My purpose here is...
What is skeptical criticism of Buddhism?
But allow me first to refer the Buddhists here to my very first post in this thread, the title of which is "Skeptical criticism on Buddhist beliefs and observances."
Here below is a snapshot of the first post from yours truly.
My purpose is really
to meet with skeptics here who can tell me how Buddhist doctrines like rebirths and Nirvana cannot stand up to skeptical criticism.
And also the usefulness of meditation, specially that of the Zen school.
But I am disappointed that I am not meeting the kind of skeptical critics here as I was thinking of meeting, instead I have come across Buddhists who feel they have to make known to me how Buddhism is not what I think it to be.
I admire your zeal, but I reserve the liberty to judge your explanation and defense according to my criteria on fair and academic skeptical criticism of Buddhism, for which I was and am still expecting to meet with people having my kind of skeptical criticism.
So far the most congenial to my idea of a skeptical critic is Epepke, but he is not around all the time.
Why should Buddhists bother about skeptical critics like yours truly, judging Buddhism on their idea of what is skeptical criticism, and exchanging views among themselves, the critics that is?
Good Buddhist friends here, there are religious people like yourselves, for example, the Amish, who don't bother with explaining their beliefs and their practices; they would not care less how outsiders study them and ascertain themselves, the outsiders that is, that Amish beliefs and practices are not in accordance with their idea of the objective laws and facts of nature and science, as they perceive them to be within their concept of a naturalistic universe.
I believe I have time and again stated that my purpose here is not to lend a sympathetic ear to Buddhism, but to scrutinize it meticulously in the light of science and logic, and to hear others similar to myself expressing also their critical observations.
Why am I interested in doing my kind of skeptical criticism on Buddhism? Because it arouses my curiosity.
Considering that in the marketplace of ideas there are already innumerable skeptical critics who are uncompromising in their probing examination of paranormal phenomena, pseudoscience, and the supernatural, and religions, I notice that almost no one has turned his attention to Buddhism.
So I think that I might do something different, specially noticing that Buddhism seems to be favored by Westerners of the intellectual types.
As Buddhists here keep on insisting that I don't know what I am criticizing about in Buddhism, so also I keep on bringing up issues and aspects in regard to Buddhism, over which I also think that I have applied skeptical criticism validly.
And that is to the best for us both, the Buddhists here and myself, in that we are keeping our cerebral cells active and healthy and productive, by continuing this exchange.
But I wish more skeptics like Epepke would join me.
In the meantime, please don't imagine that I am into some kind of conspiracy with anti-Buddhist agenda -- not flattering myself though; for someone here has accused me on quite arbitrary grounds with being earlier a member of some Western cult and then later an adherent of some Hindu sect.
Hahaha and hehehe. Can't anyone engage in some sound skeptical criticism of Buddhism without being identified with some religious fundamentalist groups?
Before I forget, what is skeptical criticism of Buddhism? In my view, it is to look at Buddhism and judge it in the light of science and logic as science and logic are the tools in our knowledge and mastery as much as possible of what we might call the purely naturalistic universe, that of matter and energy and the laws governing them.
Yrreg