Skeptical criticism on Buddhist beliefs and observances.

I distrust this. I know that I would be a lot happier with more money. I know that I am happier right now because I got some money for Christmas. I get to pay my medical bills for a couple of months, and I get to have my broken wisdom tooth pulled. This makes me feel a lot better. Surely, those who say that "money does not buy happiness" are missing the point. It may not, but lack of money definitely buys unhappiness, and the bills are always paid.

This is inherently because the "happiness" you speak of is different from the sort of "happiness" (or contentment) that Buddhism attempts to achieve. You're talking of being happy within the framework that Buddhism hovers over, as a sort of meta-framework. This is sort of hard to explain, but basically things such as broken wisdom teeth and other things one can be made happy by money are essentially quite ephemeral. I hope you don't try to mock this sort of statement by saying that the pain is real and such, Buddhism has a sort of detached, meta-cognitive view on life.. as such it's easily under attack by those who never try to think in the Buddhist point of view.

I'm not saying that you are wrong -- certainly on the pragmatic level you are right. What I'm saying is that your arguments are missing the point.
 
The way I see it, the man had a terrific sense of self-importance, what we might say with certainty, saturated with a grand messianic complex.

Again yrreg, what teachings of the buddha would lead you to believe this, I will state again, this is what may make you a sceptic of the buddha but not a general sceptic. You just say this because it is what you think and feel.
You have offered no evidence to support your beliefs, you are just projecting yourself onto the world, and claiming yourself as the world.
So please substantiate your claim with something other than your personal thought.

The buddha did not stand on the street corners like a street preacher, he did not advertise his arrival in a town.

The first people he spoke to about his thought were his former teachers, not the piblic at large.

So where is any evidence that he had a messianic complex?
He does not say so, but he feels so. Or he says the opposite but feels himself so very important, chosen by destiny to give mankind the answer to the most important question they must ask, and the the answer they must have.

You are the only one saying this, the buddha never claimed that his teachings were so, it has been written in this thread many times:
The buddha never taught that his was the only path, he never taught that his was the only answer, he never taught that his thoughts were important.
He constantly stated to his student that they must examine the thoughts and teachings and decide for themselves that they might be true.
When he meets the founder of Jainism, they both greet each other and go thier ways.
You are again projecting yourself, with no evidence that what you say is what the buddha taught.
That is most unsceptical.
And who knows the question and the answer? Who else but he, Buddha.
He never said his was the only questions or the only answer.
Well, he is not alone among the innumerable self-important guys who know the question and the answer.

What is the most challenging probe is how he succeeded like as other founders of religion succeeded, for example, Moses, Jesus Christ, Mohammad, and one L. Ron Hubbard.

The secret is in his personality, in his times, and in his audience.

Anyone the way I see it can succeed also with founding a religion or a system like that similar to Buddha's.

If you can see ahead to fifty years of good health, you can start today preaching your particular kind of philosophico-religious system; but first you have got to be perplexed yourself by the question of what is existence and all the caboodle and then fashion your own answer.

Start convincing people that your question is what they should be most preoccupied with, and the answer they want is what you have found out to be the one.
The buddha never taught this, you are the one, who acts this way, you are the one who without knowledge, evidence or any support says that what you believe is right, you don't study what you talk about, you only ask that others agree with you.
Look in the mirror yrreg, the buddha is the mirror and you only see yourself, you ignore the buddha and only state nonsense that is your own beliefs and preconceptions.

This is why I believe that you are a fyndamentalist, if the buddha was the earth and buddhism is geology, you are analogous to the creationists who say,
I do not have to study the earth,
I do not have to study geology.
Only what I think and believe is true, I don't have to offer evidnece or proof, only what I think matter.
Very unsceptical.
Work at that for five years, ten, twenty, twenty-five, and you will succeed. Why? Because there's a sucker born every minute looking for a teacher and leader to follow.

Then you can start living fabulously on your followers.

Did Buddha live fabulously on his followers, not carnally but oh so psychically, what a high he was on all the time; he would not exchange that for a harem of houris, a mansion like that of Bill Gates, and luxurious jet liners; no, not for him the lifestyle of the rich and famous, but yes recognition as the what, last of the Buddha and the ultimate one, after him no more greater and better.
A sceptics would look at the evidence, you have merely supplanted your own culture and beliefs and put them on the buddha, what you see is only your own thoghts and your own beliefs.
If asked for evidence you will only state:
I do not have evidence, I do not need evidence, I am only here for fun.
That is your just engaging in mental masturabation, a show that is your stage , your actors, your scripts and your audience.
Only you, not the world.
Very unsceptical.
And even before he died and against his feigned protestations, he was already recognized as a god and treated and prayed to as one.
And if we think you are a fool, does that make you one?
Or is that only our mistaken belief.
[Cynical hahaha and hehehe.]

I almost forget, whatever philosophico-religious order you go into, never, never, ever, go against but instead recognize and advocate the universal moral and civilized values of mankind, like the eightfold path and the ten commandments, sanctity of home and family, marriage, peace and order in society.


Yrreg

The only person you are talking to is yourself, it must be fun to laugh by yourself.
be blessed in yourself, and you live Yrreg, may you find joy, comfort and happiness, may you be nourished and free from ill, may you have friends and family that are content and well.
 
Here is an approximation of that 'in a nutshell':




There is a thread under the area of "forum help and member support" called "Custom title please". You can request a label there. This might be less conspicuous than text in an avatar, which tends to look like you need help.
A link to the thread is here:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=45138

If I were prone to give advice (which I'm not), I would take the advice of several earlier posters and narrow your criticism. Buddhism is very broad, and some of what you post is mistaken, similar to accusing Protestants of worshiping the Pope. I suspect that most Buddhists would welcome answering specific criticisms (well, once anyway), but asking them how many times they beat their wives is not likely to provoke a response.


I am afraid that Yrreg cares only for his own thoughts and ranting, it is likely that he will ignore your post and never respond to anyone but himself.
 
Also, I have to say that while attributing suffering to something inside the individual might result from a genuine desire to help, it is also a brilliant invention for someone who wishes to maintain a class-based society. If suffering is inside the individual and should properly be addressed with meditation and so forth and so on, well, that's quite a handy idea for a ruling class that wants to live well in a low-calorie-per-capita society. Ultimately, though, in Nietzschean terms, it's based on ressentiment, a process by which people who have no power to effect change claim their lack of power as a moral strength.
A very telling point to which I have few counters, the buddha did admit and allow for all castes to enter the sangha, he did teach that all should be treated equally and the like. I didn't view his practise as say like the catholic church supporting the political structure , because like jesus he encouraged people to live outside the structure.

But it is a very telling point from the modern stand point of action based change as opposed to internal based change.

I don't believe that the buddha told people to accept thier life as it was, it is more that they taught that if you discard the fretting and lusting and wailing, then you can procede with your life as it is, and do what you do more effectively.

Thich Naht Hahn did not accept the Vietnam war, in his own fashion he worked to end it, as it ravaged his country.
 
What sort of evidence would you want? If the writings of meditators for centuries is anything to go by, it's impossible to define englightenment in words or writing thus making this untestable. Areas of experience and consciousness like this are, as it stands, not suited to scientific evaluation.

I'm not the one who has to figure out what would be evidence; that's up to the person making the empirical claim. If it's unfalsifiable, call a spade a spade: faith.

Have you tried to meditate and stay in mindfulness? From my experience you can develop an altered consciousness which one might describe as being more awake. It's a state of non-judgement.

I've had an awful lot of mental states. Once when I had hypnotized myself, I got my heart to stop, or at least flutter very quickly without beating, for a few seconds. (Thanks to another thread for suggesting a possible mechanism.) I'm willing to bet that you haven't done that.

I've also learned to do something in my brain that feels a lot like getting my endorphine receptors filled, and I'm willing to bet that you can't do that either.

My natural state is not to judge, except for one reservation I make only when writing on fora, that of judging intelligence.
 
A very telling point to which I have few counters, the buddha did admit and allow for all castes to enter the sangha, he did teach that all should be treated equally and the like. I didn't view his practise as say like the catholic church supporting the political structure , because like jesus he encouraged people to live outside the structure.

Admirable. But I think that, as most religions have been criticized, possibly not in original intent but in execution, as control mechanisms, I think that such a criticism is equally valid to Buddhism.

I do think that, whatever the degree of nefarious intent (and I'm not going to get into particular monsters here), Buddhism can provide a handy handle for blaming the victim.
 
Asking me to prove buddhism is like asking me to prove velvet is soft and feels good. I can try to explain it and prove it objectively, but will fail.

I can give blindfolded people samples of velvet and sandpaper, double-blind, and derive conclusions from that.

You forget what I've said several times about two kinds of skepticism. If the experience cannot be examined, then the effect of the experience on walking-around-type-people can be.
 
Yes, and I know this one self-proclaimed christian who runs this 'god hates fags' website. I know another one who seems to believe having this rosary around the rear view mirror in her car somehow brings her good luck. Have I said anything at all about Christianity or the teachings of Jesus or have I simply said some things about the man who runs the website and the woman who hangs the rosary in her car?

That's a good question.

With respect to Christianity, there's a thing called the Nicene Creed. It has words. I can compare words that are said with the words that are in the Nicene Creed.

However, in this thread, I have seen repeatedly that anyone who self-identifies as a Buddhist probably is. So how can I compare the words? Especially since Gautama Buddha said that one should not trust the words.
 
Two comments.

1. About the possession of money, the way I see it --

and it is my honest view not borrowed from any teacher or master or guru or some enlightened Buddha coming to you in some costume, and using words which they have to qualify on and on and on until you wonder whether he might in fact gotten lost, or have inextricably entrapped himself, looking with heavenward lifted eyes and sighing deeply, and also maybe with eyes half closed or fully closed to not see the world, as in those massive structures of Buddha on his haunches...

-- the genuine test of detachment can only be administered legitimately to people with plenty of money, not to people without money; and solid happiness can only be present in people with a lot of money, not in those with insufficient money that they can't overcome desire to stay alive and well -- and thereby is suffering (I agree with Buddha here).

About Buddhists being detached from money, I think it will be most rewarding to make a survey how Buddhist masters and monks live compared to the average people, and how many Buddhist monks or ascetics today are living like true beggars who do lead life of destitution, or as beasts of the forest without a thought for the morrow.

2. About the knowledge that comes from experience of which some Buddhists here keep harping that their adherence to Buddhism comes from their expediences with it, which validate the truth of Buddhism.

That kind of experience they talk about is not the kind that can be studied in the laboratory as regards the objects of their experience. For example, someone tells us that karma is certainly true because he experiences it, the same also with Buddhists who tell us that Nirvana is true because they experience it; indeed, the experience can be seen in the oscilloscopes in the appearance of waves but the target of the experience, are they present to the experiencer when he is not experiencing? unlike experiencing the sun rising and the sun setting which leads everyone to appreciate the beauty of such a scenery.

If patriotism is the last refuge of politicians and warmongers, then experience of the mystical kind is the last refuge of a subject in hallucination, or delusion, or illusion.


Yrreg
 
This is inherently because the "happiness" you speak of is different from the sort of "happiness" (or contentment) that Buddhism attempts to achieve. You're talking of being happy within the framework that Buddhism hovers over, as a sort of meta-framework. This is sort of hard to explain, but basically things such as broken wisdom teeth and other things one can be made happy by money are essentially quite ephemeral. I hope you don't try to mock this sort of statement by saying that the pain is real and such, Buddhism has a sort of detached, meta-cognitive view on life.. as such it's easily under attack by those who never try to think in the Buddhist point of view.

I'm not saying that you are wrong -- certainly on the pragmatic level you are right. What I'm saying is that your arguments are missing the point.

I will not mock your statements.

However, I will for a moment point out the obvious, that I am making these statements as experiments to see the reactions. So when you tell me that I am missing the point, you're missing the point. It's still good data, though.
 
I will not mock your statements.

However, I will for a moment point out the obvious, that I am making these statements as experiments to see the reactions. So when you tell me that I am missing the point, you're missing the point. It's still good data, though.

I don't doubt I'm missing the point, because I didn't read your post in full.. :D Just seeing the amount of text on the page, along with yrreg's posts give me quite a headache. So I just skim.. :D:eek:
 
That kind of experience they talk about is not the kind that can be studied in the laboratory as regards the objects of their experience. For example, someone tells us that karma is certainly true because he experiences it, the same also with Buddhists who tell us that Nirvana is true because they experience it;

Yrreg

What, exactly, are you struggling against?

Strip away 2,500 years of human packaging, ritualizing, tacking on cultural and religious trappings and what do you have? The teachings of Buddha, the 4 noble truths. Forget all the other stuff the essence of buddhism, the cornerstone upon which it stands or falls, is the 4 noble truths. The buddha taught that there was nothing esoteric about his teaching, all humans were capable of seeing for themselves where the path he presented led to. Forget the buddha, he is dead and not relevant to being awake. Certainly respect is due if one finds his teachings to be of benefit, but the guy was human and a product of his place/time.

Forget karma, it isn't important. There is nothing about karma in the 4 noble truths. All this stuff is trappings. Maybe they are true, maybe they are not, it simply isn't relevant to awakening.

Either your investigation leads you to a point where you begin practice or it does not. I submit to you that if you understand what being awake/enlightened is you would likely realize you have spent a brief moment or two awake already in your life. It is direct perception of what is being seen before the brain begins conceptualizing it. As such it is completely natural, nothing metaphysical about it. Further, our minds are already seeing, directly perceiving so there is nothing to do in terms of developing special abilities, everyone already has the ability and is directly perceiving what we see, we simply don't pay any attention to it as we have confused our mind's conceptualizations of what we see, with the thing we see. We see the terrain, but our mind conceptualizes it as a map. We have mistaken the map for the terrain.

Perhaps you experienced this with a lover, observing a work of art, out in nature, walking in a crowded area, who knows? Have you never, not even for a moment in your life had a brief moment where you simply saw what you were examining and became aware of it with your mind seeming to have slipped out of gear and the conceptualizing, the labeling, the categorizing, the association with prior beliefs, experiences and all that 'stuff' our brains habitually do began?

To be awake means to see like that. It is something we all do every moment, we simply don't pay any attention to it, we see something and we are asleep to what we see, we allow our busy, tireless minds to conceptualize what we have seen and we regard these constructs of the mind as reality when in fact concepts and conceptualizations can't be reality any more than a map can be the terrain it conceptualizes.

Waking up to what we are already experiencing is enlightenment, buddhahood, whatever you wish to call it.

That it is possible is self evidently true to anyone who has experienced it, even for a brief moment and was caught off guard by it. I rather suspect most people who have reached adult years can recall at least one such moment in their lives.
 
One of my favorite Zen stories is about a man who asks a Zen master what happens to people after they die.

'I have no idea', the master told him.

'What!?', the man explaimed, 'but aren't you supposed to be a Zen master?'

'I am', the master replied, 'but I'm not a dead one.')

A pure Zen answer. Nice. What else is there to discuss about?

Buddhism is like anything people in here are accustomed to discuss about.
 
I don't doubt I'm missing the point, because I didn't read your post in full.. :D Just seeing the amount of text on the page, along with yrreg's posts give me quite a headache. So I just skim.. :D:eek:

Fair enough.
 
About the experience or the attainment or the arrival in regard to Nirvana, what is it?

Ahh, can someone explain what is to see to a blind person? But if I tell you that you have to see for yourself you are right in that that doesn't say anything.

Still, you have to see for yourself. Happy paradox.
 
Why reach Nirvana, "a state of nothingness", during life when it is evident that this state happens in death without even trying?

Tricky question, easy answer:

If you awake yourself to that what you already are (this is, if you really embrace it) there will be no trace of the human you were before. This allows "you" to experiment a kind of life that no human can live.

Humans are trapped inside their heads, busy thinking, planning, doing, worried about their retirement plans, about the money they will spend today.

Sure, thats good for some of them, but there are others who will choose different.

That is nice.
 
2. About the knowledge that comes from experience of which some Buddhists here keep harping that their adherence to Buddhism comes from their expediences with it, which validate the truth of Buddhism.
You ought to be on talk radio, no one here who has discussed buddhism at lenth has made any claims for the 'truth' of buddhism.
I think that most people here have stated quite the opposite, that the teachings of the buddha can be examined to see if they have value in one's own life. If so they can be used , if not then not.
That kind of experience they talk about is not the kind that can be studied in the laboratory as regards the objects of their experience.
And that is more of just the words that come from your mouth. You have never studied social science, and so know you will drone endlessly about yet more that you have no knowledge of. The experience of human live can be studied and gosh even quantified. there are things like the Beck Depression Inventory or quality of life surveys. They tools with varying degrees of accuracy and validity.
For example, someone tells us that karma is certainly true because he experiences it, the same also with Buddhists who tell us that Nirvana is true because they experience it;
Who said that this is truth?
Oh, I see , it is just you saying that it is true.
indeed, the experience can be seen in the oscilloscopes in the appearance of waves but the target of the experience, are they present to the experiencer when he is not experiencing? unlike experiencing the sun rising and the sun setting which leads everyone to appreciate the beauty of such a scenery.
blah blah blah, all fluff.
If patriotism is the last refuge of politicians and warmongers, then experience of the mystical kind is the last refuge of a subject in hallucination, or delusion, or illusion.


Yrreg

And believe in the words that come out of ones own mouth is the refuge of people who claim to be sceptics but aren't.

Poseur, plonk.

Goodbye yyreg. Be blessed in your life and yourself.
 
For example, someone tells us that karma is certainly true because he experiences it, the same also with Buddhists who tell us that Nirvana is true because they experience it; indeed, the experience can be seen in the oscilloscopes in the appearance of waves but the target of the experience, are they present to the experiencer when he is not experiencing? unlike experiencing the sun rising and the sun setting which leads everyone to appreciate the beauty of such a scenery.

If patriotism is the last refuge of politicians and warmongers, then experience of the mystical kind is the last refuge of a subject in hallucination, or delusion, or illusion.

And then you learn that there is something called perspective. A different one can let you experience the world from a point of view that can be "absurd" to a different observer.

Think in boys playing with their Nintendo DS, to an external observer, say a 60 years old adult, what they are doing appears to be meaningless; "how can they enjoy to be sitting in there, listening to all those weird sounds, and looking at the small screens, without having some real fun?, like playing with a ball for crying out loud!"

If he never look at the screens (maybe even if he does) what the boys are doing will remain as a "stupid thing", the last refuge for whatever the old guy wants.

Different perspectives can give you an astonishingly different point of view of what is called "reality" (just a collection of words, desires and beliefs).
 
Last edited:
Think in boys playing with their Nintendo DS, to an external observer, say a 60 years old adult, what they are doing appears to be meaningless; "how can they enjoy to be sitting in there, listening to all those weird sounds, and looking at the small screens, without having some real fun?, like playing with a ball for crying out loud!"

Interesting that you should bring this up. I was at the home of my fiancee for Christmas. There was a relative a number of times removed who was playing a Nintendo DS. So I went up to him and asked him about it. He showed me the screen and told me about the game. It took all of five minutes.

However, when asking about Buddhism, I get stuff like the following. Note that what follows is all based on things that people have said about Buddhism in this thread, and if anything, I've pulled punches with the analogy, and the analogy is less extreme than yours:

"Following the teachings of the Buddha will lead you to The Screen. The Screen of the Buddha is not the same screen as your screen. If you had seen The Screen, your life would be transformed, and you would be a different person. Do not mock me by talking about screens. You do not know The Screen. This concept is hard for a Westerner to understand, because the West does not have True Screeniness. And the Screen of the Buddha has the Hoojimongle and the Nuttybunnies. And the Buddha said that it may not be the only Screen, and you can find your own path to the Screen. Read the Dhormat, and follow the Five Noble Aphorisms, of which one is broken into the Thirteen Platitudes. And there's nothing supernatural about this, nosirree Bob!"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom