Skeptical criticism on Buddhist beliefs and observances.

All praise the Nuttybunny!

The mantra is as follows,
Peanuts, lettuce, clover , almonds, may the Nuttybunny fill my belly, may the Nutty bunny gaurd me from harm, may the Nuttybunny give me the winning numbers to the Lotto. Peanuts. lettuce, clover almonds.
 
However, when asking about Buddhism, I get stuff like the following.

Read the 4 noble truths (preferably written by a good writer) and then there is nothing for anyone to explain to you. Everything else is experienced directly and if you asked 10 people to describe the experience of sex, eating a food, going to the bathroom or shopping you would get similar analogies and different ways of attempting to express that which is directly experienced and you would likely find them all inadequate and even confusing if you had never gone shopping, gone to the bathroom, had sex or eaten food.(<-- is that a run on?)

The confusion sets in, I think, when we expect a simple list of 10 commandments, or the kind of thing we find covered in a 'Religions of the World' course and try to make the answers fit in with such a methodolgy. Buddhism, at least to anyone participating in this thread, isn't a religion in that sense.
 
An attitude of know nothing nonchalance.

Originally Posted by Ryokan :
One of my favorite Zen stories is about a man who asks a Zen master what happens to people after they die.

'I have no idea', the master told him.

'What!?', the man explaimed, 'but aren't you supposed to be a Zen master?'

'I am', the master replied, 'but I'm not a dead one.')​


A pure Zen answer. Nice. What else is there to discuss about?

Buddhism is like anything people in here are accustomed to discuss about.

What is the point of the Zen story?

The Zen master is telling the inquirer that without experience one can't answer his question, What happens after death? And he has to be dead first to experience what happens to himself after his death; but since he is not dead he can't answer that question. And therefore the inquirer is a nincompoop?

There is the attitude here of the Zen master which I find unacceptable, evading the real question of the inquirer by diversion to the almost impossibility of finding an answer to his question -- because the Zen master is just too lazy to think and hypothesize on the one hand, and on the other has bathed himself in his so self-complacent idea of his right posture, namely, nonchalance.

The question of the inquirer might be very difficult to answer from the part of the Zen master prior to his death, and to all appearances impossible to answer upon his death.

But the attitude of the Zen master should he be in today's world and professing to be intelligent, learned, and well-exposed to the issues and findings of today's world, is unworthy of himself as described, namely: "intelligent, learned, and well-exposed to the issues and findings of today's world."

It is the know nothing and no curiosity nonchalance attitude, which I submit is totally inimical to skeptical criticism.

If I were a Zen master -- which of course I consider it to be a waste of time and labor and a disaster of a lifestyle and philosophy of life and the world, I would tell the inquirer the following:

Well, I am not a Zen master, but if I were one with an enlightened mind and heart, meaning not a purist type but some kind of a compromised one, I will tell you what: What you mean, sir, is what is my opinion about what happens after death to me and to you; by opinion I think you are more interested in a wish, a wish for an answer that is comforting to all of us who are destined to death.

Okay, to make a big picture but in a short statement: I wish I would continue to exist in a conscious kind of existence and be able to communicate with people on the life side of the grave. That is my answer to your desire for an opinion or a wish for an answer.

Now, here is what I think an experiment we can both do together: in view of whoever die first, make some arrangement between us prior to death whereby we can still communicate with certainty, that the one dead and the one alive can exchange information; then we can get to know what happens after the death at least of either of us two.​


That is why I am of the very strong opinion (wish) that people would not take all these Zen and Buddhist materials so seriously as to be devotees, but only insofar as archaeological interests.


Yrreg
 
Read the 4 noble truths (preferably written by a good writer) and then there is nothing for anyone to explain to you.

Yeah, your or someone else said. And then, you or someone says "that's not what the Buddha meant by 'happiness' or 'awake'" or some such crap.

Everything else is experienced directly and if you asked 10 people to describe the experience of sex, eating a food, going to the bathroom or shopping you would get similar analogies and different ways of attempting to express that which is directly experienced and you would likely find them all inadequate and even confusing if you had never gone shopping, gone to the bathroom, had sex or eaten food.(<-- is that a run on?)

The difference is that nobody is ever going to tell me, if I had some good sex, "Ah, you may think that is good sex, but it's not Good Sex(TM) as the Buddha meant it, which can only be achieved by reading and following the Seventeen Really Cool Bromides."

Well, tantrists might say this.
 
There is the attitude here of the Zen master which I find unacceptable, evading the real question of the inquirer

If you don't understand the answer, then this means the answer is not there? There is an incredible profound insight that you completely miss. What is interesting is that that insight is transparent and evident to anybody who has perceived what Buddhism is about! How can that be?

Buddhism is about how you perceive what its called "reality". Its Not at all about "knowledge", in the way you apparently understand it.

You see, words have limits, maybe some Wittgenstein is what you need? Break the logic, transcend the meaning, reach the universe before interpretation.

And even these words are FAR from what Buddhism is about. If it helps your "cause" to diminish it when in reality you simply don't understand it, you are in your right. Please, continue to doubt, and to be "skeptic". Maybe you will find someday about those language and logical limitations I have tried to explain, and you will finally understand what the Zen Master was saying to his apprentice (using a much simplier and elegant answer than my rude attempt).

Beliefs and concepts can't reach the escence.
 
The difference is that nobody is ever going to tell me, if I had some good sex, "Ah, you may think that is good sex, but it's not Good Sex(TM) as the Buddha meant it, which can only be achieved by reading and following the Seventeen Really Cool Bromides."

I don't understand from where you get this impression. It doesn't matter anything anyone says, including the Buddha. There is an old saying in meditation: "if you see the Buddha, kill it", meaning that nothing is what it is, unless it is what it is. Words and explanations cant reach that far.

Other than that, I think you are right. Nobody has the rights of the "truer truth".
 
This is a telling post. We have to remember that Buddhism is possibly one of the most "human" religions ever. By that I mean it is a human construction, and carries flaws and such that other religions do. But it is also most human without the worship of any god or other such deities.

The thing is, Buddhism has BECOME a deity-worshipping religion for the masses. As a Chinese, I can tell you that it is embedded deeply in many Chinese to pray to Buddha and wish for luck, protection and prosperity. This is a practice that extends itself in China, Hong Kong, Taiwan, Singapore and Thailand. In modern terms it has become really, something like a parallel of Christianity, with the main distinction of modern Christianity being of Chrisitans having a "closer" relationship with god. Also consider how Buddhism in India started with the practice of not eating cows, which were considered sacred (because of their contribution to agriculture and such). When the religion spread to the chinese nations, it changed.

So we might consider "modern" Buddhism to really be quite warped. So let's take a couple of steps back and look at Buddha and his time.. the problem is, we only have recorded text that was written LONG after Buddha's death. I have read that it was one of his disciples, with allegedly superb memory, who was in charge of writing the Sutras. Who knows what degree of accuracy is presented, and this could explain the embellishment of gods and such, who communicated to Buddha from time to time (in reality, they were part of the cultural and religious fabric in that contemporary Indian era). So we know that what we have is an incomplete picture, and we must be skeptical.

In some texts, after Gautama (Buddha) achieved enlightenment, he walked to the nearest town to start spreading his teachings and wisdom. Along the way, he meets a man who asks Gautama who he was. Gautama replied, "I am Buddha." (Remember that in those terms, he meant, "I am enlightened" or "I am the awakened one") The man laughed, and walked right by him. Buddha didn't have any mystical, supernatural power or aura. He was man, like you and I. In fact, his death also led to the splitting of Buddhism into its two main sects; Theravada and Mahayana. This was something that pained him, and the politics within the organization was also a source of trouble.

As such the picture seems to be that Buddha really was human, like you and I. He steps on things and bleeds as well (recorded in texts), and possesses no special aura that could convert the passing man. I guess maybe in all, he was really just a wise man. Buddhism *is* a philosophy more than a religion, and you are right in the sense that Buddha did not want an "ism" and other established organizations/cultures that presents only dogmas. These were limitations. But without them, information becomes very, very difficult to disseminate. I think he was aware of this cost, and went ahead anyways.

The lesson seems to be, read Buddhist texts but never take them as truths just because they're texts. Be skeptical, be a critical thinking person. Be less mindful of worldly desires and items. I am sure there will be much one can learn from the texts, and then incorporate into your life. This is difficult -- change requires practice and patience. But in all, I think there is a multitude of ways one can construe Buddhism, and what's most important is critical thinking, a willingness to adopt such principles and incorporate them into your life, and ultimately have a sense of calm, a sense of purpose, and a sense of "knowing".
:clap:
 
Yeah, your or someone else said. And then, you or someone says "that's not what the Buddha meant by 'happiness' or 'awake'" or some such crap.

Possibly, but having read, with comprehension, the few words the buddha actually said regarding the path you don't require anyone else's approval. Indeed if you require some expert's approval to know you are on the path, you aren't on the path. If there is anything I have learned about buddhism so far it is that it is far simpler than I ever imagined.

The difference is that nobody is ever going to tell me, if I had some good sex, "Ah, you may think that is good sex, but it's not Good Sex(TM) as the Buddha meant it, which can only be achieved by reading and following the Seventeen Really Cool Bromides."

Well, tantrists might say this.

Heh, heh tantrists might say that ;-)

Seriously though, buddhism is the 4 noble truths with the 4th being the 8-fold path. That is it. Read it, learn it, try it out. You are now an expert.

Anyone who says differently is simply wrong.

Whether or not buddhism is 'true' is up to the individual who walks the path. Seriously, get 'Buddhism Without Beliefs" or "Buddhism Plain and Simple" and spend a couple hours reading the book, and 1 hour (20 or 30 minutes per session) in meditation and you are the expert. There is nothing [necessary] further for you to learn from anyone.

It is that easy to understand and then follow the practice or leave it lay at the wayside.

No, you won't feel like an expert, but you will know everything you need to know to make the journey.

What could be simpler? Spend a couple hours learning from a skilled author, 1 hour in practice and after the investment of $10 and 3 hours time you are completely able to determine if you have found a worthy way of life or bunk you wish to cast aside. There is no test. By way of comparison college is mega expensive and time consuming.
 
Buddha says not to ask questions.

You learn nothing if you're not sceptical. Even the Buddha himself told us to be sceptical about all things, even to approach Buddhism with sceptical eyes!

Look at the Kalama Sutra, for example. Is this not a guide to scepticism?

Here is a post I placed in another thread but I am repeating it here to show how Buddha is only 50% skeptical, namely, not to accept anything rashly, but against favoring skepticism when it comes to entertaining all kinds of and endless questions from his listeners.

Yrreg said:
I've learned a little about Buddhism. I was rather surprised to find an ancient religion where part of the teaching was to not accept its teachings by faith. I've learned that there are actually some reasonable skeptics out there, and even a few, like ceo_esq and LW, who do call BS on some of the junk that runs around in atheist/skeptic circles.
From Yrreg in another thread on lessons from JREF forum, Buddhists are not supposed to ask questions about so many things:


That part about being skeptical as allegedly propounded by the Buddha, that is only an incident[al] lesson from the Buddha; you must remember and this is the most important lesson from the Buddha, namely, not to ask questions which Buddha considers of no profit for the abolition of suffering and the attainment of Nirvana.

Questions like what questions? Like where does the universe come from, and similar matters.

Buddhists even love the anecdote from the Buddha about how one should attend right away to a man wounded by an arrow, instead of asking from where the arrow came, who shot it, etc. But they mean that aside from attending to the wounded man, no need to find out everything about why people shoot arrows on other people, how arrows travel in the air, how to avoid being hit by arrows, how to prevent being pierced by an arrow impacting into your body, etc.

So, good friend, don't praise Buddhism to the sky in terms of that single paragraph from a single sutra which could be spurious, about not depending on others but on yourself and your thinking to accept anything as true, because the other side of the coin in Buddhism tells you not to ask questions.


Yrreg

So, tell me if I am wrong: that Buddha is only 50%, not 100% partial to skepticism in his disciples, only 180 degrees of the circle, in supposedly incalculting skepticism in his folowers, namely, distrust in not accepting any doctrines easily; but not advocating skepticism in the opposite remaining 180 degrees, by his disapproval of countless and endless questionings from among would-be followers.


For myself the badge of a genuine full-blooded skeptic is countless and endless questionings.


Yrreg
 
Here is a post I placed in another thread but I am repeating it here to show how Buddha is only 50% skeptical, namely, not to accept anything rashly, but against favoring skepticism when it comes to entertaining all kinds of and endless questions from his listeners.
I don't suppose you can provide a source for this belief?

Or will you say that it is locked on a mysterious astral plane that only the initiated can access? The buddha is alleged to have answer most questions.
So, tell me if I am wrong: that Buddha is only 50%, not 100% partial to skepticism in his disciples, only 180 degrees of the circle, in supposedly incalculting skepticism in his folowers, namely, distrust in not accepting any doctrines easily; but not advocating skepticism in the opposite remaining 180 degrees, by his disapproval of countless and endless questionings from among would-be followers.
The buddha encouraged people to ask questions, what source do you have to state that the buddha only answered half the questions?

[humor]
Yrreg: I tell you emphaticaly that the buddha is plindyblindy.

DD: Where is it said that the buddha is plindyblindy?

Yrreg: I don't like to read anything about buddhism but I think that it is true.

DD: Would you show me that somewhere the buddha is stated to be plindyblindy?

Yrreg:
posted by yrreg
Yrreg: I tell you emphaticaly that the buddha is plindyblindy.

DD: I see that you beleieve that the buddha is plindyblindy, is there some place where you can show that buddhists believe the buddha is plindyblindy?

Yrreg: This shows the blind faith that buddhists place in the buddha, you feel that the buddha is some sort of god.
For myself the badge of a genuine full-blooded skeptic is countless and endless questionings.


Yrreg

Don't hurt yourself patting your self on the back!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom