Skeptical criticism on Buddhist beliefs and observances.

It is a release from suffering, desire and the finite state of self. It arises from the understanding that everything is interconnected (everythingness).
snip
Believing in the self results in viewing ourselves as seperate, disconnected from everything else. Nothingness is viewing our 'self' as a fictional construct which impedes our ability to realize how we are interconnected to everything else.
snip
For the remainder of your inquiry I leave to to those who actually know what they are talking about. I hope that nothing I have said has been factually incorrect, but prefer the posts of those who better understand than I do.


Username , it seems to me that you have a clear understanding. Welcome, belated.
 
OK, so getting back to the topic.

As a skeptic, I should consider this something more than smug, fantastic, moralistic, imaginary wish-fulfillment exactly how, except as a rather naive interpretation of psychology and social interaction?

Other than being the plot of practically every episode of The Twilight Zone, which was at least admittedly supernatural, what is it about this that isn't anti-science?

If it's natural, show me the boson. If it's supernatural, just admit it.

It is supernatural. I admit it. I do not believe it now and never have. I make no defence of it. It is an absurd hang over from the Hindu roots of Buddhism.

For me though it doesn't matter. Buddhism is in itself a compounded thing. It is made up of the habits, cravings and sense experiences of those who created it passed down through generations of adherents.

Like all things Buddhism is subject to change and development. In time it, like everything else, will pass away to nothing.

For me Buddhism is the Four Noble Truths. Everything else is the dusty, dead hand of time.
 
For me Buddhism is the Four Noble Truths. Everything else is the dusty, dead hand of time.

Indeed. As I said earlier, everything else is secondary. The Four Noble Truths was the most important teaching of the Buddha, and is the core of Buddhism.
 
Not the whole truths.

Ryokan said:
Originally Posted by Camillus :
For me Buddhism is the Four Noble Truths. Everything else is the dusty, dead hand of time.​
Indeed. As I said earlier, everything else is secondary. The Four Noble Truths was the most important teaching of the Buddha, and is the core of Buddhism.


Columbia Encyclopedia said:

The basic doctrines of early Buddhism, which remain common to all Buddhism, include the “four noble truths”: existence is suffering (dukhka); suffering has a cause, namely craving and attachment (trishna); there is a cessation of suffering, which is nirvana; and there is a path to the cessation of suffering, the “eightfold path” of right views, right resolve, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and right concentration. Buddhism characteristically describes reality in terms of process and relation rather than entity or substance.

The socalled four noble truths are not completely true, they are actually speculations.

1. existence is suffering (dukhka), not the whole truth, there is a lot of happiness in existence;

2. suffering has a cause, namely craving and attachment (trishna), not true; craving and attachment (aspirations) satisfied is happiness, frustrated is sorrow; the thing to do is to be realistic with your aspirations and to work as to attain your aspirations and not get frustrated;

3, there is a cessation of suffering, which is nirvana: purely speculative, can't have any truth value in actual reality;

4. and there is a path to the cessation of suffering, the “eightfold path” of right views, right resolve, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and right concentration: the eightfold path is good for civilized, peaceable life and thereby also realistic happiness, but not the kind of cessation from suffering speculated on in Buddhism.

Buddhism characteristically describes reality in terms of process and relation rather than entity or substance, which is missing the whole picture; because relation and process in the real world and in life have got to have subjects to be related to and to be processed.

The four noble truths of Buddhism are not truths, but speculations only, and if seemingly true, partially and minimally, therefore not dependable for ordering one's life and thoughts and acts.


Suggestion: Better read and follow with discretion and a peasant's savvy the Meditations of Marcus Aurelius (AD 121-180).


Yrreg
 
Ah, Marcus Aurelius, we barely knew you. I wonder what Europe, or even the world, would've looked like if he had lived a decade or two more.

Yrreg, I've told you this before, but the first noble truth doesn't say that existance is suffering. That's a strawman, no matter what the Columbia Encyclopedia says. The first noble truth is most commonly translated as 'there is suffering'. Also, the noble truths are a lot more indepth than short sentences. I trust you've been to www.4truths.com to learn more about the truths, so you avoid strawmen in the future?

From Wikipeda :

Dukkha: There is suffering. Suffering is an intrinsic part of life also experienced as dissatisfaction, discontent, unhappiness, impermanence

Also note that the word Dukkha, which above is translated into suffering, is a word that can mean many things.

Here's an indepth article about the word, if you wish to learn.

Edit : Elaborated and corrected spelling.
 
Last edited:
It's an impasse! fault of Buddhists...

What's going to happen to Buddhist scholars and mentors? because they insist that people who do study what Buddhism is all about, and that from a purely academic standpoint, in order to present Buddhism as it actually is as a philosophy and a religion and a lifestyle or way of thinking and living and acting, for example people like contributors to encyclopedias, that these people do not get Buddhism and Buddhists correctly.

Maybe precisely very serious skeptics don't bother to dialogue with Buddhist masters, because the Buddhist masters always insist the critics don't get them correctly -- unless and until these critics also convert to Buddhism and start also insisting that non-Buddhists don't get them correctly when these non-Buddhists criticize Buddhist beliefs and practices.

I think we have to ask pollsters to do a survey on the most intelligent and learned students of human thought and behavior systems, asking them to draw up a list of Buddhist beliefs and practices, and how they vote on their understanding of these beliefs and practices as they discern them to be in fact the teachings and the prescriptions of Buddhists, as can be reasonably gathered from their spoken and written words, Buddhists' that is.

But who is going to do such a polling when they have got more absorbing and worthy surveys to conduct?


In the meantime I confess to be also deriving some good fun here, exercising my own kind of skeptical criticism on Buddhism; and I think there are others now appearing here, like myself.


Yrreg
 
You (and the Columbia Encyclopedia) claim that the first noble truth says that existance is suffering.

Are you going to be a good sceptic and provide evidence that this is that the first noble truth says? Or do you prefer that one source that agrees with you, and lets you make strawman attacks?
 
yrreg - I remain disappointed in your attitude, your agenda, your writing skills, your listening skills, and your lack of interest in learning.

What you have written to date is unworthy of you.
 
skeptical criticism on Buddhism

You cannot critique that which you are unwilling to understand.

The first noble truth says that there is suffering, unsatisfactoriness, unpleasantness and other "bad, negative or uncomfortable" states that we all experience in this life.

Apply your skepticism as you see fit to this.

If you wish to persuade the 'others like you' that you believe are arriving to apply 'your own kind' of skeptical criticism to buddhism I believe you are going to end up disappointed by the lack of others applying 'your own kind' of skeptical criticism.

If this causes you disappointment, then you have experienced the first noble truth firsthand. Having experienced it, you now understand it. Time for the second truth which will teach you the cause of the disappointment.
 
The socalled four noble truths are not completely true, they are actually speculations.

1. existence is suffering (dukhka), not the whole truth, there is a lot of happiness in existence;
Debate is a good thing, there are those who interpret the first truth to be that way.

You are again quoting a non-buddhist text. If someone says that quantum mechanics means you can travel back in time, does that mean that is what QM states?
2. suffering has a cause, namely craving and attachment (trishna), not true; craving and attachment (aspirations) satisfied is happiness, frustrated is sorrow; the thing to do is to be realistic with your aspirations and to work as to attain your aspirations and not get frustrated;

And have you ever met a person who worried that they would loose thier job or someone they love. There is more to the second truth than you suppose.

I suppose that there are two kinds of suffering, the direct physical causes of existance and the human mindset.

The buddha never claimed that the eightfold path would make a tooth ache go away of cause grief to go away. My interpretation is that buddha felt that much suffering is caused by psychological9modern term) conditions. Cognitive therapy is very similar.
3, there is a cessation of suffering, which is nirvana: purely speculative, can't have any truth value in actual reality;

Ah so you discount the value of psycho-therapy as well, WHERE IS YOUR EVIDENCE?

As has been explained to you, the interpretation is open to the student.

4. and there is a path to the cessation of suffering, the “eightfold path” of right views, right resolve, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and right concentration: the eightfold path is good for civilized, peaceable life and thereby also realistic happiness, but not the kind of cessation from suffering speculated on in Buddhism.

This is a straw man in a straw house, you have defined suffering outside the teachings of the buddha.

Have you practised the ightfold path,
oh I see this is just a priori assumption that rationalizes your world view.
Buddhism characteristically describes reality in terms of process and relation rather than entity or substance, which is missing the whole picture; because relation and process in the real world and in life have got to have subjects to be related to and to be processed.

And the subjects of buddhism are the body, thoughts, emotions, perceptions and habits.

Where are there subject beyond that?
The four noble truths of Buddhism are not truths, but speculations only, and if seemingly true, partially and minimally, therefore not dependable for ordering one's life and thoughts and acts.

It is up to the student to think upon the four truths and to decide thier veracity.
It would seem that you feel they are not true. That's great!
Suggestion: Better read and follow with discretion and a peasant's savvy the Meditations of Marcus Aurelius (AD 121-180).


Yrreg
 
What's going to happen to Buddhist scholars and mentors? because they insist that people who do study what Buddhism is all about, and that from a purely academic standpoint, in order to present Buddhism as it actually is as a philosophy and a religion and a lifestyle or way of thinking and living and acting, for example people like contributors to encyclopedias, that these people do not get Buddhism and Buddhists correctly.
It is up to each student to decide for themselves what the teachings of the buddha mean, using an encyclopedia is not preffered.

Buddhism has many different aspects, some are religous and some are philosophical, there are many mystic shools of buddhism, there are many rational schools of buddhism.
Maybe precisely very serious skeptics don't bother to dialogue with Buddhist masters, because the Buddhist masters always insist the critics don't get them correctly -- unless and until these critics also convert to Buddhism and start also insisting that non-Buddhists don't get them correctly when these non-Buddhists criticize Buddhist beliefs and practices.
And your evidence is where?

If you wish to present specific beliefs then they can be criticized.

There are no buddhist teachers in your statement, can you show me where a respected teacher said this?
I think we have to ask pollsters to do a survey on the most intelligent and learned students of human thought and behavior systems, asking them to draw up a list of Buddhist beliefs and practices, and how they vote on their understanding of these beliefs and practices as they discern them to be in fact the teachings and the prescriptions of Buddhists, as can be reasonably gathered from their spoken and written words, Buddhists' that is.

Ah, the populism fallacy again, so if every one in the USA thinks that they talk to god, that means god exists?
But who is going to do such a polling when they have got more absorbing and worthy surveys to conduct?


In the meantime I confess to be also deriving some good fun here, exercising my own kind of skeptical criticism on Buddhism; and I think there are others now appearing here, like myself.


Yrreg

Another mistaken belief!
;)
 
yrreg

If you are interested enough to debate the topic then you would almost certainly enjoy reading the book "Mindfulness In Plain English". It is, on the whole, a clear and quite logcal explaination of much of what is being discussed. It certainly appealed to my skeptical mindset.

In fact you can read most of it online: http://www.urbandharma.org/udharma4/mpe.html

You might even give some meditation a try, just to see what happens. It will make the concept of nullification of Self easier to see from the bhuddist point of view.

An aside: since reading that text, I've found watching my 18 month old son's "de-bhuddification" interesting viewing. He started off with not much concept of self and through systematic labelling in concept, words, pictures ahas developed a strong one. He appears to be doing the opposite of what some meditation tries to achieve.
 
An aside: since reading that text, I've found watching my 18 month old son's "de-bhuddification" interesting viewing. He started off with not much concept of self and through systematic labelling in concept, words, pictures ahas developed a strong one. He appears to be doing the opposite of what some meditation tries to achieve.

I work with 1-3-year-olds, so I know exactly what you mean :)

There's no one with a stronger ego than a 2-year-old. The world belongs to him/her.
 
Buddha overwhelmed by the sight of suffering.

I have here two questions which I think Buddhists should answer honestly and without quibbling.


1. From my stock knowledge, I have come to know that Buddha or the Gautama or the person hailed by Buddhists as the founder of their religion called Buddhism, was overwhelmed by the sight of suffering.

Now, we can quibble for ever whether he was saying that all life is suffering or that there is suffering in life, but what I understand is that his dismay with what he saw to be suffering was so intense that in effect he felt that life is all suffering.

If Buddhists here maybe can produce the earliest text of any mention by him of suffering and its description, then we might see that for the man there is so much and so keen of suffering in life that, as I said, the man in effect, that is in his heart and mind, psychologically was devastated so that for him all life is suffering.

And that is why he built his kind of religious philosophy on the cornerstone of suffering.


2. The way I see Buddhists here representing Buddhism in most quibbling manners in order to convince people who do read plain and quick accounts of Buddhism from encyclopedias and reports of witnesses, in order to show that Buddhism is a most intricate and most subtle system of thought -- and ordinary people reading encyclopedias and reports of witnesses can see what simply Buddhism is all about, (sorry for the long sentence, hahaha), I wonder if Buddhists themselves who hope to attain Nirvana will ever attain it at all: since they might end up doubting themselves if they have acquired in their heart and mind the Buddhism that is efficacious in bringing them to Nirvana -- because they might miss some intricacies in it or get any of the intricacies wrongly or imprecisely.


I must apologize for these long sentences; but I guess you get what I am driving at. Anyway, to be succinct:

1. Please, as you are Buddhists and searchers of Buddha's original words, as original as you can find them, please present here his most original or most authentic statement on suffering and its description.

2. If you Buddhists keep on quibbling in order just to sound very profound and to keep on thinking that anyone so much as pointing out the difficulties of Buddhist doctrines and observances should be, shall I use the word? gainsaid; then you might yourselves end up wondering among yourselves who have got the real McCoy of Buddha's most original genuine unadulterated words, which he spoke without any modifications from when he started preaching to when he breathed his last, if at all he ever spoke always uniformly without any changes in the course of his preaching years.

Again for the second question, what I want to tell the Buddhists here is that it can be most counterproductive for you to keep on making more and more intricate and unwieldy labyrinthine mazes, in order just to satisfy yourselves that observers outside don't get Buddhist beliefs and practices correctly, that you might inevitably get lost inside your own mazes, and never ever get to Nirvana.

And that would be truly ironic if not comic. Anyway, shall we all have a hahaha and a hehehe?

Hahaha and hehehe!


Yrreg
 
Praying to the laughing Buddha.

I read from some website hosted by an intellectual Buddhist, and he answers a lot of questions about Buddhism.

One question is about praying to Buddha for favors.

He went on and on and at the end did not succeed in answering the question, except about honoring Buddha which is a most salutary practice, but one must not be immersed in material things, etc., etc., etc.

Now, what I know from stock knowledge is that everyone is praying to Buddha for favors of all kinds.

I guess all of them are missing the solid, authentic, genuine, 100-carat, true. unadulterated, unalloyed, pure Buddhism: they don't know what is suffering as preached by Buddha, and what he means with there is suffering in life, or existence is suffering, or life is all suffering, or suffering exists; and they don't know what is the self or non-self, or rebirths, or Nirvana.

Anyway, I think all of them would rather follow the laughing Buddha, and not the gaunt one with eyes sinking in gloom and doom.

Here is what I like about Buddhism, the fat laughing Buddha.

attachment.php

I am sure that Buddha is laughing at whatever is laughable here, with his more profound followers making his simple message more and more complex and complicated, that no one can find his way into Nirvana.


I think Buddhism for the so-called intellectual Buddhists is not a religion but a para-religion, like there are normal phenomena and there are paranormal phenomena.



Yrreg
 

Attachments

  • laugh buddha.jpg
    laugh buddha.jpg
    31.1 KB · Views: 39
It is supernatural. I admit it. I do not believe it now and never have. I make no defence of it. It is an absurd hang over from the Hindu roots of Buddhism.

That's fair and honest, and I appreciate it.
 
No. Kung Fu Tse is Master Kung, Kung being his family name. Kung fu means something like "skill acquired through hard work" and can apply to cooking or hairdressing as much as martial arts.

Thanks, but I'm still confused. When Kung Fu Tsu tried to pick up women in bars, did he tell them that his last name meant "hard work" or is it simply homophony of no significance?

My last name sounds like a breakfast cereal (Pepke, the key to pep!), but it isn't one. However, I have to wonder about people named "Strange" or "Whitehead."
 
I have here two questions which I think Buddhists should answer honestly and without quibbling.

Well, as I have said previously I am not a buddhist, I am simply learning about buddhism. However, I believe I can answer your questions as they are fairly simple questions to answer.

1. From my stock knowledge, I have come to know that Buddha or the Gautama or the person hailed by Buddhists as the founder of their religion called Buddhism, was overwhelmed by the sight of suffering. Now, we can quibble for ever whether he was saying that all life is suffering or that there is suffering in life, but what I understand is that his dismay with what he saw to be suffering was so intense that in effect he felt that life is all suffering.

I have mentioned to you the book "Buddhism Without Beliefs" and I now mention another "Buddhism Plain and Simple" which I am now reading. Both do an excellent job of dropping the 2,500 years of religious and cultural trappings that the buddha's teachings have accumulated in many schools. I recommend either or both. Your misperception of buddhism is simply that, a misperception. This has been pointed out numerous times.

I would like you to acknowledge that this has been pointed out to you several times by saying "Yes, I acknowledge I have been told several times that my perception of the first noble truth is incorrect and I have been provided with both websites and books to correctly inform myself with." This way I can see if it is worth time to respond to you. So far I have seen you lecture, but not engage in conversation. If I am to spend any further time with you I need to see you acknowledge what has been said previously.


If Buddhists here maybe can produce the earliest text of any mention by him of suffering and its description, then we might see that for the man there is so much and so keen of suffering in life that, as I said, the man in effect, that is in his heart and mind, psychologically was devastated so that for him all life is suffering.

What does it matter? The person known as the buddha is 100% irrelevant. The buddha was a human. He is long dead. Nobody looks to the buddha for anything since dead people can't help the living. The buddha taught that his teachings (like everything else in life) should not be believed, they should be seen. We can look at the teachings and because they don't get into fairy tails that require faith, but rather speak only of the present moment we can see if the teachings are true. Consider the 4 noble truths. Once you understand them (which it is apparent that as of this post you have something vested in not understanding them) you can judge for yourself if they are true to your own experience or not. If you consider them not true then you can move along. As for myself I have come to understand the first of the three noble truths intellectually and I regard them as true. Not because I believe them to be true, but because they are self evidently true, demonstrably true. Every single person on the planet, upon understanding them, can see that they are true. No faith required. No years in tibet or any other country required. No rituals or rites of purification required.

And that is why he built his kind of religious philosophy on the cornerstone of suffering.

If you believe buddhism is based upon suffering then you have absolutely no understanding of buddhism. This is fine, a week ago I was very ignorant of buddhism and I, too, thought the first noble truth was "life is suffering". I did a little digging though and I now realize this is not at all close to the truth. Unfortunately encycopedias and non buddhists generally get this wrong. Buddhists (some of them) don't help matters when they translate duhkha as suffering. I can understand how you can think "Life is suffering" is the first noble truth, but it isn't. duhkha refers to a wheel out of kilter. It isn't possible to translate directly into English. Therein lies the difficulty and confusion.

2. The way I see Buddhists here representing Buddhism in most quibbling manners in order to convince people who do read plain and quick accounts of Buddhism from encyclopedias and reports of witnesses, in order to show that Buddhism is a most intricate and most subtle system of thought -- and ordinary people reading encyclopedias and reports of witnesses can see what simply Buddhism is all about, (sorry for the long sentence, hahaha), I wonder if Buddhists themselves who hope to attain Nirvana will ever attain it at all: since they might end up doubting themselves if they have acquired in their heart and mind the Buddhism that is efficacious in bringing them to Nirvana -- because they might miss some intricacies in it or get any of the intricacies wrongly or imprecisely.

There are no intracies to buddhism as far as I can see. It is the 4 noble truths and the 4th noble truth is in 8 parts. There is no secret language (although the translations can suck which is why I recommend reading a book by an author who speaks English natively who has studied and been approved to teach by a recognized buddhist authority. It really helps to cut through the translational issues.). As I learn about buddhism I am coming to realize it is quite likely the most plain and simple teaching on life I have ever encountered. So plain and simple that all one has to do is understand the 4 noble truths (read a book written by someone who speaks English, I recommended 2 above) and you now know absolutely everything you need to know to attain what some called buddhahood or enlightenment. One author says "freedom of mind" is a better term for English speaking audiences than the term enlightenment since it has 'mystical' connotations in our culture.

Nirvana is simply being awake in the now. As such we all are already buddhas since we are all in the now. We are simply sleeping buddhas who experience the now without really being awake in it. Buddhism is waking up, not to some esoteric faith or lighting incense or praying, but waking up to the now and fully experiencing it.

1. Please, as you are Buddhists and searchers of Buddha's original words, as original as you can find them, please present here his most original or most authentic statement on suffering and its description.

No. This isn't relevant. If you desire this information, you do the research.

2. If you Buddhists keep on quibbling in order just to sound very profound and to keep on thinking that anyone so much as pointing out the difficulties of Buddhist doctrines and observances should be, shall I use the word? gainsaid; then you might yourselves end up wondering among yourselves who have got the real McCoy of Buddha's most original genuine unadulterated words, which he spoke without any modifications from when he started preaching to when he breathed his last, if at all he ever spoke always uniformly without any changes in the course of his preaching years.

I couldn't care less if the buddhism of today is the buddha's original words. It doesn't matter. There is no magic in the words or the long dead guy known as the buddha. They are simple teachings that we are told to examine ourselves and see for ourselves if they are true. We are not to believe simply because some authority (the buddha) says it is so. To believe because an authority says so is contrary to buddhism, contrary to being awake. The teachings we know as buddhism could have been written yesterday by a 7 year old and they would be no more or less true.

Again for the second question, what I want to tell the Buddhists here is that it can be most counterproductive for you to keep on making more and more intricate and unwieldy labyrinthine mazes, in order just to satisfy yourselves that observers outside don't get Buddhist beliefs and practices correctly, that you might inevitably get lost inside your own mazes, and never ever get to Nirvana.

You, and anyone else, who want to understand what buddhism is can do the same thing I did beginning one week ago. Get a book and read it. Read the first 20 or so pages of "Buddhism Plain and Simple" and you now understand buddhism well enough to critique it as you see fit.

And that would be truly ironic if not comic. Anyway, shall we all have a hahaha and a hehehe?

Hahaha and hehehe!

No laughter here, I feel horribly for you (because you seem to choose to persist in ignorance) which is why I am being patient with you rather than responding with insults or simply ignoring you.

Again though, if you wish to have me respond to you in the future I need you to do as I asked in my 3rd paragraph.
 
Yrreg, I've told you this before, but the first noble truth doesn't say that existance is suffering. That's a strawman, no matter what the Columbia Encyclopedia says. The first noble truth is most commonly translated as 'there is suffering'.

Look, I swear, I don't even know yrreg.

But I've never seen the First Noble Truth translated as "there is suffering" before now. I remind you that I've read translations in both English and German. Usually, what I've seen is translated to (possibly doubly) as "life is suffering," with "existence is suffering" a distant second.

You claim that it is most commonly translated as "there is suffering," but if it's common, I haven't seen it, and it isn't my fault if I haven't read your approved sources. I appreciate your giving sources, but I think it could be done with less smarminess and judgementalism. FWIW, you are starting to come across as a Christian with a peculiar sect who expresses scorn that not everyone reads the same thing that you do or understands it the same way, and it seems like a rather cheap kind of running interference.

I'm well aware that you may not think you're doing it, but please remember: I'm only inside one brain that I'm aware of, and that's the one in my head. It's not my fault if the Columbia Encyclopedia gets it wrong. I have no connection with them, and I certainly haven't been asked to peer-review any articles.

Furthermore, to consider something a straw man, I think you have to show intent to mislead. I haven't seen (in my interpretation) evidence either for an attempt to mislead or an attempt to show intent to mislead. At worst, it's a misconception.
 
Hiya Yrreg!

I gave the first noble truth some consideration and realized I did not have a good source for where it came from, if you want to buddhist quibbling, there is a subject for it. There is controversy over when the four truths were first taught, there is controvery over what the meaning of the truths is, there is controversy everywhere and much quibbiling. It is very enlightening to see that buddhists themselves can not come to monolithic agreement of the four truths.

There is a qute allegedly from the buddha that state 'birth is dukkha, ageing is dukkha, dying is dukkha.." and it goes on at length to state many different things which are dukkha, so while the quote does not expressly state that 'existance is suffering' it certainly covers a lot of ground and therefore could loosly be translated as such.

There is much hair splitting even as to the meaning of dukkha!

On the four tuths, these two quotes seem to represent the majority of views to be found in an hour.
Noble Truth (Ariya-Sacca) is short for "truth of the Noble ones (or of those who have attained a high degree of advancement)", "truth attainable by the noble ones", "truth by which one is ennobled". It should first be understood that it is not simply truth that is agreeable to the world or to oneself, but truth that is directly born of wisdom. The four Noble Truths are :-

1. Dukkha or suffering; which means birth, decay and death which are the normal incidents of life. It also means sorrow, lamentation, pain, grief and despair which are at times experienced by our body and mind. To be separated from the pleasant, to be disappointed, or to be in contact with the unpleasant are also suffering. In short our body and mind are subject to suffering or, in other words, we may say that our existence is bound up with suffering*.

http://www.dhammathai.org/e/dhamma/buddhateach01.php
Sujin: The realities which arise and fall away are dukkha and nobody can change this truth. The term dukkha sacca or dukkha ariya sacca refers to one of the three characteristics of conditioned realities, namely their arising and falling away 29 . Nobody can prevent the reality which has arisen from falling away again. The characteristic of the reality which arises and falls away is dukkha, because arising and falling away is suffering, not happiness. All people want happiness which lasts, which continues forever and which does not fall away, but conditioned realities have the characteristic of dukkha, because they arise and then fall away immediately. There are three characteristics common to all conditioned realities, namely: the characteristic of impermanence, that is, the arising and falling away, the characteristic of dukkha, suffering or unsatisfactoriness, since what arises and falls away cannot be happiness, and the characteristic of anattå, non-self. There is no self who can exert control over realities, because they are as they are, according to their own nature.

http://www.vipassana.info/Taking refuge3.htm
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom