gone through some kind of ordination or initiation or public profession of an auto de fe.

As I pointed out earlier:

Of course, at this point, we'll usually get into a NARB phenomenon ("Not A Real Buddhist").

I told you so.
 
yrreg - You're getting to be quite unpleasant.

Who are you to say that a Buddhist needs to be certified as a Buddhist or belong to some Buddhist organizations that you recognize as official?

Yech. How transparently authoritarian can you be?

Ryokan speaks for himself, as all of us do. He has never claimed otherwise. I like him.

The labels are for fun. Ryokan's is a good one and appropriate. He has the best claim to it. You are not a contender.

Please lay off the nastiness and the insults and either say something of substance or be light and airy, offering something interesting or amusing or both.
 
I am excited with this idea.

I will write after this post, to the owners/managers of the JREF Forum, asking them to remove or to require you to sport another label less misleading to readers of the JREF Forum, namely, your self-conferred title of 'Resident Buddhist'.

Then we will sit back and see what happens.


Yrreg


Ah, the man with the mission, he can't prove his unfounded assertions, so he switches attacks, can't come up with his own ideas, so he spouts other's silly ones.

You look and act like a fundamentalist.

There are plenty of people who claim to be buddhists that are full of mistaken beliefs, there are plenty of sceptics who are full of mistaken beliefs.

You are now again engaging in 'words mean only what I say they mean'.

Are you going to ask Ed to change his title.
 
This is the best way to find out how things will turn out, do an experiment.




So, let's sit back and wait for the results.

Yrreg
Trooooooooooooooooll, awoo, I saw a werewolve drinking a pina colada at Trader Vics, his hair was perfect.
 
Last edited:
yrreg - You're getting to be quite unpleasant.

Who are you to say that a Buddhist needs to be certified as a Buddhist or belong to some Buddhist organizations that you recognize as official?

Yech. How transparently authoritarian can you be?

Ryokan speaks for himself, as all of us do. He has never claimed otherwise. I like him.

The labels are for fun. Ryokan's is a good one and appropriate. He has the best claim to it. You are not a contender.

Please lay off the nastiness and the insults and either say something of substance or be light and airy, offering something interesting or amusing or both.


: looking down and scuffing the toe of my shoe:

Well, I kinda started it.
 
yrreg - You're getting to be quite unpleasant.

Who are you to say that a Buddhist needs to be certified as a Buddhist or belong to some Buddhist organizations that you recognize as official?

Yech. How transparently authoritarian can you be?

It's too bad there isn't a point-missing competition here. If there were, I'd nominate this post.
 
One skeptic critical of Buddhism.

Yesterday, 09:53 AM #130 epepke Illuminator

--------------

Join Date: Oct 2003 Posts: 4,592

Originally Posted by yrreg :
Dear good friend and brother, Ryokan, let's not be disingenuous, what I am referring to are Buddhist enthusiasts, not certifiable Buddhists who might have documentary evidence of their Buddhist affiliation or have gone through some kind of ordination or initiation or public profession of an auto de fe.​


As I pointed out earlier:

Of course, at this point, we'll usually get into a NARB phenomenon ("Not A Real Buddhist").

I told you so.


[Epepke]*

__________________

"It probably came from a sticky dark planet far, far away."
- Godzilla versus Hedora​

Dear Epepke, thanks; you are the only skeptic here critical of Buddhism; at least I have not seen others here with your kind of critical approach, but I still have to read all the posts here very carefully and see whether another one or two entertain the same kind of rigorous skepticism you show here in re Buddhism.

What do you say? I think there is a radical fault in the attitude of our Buddhist brethren here, namely, they do not seem to be acquainted with the distinction between fiction and fact.

I am trying to distill the facts from the fictions in Buddhism but they are to all appearances getting them all mixed up.

Addressing skeptics here who are not Buddhists, please join in and also give me some critical assessment of Buddhism. There is no better way to get to know a religion than to do a skeptical criticism of it and read the explanations, defenses, emotional reactions from the religion's adherents.

Ryokan here is a softspoken and mild Buddhist, but he has shall we call them, fans who tend to see any critical regards as insults to their in effect, master.

--------------

*Epepke, is that some Greek word, a proper name derived from some noun or verb or adjective? I must look up the word.

I thought I might as well enter this phrase in Google, define epepke, and this is what I read for its first find. Well, what a catch, glad to meet you here, Epepke.

Results 1 - 68 of about 681 for define epepke. (0.79 seconds)

epepke


User:Epepke - SkepticWiki

Definition. epepke is a contributor to the SkepticWiki. [edit]. Contributions.

epepke has written or contributed to, amongst others: ...
www.skepticwiki.org/wiki/index.php/User:Epepke - 10k - Cached - Similar pages

---------------

User:Epepke
From SkepticWiki
[edit]
Definition
epepke is a contributor to the SkepticWiki
[edit]
Contributions
epepke has written or contributed to, amongst others:
* SkepticWiki:Community Portal
* Talk:People(index)
* Talk:Main Page
* Talk:Relativity (Misconceptions)
* Talk:Second Law of Thermodynamics
* Theory of Evolution
* Talk:Osteopathy
* Talk:Theory of Evolution
* Guns, Germs, and Steel
* Talk:Guns, Germs, and Steel
* Talk:Thermodynamics
* Talk:Sympathetic Magic
* Humpty Dumpty
* Talk:Herbal medicine
* Talk:"Hitler was an Atheist"
​

Just a moment, I will see what the word, epepke, means.

There seems to be a lot of hits from Google on epepke, but I have to stop now. Here is something I found, a line from JREF Forum turned up by Google:

I'd love to work in India, but it doesn't seem they're hiring the likes of me. – Epepke, 07-25-2005 05:03 AM

Anyway, tell me, Epepke, what is the meaning of your label, epepke? And are you, Epepke, a member of any philosophical or religious system like one named after its founder, say, Buddhism? or you are a hard-core skeptic without any professed loyalty to any great mentor of the past or present?
 
Dear Epepke, thanks; you are the only skeptic here critical of Buddhism; at least I have not seen others here with your kind of critical approach, but I still have to read all the posts here very carefully and see whether another one or two entertain the same kind of rigorous skepticism you show here in re Buddhism.

I do not know that I am the only skeptic who is skeptical of Buddhism. I seem to be one of the most vocal on this thread, and I've tussled with Buddhists a number of times on other fora.

What do you say? I think there is a radical fault in the attitude of our Buddhist brethren here, namely, they do not seem to be acquainted with the distinction between fiction and fact.

What I have seen so far consists of a lot of apologia similar to what I have seen from other ists, and a lot of stuff that has a quality that I do not yet have a name for. Namely, that inasmuch as it is falsifiable it is trite, and inasmuch as it is interesting it is unfalsifiable.

*Epepke, is that some Greek word, a proper name derived from some noun or verb or adjective? I must look up the word.

Nothing so interesting as that, I'm afraid. It is my name as listed in scientific publications, E. Pepke. I come from a day when people used their real names, and I still do.

There seems to be a lot of hits from Google on epepke, but I have to stop now.

I'm sure there are. I have been contributing to online fora since 1976, and I'm sure that everything that I have contributed since 1985 or so is on a disk at Google somewhere. It's a major satisfaction in life that I cost Google real money.

I've been threatened with death a few times, but I don't worry about it, because I can shoot the salivary glands off of a fruit fly at quite a long distance.

Anyway, tell me, Epepke, what is the meaning of your label, epepke? And are you, Epepke, a member of any philosophical or religious system like one named after its founder, say, Buddhism? or you are a hard-core skeptic without any professed loyalty to any great mentor of the past or present?

Well, I like Nietzsche, and I've called myself a Nietzschean Immoralist, but that was tongue-in-cheek and in reference to specific points. But, no, although I find many people interesting, I'm not loyal to any mentor, religious, philosophical, or scientific figure.

Although I thank you for this exercise in vanity, perhaps we could get back to the subject at hand.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom