The big picture and the short statement, and the proof of the pudding.
I think Username has put it rather well yrreg.
You seem to be trawling the net for 2nd hand criticisms of bhuddism in general and quoting them. I think if you tried reading the recommended links and books you might develop some questions of your own, based on your own understanding of the subject.
If you are really interested in discussing it then at least read that link I posted. It's a good book designed for "western minds" (ie without most of the mystical religious trappings), online, for free. I've no doubt you will find fault with some of the logic. I know I did. But at least we can then have a useful discussion. It's not like there are no logical problems with it worth picking at.
We have here, Splossy, two questions which I believe my answers make up a valid reason for my conduct here.
1. Can one lawfully criticize Buddhism without reading Buddhist canonical texts?
2. How come there are so few visibly present or easy to spot skeptical critics of Buddhism?
To the first question I must confess that I am very loathe to invest time and labor in reading canonical texts of Buddhism, in order to filter out the irrational and the nonsensical in Buddhism. I prefer to get acquainted with Buddhism by looking at the big picture and reading the short statement.
The big picture and the short statement are provided by people who do contribute dependable accounts of Buddhism in solid reference works like encyclopedias; I specially favor the more succinct ones like one volume works.
Consider what every intelligent buyer and user of an appliance always looks for in deciding to buy a particular model, first consider the big picture; for example a refrigerator, the question to ask right away is: "Is it owner and user friendly?" which means is the price reasonable, does it get its job done faithfully, durably, and is it easy to operate even by a child, and it does not consume excess power.
And second, the short statement: Does it come with a brief, easy to read and understand manual of operation, maintenance, and troubleshooting, and also a list of telephones and addresses to contact in case any difficulty should crop up.
So also with Buddhism, I only need the big picture and the short statement. If serious scholars of philosophy and religion cannot produce the big picture and the short statement of Buddhism, then the fault is not with the scholars but with the system of Buddhism -- it is intrinsically impossible to produce a reliable big picture and an intelligible short statement of Buddhism. To the credit of Buddhism, scholars have managed to succeed in producing the big picture and the short statement of Buddhism, which people can find in recognized encyclopedias and general works for reference.
Can I lawfully and validly criticize Buddhism on the big picture and the short statement? Certainly, just as I can lawfully and validly criticize a refrigerator on its big picture and its short statement.
Now we come to the second question, "How come there are so few visibly present or easy to spot skeptical critics of Buddhism?"
Because Buddhism in the West is not as competitive a system as say Christianity, and now Islam, namely, not a threat to liberty and free inquiry of people who prize liberty and free inquiry. If and when it should become politically influential and powerful, then we will witness the skeptics rising up to expose all the Achilles' heels of Buddhism.
And perhaps there is an unspoken deference to the present Dalai Lama in exile, who was even honored with a Nobel Peace Award, out of consideration for his status as a victim of political persecution, he and his country; when considering his character as a one man hierocratic ruler set up on the basis of discovery as the re-incarnation of a previous Dalai Lama, Westerners inured to the ideal of democracy will otherwise find unpalatable.
I say not easy to spot skeptical critics of Buddhism, because there are certainly many if I look long and hard.
Now, why do I want to meet with these skeptics of Buddhism? To find out whether they also have the kind of criticisms of Buddhism as I have, and thereby to experience the satisfaction that I am not the only one who can see into the unreason and inutility of Buddhism.
As a matter of fact I like to call Buddhism a para-religion and a para-philosophy; as I said elsewhere here I think twice already,
para in the sense of being a simulation of religion and of philosophy.
It does not work when it is drawn to its strictly logical consequences. For example, I gave already two instances when Buddhists cannot follow their religion to its uncompromising logic without dying of hunger or going down in a sinking ship. (See
this post, and
this post).
I will give another test that Buddhism cannot be followed to its logical conclusion without jeopardizing one's life.
There is this story about a head Buddhist monk in a Far Eastern country, distinguished for his detachment from the world and could meditate immobile for days on end. One day by some twist of Buddhistic fate he was bitten by a mad dog. He repaired himself to the hospital for treatment and immunization.
The doctor he approached was one who used to debate with him about the worth of life and the impracticality and even foolhardiness of Buddhism.
"You don't have to worry about dying," the doctor reminded him, "because you have always been longing for the extinction of the self and to end up in Nirvana; besides, if you don't get to Nirvana you will still come back in another rebirth."
"Doctor," the head monk addressed the physician, "don't be sarcastic, you know as well as I that Buddhism is a religion, a speculative system, when everything is going all right in life and we are not in danger of death, keeping faith with the logic of Buddhism is no big deal, but when death is knocking at the door, I would be stupid not to seek the latest medical measures to save and prolong my life."
And this smart monk reminded the physician, "Remember doctor, your duty in conscience is to save life, not to talk religion and philosophy."
So, shall we have a hahaha and a hehehe?
Yrreg