Skeptical criticism on Buddhist beliefs and observances.

How do you know, yrreg, you refuse to read the Buddhist texts, so how would you know what's in them?

And no one has claimed that reading Buddhists texts will work miracles. The Buddha showed us a path to end suffering, but never claimed it was the only path.
 
Hard of understanding?

yrreg, do you think consiousness, self, [add term here] is continuous?
Do you think its a single, "monolithic" entity or a composite feature?

The answers to these questions may help you understand the points some posters are making.

I am not the only one who might not be able to understand what Buddhists are thinking and talking about in regard to the sentence 'there is no self'.

Consider this observation of Ryokan, himself the Resident Buddhist here in JREF Forum:

More than one non-Buddhist have visited this thread and seemed to understand what Buddhists means by 'there is no self'. -- Ryokan, post #50​

...seemed to..., which 'seemed to' means as well 'seemed not to'.

What I understand so far from the Buddhists here and what I might consider to be Buddhist sympathizers, about the self is:

1. the self is the soul, but the soul for Buddhists does not exist;

2. the self is not the person either;

3. the self or the person is composed of anatomical parts and physiological processes, but the whole collection is neither self nor person, self and person still don't exist;

4. there are changes occurring in a self or person, but there is no self or person.

At this point, I seem to see that for Buddhists here, there is only change but no subject of change. Perhaps I get this impression also wrongly.

Anyway, addressing the skeptics here, and I also include myself among the skeptics here, do we have two kinds of skeptics among several kinds, namely, the ones who believe in a subject that undergoes changes, and the ones that believe that there is only change but without any subject, i.e., of change?

Yrreg
 
...seemed to..., which 'seemed to' means as well 'seemed not to'.

I said 'seemed to' because I'm not a mind reader.

What I understand so far from the Buddhists here and what I might consider to be Buddhist sympathizers, about the self is:

1. the self is the soul, but the soul for Buddhists does not exist;

Buddhism does not have the concept of a soul, therefore 'self' is the closest thing.

2. the self is not the person either;

There is no self. No one has claimed that persons don't exist, though, so I don't know where that came from.

3. the self or the person is composed of anatomical parts and physiological processes, but the whole collection is neither self nor person, self and person still don't exist;

The collections of parts can be refered to as a person. However, there is no 'self', that person changes from day to day, hour to hour.

4. there are changes occurring in a self or person, but there is no self or person.

Changes can no occur in the self, as there is no self. There is no self, because the person changes all the time.

Yes and no. See answer to #3.

At this point, I seem to see that for Buddhists here, there is only change but no subject of change. Perhaps I get this impression also wrongly.

Everything is in constant change. Nothing ever remains the same.

Anyway, addressing the skeptics here, and I also include myself among the skeptics here, do we have two kinds of skeptics among several kinds, namely, the ones who believe in a subject that undergoes changes, and the ones that believe that there is only change but without any subject, i.e., of change?

Yrreg

I would say that there are as many different kinds of sceptics as there are sceptics, none two are alike :)
 
Take it from the believers.

How do you know, yrreg, you refuse to read the Buddhist texts, so how would you know what's in them?

And no one has claimed that reading Buddhists texts will work miracles. The Buddha showed us a path to end suffering, but never claimed it was the only path.

When there are texts about something and there are people who take them seriously and live by them, the surest way to know what they know from the texts is to ask them, the people taking the texts seriously.

For if anyone who is not a believer in the texts and what the texts stand for, or generally don't give any fealty to them, then for him to read the texts and to derive their meaning, it would be for such a person to come into more conflicts with believers of the texts and claimants to know what they mean.

No, I Will not and I do not think it is productive on my part to read ancient Buddhist texts, when they are Buddhists today who do believe in them and who do profess themselves to know whereof these texts talk about and that they talk sense.

So, for the purpose of this thread, I will always depend on Buddhists here, like Ryokan the Resident Buddhist, to tell us what they know whether from the ancient Buddhist texts or from their meditation what they mean by what they use of words.

Maybe the Buddhists here can refer me to authoritative interpreters of Buddhists texts, like in the civil domain we have courts to tell us what legislators mean with the laws they passed, so that all Buddhists like all citizens of a country believing in official and final interpreters of texts willy-nilly give their concurrence and obeisance.


Yrreg
 
When there are texts about something and there are people who take them seriously and live by them, the surest way to know what they know from the texts is to ask them, the people taking the texts seriously.

When there are texts about something and there are people who take them seriosuly and live by them, I will read them to understand what they're about. If you ask people, you only get opinions. A good sceptic always goes to the source.

I have read the bible several times, to be able to discuss Christianity with those that believe in them. If I had relied upon information from those that believe, I don't think I would have the same knowledge about the bible that I now have.

For if anyone who is not a believer in the texts and what the texts stand for, or generally don't give any fealty to them, then for him to read the texts and to derive their meaning, it would be for such a person to come into more conflicts with believers of the texts and claimants to know what they mean.

So you have no wish to learn first hand. Okay.

No, I Will not and I do not think it is productive on my part to read ancient Buddhist texts, when they are Buddhists today who do believe in them and who do profess themselves to know whereof these texts talk about and that they talk sense.

Then how do you know that what you get is the truth? Much better to go to the source, like a real sceptic would.

So, for the purpose of this thread, I will always depend on Buddhists here, like Ryokan the Resident Buddhist, to tell us what they know whether from the ancient Buddhist texts or from their meditation what they mean by what they use of words.

Again with the resident Buddhist, I'm starting to regret that custom forum title... Yrreg, am I correct in assuming English is not your first language?

Dictionary.com defines 'resident' as :

One who resides in a particular place permanently or for an extended period.

So Resident Buddhist simply means that I'm a Buddhist who resides in this forum. It has no other meaning. I'm a Theravada Buddhist.

Maybe the Buddhists here can refer me to authoritative interpreters of Buddhists texts, like in the civil domain we have courts to tell us what legislators mean with the laws they passed, so that all Buddhists like all citizens of a country believing in official and final interpreters of texts willy-nilly give their concurrence and obeisance.


Yrreg

Buddhism has no 'central command'. It's not a dogma religion. In theory, every Buddhist reads the texts and then interprets them his own way. This is not only allowed, it's encouraged; this is the reason why there are so many denominations, and why they are all good friends even if they interpret the words of the Buddha differently; in Buddhism, there is no heresy. It's less a religion than it is a philosophical direction. Buddhists only have one thing common, they seek to extinguish their suffering. That's what Buddhism is about. No gods, magic chants or crystals are required, nor are they forbidden. Buddhism has no 'thou shalts' or 'thou shalt nots', but has advice. Advice that you are free to ignore if you wish, it makes you no less a Buddhist.

If you really wish to learn, I can guide you to the very CORE of Buddhism, the number one teaching of Gautama Buddha : The Four Noble Truths. All other teachings are secondary.

Here is a very quick, simple and easy to understand guide to the Four Noble Truths.

Here is a more thorough guide, with references to Buddhist texts.

These are not ancient texts, so you should take a look.

A shame you won't read ancient texts, though, some of the more enlightening moments I've ever had has been reading Plato ;)
 
(Originally Posted by yrreg)
So, Buddhists think and talk to the effect that the self or the person does not exist; even if it is a collection of anatomical parts and physiological processes, it does not exist either.​

And would you please point out dear yrreg where anyone who is explaining the teachings of the buddha has said that the parts do not exist. The person as a body does exist, the person as feelings does exist , etc.

Could it be that you have yet to prove that a self exits beyond the parts, or do you just unscepticaly assume that the self exists?
Good brother, Ryokan, you admit Ryokan and Yrreg exist, but you maintain that the selves of Ryokan and Yrreg don't exist.

And the reason is because both Ryokan and Yrreg change from day to day, like "Tomorrow your body will contain a slightly different mass than it did today."

You mean obviously then that there is no subject that changes in Ryokan and in Yrreg. even though there are changes.

Again: Are you clearly saying then that there is change but no subject changing?
Prove that there is a subject that is beyond the transitory parts that we call a self.

Can you? Or do you just assume that the self exists?
-------------




...seemed..., so, you are not sure that people really understand or accept what Buddhists mean by 'there is no self'?



You have a very hard time trying to prove; but not me for there is no need to prove with words my existence and that of others like myself, we just pinch each other and ask still others to pinch us.

And that proves what?
That bodies exist, that thoughts exist and that sensations exist.

Where is the self in the pinching.

Does Terri Schiavo have a self?
There is indeed grievous pseudo-reasoning here. I will gift readers here with a reward that will delight them, if they can point out to me where the pseudo-reasoning is located.


Yrreg

The pseudo reasoning is that you p0ssibly put words in other peoples mouths.

I have asked you a number of serious and not so serious questions. If you can reason than why not answer them/

Are you writing a term paper, or are you masquerading as a sceptic?

Why are you not sceptical of your belief in the self.

Where is your self and what is it made of?
 
I like to invite you to do a study, simple one, which I think is what skeptical criticism is concerned with, namely, look around and observe the people you meet everyday, starting with your home and branching out to your routine places of work, play, family and personal errands, social contacts, choose any twenty persons whom you see to be getting along in life the way you are, and seriously examine whether you can manage as well and even better as they, without reading Buddhist texts but with just following the wisdom in Aesop's fables, or the wisdom any street sweeper with a well-managed home and family lives by.




Yrreg

And why don't you conduct the study yourself?

Go find a hundred people who actively practise the teachings of the buddha, and a hundred who are sceptics but not buddhists, and then do a quality of life survey.

What result will you get?

To compare the teachings of the buddha to Aesops fables is a fallacy of genralization and categorization.

Why do you not follow the rules of logic and reasoning yourself?
 
When there are texts about something and there are people who take them seriously and live by them, the surest way to know what they know from the texts is to ask them, the people taking the texts seriously.

The buddha dying words were supposedly "Be ye lamps unto yourselfs".

The buddha taught that the the path of the buddha could not be truely learned from the words of others but by studying the teachings and deciding for one's 'self' as a person if they are true.

If they are then you can follow the path or not, if they are not true, then there are other paths.

The dharma is not a dogma, it is a set of teachings, you can not learn math by having others solve your equations.
For if anyone who is not a believer in the texts and what the texts stand for, or generally don't give any fealty to them, then for him to read the texts and to derive their meaning, it would be for such a person to come into more conflicts with believers of the texts and claimants to know what they mean.
That is bald faced assertion with little or no support or evidence. It may be true for some cults and philosophies but you haven't demonstrated your assertion to be more than speculation..

Only the individual may come to a decision if the teachings of the buddha have merit.

It is not the tenants of buddhism that lead to enlightenment but following the path. Belief in the map is un-needed to use the map.
No, I Will not and I do not think it is productive on my part to read ancient Buddhist texts, when they are Buddhists today who do believe in them and who do profess themselves to know whereof these texts talk about and that they talk sense.
The buddha taught that it was up to each person to decide for themselves if the teachings were useful and had merit.
So, for the purpose of this thread, I will always depend on Buddhists here, like Ryokan the Resident Buddhist, to tell us what they know whether from the ancient Buddhist texts or from their meditation what they mean by what they use of words.
It is up to each person to decide if the teachings of the buddha have merit.

The purpose of meditation is to learn to examine the thoughts and feelings and to learn to calm them so one may lead a purposeful and non-reactive life.
Maybe the Buddhists here can refer me to authoritative interpreters of Buddhists texts, like in the civil domain we have courts to tell us what legislators mean with the laws they passed, so that all Buddhists like all citizens of a country believing in official and final interpreters of texts willy-nilly give their concurrence and obeisance.


Yrreg

See , it is perhaps that you mistake the teachings of the buddha, they are not like the law, they are more like science and medicine. It is up to the individual to decide on the merits of the teachings of the buddha and what they mean, there is not a dogma or catchecism.

Often practioners of different schools live together in the same settings, without needing to have "official and final interpreters of texts willy-nilly give their concurrence and obeisance".

the meaning of the teachings and texts are up to each person to decide and figure out for themselves.

There are no tenants of faith in most buddhist sects, there paths and tools to lead to a better life. But each person is free to do as they will and interpret the meanings as they wish.

Some buddhists may argue as to the meaning of things but they are not the teachers that most seek out.

You can hear of the dharma from others but it is up to the individual to understand it.

There is a koan.

"A student sees his master on the back of a galloping horse.

The student eager to know where his master is going shouts out:
"Master to where do you journey?"

The master replies :
"I don't know, ask the horse!" "
 
I am not the only one who might not be able to understand what Buddhists are thinking and talking about in regard to the sentence 'there is no self'.

Consider this observation of Ryokan, himself the Resident Buddhist here in JREF Forum:

More than one non-Buddhist have visited this thread and seemed to understand what Buddhists means by 'there is no self'. -- Ryokan, post #50

...seemed to..., which 'seemed to' means as well 'seemed not to'.

What I understand so far from the Buddhists here and what I might consider to be Buddhist sympathizers, about the self is:

1. the self is the soul, but the soul for Buddhists does not exist;

2. the self is not the person either;

3. the self or the person is composed of anatomical parts and physiological processes, but the whole collection is neither self nor person, self and person still don't exist;

4. there are changes occurring in a self or person, but there is no self or person.

At this point, I seem to see that for Buddhists here, there is only change but no subject of change. Perhaps I get this impression also wrongly.

Anyway, addressing the skeptics here, and I also include myself among the skeptics here, do we have two kinds of skeptics among several kinds, namely, the ones who believe in a subject that undergoes changes, and the ones that believe that there is only change but without any subject, i.e., of change?

Yrreg
Yrreg,

Do you understand that there is a distinction between concepts of the mind and physical objects?

Do you understand that the word "table" is just a word, a concept, a thing of the mind, and that the label "table" is not the same as the physical thing you eat your dinner at, or rest your computer on?

If so, what is difficult to understand about the fact that "self" is just a word, a label?

Nobody has denied the existence of the body. Nobody has denied that there is a collection of cognitive processes which is able to think. But what those processes think about themselves is not the same as the processes themselves. So the idea any of us have of "self" or "soul" or whatever you want to call it, is just that - only an idea, a thing of the mind. That in no way denies the existence of the body or the processes within it. What Buddhists deny is the false ideas they have about (them)selves.

If you ask an ordinary person who they are they will tell you. If you ask them the same question the next day they will say, "I'm still me! I'm the same as I was yesterday!". And that is not true. There is not some separate thing which remains the same all the time and which constitutes "me". There is simply a set of processes which operate under the illusion that they are continuous and unchanging, and they are neither continuous nor unchanging. It is that illusion of a continuous, "self" or "I" which Buddhism addresses.

And Buddhism does not address it by thinking about it! That would be absurd. You can't stop a thought by thinking about it! Instead, Buddhism recommends that you concentrate your activities in the real world and try to stop thinking about "your" "self". It is based on practical action and living in the day to day world. That process of focussing attention on the real world instead of focussing on some imagined "self" is called meditation. Meditation is not about thinking, if anything it's about not-thinking (as far as that is practically possible). Above all, it's about acting physically in the real world.

So the problem that Buddhism is designed to address is that there are changing processes which operate under the illusion that they are not changing, and that they are not merely processes. The delusion about the true nature of the processes is what Buddhists believe ultimately leads to suffering, wrong-doing and immoral actions. What Buddhists try to do is to learn how to live without this delusion and as a result hope to avoid suffering, wrong-doing and immoral actions.

So yes, there are processes. The processes change. Therefore there is a subject of that change. But what those processes tend to believe about themselves is not true. They believe themselves to be unchanging and somehow distinct from the physical body of which they are a part. Therefore, the processes idea of themselves is an illusion. It is merely an idea not a reality. In that sense what the processes think themselves to be does not really exist.

There is no conflict with skepticism - in fact Buddhism is a refined form of skepticism, it is skepticism about the "self" - something that most skeptics take for granted.

And Ryokan's "Resident Buddhist" title has no special meaning. He is not the only Buddhist on here, nor is he some kind of "special" Buddhist on here. The admins allow some posters to choose titles for themselves, most of them are jokes, some of them are not, but none of them mean anything special.

Anyway, instead of constantly telling us what you (wrongly) think we believe, why don't you tell us what you believe? Do you believe you have a soul? Do you believe that you are something special and unchanging, that you have some sort of personality or essence separate from the physical processes of your body? Understanding your point of view may help us communicate.
 
I am not the only one who might not be able to understand what Buddhists are thinking and talking about in regard to the sentence 'there is no self'....snip...
Have you ever considered that materialists (OK, at least some of us) say similar things? Materialism´s principles may bring to to such conclusion.

What I understand so far from the Buddhists here and what I might consider to be Buddhist sympathizers, about the self is:
...snip...At this point, I seem to see that for Buddhists here, there is only change but no subject of change. Perhaps I get this impression also wrongly.
Try a materialistic approach. Remember when I asked you
yrreg, do you think consiousness, self, [add term here] is continuous?
What happens with the self during a coma or a dreamless sleep? Is it still there? No. There is no self in these cases. Selves are generated by brain activity. When the activity is below a certain treshold, there is no self. It is thus discontinuous, but we experience an illusion of continuity ("I am the same person I was yesterday"). This is quite similar to Buddhism.
Do you think its a single, "monolithic" entity or a composite feature?
If you consider the self as a collection of "parts" (say, routines, algorithms, whatever, stored within the brain), it is not a single, unique undividable monolithic entity. But we experience selves as single entities ("I know that I am"). So, if there is no self in this sense. The self is an illusion. Memories and behavior patterns (algorithms) stored in the brain compose selves when the brain is active. The memories of events are not the self; the algorithms are not the self, the brain is not the self. The sum of all these parts are the self. This is quite similar to Buddhist thinking, isn't it?

Selves are immutable? No. Because we learn, we experience new things, we learn new behaviors. Ou behavior changes, due to the new experiences we have, the new informations we aquire and even due to changes in our body. The parts that compose the self change, so the self change, even though there is no single monolithic continuous entity called self. Again, similar to Buddhistic teachings, don´t you think?

Anyway, addressing the skeptics here, and I also include myself among the skeptics here, do we have two kinds of skeptics among several kinds, namely, the ones who believe in a subject that undergoes changes, and the ones that believe that there is only change but without any subject, i.e., of change?

Yrreg
We skeptics don´t "belive" , we think. Actually we think we have the illusion that we think.
 
Ancient texts and "there is no self".

As regards ancient texts like the Buddhist scriptures, the reading of such texts serves to inform the reader whether such and such a thing is mentioned there.

To save time and labor, we can just ask people like Buddhists who do read Buddhist scriptures and take them seriously to tell us whether such and such is mentioned in them and how they understand such and such.

That is why I claim that for myself I will just depend on Buddhists to tell me whatever they want me to know by reading the Buddhist scriptures about the self or the non-self in Buddhism.

Is that a sensible approach to know what Buddhists mean by the self or the non-self? Yes, of course, unless, I and Buddhists are going to argue about what's in the Buddhist scriptures about the self or non-self and how the Buddhist scriptures understand self and non-self.

Let the Buddhists argue among themselves on the contents and meanings of these contents in their ancient texts. I will just depend on whatever they come to in terms of a concurring idea and its meaning. If they don't have any consensus, then I can draw the conclusion in terms of skeptical criticism that there is nothing definite from Buddhists about the self or non-self.

Now, considering that or presuming that Buddhists generally or as a whole maintain that there is no self:

Then it is for me now to establish again from their messages here what they mean by self, person, soul, collection of anatomical parts and physiological processes; since they claim that I don't get them correctly.

So, please stand by or keep posted, I will go through the messages again and draw some definite ideas from the Buddhists here interacting in this thread about doing skeptical criticism on Buddhist rebirths, Nirvana, and meditation.

My purpose here is to apply skeptical criticism to Buddhist rebirths, Nirvana, and meditation; and for the present we or I am concerned with the self or non-self in Buddhism.


Yrreg
 
Let's simply matters, shall we?

First, let's leave Buddhist scriptures out of this discussion, why? Because we have people who can tell us about them and their contents, and believe them, namely, Buddhists, like Ryokan and others here of the similar mind.

Let's just ask the Buddhists here about my concern for the present, the existence of the self. But shouldn't I read the Buddhist scriptures? No need, because I am not concerned with whether such and such is found in them, but with what Buddhists in the present instance understand by 'there is no self.'


Second, there have been explanations by Buddhists here on 'there is no self'; so, let's simplify the issue by now employing another common word, body.

When you hurt yourself very badly by shooting yourself while cleaning say your hunting rifle, you rush to the hospital and the doctors ask you: "How did you shoot yourself?"

Is that self referred to by the doctor your body?

What else if not your body.

So, the word self means also the body.

May I therefore inquire of the Buddhists here whether they can accept the existence of the self as the body.

If they prefer, then we will not use the word self, but keep to the word body; would that be all right with Buddhists?


Yrreg
 
A long rationalization for being intellectually lazy.

I can think of many reasons for reading some of the Buddhist scriptures in addition to discussing the issues with Buddhists on the forum.

Why ask questions if you're not prepared to listen to and consider the responses?

Also, a warning: the people in this discussion are using many of the same words but understand them to mean different things. Communications and understanding will not occur.
 
First, let's leave Buddhist scriptures out of this discussion, why? Because we have people who can tell us about them and their contents, and believe them, namely, Buddhists, like Ryokan and others here of the similar mind.

Let's just ask the Buddhists here about my concern for the present, the existence of the self. But shouldn't I read the Buddhist scriptures? No need, because I am not concerned with whether such and such is found in them, but with what Buddhists in the present instance understand by 'there is no self.'


Second, there have been explanations by Buddhists here on 'there is no self'; so, let's simplify the issue by now employing another common word, body.

When you hurt yourself very badly by shooting yourself while cleaning say your hunting rifle, you rush to the hospital and the doctors ask you: "How did you shoot yourself?"

Is that self referred to by the doctor your body?
Again the ideas of the buddha are not that the body does not exist or that the thoughts, emotions and actions do not exist, but that it may be that our perseption of a self as the overarching connection between the things does not exist.

In your example:
There is the body , motivated with thoughts and emotions, guided by perceptions and habilts which is engaged in an activity of cleaning a gun.

Perhaps not enough forethough was given in that there is a round in the gun and it discharges.

The body is injured by the bullet, there are thoughts and feelings and perception and habits.

When the doctor asks the person, how did you do this?

What does the word 'yourself' mean?

Do you think that a 'law' has some meaning outside of the human linteractions in a community?
Do you think that an 'organization' or sports club has some existance other than through the interactions of it's members?

Saying that the buddha taught that the self is the body would be an overgeneralization.

There is no evidence that a 'self' exists other than the body, thoughts, feeling,perceptions and habits. There is an aggregate of events, we refer to as the self. It is a reference, just like the word 'country', a country exists only in human concepts, it is a referant to a collection of things that are lumped together for convinience in human communications.
What else if not your body.

So, the word self means also the body.

May I therefore inquire of the Buddhists here whether they can accept the existence of the self as the body.

If they prefer, then we will not use the word self, but keep to the word body; would that be all right with Buddhists?


Yrreg


Over generalization?
You seem to ask the same questions and make the same generalizations over and over:

Can you prove that the self exists other than a human concepts used to refer to group of seperate events.

Does an orchestra exist outside of the collection of people playing musical instruments. When the concert hall is empty is the orchestra still there?
 
Some kind of communication block here... 1

Thanks to every Buddhist here, if they do admit with me that for people outside Buddhism who do not have any reverential deference to ancient Buddhist text and even Buddha himself, then there is no need for them to read the texts, but more than sufficient to ask Buddhists who do read them to tell us what and what the texts say and how and how they understand them, or in brief what they themselves as Buddhist maintain about this or that idea and how they can explain them to outsiders.

---------------

About the existence or non-existence of the self, I think I am getting a definite grasp of what is the obstacle between Buddhists here and myself in coming to a consensus on the issue.

The blockade between us can be found in our conception or psychological attitude toward the material world, by which world I refer to the collection of all and any entities, like gases, fluids, and solids which we study as early as in the first school days wen science is introduced to the classroom.

This is the world of matter and energy, which -- though not a professional scientist myself -- I believe I do have a reliable knowledge of as to survive in the midst of handling combustible or explosive materials, which I do everyday when I light up the stove which runs on liquefied petroleum gas, or when I fill up my car fuel tank with gasoline.

And now with the new year's arrival looming very close, I have to remind my family, a wife and two kids, to absolutely have nothing to do with firecrackers or Roman candles or any fireworks at all.

The world I am talking about is also that of living cells, and tissues, and blood, biologically functioning anatomical parts and physiological processes, which I possess for being at this very moment alive and well and acting.

I am sure at this point of my message here, the whole world knows what I am talking about, on the world that mankind is living in and operating in and subject to, as to so many constraints and at the same time all kinds of possibilities.

Now, how (as in the sense of by what ways and means) do we interact with and relate to this world? First and foremost and directly by and with our senses of sight, hearing, touch, smell, and taste -- and for humor's sake, some smart guys also tell us, by sex (which also I assent to with the utmost of concurrence).

Where does the self come in, in this world?

For me it is a distinct part of this world; the me is a self which sees, hears, touches, smells, tastes this world, and also very importantly exercises also these processes in regard to itself, as to see, hear, touch, taste, and smell itself or myself, and even most importantly to exercise awareness of its own mental operations like thinking and remembering and imagining, and no less important the what we call emotional events of sadness, joy, exuberance, guilt, envy, humility, ambition, love, altruism, greed.

The self then is what I refer to as the subject and the agent of all the interactions and relations I perform or undergo with the world, which world also includes myself.

The world as I describe it exists independently of me, and I am a part of this world but with a distinct existence, meaning if someone is not thinking of the world, the world continues to exist, and also if all entities capable of being aware of my existence are not aware of my existence, I continue to exist.

It is this world and this self of mine that I am talking about when I have been seeking to find out from the Buddhists here, what they mean by the self and whether the self exists for them or insofar as they are concerned -- they say no; but they are at pains to explain to me that they also take the world and their selves seriously in terms of keeping themselves alive and safe and healthy and functional.

So, I think our blockade to mutual understanding is the psychological attitude we respectively harbor for the world and the self as I have described in this message.

To myself, the world and the self are very psychologically and really in my own estimation most important, understanding importance in any way people would want to understand importance as to give it importance.

To Buddhists, the world and the self are not psychologically and thereby also not really in their estimation important at all; so unimportant that they simply declare that 'the self does not exist'; yet they keep explaining themselves for keeping themselves alive, safe, healthy, and functional in their selves and at least survivable as biological beings in this world.

I think that in essence is the blockade between me and Buddhists.

See next post for more considerations of this attitude from Buddhists.

Yrreg
 
So far Ryokan is the only Buddhist, unless I am mistaken, among us here in this thread. He calls himself Resident Buddhist.

We all here so far, including Ryokan, use the words: Buddhism, Buddhist.

But Ryokan brings up several kinds of Buddhism, Buddhists:

1. Resident Buddhist
2. Tibetan Buddhism
3. Pure Land Buddhism
4. Orthodox Buddhism
5. Zen Buddhist
6. Theravada Buddhist

And he also brings up the word, Dharma.

So, may I ask him what he understands by rebirths and Nirvana and meditation and Dharma in his kind of Buddhism, which is for himself here that of a Resident Buddhist, and as regards the particular faction thereof, that of Theravada Buddhism.


From my own part, on my stock knowledge, I understand:

1. Rebirths as returns to life after death, like for example when yrreg dies he will come back to life,

2. Nirvana as the end state of a human like Ryokan when he will be released from rebirths and sufferings.

3. Meditation is a process of occupying one's mind with some thoughts in order to reach some insights into life and the universe,

4. Dharma is a collection of teachings in Buddhism.


After we are informed by Ryokan, our Resident Buddhist here, on the words, then we can proceed to exercise our skeptical criticism on the notions and entities represented by the words.

If Ryokan cannot furnish us with the requisite information, then we will have to think of other ways and means and maybe other resource people to obtain the requisite information.

yrreg
I just joined the forum and am also a Buddhist, so Ryokan is not alone anymore. Also, I believe another Buddhist will be joining shortly. I do not intend to defend myself or my beliefs, but I may from time to time put forward ideas that I think are of some use or interest.
Rick S.
 
Yrreg, that is great and you are very free to have your belief, but that fact that you experience the self, that is your belief, if you disagree with the teaching of annatta than sobeit.

You can even follow the eightfold path without faith.

As an aside you be a buddhist by learning from the buddha, different people follow the eightfold path with out the vows to follow the precepts.

I for example consider myself to be a pagan nihilist buddhist. I try to be mindfull of the eightfold path in all activities , allow at this time I do eat meat and kill roaches. At times I have been a vegetarian, and I eat meat as little as I can, But I still try to learn from the teachings of the buddha.

I again suggest that the path of the dharma is an individual path, one can hear the words of others discuss the dharma, but one should learn of it and decide if it makes sense.

You can believe in the self, gods, demons, and spirits and still follow the eight fold path.
 
To Buddhists, the world and the self are not psychologically and thereby also not really in their estimation important at all; so unimportant that they simply declare that 'the self does not exist'; yet they keep explaining themselves for keeping themselves alive, safe, healthy, and functional in their selves and at least survivable as biological beings in this world.

I think that in essence is the blockade between me and Buddhists.

See next post for more considerations of this attitude from Buddhists.

Yrreg

My dear one, that is not a teaching of the buddha, the world is all the exists, there is no soul, there is no after life, the buddha taught that the world and our actions are all that do exist. At least that is my understanding.

You don't have to believe that there is an immortal self to want to prevent suffering. You don't have to believe in a self behind the perceptions to want to prevent suffering.


I think that perhpas you should reread the posts and think about them.

Where has anyone here said that the world is not important?

There are many erroneous teachings about buddhism, the world is not illusion, it is all that appears to be.

Yuo are the one who made this staement
the world and the self are not psychologically and thereby also not really in their estimation important at all

are you a buddhist and if so where did the buddha teach that the world is not important.

I work everyday to counsel and link people to mental health services, I talk to people who are thinking of commiting suicide and try to prevent it. With my coworkers and clients I try to have compassion and patience and to talk with them gently and listen to thier suffering. I try to show the koy of life to all I interact with, I and my co-workers are often quite silly and joke a lot. I act to reduce my impact upon the suffering of others, I am human and do create suffering, through angry acts and deeds but I try to aknowledge them and learn from them.

I love my wife, I have two children, I cherish a dog and cat, I have meaningful relationships with friends and co-workers. I tend a house and garden, I dance and play music, I like video games and computers.

Yet I do not believe that I have a 'self' that exist beyond the five skandha enumerated by the buddha.

I can do all the things that I feel I need to and yet learn from the teachings of the buddha, I am more in the world and mindful of it because of my learning. And that is enough for me, if you do not find merit in the teachings of the buddha, great!
 
Some kind of communication block here... 2

I am back from breakfast which the good wife will not brook any delay when she calls, otherwise she will pick up everything and get herself ready to leave the house for work.


And during breakfast I had an enlightenment. I remember suddenly that in college with the class in what we might call psychology 101, there was mention of the phenomenon of human thinking and behaving which is called denial syndrome.

So, that is the explanation for why Buddhists and also starting with Buddha the master himself could not and would not accept the existence of the self, when everyone else from the lowly street sweeper to the richest man on earth (Bill Gates?), to the mightiest man on earth (George Bush?), accept it and live with it, and exert their utmost efforts to cope with it -- because Buddhists find the self too painful to accept.

And it could not be otherwise for them, seeing that the only insight to life they entertain, and thereby their fundamental principle declares categorically, that all life is suffering; when everyone else knows that all life is not suffering but there are also a lot of joys and pleasures to life, and life is getting better and better as we face it and work to make it better -- in any way you care to understand better so that life is better for you -- i.e.,to keep alive better and to get on in life better, and maybe one day to live indefinitely, or to be able to come back from death -- which is not impossible, if we would define life as we must in order to know what kind of life we want to live for indefinite duration, or to restore when it is extinguished.

------------------

Again the ideas of the buddha are not that the body does not exist or that the thoughts, emotions and actions do not exist, but that it may be that our perseption of a self as the overarching connection between the things does not exist.

"...but that it may be that our perseption of a self as the overarching connection between the things does not exist."

That may be indicates the psychological hesitation, or reluctance, or even resistance to accept the existence of the self, and be liberated from all kinds of difficulties with the fact of admission on the one hand, but edging it with reservation and qualification, on the other.

One very radical axiom of skeptical criticism is KISS, meaning in the present context, keep it simple and short, in dealing with a philosophy of life.

Why don't you just say, I mean the Buddhists here, that there is a self and we love to keep it lasting as long as we can succeed in keeping it around and functional; and that sometimes we are weary of the self for it is a limited entity in terms of what we desire of it and life, but we will not let the frustration of unrealistic desires overcome us so that we give up on life, or indulge in a self-defeatist attitude.

Our determination should be: We will simply take of the good in the self and in life and bear with the ills that come along with the limitations and deficiencies of self and life, instead of denying the existence of the self altogether, but futilely and to no purpose whatsoever except to feel so what? transcendental?

In your example:
There is the body , motivated with thoughts and emotions, guided by perceptions and habilts which is engaged in an activity of cleaning a gun.

Perhaps not enough forethough was given in that there is a round in the gun and it discharges.

The body is injured by the bullet, there are thoughts and feelings and perception and habits.

When the doctor asks the person, how did you do this?

What does the word 'yourself' mean?

For myself the doctors are referring to the body when they use the word self in the question,"How did you shoot yourself?" Suppose you tell me if you had accidentally shot yourself and gone to the hospital, and the doctors asked you, "How did you shoot yourself?"

Do you think that a 'law' has some meaning outside of the human interactions in a community?
Do you think that an 'organization' or sports club has some existence other than through the interactions of it's members?

By law you mean law as in the law against infringement of copyright and patent?

The way I see it, there is no law as understood in the example above where there are no human interactions. What do you think?

An organization as for example a sports club is an entity created by convention of the members forming it, and given legal existence by the government for the purpose of safeguarding and enforcing all transactions, entered into by the members acting as a collectivity with other human entities like human individuals or other such similar collectivities.

Does such an organization continue to exist when the members do not engage in interactions among themselves and with outsiders, or even when all the members should cease to exist as when they should all die the biological death of the self?

We have to consult legal experts in corporations law, but I seem to know of a general principle in corporate law or similar such laws governing similar or analogous collectivities, that such an entity does not cease automatically unless the government gives it a certificate of dissolution or termination, what we might see as some sort of certificate of death. (Correct me legal experts here if I am mistaken.)

Such an organization is a moral self as distinct from a natural self, but it has real existence in the sense that it can transact acts with other moral or natural selves with binding force like transactions between purely natural selves.

Saying that the buddha taught that the self is the body would be an overgeneralization.

There is no evidence that a 'self' exists other than the body, thoughts, feeling,perceptions and habits. There is an aggregate of events, we refer to as the self. It is a reference, just like the word 'country', a country exists only in human concepts, it is a referant to a collection of things that are lumped together for convinience in human communications.

We are talking about the body as the self in regard to the human body, one with a head and limbs and organs functioning, a natural body. This kind of a self-body is not a creation of humans getting together to create a moral body like the sports club or even a huge collectivity like a country or a political state.

A human body is a self for all purposes of self until it is bereft of life signs and such signs can't no longer be restored with today's science and technology; it is still a self even should only the brain of such a natural self/body alone remains and survives in some nourishing fluids if brain waves can still be detected.

No, there is no essential identity between a natural human body and a country.

Over generalization?
You seem to ask the same questions and make the same generalizations over and over:

Can you prove that the self exists other than a human concepts used to refer to group of seperate events.

Does an orchestra exist outside of the collection of people playing musical instruments. When the concert hall is empty is the orchestra still there?

I think both you and I can prove the existence of a self, a human natural self that is, by the pinching test, pinch whoever is beside you and ask him to pinch you in return.

An orchestra is a moral self but it is already present even before the arrival of the concert goers and after their departure it is still present, as long as the natural selves making up the orchestra remain in the hall; and even when they leave the hall, as long as the members thereof are related together by their convention or agreement and specially when the government grants it a legal existence.

-------------

I suggest most heartily that Buddhists dwell most intensely and with the maximum of concentration on the topic of denial syndrome and apply the fruits of their meditation to Buddhist non-self.


Dancing_David said:
__________________

Also do something or stay away from Christmas .- S&S
Lemme guess, you were a humanities major in college? It would explain your shoddy critical thinking. -EvilYeti
If you do not exercise skepticism towards your own beliefs than you are not a skeptic in the original meaning of this term. You are a pseudo-skeptic or cynic. Your position is no better than the most starry eyed believer. Interesting Ian

Yes, I agree with you completely and unreservedly in those lines from you which I put in bold.


Yrreg
 
And it could not be otherwise for them, seeing that the only insight to life they entertain, and thereby their fundamental principle declares categorically, that all life is suffering;

This is a very common mistake about Buddhism. Buddhism, and the Buddha, never ever taught that life is suffering. If you had bothered to read the links to the Four Noble Truths I gave you earlier, which were not 'Buddhist texts' but introductions to the core of Buddhism, you would've seen that the closest teaching on this is the first Noble Truth, which states : There is suffering.

I assume you do not disagree on the fact that there is suffering.


One very radical axiom of skeptical criticism is KISS, meaning in the present context, keep it simple and short, in dealing with a philosophy of life.

This axiom applies very well to Buddhism. In fact, we keep it so simple and short that we see ourselves as the sum of our parts instead of introducing a self that does not stand up to critical scrutiny, or a magical soul. Buddhism is all about action and reaction, cause and effect.

I suggest most heartily that Buddhists dwell most intensely and with the maximum of concentration on the topic of denial syndrome and apply the fruits of their meditation to Buddhist non-self.

You say Buddhists are in self-denial, I say prove that the self exists! You claim that a simple pinch will solve this, but I don't believe it can, beyond all doubt. How do you prove the pain from the pinch is not an illusion?

But again, that's really not what Buddhism teaches! Buddhism teaches that there is no permanent self, a self that endures no matter what happens, be it brain damage, loss of limb, memory loss, personality change, influence of drugs and/or death.

You mentioned George Walker Bush as one who believes in this permanent self. But isn't Bush claiming to have been reborn? Is his self the same as before his rebirth?

Yes, I agree with you completely and unreservedly in those lines from you which I put in bold.

If you knew who Interesting Ian is, you wouldn't be so quick to put his words into your moth :D

But even so, I don't believe you will find another religion where the individual members not only use scepticism towards the teaching, but are actually encouraged to do so, in the same degree as Buddhism. Buddhism has no central authority, even amongst the three main denominations (Theravada, Mahayana, Tibetan Buddhism). Every sangha (a Buddhist community) and every individual is free to interpret the teachings as he or she will.

Getting to Buddhism was a verly long road for me, as I started out as an atheist, a sceptic and rabid opponent of everything religion. But to oppose religion, I needed knowledge in religion, so I studied them all. That's how I found Buddhism, or how Buddhism found me. I found out that I had been a Buddhist all this time! I'm still an atheist and a sceptic.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom