Skeptical criticism on Buddhist beliefs and observances.

So, who or what is it that is facing the computer screen and typing on the keyboard when Ryokan is writing a message to post in this thread with the use of computer equipment?
The computer is creating the characters. It's almost like the computer is an extension of Ryokan's body. In fact, it's hard to tell where Ryokan stops and his computer begins. We draw distinctions for convenience, so that when Ryokan dies, we don't accidentally bury his computer, but is it really important?
 
I like to meet with skeptics here who can tell me how Buddhist doctrines like rebirths and Nirvana cannot stand up to skeptical criticism.

And also the usefulness of meditation, specially that of the Zen school.

yrreg
When I first read this I thought, this sounds like Hinduism, not Buddhism. After reading a bit about Buddhism I remember some from religion class and reincarnation and Nirvana came up in Hinduism.
 
First task of criticism on Buddhism: what or who is Ryokan?

I still have not read any answer to my question to Ryokan, What or who is Ryokan in Buddhism; for he is not a self, since for him in his Buddhism the self means the soul and the soul does not exist in his Buddhism.

Of course to the question, Who is Ryokan? Ryokan might answer that he is one registered user of this JREF forum who calls himself Ryokan (even though self does not exist for him in Buddhism), and describes himself as a Resident Buddhist.

So, Ryokan as regards the who in terms of identity is a registered user of JREF forum who sports the name of Ryokan with the description of Resident Buddhist.

But what is Ryokan aside from the what of being a registered user of this JREF forum?

Is he is a human or a robot? or what? and does he exist in whatever kind of being he is to the question of what?


Here are the lines from Ryokan's messages so far, having the mentions of self and soul. See if you can get a clear idea of what Ryokan is when he is not a self since self means the soul for Ryokan, and the soul does not exist for Ryokan in his kind of Buddhism.

Ryokan said:
No problem, the Buddhists agree with you! Buddhists do not even believe in a soul, so what is there to be reborn? #4

Note that some Buddhist denominations, like Tibetan Buddhism, believe in rebirth of the self, and other denominations, like Pure Land, believe in a utopian afterlife. 'Orthodox' Buddhism, however, preaches that there is no self/soul, and that there is no way to know what happens to you after death. #4

Meditation without the Dharma does nothing except relax you and decrease stress (which is not a bad thing in and of itself). It's not a 'gateway' to other dimensions, and crystals won't help at all. #4

ETA : The reason why the word 'self' is most commonly used in Buddhism is because it does not have the concept of a 'soul', and therefore haven't needed a specialized word for it. #9

Resident Buddhist simply means that I'm this forum's resident Buddhist, although highly unofficial. It's not a denomination, just a forum title and nickname I've given myself. It has no meaning at all, please ignore it. #10

You learn nothing if you're not sceptical. Even the Buddha himself told us to be sceptical about all things, even to approach Buddhism with sceptical eyes! #10

Not according to the Buddha. There is no self that is reborn. #10

By self I mean soul. Does that make it clearer? #11

ETA : The reason why the word 'self' is most commonly used in Buddhism is because it does not have the concept of a 'soul', and therefore haven't needed a specialized word for it. #9

By self I mean soul. Does that make it clearer? #11



I think that one of the canons of skeptical criticism is the insistence on consistency and clarity in the report of an idea, notion, event, phenomenon.

So, in place of self which being the soul for Ryokan does not exist for him, but which he still uses routinely, perhaps he should tell us if he has another notion and term for the self, which is not what we non-Buddhists understand to be the self and we use the word routinely without intricate qualifications and reservations.

yrreg
 
There is no Ryokan.

There is a collection of objects, processes and attributes that appears to be capable of acting autonomously. That collection of "things", acting via a common, collective, coordinated process is able to apply labels to things in order to facilitate communication with other apparently autonomous collections of "things" with similar collective processes. The label that collective process applies to itself (as a collective) is "Ryokan".

Consider a car. A car is made from a collection of parts, wheels, springs, cogs, gears etc. If I take a sledgehammer and break "car" into pieces, I end up with a pile of wheels, springs, cogs, gears etc. But where is "car"? Why did "car" cease to exist the moment it was broken apart?

We can ask ourselves, is there some independent, autonomous "thing", which when separated from the above wheels, springs etc., constitutes "car"? The answer is no. The label "car" is simply a label we apply to a collection of things that are arranged (and/or act) in some specific configuration with some specific coordination.

In the same way if I were to separate the individual parts, processes etc., that constitute the thing called "Ryokan", then where is Ryokan? In other words is there some independent, autonomous, abiding entity called "Ryokan" which is distinct from the collection of parts we are accustomed to calling Ryokan? And like the car, the answer for a Buddhist is no. There is no independent, autonomous, abiding entity called "Ryokan" which is distinct from the collective action of a series of parts. Therefore "Ryokan" has no "thing" which can be called "self" or "soul".

The idea of "self" or "soul" is merely a convenient fiction of language that facilitates reference to a collection of processes. There is no seperate "thing" which can be identified as "self" or "soul".

With regard to "rebirth" or "reincarnation", there is no thing which passes from body to body or life to life, therefore there is no-thing which is "reborn" or which "reincarnates". However, the collective actions of the thing we call "Ryokan" has an impact on the world around it, and subsequently the world itself has influence on a new collective which is "born". In that sense it is reasonable to consider that certain attributes or effects of the thing we used to call "Ryokan", may possibly condition similar effects or attributes in some future collective by indirect influence. That is what Buddhists refer to as "rebirth" or "reincarnation".

What is "Nirvana"? Nirvana is a state in which the collection of parts is able to act (as it always does) in a collective, coordinated fashion, but without the self-referential conviction that they have a "self" or "being" or "consciousness" or an "I". In other words the parts are simply free to exist and to act without invoking certain secondary processes i.e. ego, that arise from a form of self-referential confusion.

The ultimate goal of meditation for a Buddhist is to achieve the latter state. For the collective to enter into a state in which the self-reference does not arise, a state in which there is no idea of "I", "me", "self", "soul" or anything else. There is simply action and reaction.

Meditation therefore is aimed specifically at stopping certain processes (such as self-referential thought).

The benefit of such a state is that when the collective ceases to reference itself as an autonomous, abiding, separable, entity, then it is no longer subject to certain disturbances which naturally inflict themselves on such an entity. For example, there is no suffering because there is no-thing that "suffers". There is no fear because there no-thing that fears. There can be pain, but there is no-thing which suffers the pain. There can be joy, but there is no-thing that feels joy. There is no hesitation because there is no-thing which hesitates. And so on...
 
I still have not read any answer to my question to Ryokan, What or who is Ryokan in Buddhism; for he is not a self, since for him in his Buddhism the self means the soul and the soul does not exist in his Buddhism.

Correct! Well, only partially correct. The part after the semicolon is correct. The first part is incorrect, since you obviously must have read the answer in order to answer the question correctly in the second part.

That is the beginning of wisdom. Meditate on this, and more wisdom will come.
 
Self is no soul, but what about a person?

In other words, Ryokan is not a self as self is understood to be soul, for there is no soul, but he is a collection of things; can Ryokan I presume calls this collection then a person? He is a person, if not a self?

Or may I inquire if there is in Buddhism a notion equivalent or very close to the concept of person as person is understood in law, business, medicine, education, and in all fields of human endeavors and interactions and relationships?

yrreg
 
In other words, Ryokan is not a self as self is understood to be soul, for there is no soul


You can not say "there is no self because the self is the soul, and there is no soul". That's a logical fallacy, and it also suggests that if there is no such thing as a soul, then there is no self, which is not the argument at all.
 
In other words, Ryokan is not a self as self is understood to be soul, for there is no soul, but he is a collection of things; can Ryokan I presume calls this collection then a person? He is a person, if not a self?

Or may I inquire if there is in Buddhism a notion equivalent or very close to the concept of person as person is understood in law, business, medicine, education, and in all fields of human endeavors and interactions and relationships?

yrreg
Yes, but all you're doing is substituting one label for another.

If you put together a certain collection of wheels, gears, cogs, metal etc., in a certain fashion, you can call that collection or arrangement of things, "car".

Similarly, if you take a certain collection of squidgy biological bits, chemicals, water and electrical potentials, and arrange them in a certain fashion you get what might be called, "person" or "human being".

But that "person" or "human being" has running within it certain processes that are (collectively) capable of perception/cognition and language, those processes can assign labels to things. So this overall collection of processes assigns to itself (collectively) also labels such as "self", "soul", "person", "human being" or even "Ryokan". Those processes are just simple chemical reactions and electrical functions, nothing special.

There is little distinction between any of these labels, it's pointless to try to define any one of those labels in terms of any other one, so it's meaningless to say something like "self" is "soul" or "soul" is "person" because logically that's the same as saying "A is A" and "B is B". What is the meaning of "A is A"?

Now, for the purposes of common reference we can assign different labels to different aspects of the total collection of parts and processes. We can call the whole thing "Ryokan". We can call the overall physical hardware (sans processes), "the body", we can call the result or output of the cognitive processes (ignoring the hardware), "mind" or "consciousness" or things like that. But none of these labels alter the reality of what is actually what. We still have just a collection of chemicals etc. In other words, the distinctions between these things are purely artificial and conceptual, they are conventions of language.

As a matter of convenience of course, Buddhists recognise the concept of "person". But more importantly, they are (ideally) always conscious that it is just a concept - that there is no thing which can be somehow considered independent of its constituent parts which we could legitimately call "person". In other words, Buddhists recognise labels for what they are and don't assign them any metaphysical significance (i.e. they don't believe that there is some mysterious extra element which one could call an immortal soul).

So Buddhists in general tend to be pragmatic. They use labels the same as anyone else does. But they don't necessarily accept metaphysical meanings that most people tend to associate with those labels.

But even Buddhists have problems trying to verbalise these concepts, particularly in modern western languages which have implied baggage attached to certain labels like "soul". And also there is the problem that certain terms such as "I" are self-referential and tend to cause confusion when you try to apply combinatorial logic to them (they are sequential, not combinatorial). That's why I'm making an effort to try to be precise, take what I say as literal with no implications beyond what I've said.

Buddhists often say things like "self is an illusion" - what they mean is that there is no metaphysical entity separate from the electrochemical "wetware" that makes up what we call a "human being". So strictly speaking, the idea of self as being something independent or special or transcendent or metaphysical is an illusion. That doesn't mean we can't use the label "self" as, purely a label though.
 
You can not say "there is no self because the self is the soul, and there is no soul". That's a logical fallacy, and it also suggests that if there is no such thing as a soul, then there is no self, which is not the argument at all.
Actually, it isn't really a fallacy (although it's pretty meaningless I agree) and I am precisely suggesting that that there is no self - and there's no soul either - that actually is my argument.

It may not be anyone else's argument of course, but it is mine! :D
 
I like to be ascertained, dear Ryokan, about the presence of yourself as you write a message to post in this thread before the computer monitor screen and as you type on your keyboard.

When you engage in that activity are you present?

Is that you that is present the self, as in yourself?

Now, I keep reading from you that the self does not exist, there is no self.

Do you mean there is no physical, biological, and personal self that is Ryokan who sits before a computer screen, and types on the keyboard to write messages to post in this thread?
There are many fine text upon buddhism as well as websites, the concept that the buddha taught that there is no self has many aspects.
Historical: the buddha was trained as an disciple of many of the schools current in India at the time, and atman is crucial to many of the schools. His teachings are directly opposed to the concepts of atman and karma as taught at the time.
The buddha was to my mind a vary rational and observant person who thought long and hard upon the nature of suffering and the self. His teaching (dharma, although dharma has other meanings) is an oral tradition with many repitions and clarifications. Essentialy though he taught that all the things that comprise the self are transitroy in nature and subject to change, his insight was that the human condition is comprsied of five 'heaps', they are the body, thoughts, emotions, habits and sensations. If we examine all of human life we can agree or disagree that all human life is comprised of these things.
The body is transitory and changes, a child becomes an adult and then elderly thereby demonstrating change. Thoughts are ephemeral and transitory, they always change, emotions are reactive and transitory and they always change, habits are enduring and transitory and they change, sensations are temorary and limited and they change.
All things that we might call the self are subject to change, where then is the self to reside?
I like to apply skeptical criticism on your statement that the self does not exist, there is no self; but first we have to possess together the same notion of the self.

I have just described the self I am talking about and which I know to be also what I am, a self; in your case you tell me there is no self, it does not exist. Then Ryokan what are you?

So, everyone here, shall we all attend to the existence or non-existence of the self as our first task in doing skeptical criticism on Buddhism, focusing for our purpose on that Buddhism as embraced and practiced by Ryokan.
Where does your self reside?
I have this personal observation that skepticism is applied to paranormal phenomena routinely and extensively, but we can also apply what I might call the canons of skeptical criticism to religion and philosophy, to glean what is of logic and science in these two human activities, and what bereft of all logic and science.

yrreg
 
Actually, it isn't really a fallacy

Proving something by restating it with a different word seems like a logical fallacy to me. Especially since he used the word "for".
 
In other words, Ryokan is not a self as self is understood to be soul, for there is no soul, but he is a collection of things; can Ryokan I presume calls this collection then a person? He is a person, if not a self?

Or may I inquire if there is in Buddhism a notion equivalent or very close to the concept of person as person is understood in law, business, medicine, education, and in all fields of human endeavors and interactions and relationships?

yrreg

I hope you realise that there may be a vast difference between concepts and things. There are concepts like numbers that are not things, they are labels applied by humans, so when you ask about a person then the question becomes what are you labeling as the person.

Physicaly a person is comprsied of a body, this body is never the same from momnet to moment, there is connection between the moments, but if you were to define the self solely as the body then it can be said that the body is always changing. You wake up in the morning and urinate and drink water thoughout the day, the water molecules that are the majority of your body and in flux and transition, the body is transitory and always changing the 'you' of one moment is not the 'you' of the next.
So is your bidy the self? If you loose yor memory are you yourself?

What is a person legaly? That is a truely strange and wonderful question, some say an unborn fetus, some say only the borm, some say only people who have lived a certain number of years, some say the ability to posses certain intelectual faculties. The legal definition of a person is changing and transitory.

Stop and think about what you are asking, is not each definition of a person personal, symbolic, interactive and variable. Where is the set definition of person?
 
I still have not read any answer to my question to Ryokan, What or who is Ryokan in Buddhism; for he is not a self, since for him in his Buddhism the self means the soul and the soul does not exist in his Buddhism.
You could learn these things on your own. The buddha taught that his was a mthod to freedom, it is up to each person to consider the teachings and decide if they are true, if you don't find them to be true then, fine!

The question will always come down to this, what do you call the self?
Most people think that because they have a body that the body is the self, but they ignore the fact that the body changes and that the body is different from mement to moment.

Ryokan in buddism is the sound of a chime in the wind. Does that help you? :)

And you don't have to capitalize buddhism it is a philospohy that pretends to be a Religion.
Of course to the question, Who is Ryokan? Ryokan might answer that he is one registered user of this JREF forum who calls himself Ryokan (even though self does not exist for him in Buddhism), and describes himself as a Resident Buddhist.

So, Ryokan as regards the who in terms of identity is a registered user of JREF forum who sports the name of Ryokan with the description of Resident Buddhist.

But what is Ryokan aside from the what of being a registered user of this JREF forum?
These are referenets to a body, thoughts, emotions,habits and sensations. Where is the self, in your faith that a self exists.
Can you prove that a self beyond the transitory exists?
Is he is a human or a robot? or what? and does he exist in whatever kind of being he is to the question of what?
This is foolish, Ryokan has not said that he does not have a body he has not said that he doesn't have thoughts... etc. . If he is a he.
Here are the lines from Ryokan's messages so far, having the mentions of self and soul. See if you can get a clear idea of what Ryokan is when he is not a self since self means the soul for Ryokan, and the soul does not exist for Ryokan in his kind of Buddhism.
Ryokan is a body, thought, emotions, habits and perceptions.
ETA : The reason why the word 'self' is most commonly used in Buddhism is because it does not have the concept of a 'soul', and therefore haven't needed a specialized word for it. #9

By self I mean soul. Does that make it clearer? #11



I think that one of the canons of skeptical criticism is the insistence on consistency and clarity in the report of an idea, notion, event, phenomenon.

So, in place of self which being the soul for Ryokan does not exist for him, but which he still uses routinely, perhaps he should tell us if he has another notion and term for the self, which is not what we non-Buddhists understand to be the self and we use the word routinely without intricate qualifications and reservations.

yrreg

Well yrreg , lets try the other way, why is it important to believe that you have a self?

What does the self mean to you?

Is it real or is it a concept, a rubric under which you stuff a lot of things?

Is it more than a body, thoughts, emotions, habits and perceptions?


I have already said to many things.

For another perspective completely I refer you to this essay:
When the buddha was asked he did not answer!

http://www.accesstoinsight.org/lib/authors/thanissaro/notself2.html
 
Last edited:
At the core of Buddhism is one of the few philosophies that I have any respect for.

I'm not speaking about the religious or superstitious junk that have accumulated around the various forms of Buddhism - that is woo and should be thrown away.

But the garden in the garden - the core of Buddhism - is worth becoming acquainted with.
 
What's the difference between self and soul, in the context of reincarnation?


In the teachings of the buddha, there is no self there is no soul and there is no reicarnation.

Tich Naht Hahn teaches that buddhist karma is merely the consequences of thoughts and actions, some thoughts lead to suffering, some actions lead to suffering. Some thoughts and actions do not.
 
Proving something by restating it with a different word seems like a logical fallacy to me. Especially since he used the word "for".
Well, if he was trying to use it as a proof I would agree - I didn't believe he was though. I simply interpreted it differently. I get the impression that he is not a native English speaker so I wasn't being too strict on his precise use of English. I'm not trying to argue with you, simply clarify, but the reason I thought it wasn't a strictly logical fallacy was that, if I take your version of his statement, "there is no self because the self is the soul, and there is no soul", and translate it into symbolic logic, I get:

Let A = self
Let B = soul

!A =TRUE because A=B AND !B = TRUE

(where ! represents logical NOT). The statement is not logically flawed, it's logically correct. Although it's ultimately meaningless because it's just a restatement of self-evident identities.

So, in principle I agree with you that it doesn't actually get us anywhere, which I why I wrote my last clarification - and of course you may be correct that there's a fallacy if he doesn't follow the distinction between the label and the object(s) that the label refers to. I'm just not sure at this stage whether he does actually make that confusion, let's see where he goes from here...
 
Just an observation to amplify something I mentioned before. The real problem in discussing these things is our language - and our habitual use of it.

The concepts of "self", "I", "me" etc., are self-referential. David's link suggests we should entirely set questions based on such references aside - I agree that would be the best course of action if we constrain ourselves to simply trying to resolve self-referential issues using combinatorial logic - that course of action is automatically doomed to (messy) failure.

However, what most people don't realise is that there are techniques in which you can meaningfully deal with such problems, as long as you identify their true nature. Self-referential logics tend to go into oscillation which means that if you try to resolve them into one single state or another the answer is nonsense. It's analogous to asking whether the swinging pendulum of a clock is swinging left or swinging right. The real answer is that it's doing both, but at any given single instant of time it might be doing just one or the other. So the missing element is time. When you add the element of time into logics you get a different kind of logic which is sequential logic.

The key confusion due to misunderstanding of the sequential nature of certain statements is that what is universally true for the whole system all the time is not necessarily true for each of its constituent elements all the time. But may be true for both the system and the elements at specific moments of time. So the "correct" answer at any moment depends on the actual timing of the observer. Observers with different timings will come up with different answers that appear superficially contradictory - but in the bigger picture they're not.

For example, take the statement: everything I say is a lie. This is a classic self-referential statement. The statement cannot be resolved into one constant state of truth or falsity. If I start by assuming the statement is true, I parse the statement and conclude it's false. On that basis I re-parse the statement from the assumption it's false and conclude that it's true. So it oscillates between true and false each time I parse it. The key element in the process is that each parsing of the statement sequentially follows a previous parsing - in other words it is a process on-going in time. Therefore we can say that the statement has no single value of "truth" for all points in time.

Sequential logic of this type can be useful. It's actually used in computer logic circuits and computer hardware designers will immediately recognise that the above is a linguistic equivalent of a classic flip flop circuit formed by crossing the inputs and outputs of two logic gates.

Unfortunately, it's not so useful in everyday language it just leads to confusion. In the discipline of General Semantics which I find interesting in such contexts, they use the concept of "orders of abstraction". They resolve problems of this type by making a distinction between a thing, an abstraction of a thing and an abstraction of the abstraction (and so on ad-infinitum). They then apply a rule that says that in language you cannot meaningfully equate two things that lie at different orders of abstraction.

Taking the statement, "everything I say is a lie", they observe that it's a composite confusion of different orders of abstraction. The sub-statement, "is a lie" is an abstraction applied to a more fundamental abstraction "everything I say". In other words, what I say and what I say about what I say, are at different orders of abstraction and to equate them is meaningless.

How does this relate to the questions of "self" etc., in Buddhism? Well, any statement I make about "my self" is self-referential in the same way. "Self" is a label or abstraction applied to a collection of "things". What I say about that abstraction is at a different order of abstraction, it's an abstraction of the first abstraction. So anything I say about "my self" is ultimately meaningless, because it is a confusion of two different orders.

Thus far, I've managed to avoid tying myself up in semantic knots in the discussion by referring largely to Ryokan when I have mentioned "self" - because it's not my self I don't get caught up in the self reference. But anyone reading it can do if they try to think about it in terms of their "selves".

The only reason I mention all this is because if anyone is unaware of it, it might help in understanding why Buddhism appears to be very cryptic, why some questions are answered with silence or why some questions are answered with cryptic statements, or why some questions get thrown back at the questioner. These are some of the issues raised by the commentator in David's link.

Personally though, I think we don't need to resort to such measures if we just remain aware of the real nature of the problem and make an effort to avoid getting caught up in it. It can be done but it requires "skillful means" - which is another distinctly Buddhist concept. :D
 
From the world of thinking and talking to the world of being and doing.

So, Buddhists think and talk to the effect that the self or the person does not exist; even if it is a collection of anatomical parts and physiological processes, it does not exist either.

How then would they behave in the world of being and doing?

Here is a parable from one naughty skeptic.

There was once a ruler very hostile to philosophers and religious teachers; he insisted that people who spend time and energy thinking and talking philosophy and religion, should better occupy themselves in useful activities like working in the rice fields, or if nothing else, sweeping the streets, and thereby earning a decent and honorable living.

One day there was famine in the land, the ruler had to ration the grain sparingly to every person in the land, hoping in this way that the grain stock would last beyond the famine.

Now came the Buddhists before him for their ration of grain.

“No, no grain for you because it is reserved for persons only; you deny you exist as persons, so there is no point in giving any to you,” he informed them with a very serious mien.

“What we mean,” the leader of these monks explained to the ruler, “is that we should not be attached to the self or person, because everything is transitory, fleeting, nothing is permanent.”

“In which case,” the ruler told them, “continue practicing detachment from the self or person, and glory in your detachment from this delusional and illusional world of people like us who are selves and persons.

And the ruler continued: “However, since from all appearances you are no different from us, tell you what, you continue in your starvation and see whether you can survive till the rain comes, if and when; and if you are still around, then you can work in the fields for you to earn your share of grain.”


from Pes Oir Amsus


I think one of the most fundamental canon of skeptical criticism is the distinction of the world of being and doing from the world of thinking and talking, namely: the world of being and doing should dictate the world of thinking and talking.

Incidentally, I almost forget, the ruler dismissed the monks with these parting words:

“See if you can engage yourselves in thinking and talking so as to find edible roots and grubs anywhere in the kingdom, that should be a much better way to employ your mind and your tongue.”


yrreg
 
yrreg, I think you and I interpret that story very differently.

“What we mean,” the leader of these monks explained to the ruler, “is that we should not be attached to the self or person, because everything is transitory, fleeting, nothing is permanent.”

Which part of this is untrue, yrreg? What the leader described could be said to be one of the core philosophies of Buddhism. Everything is transitory. Nothing is permanent. From the tiniest lifeform to the great universe.

The monks weren't trying to argue that they didn't exist (as Jack Chick seems to believe Buddhists believe), nor that they didn't need to eat.

All your questions have been answered to great lengths. Yet you keep repeating them.

Did you read the Kalama Sutra yet? Remember, that's the first thing I ever asked you to read. It's all right to be sceptical about Buddhism, and criticism is welcome. But in order for it to be constructive, you will have to do a bit studying to understand the answers you are given.

Actually, you're quite lucky. Reading this thread has been a joy to me, because there are so many people here who have managed to explain the concepts you are asking about, and who have answered much better and clearer than I ever could! Even I have been enlightened (pun intended!) reading through this thread.
 
Lay down these words
Before your mind like rocks.
placed solid, by hands
In choice of place, set
Before the body of the mind
in space and time:
Solidity of bark, leaf, or wall
riprap of things:
Cobble of milky way.
straying planets,
These poems, people,
lost ponies with
Dragging saddles --
and rocky sure-foot trails.
The worlds like an endless
four-dimensional
Game of Go.
ants and pebbles
In the thin loam, each rock a word
a creek-washed stone
Granite: ingrained
with torment of fire and weight
Crystal and sediment linked hot
all change, in thoughts,
As well as things.

-Riprap, by the great Gary Snyder.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom