Skeptical criticism on Buddhist beliefs and observances.

So, Buddhists think and talk to the effect that the self or the person does not exist; even if it is a collection of anatomical parts and physiological processes, it does not exist either.

How then would they behave in the world of being and doing?
Why would you believe that? Especially since I for one have been telling you the very opposite. Nobody said the collection of anatomical parts and physiological processes doesn't exist. That's the whole point - they are all that exist. What doesn't exist is the imaginary "self" that is dreamed up by thinking and talking (about itself).

Buddhism is precisely and exactly about "being and doing" - in fact that would be a wonderful definition of Buddhism, one could say that, "Buddhism is the practice of being and doing". Buddhism is not about thinking of and talking about imaginary beings (like "self", "I", "ego" etc.)

Which is not say that there should never be any thinking or talking. Thinking and talking are useful activities that can lead to a better appreciation and understanding of the world around one. But thinking and talking about the right things in the right way - i.e. not just thinking or talking about "my self".

yrreg said:
I think one of the most fundamental canon of skeptical criticism is the distinction of the world of being and doing from the world of thinking and talking, namely: the world of being and doing should dictate the world of thinking and talking.
Excellent! That in many respects is the very core of Buddhism. Now you're talking like a Buddhist! :D

yrreg said:
Incidentally, I almost forget, the ruler dismissed the monks with these parting words:

“See if you can engage yourselves in thinking and talking so as to find edible roots and grubs anywhere in the kingdom, that should be a much better way to employ your mind and your tongue.”

yrreg
And the ruler's error was of course thinking and talking about straw men, when he could have just been being and doing what needed to be done.
 
The worth of ancient texts or ancient masters, supposedly.

Have I read the Kalama Sutra?

Honestly speaking, I cannot find any worth in ancient texts or ancient masters of millennia of years back in the history of humanity, unless they are telling us how to arrive at some location on the earth where we can find hidden treasures of precious jewels made of gold, silver, diamonds, and other exotic gems.

My concern here is to apply skeptical criticism to the doctrines and observances of Buddhism, and at this point in particular on the matter of the existence of the self or person.

Here again is my impression about the Buddhists' negation of the self:

yrreg said:
So, Buddhists think and talk to the effect that the self or the person does not exist; even if it is a collection of anatomical parts and physiological processes, it does not exist either.

No, I have not read the Kalama Sutra; but since there are people who have read the Kalama Sutra, like presumably Ryokan and other Buddhists, perhaps they can do me the favor to tell me how the Kalama Sutra fits in with my impression about the Buddhists' negation of the self, as I have summed it up in the citation above reproduced from a message of mine preceding the present one.

Is the Kalama Sutra going to tell us that in effect the self or person does not exist, or it does exist, or what?

As I said, Buddhists read it, and presumably as an authoritative text for themselves; then let them tell us why it is authoritative for them and on what questions.

That will save us time and labor.

yrreg
 
I think one of the most fundamental canon of skeptical criticism is the distinction of the world of being and doing from the world of thinking and talking, namely: the world of being and doing should dictate the world of thinking and talking.

Incidentally, I almost forget, the ruler dismissed the monks with these parting words:

“See if you can engage yourselves in thinking and talking so as to find edible roots and grubs anywhere in the kingdom, that should be a much better way to employ your mind and your tongue.”


yrreg

I don't think that buddhists would be in disagreement with the parable, you notice that they did not assault any one, nor did they demand food, nor were they rude or dismissive.

Many buddhists do practise and work for a living. The aestic tradition is coomon to many cultures, the buddhists do not demand that people don't work.

There is a practise of monks going door to door for food which the buddha practised, I am not sure of the reasons why, although I could guess.

I think one of the most fundamental canon of skeptical criticism is the distinction of the world of being and doing from the world of thinking and talking, namely: the world of being and doing should dictate the world of thinking and talking.

Uh dude this is the teaching of the buddha, and buddhism does encourage you to be sceptical of all of it's beliefs and practises.
 
Have I read the Kalama Sutra?

Honestly speaking, I cannot find any worth in ancient texts or ancient masters of millennia of years back in the history of humanity, unless they are telling us how to arrive at some location on the earth where we can find hidden treasures of precious jewels made of gold, silver, diamonds, and other exotic gems.

My concern here is to apply skeptical criticism to the doctrines and observances of Buddhism, and at this point in particular on the matter of the existence of the self or person.

So you wish to critisize, but not to learn? Then what is the point of further discussion?

You have been told again and again that Buddhists believe that both people and things exist. You refuse to understand what Buddhists mean by 'self', and ask about it again and again even if you have been given the answer.

Again, what is the point of further discussion?

Here, for your pleasure, is a short version of the Kalama Sutra :


Kalama Sutta

Do not believe in anything simply
because you have heard it.

Do not believe in traditions just because they
have been handed down for many generations.

Do not believe in anything just because it is
spoken and rumoured by many.

Do not believe in anything simply because
it is found written in your religious books.

Do not believe in anything merely on the authority
of your teachers and elders.

But after observation and analysis
when you find that anything agrees with reason
and is conductive to the good and benefit of one and all
then accept it and live up to it.

- Gautama Buddha

Others have linked to texts where the Buddha talks about the existance of self (Not to mention that they have also explained it very well!). If you refuse to read them, that's fine by me. Just don't expect people to continue 'discussing' with you if you don't want to understand.

Have a nice day.
 
Ryokan - Many thanks.

I have read and agreed with the Kalama Sutra before, but I had forgotten how simply it stated a skeptical approach to the world.
 
Thanks for the reafirmation of Lao Zi (and later, Wittgenstein): "The Way, if it can be articulated, is not the eternal Way. The name, if it can be named, is not the eternal name."
 
Have I read the Kalama Sutra?

Honestly speaking, I cannot find any worth in ancient texts or ancient masters of millennia of years back in the history of humanity,

I couldn't find my keys this morning.
 
A question of authenticity, and the short statement.

Dear Ryokan:

In the best tradition of skeptical criticism, could you tell us something about the authenticity of the Kalama Sutra, namely, Was it really written by the Gautama Buddha, and when was it actually redacted into writing?

Do not believe in anything simply
because you have heard it.

Do not believe in traditions just because they
have been handed down for many generations.

Do not believe in anything just because it is
spoken and rumoured by many.

Do not believe in anything simply because
it is found written in your religious books.

Do not believe in anything merely on the authority
of your teachers and elders.

But after observation and analysis
when you find that anything agrees with reason
and is conductive to the good and benefit of one and all
then accept it and live up to it.

- Gautama Buddha

Also, do you believe that those skeptical guidelines in the Kalama Sutra were unknown to merchants and smart people and men and women who had to maintain a tight ship of a household, until Buddha came into an enlightenment of their necessity and practicality?


You have been told again and again that Buddhists believe that both people and things exist. You refuse to understand what Buddhists mean by 'self', and ask about it again and again even if you have been given the answer. -- Ryokan

From my careful reading of the messages here from you and also from people with the same persuasion or with the same sympathy, I understand that Buddhists don't believe in the existence of the self or the person. So allow me to again repeat this short statement of my impression:

(Originally Posted by yrreg)
So, Buddhists think and talk to the effect that the self or the person does not exist; even if it is a collection of anatomical parts and physiological processes, it does not exist either.​

I think if we ask people to make a short statement of what Buddhists believe about the self or person, so far in this thread, they would likewise basically come up with my brief summation of what Buddhists believe about the self or person, i.e., Buddhists don't believe in the self or person.

yrreg
 
Dear Ryokan:

In the best tradition of skeptical criticism, could you tell us something about the authenticity of the Kalama Sutra, namely, Was it really written by the Gautama Buddha, and when was it actually redacted into writing?

The Kalama Sutra is in the Pali canon, which are the oldest known Buddhist texts. Still, they were not written down until around 30BC. Until then, the traditions were maintained orally.

So is the story told in the Kalama Sutra true? Did Gautama Buddha really say this?

The truth is, who knows? And does it matter? It's the words that count, after all, not who said it.

What I quoted was, as I said, a short version of the sutra. Here's the link to the original text (translated from Pali to English, of course) : http://www.accesstoinsight.org/canon/sutta/anguttara/an03-065.html

(Although, why do I bother? You have already stated you're not interested in reading ancient texts.)

Also, do you believe that those skeptical guidelines in the Kalama Sutra were unknown to merchants and smart people and men and women who had to maintain a tight ship of a household, until Buddha came into an enlightenment of their necessity and practicality?

I'm not sure what you're asking here, sorry.


From my careful reading of the messages here from you and also from people with the same persuasion or with the same sympathy, I understand that Buddhists don't believe in the existence of the self or the person. So allow me to again repeat this short statement of my impression:

(Originally Posted by yrreg)
So, Buddhists think and talk to the effect that the self or the person does not exist; even if it is a collection of anatomical parts and physiological processes, it does not exist either.​

I think if we ask people to make a short statement of what Buddhists believe about the self or person, so far in this thread, they would likewise basically come up with my brief summation of what Buddhists believe about the self or person, i.e., Buddhists don't believe in the self or person.

yrreg

More than one non-Buddhist have visited this thread and seemed to understand what Buddhists means by 'there is no self'.

I am not claiming that Ryokan does not exist. That would be quite the paradox, wouldn't it? Nor am I suggesting that yrreg or anyone else does not exist (although you would have a very hard time actually proving that either one of us exist, beyond doubt, but there's no need to go that far; that is not what Buddhism teaches).

What Buddhists believe is that the self of yrreg does not exist. What was yrreg yesterday is not the same as yrreg is today, and what is yrreg today, is not what will be yrreg tomorrow. Today you have more more experiences and memories than you did yesterday. Tomorrow your body will contain a slightly different mass than it did today. 'You' are the sum of your parts, but those parts change all the time. Are you with me so far?
 
I'm still of two minds about Buddhism.

I've been asking questions on another board about Buddhism. This is a board that has (what is the collective name?) of Buddhists. I get two classes of answers. One class is that the ideas are just ineffable. The other class is your basic jerkwad Internet behavior: poor reading skills, straw men, supercilious egoism, snottiness, etc. Often they're combined, as in such responses as "If you really understood Nirvana, you wouldn't be asking the question. You talk the talk but you don't walk the walk." Bovine fecal matter.

Basically, they claim that the practice leads to wisdom and understanding and enlightenment, but even after scores of year of this stuff, they still act like 10-year-olds in a proportion that is about average at best. The only extra bit is that they talk about Dharma and Siddhi and other impressive-sounding words, but they can't or won't explain them. It's either something that is presented as unfalsifiable, or somehting that They, Precious Them, are Terribly Impressed with Themselves for Understanding, or both.
 
Are you trying to say that Buddhists are just people like everyone else, epepke? Get out of here!
 
Have I read the Kalama Sutra?

Honestly speaking, I cannot find any worth in ancient texts or ancient masters of millennia of years back in the history of humanity, unless they are telling us how to arrive at some location on the earth where we can find hidden treasures of precious jewels made of gold, silver, diamonds, and other exotic gems.

So you would say that the study of geology has no merits unless it leads to the same goals.

How can you judge the merits of buddhist teaching and not read or explore them. That is an apriori assumption of ignorance of the facts.

No sceptical or scientific.
My concern here is to apply skeptical criticism to the doctrines and observances of Buddhism, and at this point in particular on the matter of the existence of the self or person.

Here again is my impression about the Buddhists' negation of the self:
Which is your belief and you are welcome to it, however would you critique the value of geology without studying it?
No, I have not read the Kalama Sutra; but since there are people who have read the Kalama Sutra, like presumably Ryokan and other Buddhists, perhaps they can do me the favor to tell me how the Kalama Sutra fits in with my impression about the Buddhists' negation of the self, as I have summed it up in the citation above reproduced from a message of mine preceding the present one.

So should an ostrich that sticks it's head in the sand tell others to explain to them that thier head is not in the sand?
And that there sand is the only sand in the world?
Is the Kalama Sutra going to tell us that in effect the self or person does not exist, or it does exist, or what?
If you wish the answer to why Ryokan suggested you read the sutra you should reference Ryokans post, not yours, perhaps?
As I said, Buddhists read it, and presumably as an authoritative text for themselves; then let them tell us why it is authoritative for them and on what questions.

That will save us time and labor.

That will also save you the time of reading what Ryokan wrote?
;)
 
Dear Ryokan:

In the best tradition of skeptical criticism, could you tell us something about the authenticity of the Kalama Sutra, namely, Was it really written by the Gautama Buddha, and when was it actually redacted into writing?

Who made those claims?

Michael Jackson?

Also, do you believe that those skeptical guidelines in the Kalama Sutra were unknown to merchants and smart people and men and women who had to maintain a tight ship of a household, until Buddha came into an enlightenment of their necessity and practicality?

Who made this claim, Micheal Jordan?
You have been told again and again that Buddhists believe that both people and things exist. You refuse to understand what Buddhists mean by 'self', and ask about it again and again even if you have been given the answer. -- Ryokan

From my careful reading of the messages here from you and also from people with the same persuasion or with the same sympathy, I understand that Buddhists don't believe in the existence of the self or the person. So allow me to again repeat this short statement of my impression:

(Originally Posted by yrreg)
So, Buddhists think and talk to the effect that the self or the person does not exist; even if it is a collection of anatomical parts and physiological processes, it does not exist either.​
A broken record repeats itself, does it play music?

A dog returns to it's barf , should it barf or bark?
I think if we ask people to make a short statement of what Buddhists believe about the self or person, so far in this thread, they would likewise basically come up with my brief summation of what Buddhists believe about the self or person, i.e., Buddhists don't believe in the self or person.

yrreg

Then you chose to not understand what is being said, be blessed for being who you are!
 
Pseudo-reasoning galore.

(Originally Posted by yrreg)
So, Buddhists think and talk to the effect that the self or the person does not exist; even if it is a collection of anatomical parts and physiological processes, it does not exist either.​


Ryokan_#50 said:
More than one non-Buddhist have visited this thread and seemed to understand what Buddhists means by 'there is no self'.

I am not claiming that Ryokan does not exist. That would be quite the paradox, wouldn't it? Nor am I suggesting that yrreg or anyone else does not exist (although you would have a very hard time actually proving that either one of us exist, beyond doubt, but there's no need to go that far; that is not what Buddhism teaches).

What Buddhists believe is that the self of yrreg does not exist. What was yrreg yesterday is not the same as yrreg is today, and what is yrreg today, is not what will be yrreg tomorrow. Today you have more more experiences and memories than you did yesterday. Tomorrow your body will contain a slightly different mass than it did today. 'You' are the sum of your parts, but those parts change all the time. Are you with me so far?

Good brother, Ryokan, you admit Ryokan and Yrreg exist, but you maintain that the selves of Ryokan and Yrreg don't exist.

And the reason is because both Ryokan and Yrreg change from day to day, like "Tomorrow your body will contain a slightly different mass than it did today."

You mean obviously then that there is no subject that changes in Ryokan and in Yrreg. even though there are changes.

Again: Are you clearly saying then that there is change but no subject changing?

-------------


More than one non-Buddhist have visited this thread and seemed to understand what Buddhists means by 'there is no self'.

...seemed..., so, you are not sure that people really understand or accept what Buddhists mean by 'there is no self'?

I am not claiming that Ryokan does not exist. That would be quite the paradox, wouldn't it? Nor am I suggesting that yrreg or anyone else does not exist (although you would have a very hard time actually proving that either one of us exist, beyond doubt, but there's no need to go that far; that is not what Buddhism teaches).

You have a very hard time trying to prove; but not me for there is no need to prove with words my existence and that of others like myself, we just pinch each other and ask still others to pinch us.

What Buddhists believe is that the self of yrreg does not exist. What was yrreg yesterday is not the same as yrreg is today, and what is yrreg today, is not what will be yrreg tomorrow. Today you have more more experiences and memories than you did yesterday. Tomorrow your body will contain a slightly different mass than it did today. 'You' are the sum of your parts, but those parts change all the time. Are you with me so far?

There is indeed grievous pseudo-reasoning here. I will gift readers here with a reward that will delight them, if they can point out to me where the pseudo-reasoning is located.


Yrreg
 
I like to meet with skeptics here who can tell me how Buddhist doctrines like rebirths and Nirvana cannot stand up to skeptical criticism.

And also the usefulness of meditation, specially that of the Zen school.

yrreg

From my own experience of reading buddhist texts, most of them focus on everyday things like how we react when we experience a negative emotion or how to deal with things in a way that is meaningful and good.. maintaining balance in everything, etc. It's the New Age crowd that loves to rant on about the after-life and Nirvana, not buddhists.
 
yrreg, do you think consiousness, self, [add term here] is continuous?
Do you think its a single, "monolithic" entity or a composite feature?

The answers to these questions may help you understand the points some posters are making.
 
Concentrating on the visible world.

From my own experience of reading buddhist texts, most of them focus on everyday things like how we react when we experience a negative emotion or how to deal with things in a way that is meaningful and good.. maintaining balance in everything, etc. It's the New Age crowd that loves to rant on about the after-life and Nirvana, not buddhists.

Good brother, Filip, do you know of people who do not read Buddhist texts and yet also "on everyday things like how we react when we experience a negative emotion or how to deal with things in a way that is meaningful and good.. maintaining balance in everything, etc.," they manage as well as you do, and maybe even better?

I like to invite you to do a study, simple one, which I think is what skeptical criticism is concerned with, namely, look around and observe the people you meet everyday, starting with your home and branching out to your routine places of work, play, family and personal errands, social contacts, choose any twenty persons whom you see to be getting along in life the way you are, and seriously examine whether you can manage as well and even better as they, without reading Buddhist texts but with just following the wisdom in Aesop's fables, or the wisdom any street sweeper with a well-managed home and family lives by.

You can get the text of Aesop's fables with any search engine like Google. Or you can interview street sweepers, garbage collectors, old folks cleaning office buildings at night.


Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom