Skeptical criticism on Buddhist beliefs and observances.

Kung fu-tze and Kung fu.

I am fond of etymologies. I looked up the names
of Kung fu-tze and Kung fu, and the following snapshots
are what I have found about the two names.

(I really enjoyed pasting these snapshots here,
now without having to see the thumbnail attachment
always appearing at the bottom of the message.)



On the meaning of the name. Kung fu-tze:




Short bio of Kung fu-tze, Master Kong, or Confucius:




History of the term, Kung fu in the West:



Please proceed to next post.


Yrreg
 
The big deal of dukkha which is plainly, simply, and clearly suffering.

218
username #218 said:
Yrreg said:
1. Please, as you are Buddhists and searchers of Buddha's original words, as original as you can find them, please present here his most original or most authentic statement on suffering and its description.

No. This isn't relevant. If you desire this information, you do the research.

In fact I did try to find the most original and most authentic words of Buddha on suffering and its description. And I think I have read enough to state that his idea of suffering and his description of suffering is exactly what every man in the street knows suffering to be suffering, namely, anything that causes pain, ache, discomfort, sorrow, and angst: what I might call physical pain, emotional pain, and psychic pain.

And that is what Buddha if he ever thought about it, realized what namely suffering is all about. And anyone without being a Buddha and meditating years and years away from home and family, but with a little reflection and having lived life with all its ups and downs can see for himself, what suffering is all about.

Call it dukkha and try to bring in all kinds of aspects and nuances of pain, it is still all under the English word of suffering.

And that is why I keep having this impression that Buddhist masters try to dazzle or hoodwink people with attempts at profundity and subtlety when things are so simple. Why do they engage in those attempts? Why else but to make themselves look and sound so deep and so recondite, to convince themselves that they are so mystical, exactly as the Wordweb online dictionary defines mystical:

(3) Having an import not apparent to the senses nor obvious to the intelligence; beyond ordinary understanding...​

Anyway if the Buddhists here don't agree with my understanding of suffering, then I invite them to bring up the words of Buddha using the term, dukkha, and giving instances of dukkha, which everyone who knows suffering and English will tell you that Buddha means simply and plainly and clearly, suffering.


Yrreg
 
The four noble truths make up a contradiction impossible to untangle.

While I was looking up the words of Buddha on the truth of suffering, you know what I read from Muslim critics of Buddhism?

They point out something which logicians should see easily.

Here, examine the four noble truths, and see whether you can see the contradiction embedded in them.

1. existence is suffering (dukhka);
2. suffering has a cause, namely craving and attachment (trishna);
3. there is a cessation of suffering, which is nirvana;
4. and there is a path to the cessation of suffering, the “eightfold path” of
right views, right resolve, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and right concentration.

​

You don't see the contradiction as you seriously pursue the four noble truths and practice the eightfold path? the contradiction that will keep you forever eternally in suffering, and never ever let you get to Nirvana if Nirvana means anything worth getting to?

Okay, then look at it this way:

How can you persist perseveringly in the pursuit and practice of the eightfold path of right conduct, unless you desire to succeed in them? In which case you are chasing after a craving and an attachment continuously without any interruption; but if you don't have that craving and that attachment for the pursuit of the right conduct as enumerated in the eightfold path how are you ever going to arrive at cessation of suffering?

Think about that.


Yrreg
 
The way I've thought of it is that one is not going to reach nirvana or any state close itto it 24/7. Yet during meditation it might be possible, for a short time, to reach a perfect state. You also might be able to reduce the net amount of desire, delusion and attachement in your life even through the attachment to reaching the end goal.

Maybe the last step in reaching Nirvana is to stop striving for it?

I think it is a paradox that is well recognised by bhuddists and features in many texts.

Not that I'm a bhuddist mind. I find it an interesting way of looking at the world and I wanted to give meditation a go to see what happens when you try to let go of thought and attachment. As it turns out it's really quite a bizarre and englightening. As well as very difficult.
 
Last edited:
Try Stoicism, the spirituality for skeptics, very naturalistic.

I still think Buddhism is reminiscent of the
paranormal, the pseudoscience, and the supernatural,
which is what the JREF is inimical to.

Perhaps skeptics would like to try a philosophy
or lifestyle that might pass for spirituality,
without going into esoteric metaphysics, I would
suggest Stoicism.

Here below is a snapshot from the Free Encyclopedia
about Stoicism. Just correct me if Stoicism is also
full of the paranormal, the pseudoscience, and the
supernatural.



I enjoy learning how to upload images into this
JREF message board; and I seem to be getting
better and better. It's really fun and I am
acquiring a useful skill.

See if Buddhists can acquire useful skills
meditating on the four nobles truths.

The next task is to master resizing an image to fit
properly into the message box here.


Yrreg
 
Perhaps skeptics would like to try a philosophy
or lifestyle that might pass for spirituality,
without going into esoteric metaphysics, I would
suggest Stoicism.

Here below is a snapshot from the Free Encyclopedia
about Stoicism. Just correct me if Stoicism is also
full of the paranormal, the pseudoscience, and the
supernatural.
From your links:

the foundation of Stoic ethics is that good lies in the state of the soul itself;
Soul?

Living according to reason and virtue, they held, is to live in harmony with the divine order of the universe
Feel free to explain "the divine order of the universe"...

The Stoics held Logos to be the animating or "active principle" of all reality. The Logos was conceived as a conduit for divine power that, in essence, orders and directs the universe. Human reason and the human soul were both considered adjuncts of the Logos, and therefore immortal via the continual recycling of the universe.
Feel free to explain "Logos", and what the "divine power" is and how it orders and directs the universe. Also the "soul" and immortality etc...

So you consider talk of "souls", "divine orders", "divine power", "immortality" less metaphysical, supernatural, paranormal and less pseudoscientific than Buddhism which doesn't rely on such things or require such beliefs? Odd indeed...
 
I enjoy learning how to upload images into this
JREF message board; and I seem to be getting better and better. It's really fun and I am acquiring a useful skill.

A far more useful skill is cutting and pasting, which makes it a lot easier to read and quote from you.
 
Thanks for the advisement, Pragmatist.

Originally Posted by yrreg :
Perhaps skeptics would like to try a philosophy
or lifestyle that might pass for spirituality,
without going into esoteric metaphysics, I would
suggest Stoicism.

Here below is a snapshot from the Free Encyclopedia
about Stoicism. Just correct me if Stoicism is also
full of the paranormal, the pseudoscience, and the
supernatural.​

From your links:

Soul?

Feel free to explain "the divine order of the universe"...

Feel free to explain "Logos", and what the "divine power" is and how it orders and directs the universe. Also the "soul" and immortality etc...

So you consider talk of "souls", "divine orders", "divine power", "immortality" less metaphysical, supernatural, paranormal and less pseudoscientific than Buddhism which doesn't rely on such things or require such beliefs? Odd indeed...

I have to read more on Stoicism and see how it differs from Buddhism, and why I have the impression that Buddhism is not as naturalistic as I seem to see with Stoicism.

Maybe you might want to consider adopting the opposing lifestyle to Stoicism, Epicureanism, which also from my stock knowledge is purely naturalistic.

Why do I imagine that Buddhism is not naturalistic? Because it makes of the moral order or rightness and wrongness -- consider the eightfold path or eight kinds of rightness -- the cosmic order; and I have the idea that the cosmic order or the universe as known in today's science is a naturalistic universe, there is no rightness and wrongness in it.

Where does rightness and wrongness come from? It comes from human values constituted from several factors, like religion, constraints of settled society, decency, survival of the species.

But in the universe before man's appearance and after man's appearance and outside man's history there is no moral order, it is to my impression all a blind universe.

And I think that Buddhism is basically a moralistic philosophy whereby the universe is a moralistic one. You notice that there is a continuous evaluating of human behavior on the basis of rightness in order that an individual will be spared ultimately from recurring rebirths and be what? absorbed into Nirvana, whatever that be, which if anything is the final end of man.

Anyway, thanks for your correction or observation about Stoicism being involved also with the soul, and the divine, and therefore also the supernatural.

I will have to do some more reading about Stoicism and Epicureanism, and see whether they are in fact purely naturalistic, but for your information about the use of certain words like soul, divine, in the encyclopedia article.

Yrreg
 
Try doing this...

A far more useful skill is cutting and pasting, which makes it a lot easier to read and quote from you.

See if you can cut and paste the following graphic in a message, like I have done here, below.



Then tell me how you do it, that should be a great service of goodness from your part.

See if doing Buddhist meditation will enable you to do what I have done above.


Yrreg
 
See if you can cut and paste the following graphic in a message, like I have done here, below.



Then tell me how you do it, that should be a great service of goodness from your part.

See if doing Buddhist meditation will enable you to do what I have done above.


Yrreg

I tried, and... lo and behold, it worked!

header_text.gif


ETA : I guess I must return to my meditating, it doesn't seem to have worked perfectly.
 
218

In fact I did try to find the most original and most authentic words of Buddha on suffering and its description. And I think I have read enough to state

In my last post to you I asked you twice to acknowledge a particular thing I said. I indicated twice that if you posted to me again and did not acknowledge that piece of information I would not discuss this topic with you further.

you have not acknowledged that piece of information I requested of you twice in my last post with you therefore I am done discussing this issue with you.

You appear to desire to lecture on a topic you refuse to understand, and not listen.

There is no value in my continuing to talk if you won't listen.
 
No, you didn't get that by Buddhist meditation.

I tried, and... lo and behold, it worked!

header_text.gif


ETA : I guess I must return to my meditating, it doesn't seem to have worked perfectly.

Jjramsey, if you want to know how Ryokan did that trick above, ask me and I will tell you.

No, Ryokan did not learn that from Buddhist meditation, and he did not do it by the cut and paste routine, on the graphic as shown on your computer screen.

Now, I am waiting for Ryokan to arrive at what I have done above in reproducing that complete logo of Randi_org, from Buddhist meditation that is.

randicon6pi.gif


Maybe Ryokan can do some experimentation with meditation, on mundane matters and see if he can get somewhere; what about you, Jjramsey? like this: sit on your haunches in the best tradition of Buddhist meditation posture, do deep breathing, close you eyes, now try thinking of the non-self -- but first I assume even Buddhists have to formulate some kind of intention about what they are heading after in meditation.

Ryokan is an old poster here, he will know how to reproduce that logo from my post, and he will succeed; but that would be dishonest, because he would be doing essentially now a copying and pasting routine.


Anyway, Jjramsey, if you like to know how to put a graphic in a message box here, ask me and I will tell you how -- as I learned all by myself, searching for instructions in this forum page, and also experimenting around, and making use of the applications from Microsoft Word and Paintbrush, and doing some scouting around with Google.


Yes, I am still trying to find the best ways and means for resizing a graphic to a scale that will fit in properly in the message box of this forum.

It is a good pastime and more important brings me a skill, useful for anyone engrossed in computer and internet tasks.

But back to Buddhism, it is a system of thought and behavior that might allow you to feel that you are into some transcendentally momentous undertaking, stretching from your mother's womb to the tomb and beyond, but aside from that feeling will not produce so much as a grain of wheat, or get air into a deflated car tire.


Yrreg
 
Jjramsey, if you want to know how Ryokan did that trick above, ask me and I will tell you.

Actually, I've already done it before. My point was that it is silly to paste in images when pasting text will not only do but do better, since as I said before, doing the latter "makes it a lot easier to read and quote from you."
 
;
4. and there is a path to the cessation of suffering, the “eightfold path” of
right views, right resolve, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and right concentration.

​
[/indent]

You don't see the contradiction as you seriously pursue the four noble truths and practice the eightfold path? the contradiction that will keep you forever eternally in suffering, and never ever let you get to Nirvana if Nirvana means anything worth getting to?

Okay, then look at it this way:

How can you persist perseveringly in the pursuit and practice of the eightfold path of right conduct, unless you desire to succeed in them? In which case you are chasing after a craving and an attachment continuously without any interruption; but if you don't have that craving and that attachment for the pursuit of the right conduct as enumerated in the eightfold path how are you ever going to arrive at cessation of suffering?

Think about that.


Yrreg


That is of course a possibility, that a student would strive for enlightement , and crave the release that they percieve to be Nirvana. And I am sure that there are practioners of buddhism who do so.

Yet the teachers would advise against it:

The Buddha was once asked, "What is it that prevents us from being enlightened, being liberated in this very life?" He replied that it's attachment to sensual pleasures -- sensual delight through the eye, ears, nose, tongue, body. "One with craving and clinging is unable to experience nibbana in this very life; one without clinging is able to experience nibbana in this very life."
Sorry the following is a very long citation but it does adress the point directly:
Third, the Buddha points to silabbatupadana, or clinging to rules and vows, to precepts and practices that one assumes will lead to purity. Oftentimes it's translated as "attachment to rites and rituals." One becomes attached to superstitious beliefs like receiving blessings by being sprinkled with holy water or by bathing in the Ganges, which were common practices in the time of the Buddha. The mind carries it through in so many ways.We try to do the right thing, to get everything lined up in our conduct or through our practices. Spreading lovingkindness, doing dedications of blessings, even seeing everything as anicca, dukkha, anatta -- these can be just as much a rite or ritual as anything else. Simply repeating in the mind "this is impermanent, unsatisfactory and not self" will not purify one. This is definitely a practice the Buddha taught, but it's important to be attentive to how it is being held.
This doesn't mean we shouldn't do certain practices or devotional rituals. But just doing these practices is not what is going to bring about purification. True accomplishment comes when we really give ourselves to the practice, putting in effort in a way that is not self-oriented or self-fixated. Are we able to drop what "I want to get out of it," or the obsession with getting everything right, even in terms of the precepts? One has to recognize that the training is for the attenuation of clinging and attachment. What really wears us out is when we don't notice our attachments, clinging and seeking. The idea of "I'm doing the practice" gets in the way of being attentive to what's happening in the heart and mind.When we are attentive, we can actually do the practice and enjoy it, delight in it and benefit from the results.


http://www.saigon.com/~anson/ebud/ebdha284.htm
 
Last edited:
I
Why do I imagine that Buddhism is not naturalistic? Because it makes of the moral order or rightness and wrongness -- consider the eightfold path or eight kinds of rightness -- the cosmic order; and I have the idea that the cosmic order or the universe as known in today's science is a naturalistic universe, there is no rightness and wrongness in it.

I have ofetn wondered about the use of the 'right' in the eightfold path but have not reasercehed the sankrit words attributed to the buddha, in my own personal restatement, itend to use the word 'gentle', but then I feel that I can cut and paste my morals beliefs. My understanding is that the 'right' means the 'right way to end suffering'. But again I have not researched the origins.
And I think that Buddhism is basically a moralistic philosophy whereby the universe is a moralistic one. You notice that there is a continuous evaluating of human behavior on the basis of rightness in order that an individual will be spared ultimately from recurring rebirths and be what? absorbed into Nirvana, whatever that be, which if anything is the final end of man.

That is your interpretation, as has been discussed before nibbanna translates as extinguishment, of desire attachment and suffering. A buddhist need not live thier life in seclusion and seperate from the world, but as a part of a living vibrant world.
Or so have many of the teachers done.
 
sit on your haunches in the best tradition of Buddhist meditation posture, do deep breathing, close you eyes, now try thinking of the non-self -- but first I assume even Buddhists have to formulate some kind of intention about what they are heading after in meditation.
That is not what I was taught, it would be a different practise than has been taught by the teachers I have met.

I have been told :
focus on the breathing, either the rising of the diaphram with the inbreath and it's descent with the out breath, or merely the passage of ait in and out of the nostrils.
in the begining of the practise it does help to close the eyes and sit someplace quite. Those who are more comfortable in a chair should sit in a chair.
focus on breathing.
when you find yourself thinking , say to yourself gently, 'thinking' and focus on the breathing.
cont.

This is the practise as I was taught it, the purpose if to eventualy reach a place where thinking and perception are reconnised and the thinking is lessened.
It is very interesting what a busy place the mind can be and how the thoughts arise and fall.

That is the practise as I was taught it.
Other practises vary.
.

But back to Buddhism, it is a system of thought and behavior that might allow you to feel that you are into some transcendentally momentous undertaking, stretching from your mother's womb to the tomb and beyond, but aside from that feeling will not produce so much as a grain of wheat, or get air into a deflated car tire.


Yrreg

That may be. And certainly some people may percieve things that way. My understanding is that the practise is to learn to live in the moment, and that transcendance is not the goal.

You keep stating that buddhists are non-productive, if you plant, tend and harvest the wheat mindfully and without harming yourself and others, that is a buddhist practise.
If you change a car tire without adding to your suffering, but with joy and mindfullness, that is a buddhist practise.

There is monastic buddhism, and there are many buddhists who live outside the monastery, and as in other monasteries there are buddhist ones where farming and other trades are practised, but they are very rare. At least from my limited understanding.

Edited to add this

Very limited undertsanding according to this.
The parallels between the role of respect in Buddhist practice and in manual skills explains why many Buddhist teachers require their students to master a manual skill as a prerequisite or a part of their meditation. A person with no manual skills will have little intuitive understanding of how to balance respect.


http://hinduwebsite.com/buddhism/essays/openingdoor.htm
 
Last edited:
But back to Buddhism, it is a system of thought and behavior that might allow you to feel that you are into some transcendentally momentous undertaking, stretching from your mother's womb to the tomb and beyond, but aside from that feeling will not produce so much as a grain of wheat, or get air into a deflated car tire.

Yrreg

So this was your end from the beginning. To put down buddhism.

May I ask why you couldn't have been honest with us? Why not just make a thread titled "Buddhism sucks ass!"?

If your goal was to simply put down buddhism you could have done so without wasting the time of several people.

As I have said before, I am not a buddhist, I have simply gotten interested in it from Ryokan's posts and have been doing some reading. Even with my limited understanding (I have practiced meditation exactly twice since this undertaking) I can see you don't have a clue to what buddhism is and when you speak of meditation you don't appear to have a clue as to how that is practiced either in the buddhist traditions.

Yet, you criticise.

You criticise what you do not understand even though your questions have been answered. Still you do not understand or appear to try, but you continue to criticise.

You may fancy yourself a skeptic, but a skeptic knows to first correctly understand a claim before criticising it. To do otherwise is to erect and attack strawmen which is what you have been doing. Such behavior is unworthy of being called skepticism and is fit only to be called lazy.

Now if only someone less lazy and more honest would come along and make a thread for skeptical examination of buddhism, we might all profit from the discussion. This thread has just been a waste of time while you attempt to make yourself feel intelligent at the expense of people you don't know and whose ways you do refuse to understand.
 
My purpose here is...

What is skeptical criticism of Buddhism?

But allow me first to refer the Buddhists here to my very first post in this thread, the title of which is "Skeptical criticism on Buddhist beliefs and observances."

Here below is a snapshot of the first post from yours truly.



My purpose is really
to meet with skeptics here who can tell me how Buddhist doctrines like rebirths and Nirvana cannot stand up to skeptical criticism.

And also the usefulness of meditation, specially that of the Zen school.​

But I am disappointed that I am not meeting the kind of skeptical critics here as I was thinking of meeting, instead I have come across Buddhists who feel they have to make known to me how Buddhism is not what I think it to be.

I admire your zeal, but I reserve the liberty to judge your explanation and defense according to my criteria on fair and academic skeptical criticism of Buddhism, for which I was and am still expecting to meet with people having my kind of skeptical criticism.

So far the most congenial to my idea of a skeptical critic is Epepke, but he is not around all the time.

Why should Buddhists bother about skeptical critics like yours truly, judging Buddhism on their idea of what is skeptical criticism, and exchanging views among themselves, the critics that is?

Good Buddhist friends here, there are religious people like yourselves, for example, the Amish, who don't bother with explaining their beliefs and their practices; they would not care less how outsiders study them and ascertain themselves, the outsiders that is, that Amish beliefs and practices are not in accordance with their idea of the objective laws and facts of nature and science, as they perceive them to be within their concept of a naturalistic universe.


I believe I have time and again stated that my purpose here is not to lend a sympathetic ear to Buddhism, but to scrutinize it meticulously in the light of science and logic, and to hear others similar to myself expressing also their critical observations.

Why am I interested in doing my kind of skeptical criticism on Buddhism? Because it arouses my curiosity.

Considering that in the marketplace of ideas there are already innumerable skeptical critics who are uncompromising in their probing examination of paranormal phenomena, pseudoscience, and the supernatural, and religions, I notice that almost no one has turned his attention to Buddhism.

So I think that I might do something different, specially noticing that Buddhism seems to be favored by Westerners of the intellectual types.

As Buddhists here keep on insisting that I don't know what I am criticizing about in Buddhism, so also I keep on bringing up issues and aspects in regard to Buddhism, over which I also think that I have applied skeptical criticism validly.

And that is to the best for us both, the Buddhists here and myself, in that we are keeping our cerebral cells active and healthy and productive, by continuing this exchange.

But I wish more skeptics like Epepke would join me.

In the meantime, please don't imagine that I am into some kind of conspiracy with anti-Buddhist agenda -- not flattering myself though; for someone here has accused me on quite arbitrary grounds with being earlier a member of some Western cult and then later an adherent of some Hindu sect.

Hahaha and hehehe. Can't anyone engage in some sound skeptical criticism of Buddhism without being identified with some religious fundamentalist groups?

Before I forget, what is skeptical criticism of Buddhism? In my view, it is to look at Buddhism and judge it in the light of science and logic as science and logic are the tools in our knowledge and mastery as much as possible of what we might call the purely naturalistic universe, that of matter and energy and the laws governing them.


Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom