Skeptical criticism on Buddhist beliefs and observances.

Before I forget, what is skeptical criticism of Buddhism? In my view, it is to look at Buddhism and judge it in the light of science and logic as science and logic are the tools in our knowledge and mastery as much as possible of what we might call the purely naturalistic universe, that of matter and energy and the laws governing them.
Yrreg

Uh huh.

See, here is the thing. If you wish to apply 'skeptical criticism' to something, you first have to understand the subject you are exploring.

You have recieved assistance from many in the form of links and book recomendations. Your posts reflect a persistent ignorance. You haven't read anything presented to you. So, you don't understand buddhism in any way because you have made the choice not to.

Yet you still criticise and wonder why you are alone. You lament the fact there are not hoards of skeptics joining you.

See, skeptics learn that they have to understand a topic before they are fit to criticise it. You refuse to understand the topic you choose to criticise.

You are not a skeptic, you are simply an ignorant person who refuses to self educate, but wishes to criticise and gets upset when you have no audience to cheer you on in your ignorance.

Sorry. Go read a book and try again.

This is a place where skeptical criticism is welcomed on any topic, but ignorant bashing is ignored or negatively commented upon. Yours is ignorant bashing, not skeptical criticism.
 
yrreg - Your biggest problem is that you are neither competent nor interested in becoming competent to engage in "sound skeptical criticism" of Buddhism or, as far as I can tell, anything else.

You seem to have no interest in familiarizing yourself with the subject that you are attempting to critique.

You insist on attacking strawmen that have nothing to do with the subject that you are attempting to critique.

You are wasting everyone's time.
 
While I was looking up the words of Buddha on the truth of suffering, you know what I read from Muslim critics of Buddhism?

They point out something which logicians should see easily...
You do not endlessly follow the path, in the end you and the 'path' become one. This is a useful concept to understand because you are going to encounter it in eastern philosophy.

I do like the Stoics, they're cool. The concept of 'Logos' sounds a lot like the 'Tao' to me though. A search on the term 'axial age' might be helpful.

To my pov, ideas like the Logos or Tao are not so much supernatural ideas as artistic ones. Because of that, similar concepts in art are sometimes easier to understand and may help.

If you were to paint a birch tree, we could just paint the tree. This is really hard but it can be done. We could also not paint the tree itself, but paint what it is not. There's even a term for it - "negative space".
By rendering the background (world) of the tree, the tree gradually appears out of the weird and wrong looking shapes.

I might be mistaken but this seems like an idea you are struggling with. We judge the final result as being the painting of a tree, but we have actually rendered everything but the tree.

This Buddhist idea is like that, 'By our thoughts we make the world' is a very Buddhist idea. The 'paths' and meditations aren't the thing itself, but only a way to describe what is our oneness with the world.

So anyway there is no logical paradox as the 'Muslims assert'.

You are free to call me confused, I'll be away for a few days though.

I am much more a philosophical Taoist than a Buddhist but I enjoy most Buddhists. The first atheist I ever met was a Buddhist. The difference between Taoism & Buddhism is sort like like the difference between growing a wildflower garden and a well ordered one with petunias... :)

Happy Holidays all, I really need to finish packing now...
 
I think Username has put it rather well yrreg.

You seem to be trawling the net for 2nd hand criticisms of bhuddism in general and quoting them. I think if you tried reading the recommended links and books you might develop some questions of your own, based on your own understanding of the subject.

If you are really interested in discussing it then at least read that link I posted. It's a good book designed for "western minds" (ie without most of the mystical religious trappings), online, for free. I've no doubt you will find fault with some of the logic. I know I did. But at least we can then have a useful discussion. It's not like there are no logical problems with it worth picking at.
 
As I learn about buddhism I am coming to realize it is quite likely the most plain and simple teaching on life I have ever encountered.

I can think of simpler. Carpe diem, for instance.

So plain and simple that all one has to do is understand the 4 noble truths (read a book written by someone who speaks English, I recommended 2 above) and you now know absolutely everything you need to know to attain what some called buddhahood or enlightenment.

Now this is what we like to call an "empirical claim" around here.

Is there any evidence for it?

Forget mysticism, forget the theory, forget the straw men. Is there any evidence for this that is stronger, say, than the evidence for homeopathy (which, I remind you, some people adhere to rather strongly for personal reasons)?

Nirvana is simply being awake in the now. As such we all are already buddhas since we are all in the now. We are simply sleeping buddhas who experience the now without really being awake in it. Buddhism is waking up, not to some esoteric faith or lighting incense or praying, but waking up to the now and fully experiencing it.

I think I'm awake. At least I'm not asleep. If I were asleep, I would have a harder time typing this.

Now if the past is any indicator of the future, you're going to get shirty on me and tell me I don't understand what you mean by awake. But seriously, if it is so simple, so clear, and there are no intricacies, then it shouldn't be necessary to explain it.

And if it is necessary to explain it, then what is it? How can I distinguish someone who is awake from someone who is simply awake?



No. This isn't relevant. If you desire this information, you do the research.



I couldn't care less if the buddhism of today is the buddha's original words. It doesn't matter. There is no magic in the words or the long dead guy known as the buddha. They are simple teachings that we are told to examine ourselves and see for ourselves if they are true. We are not to believe simply because some authority (the buddha) says it is so. To believe because an authority says so is contrary to buddhism, contrary to being awake. The teachings we know as buddhism could have been written yesterday by a 7 year old and they would be no more or less true.



You, and anyone else, who want to understand what buddhism is can do the same thing I did beginning one week ago. Get a book and read it. Read the first 20 or so pages of "Buddhism Plain and Simple" and you now understand buddhism well enough to critique it as you see fit.



No laughter here, I feel horribly for you (because you seem to choose to persist in ignorance) which is why I am being patient with you rather than responding with insults or simply ignoring you.

Again though, if you wish to have me respond to you in the future I need you to do as I asked in my 3rd paragraph.[/QUOTE]
 
I can think of simpler. Carpe diem, for instance.

Now this is what we like to call an "empirical claim" around here.

Is there any evidence for it?

Forget mysticism, forget the theory, forget the straw men. Is there any evidence for this that is stronger, say, than the evidence for homeopathy (which, I remind you, some people adhere to rather strongly for personal reasons)?

I think I'm awake. At least I'm not asleep. If I were asleep, I would have a harder time typing this.
[/QUOTE]

What sort of evidence would you want? If the writings of meditators for centuries is anything to go by, it's impossible to define englightenment in words or writing thus making this untestable. Areas of experience and consciousness like this are, as it stands, not suited to scientific evaluation.

Being awake as opposed to asleep is not the same as the "awake" that the poster was talking about. It is a metaphor.

Have you tried to meditate and stay in mindfulness? From my experience you can develop an altered consciousness which one might describe as being more awake. It's a state of non-judgement. Ok it's pretty much impossible to completely stop your brain from labelling, categorising and judging but you can lessen it a lot. This creates a mental state that feels as if you are "more in touch" with the bare bones of what is happening around you.

It's not something that will show up on a chart or in a test tube. Maybe it would show up on an NMR or PET scanner but it still wouldn't give us much insight. Some things have to be experienced. It's like trying to explain what btripping on magic mushrooms is like to someone who has never taken them.
 
Now this is what we like to call an "empirical claim" around here.

Completely so. I agree 100%

Is there any evidence for it?

Yes, I believe so, but you will have to rely upon empiricism ;-)

Forget mysticism, forget the theory, forget the straw men. Is there any evidence for this that is stronger, say, than the evidence for homeopathy (which, I remind you, some people adhere to rather strongly for personal reasons)?

Objective evidence? No, none. Empirical evidence? I think so, but you have to judge for yourself. Asking me to prove buddhism is like asking me to prove velvet is soft and feels good. I can try to explain it and prove it objectively, but will fail. I won't fail because velvet isn't soft and smooth and feels really good, I will fail because I have no idea how to put the sensation into words that really convey the feeling/experience. However if you feel velvet you immediately know for yourself how it feels. Upon knowing how it feels, try and convince anyone who hasn't felt it. Good luck! ;-)

I think I'm awake. At least I'm not asleep. If I were asleep, I would have a harder time typing this.

Now if the past is any indicator of the future, you're going to get shirty on me and tell me I don't understand what you mean by awake. But seriously, if it is so simple, so clear, and there are no intricacies, then it shouldn't be necessary to explain it.

I think you, I, and everyone else who has done a cursory examination of buddhism from an intellectual standpoint understands what awake means well enough. And we all have been awake. As I understand it buddhism simply teaches us how to spend more time awake than asleep. It isn't taking you into unfamiliar territory, just into territory you haven't spent much time in, but the time you have spent there was good.

And if it is necessary to explain it, then what is it? How can I distinguish someone who is awake from someone who is simply awake?

Why would you want to? To do so is to judge others and is quite pointless. What good can come from this?

You simply have to examine the claims yourself. You have to prove them true or false yourself, nobody buddhist or anti-buddhist can do it for you. If you find them at all convincing then you must try them yourself. Then and only then can you 'know'. We all have beliefs about many things. There are relatively few things that we 'know'. Everything that transcends mere belief and that becomes what we 'know' is something we have experienced ourselves. Once we 'know' we have no further use for 'belief'.

It is completely empirical. Sorry, but this is just one of those things that I cannot objectively prove to you and won't even try. If you are interested, try it out yourself (I recommend 'Buddhism Plain and Simple'). If you are not interested, then no preaching or evangelism here, you may simply move along and I wish you well. I will have nothing negative to say about your lack of interest in the path and I hope you will return the favor toward my interest in it, but if not, that is your business. Either way I still wish you well and will have nothing negative to say about your choice.
 
The big picture and the short statement, and the proof of the pudding.

I think Username has put it rather well yrreg.

You seem to be trawling the net for 2nd hand criticisms of bhuddism in general and quoting them. I think if you tried reading the recommended links and books you might develop some questions of your own, based on your own understanding of the subject.

If you are really interested in discussing it then at least read that link I posted. It's a good book designed for "western minds" (ie without most of the mystical religious trappings), online, for free. I've no doubt you will find fault with some of the logic. I know I did. But at least we can then have a useful discussion. It's not like there are no logical problems with it worth picking at.

We have here, Splossy, two questions which I believe my answers make up a valid reason for my conduct here.

1. Can one lawfully criticize Buddhism without reading Buddhist canonical texts?

2. How come there are so few visibly present or easy to spot skeptical critics of Buddhism?

To the first question I must confess that I am very loathe to invest time and labor in reading canonical texts of Buddhism, in order to filter out the irrational and the nonsensical in Buddhism. I prefer to get acquainted with Buddhism by looking at the big picture and reading the short statement.

The big picture and the short statement are provided by people who do contribute dependable accounts of Buddhism in solid reference works like encyclopedias; I specially favor the more succinct ones like one volume works.

Consider what every intelligent buyer and user of an appliance always looks for in deciding to buy a particular model, first consider the big picture; for example a refrigerator, the question to ask right away is: "Is it owner and user friendly?" which means is the price reasonable, does it get its job done faithfully, durably, and is it easy to operate even by a child, and it does not consume excess power.

And second, the short statement: Does it come with a brief, easy to read and understand manual of operation, maintenance, and troubleshooting, and also a list of telephones and addresses to contact in case any difficulty should crop up.

So also with Buddhism, I only need the big picture and the short statement. If serious scholars of philosophy and religion cannot produce the big picture and the short statement of Buddhism, then the fault is not with the scholars but with the system of Buddhism -- it is intrinsically impossible to produce a reliable big picture and an intelligible short statement of Buddhism. To the credit of Buddhism, scholars have managed to succeed in producing the big picture and the short statement of Buddhism, which people can find in recognized encyclopedias and general works for reference.

Can I lawfully and validly criticize Buddhism on the big picture and the short statement? Certainly, just as I can lawfully and validly criticize a refrigerator on its big picture and its short statement.


Now we come to the second question, "How come there are so few visibly present or easy to spot skeptical critics of Buddhism?"

Because Buddhism in the West is not as competitive a system as say Christianity, and now Islam, namely, not a threat to liberty and free inquiry of people who prize liberty and free inquiry. If and when it should become politically influential and powerful, then we will witness the skeptics rising up to expose all the Achilles' heels of Buddhism.

And perhaps there is an unspoken deference to the present Dalai Lama in exile, who was even honored with a Nobel Peace Award, out of consideration for his status as a victim of political persecution, he and his country; when considering his character as a one man hierocratic ruler set up on the basis of discovery as the re-incarnation of a previous Dalai Lama, Westerners inured to the ideal of democracy will otherwise find unpalatable.

I say not easy to spot skeptical critics of Buddhism, because there are certainly many if I look long and hard.

Now, why do I want to meet with these skeptics of Buddhism? To find out whether they also have the kind of criticisms of Buddhism as I have, and thereby to experience the satisfaction that I am not the only one who can see into the unreason and inutility of Buddhism.

As a matter of fact I like to call Buddhism a para-religion and a para-philosophy; as I said elsewhere here I think twice already, para in the sense of being a simulation of religion and of philosophy.

It does not work when it is drawn to its strictly logical consequences. For example, I gave already two instances when Buddhists cannot follow their religion to its uncompromising logic without dying of hunger or going down in a sinking ship. (See this post, and this post).

I will give another test that Buddhism cannot be followed to its logical conclusion without jeopardizing one's life.

There is this story about a head Buddhist monk in a Far Eastern country, distinguished for his detachment from the world and could meditate immobile for days on end. One day by some twist of Buddhistic fate he was bitten by a mad dog. He repaired himself to the hospital for treatment and immunization.

The doctor he approached was one who used to debate with him about the worth of life and the impracticality and even foolhardiness of Buddhism.

"You don't have to worry about dying," the doctor reminded him, "because you have always been longing for the extinction of the self and to end up in Nirvana; besides, if you don't get to Nirvana you will still come back in another rebirth."

"Doctor," the head monk addressed the physician, "don't be sarcastic, you know as well as I that Buddhism is a religion, a speculative system, when everything is going all right in life and we are not in danger of death, keeping faith with the logic of Buddhism is no big deal, but when death is knocking at the door, I would be stupid not to seek the latest medical measures to save and prolong my life."

And this smart monk reminded the physician, "Remember doctor, your duty in conscience is to save life, not to talk religion and philosophy."


So, shall we have a hahaha and a hehehe?


Yrreg
 
So in a nutshell, you are not willing to read up on it properly but merely trawl the net for other's opinions that back up your own. You are not going to convince me for one that not looking into something properly before criticising it is better than looking into it.

I think you'd run into problems criticising a particular refrigerator with a salesman who actually knows what he's talking about. I for one have bought things off the back of magazines ' Best Buy summaries only to find them not suited to my needs after all. I ended up wishing I'd done some research of my own.

BTW you might wish to add para-psychology to your list.
 
yrreg - You're a loser - skepticism doesn't need the like of you.

epepke - Please add me to your "Don't respond" list.

yrreg - No, we shall not "have a hahaha and a hehehe". Go troll elsewhere.
 
I think I'm awake. At least I'm not asleep. If I were asleep, I would have a harder time typing this.
And that claim would be vastly more credible if you hadn't screwed up the quotation of the post you were replying to... :D
 
It does not work when it is drawn to its strictly logical consequences. For example, I gave already two instances when Buddhists cannot follow their religion to its uncompromising logic without dying of hunger or going down in a sinking ship. (See this post, and this post).

I will give another test that Buddhism cannot be followed to its logical conclusion without jeopardizing one's life.

There is this story about a head Buddhist monk in a Far Eastern country, distinguished for his detachment from the world and could meditate immobile for days on end. One day by some twist of Buddhistic fate he was bitten by a mad dog. He repaired himself to the hospital for treatment and immunization.

The doctor he approached was one who used to debate with him about the worth of life and the impracticality and even foolhardiness of Buddhism.

"You don't have to worry about dying," the doctor reminded him, "because you have always been longing for the extinction of the self and to end up in Nirvana; besides, if you don't get to Nirvana you will still come back in another rebirth."

"Doctor," the head monk addressed the physician, "don't be sarcastic, you know as well as I that Buddhism is a religion, a speculative system, when everything is going all right in life and we are not in danger of death, keeping faith with the logic of Buddhism is no big deal, but when death is knocking at the door, I would be stupid not to seek the latest medical measures to save and prolong my life."

And this smart monk reminded the physician, "Remember doctor, your duty in conscience is to save life, not to talk religion and philosophy."

Any evidence that these stories of yours are true? Where did you find them?

I have not replied much to you lately, yrreg, and unless you answer these two questions, I will stop replying entirely.

If anyone else would like to make a new thread with valid criticism of buddhism (I've never claimed that there aren't any), I would be most happy to anwer questions.

A merry yule to you all, from your favorite Resident Buddhist :)
 
We have here, Splossy, two questions which I believe my answers make up a valid reason for my conduct here.

1. Can one lawfully criticize Buddhism without reading Buddhist canonical texts?

Of course, but you have to have a good working familiarity with Buddhism's central tenets in order to frame your arguments in a coherent way. You need to be able to anticipate and prepare for counter-arguments.

Many of those who are the most capable critics of Fundementalist Christianity on this forum have a deep knowledge of the Bible and Christian theology. They are able to make strong arguments and important points because of it. It makes it very difficult for their opponents to hide but at the same time stops the JREF member making elementary mistakes.

Do you not think it would be wise to take a leaf out of their book?

To the first question I must confess that I am very loathe to invest time and labor in reading canonical texts of Buddhism, in order to filter out the irrational and the nonsensical in Buddhism. I prefer to get acquainted with Buddhism by looking at the big picture and reading the short statement.

The big picture and the short statement are provided by people who do contribute dependable accounts of Buddhism in solid reference works like encyclopedias; I specially favor the more succinct ones like one volume works.

General encyclopaedias at best skim the surface of the topics they deal with. There are single volume dictionaries of Buddhism available (I own the Oxford one and find it very useful). Perhaps it would help if you invested in one?

None of the books recommended to you in this thread are fat works of academic obfuscation. Buddhism plain and simple is 159 pages and Buddhism without beliefs is even shorter. Even if they didn't convert you from your current beliefs they would allow you to make tighter and more coherent arguments.

So also with Buddhism, I only need the big picture and the short statement.

Not if you want your arguments to be taken seriously. The problem is that the "big picture and the short statement" give you inadequate intelligence on the disposition of the enemy. They leave you vulnerable to surprises and make it difficult to plug holes in your defences.

If serious scholars of philosophy and religion cannot produce the big picture and the short statement of Buddhism, then the fault is not with the scholars but with the system of Buddhism -- it is intrinsically impossible to produce a reliable big picture and an intelligible short statement of Buddhism.

Cobblers. There a numerous short, easy to read and understand accounts of Buddhism available that give accurate pictures of what's going on.

We have moved a long way from the stultifyingly tedious translations of a hundred years ago and the laughable poetry of The Light of Asia.

As a matter of fact I like to call Buddhism a para-religion and a para-philosophy; as I said elsewhere here I think twice already, para in the sense of being a simulation of religion and of philosophy.

It does not work when it is drawn to its strictly logical consequences.

Buddhism uses logic to demonstrate that it ideas have merit but it is explicit that it is practice that is important. You cannot think your way to enlightment.

I will give another test that Buddhism cannot be followed to its logical conclusion without jeopardizing one's life.

There is this story about a head Buddhist monk in a Far Eastern country, distinguished for his detachment from the world and could meditate immobile for days on end. One day by some twist of Buddhistic fate he was bitten by a mad dog. He repaired himself to the hospital for treatment and immunization.

The doctor he approached was one who used to debate with him about the worth of life and the impracticality and even foolhardiness of Buddhism.

"You don't have to worry about dying," the doctor reminded him, "because you have always been longing for the extinction of the self and to end up in Nirvana; besides, if you don't get to Nirvana you will still come back in another rebirth."

"Doctor," the head monk addressed the physician, "don't be sarcastic, you know as well as I that Buddhism is a religion, a speculative system, when everything is going all right in life and we are not in danger of death, keeping faith with the logic of Buddhism is no big deal, but when death is knocking at the door, I would be stupid not to seek the latest medical measures to save and prolong my life."

And this smart monk reminded the physician, "Remember doctor, your duty in conscience is to save life, not to talk religion and philosophy."


So, shall we have a hahaha and a hehehe?


Yrreg

Like Ryokan I'd like to know the provenance of this story. It's almost a Zen story but the tone is wrong. What is the source?
 
What is skeptical criticism of Buddhism?



But I am disappointed that I am not meeting the kind of skeptical critics here as I was thinking of meeting, instead I have come across Buddhists who feel they have to make known to me how Buddhism is not what I think it to be.
And that is part of sceptical critisism, if you misunderstand what nibbanna means then an explanation is in order.

I think that most people here are sceptical of the idea of reincarnation, which most buddhist schools do not teach. There are schools which teach reincarnation but it is not mainstream buddhism.

You also seem to not wnt to understand explanations of what buddhism , and meditation is in the mainstream.

I gave you a page full of potential google searches to find the more whacked out parts of buddhism, and you ignored it.
I also suggest that you wish to be sceptical of buddhism in large bold strokes and ignore when people point out what the mainstream is.
I admire your zeal, but I reserve the liberty to judge your explanation and defense according to my criteria on fair and academic skeptical criticism of Buddhism, for which I was and am still expecting to meet with people having my kind of skeptical criticism.
Which many people have, as I explained in a previous post there are many parts of buddhism which I am sceptical of, did you just ignore that?
I believe I have time and again stated that my purpose here is not to lend a sympathetic ear to Buddhism, but to scrutinize it meticulously in the light of science and logic, and to hear others similar to myself expressing also their critical observations.
You left out the part where you don't read what people write and then ignore when they say they are sceptical of something!
;)
Why am I interested in doing my kind of skeptical criticism on Buddhism? Because it arouses my curiosity.
But if you ignore explanations of what the budddhists believe to be mainstream buddhism, which is sceptical, and present mistaken beliefs and then ignore responses, it leads us mistaken to believe that you have an ulterior motive.
The one thing you do not seem to be sceptical of is your own beliefs and statements. You have yet to respond to any sceptical criticism of your own material.
Considering that in the marketplace of ideas there are already innumerable skeptical critics who are uncompromising in their probing examination of paranormal phenomena, pseudoscience, and the supernatural, and religions, I notice that almost no one has turned his attention to Buddhism.

That is a bold assertion with little proof or evidence, you have asked people to be sceptical based upon your personal beliefs about what buddhism is.

If you bring up specific beliefs, like the tibetan belief in reincarnation, I am sure that there will much scepticism.
So I think that I might do something different, specially noticing that Buddhism seems to be favored by Westerners of the intellectual types.
This is the kind of assertion that makes me believe that you have an ulterior motive and are not a sceptic.

I am very sceptical of many aspects of buddhism, as I stated in many a previous post.
As Buddhists here keep on insisting that I don't know what I am criticizing about in Buddhism, so also I keep on bringing up issues and aspects in regard to Buddhism, over which I also think that I have applied skeptical criticism validly.
And then you ignore any critical response, I will look and see if you have responded yet to my posts on the eightfold path and clinging.
In the meantime, please don't imagine that I am into some kind of conspiracy with anti-Buddhist agenda -- not flattering myself though; for someone here has accused me on quite arbitrary grounds with being earlier a member of some Western cult and then later an adherent of some Hindu sect.
I made that statement based upon your lack of critical thinking in regard to our responses and your own beliefs.
Hahaha and hehehe. Can't anyone engage in some sound skeptical criticism of Buddhism without being identified with some religious fundamentalist groups?
If you act like a troll, I will call you a troll, which is not a buddhist thing to do.
Before I forget, what is skeptical criticism of Buddhism? In my view, it is to look at Buddhism and judge it in the light of science and logic as science and logic are the tools in our knowledge and mastery as much as possible of what we might call the purely naturalistic universe, that of matter and energy and the laws governing them.


Yrreg
And they are in agreement with mainstream buddhism, and when that is pointed out to you, you seem to ignore it.

The belief in spirits, reicarnation, divas, assura, ghosts and magic as practised in some forms of buddhism is something I am very critical of.
 
That is of course a possibility, that a student would strive for enlightement , and crave the release that they percieve to be Nirvana. And I am sure that there are practioners of buddhism who do so.

Yet the teachers would advise against it:


Sorry the following is a very long citation but it does adress the point directly:



http://www.saigon.com/~anson/ebud/ebdha284.htm

Please read and respond to this post yrreg, if you wish to demostrate your critical thinking skills.
 
Scientists say they have evidence to show that Buddhists really are happier and calmer than other people.
Tests carried out in the United States reveal that areas of their brain associated with good mood and positive feelings are more active.

The findings come as another study suggests that Buddhist meditation can help to calm people.

Researchers at University of California San Francisco Medical Centre have found the practise can tame the amygdala, an area of the brain which is the hub of fear memory.

------------------------------

In a separate study, scientists at the University of Wisconsin at Madison used new scanning techniques to examine brain activity in a group of Buddhists.

Their tests revealed activity in the left prefrontal lobes of experienced Buddhist practitioners.

This area is linked to positive emotions, self-control and temperament.

Their tests showed this area of the Buddhists' brains are constantly lit up and not just when they are meditating.

This, the scientists said, suggests they are more likely to experience positive emotions and be in good mood.

Source.

The scans provided remarkable clues about what goes on in the brain during meditation.

"There was an increase in activity in the front part of the brain, the area that is activated when anyone focuses attention on a particular task," Dr Newberg explained.

In addition, a notable decrease in activity in the back part of the brain, or parietal lobe, recognised as the area responsible for orientation, reinforced the general suggestion that meditation leads to a lack of spatial awareness.

Dr Newberg explained: "During meditation, people have a loss of the sense of self and frequently experience a sense of no space and time and that was exactly what we saw."

Source.

"What science and Buddhism really share is the goal of understanding the nature of reality," Adam Ingle of the MindLife Institute, who organised the experiment, told BBC World Service's Reporting Religion programme.

"The difference is that science uses the scientific method and a lot of technology and objectives - it starts from the outside and probes the nature of reality.

"Buddhism uses the human mind, reformed through meditation, starting from the inside, looking at the same questions."

Source.

Ten volunteers were tested before and after 40 minutes of either sleep, meditation, reading or light conversation, with all subjects trying all conditions. The 40-minute nap was known to improve performance (after an hour or so to recover from grogginess). But what astonished the researchers was that meditation was the only intervention that immediately led to superior performance, despite none of the volunteers being experienced at meditation.

“Every single subject showed improvement,” says O’Hara. The improvement was even more dramatic after a night without sleep. But, he admits: “Why it improves performance, we do not know.” The team is now studying experienced meditators, who spend several hours each day in practice.

---------------------------------------

They found that meditating actually increases the thickness of the cortex in areas involved in attention and sensory processing, such as the prefrontal cortex and the right anterior insula.

“You are exercising it while you meditate, and it gets bigger,” she says. The finding is in line with studies showing that accomplished musicians, athletes and linguists all have thickening in relevant areas of the cortex. It is further evidence, says Lazar, that yogis “aren’t just sitting there doing nothing".

Source.

(CNN) -- Regular meditation has been touted as a stress reducer for years, but a recent study says practitioners benefit from a brain boost as well.

CNN anchor Fredericka Whitfield spoke with Sara Lazar, a research scientist at Massachusetts General Hospital and an instructor at Harvard Medical School, about the study and meditation's apparent benefits.

WHITFIELD: Explain to me why, based on your study, have you learned that meditation really has a calming effect and perhaps even may boost brain power?

LAZAR: What we found was that people who have been practicing Buddhist insight meditation have a thicker cortex in some parts of their brain than people who don't meditate.

Source.

Scientific enough for you, yrreg? :)

(Also, do you see that I provide sources? That's very common on a sceptics board, to show that you're not just pulling stuff out of your ass.)
 
Last edited:
I enjoy learning how to upload images into this
JREF message board; and I seem to be getting
better and better. It's really fun and I am
acquiring a useful skill.

Yes, it's a good thing you've stopped using attachments. Attachments are bad for you ;)
 
To Ryokan and Mercurycurrent, with love; and me now a Resident Buddhist Critic.

Ryokan said:
Source.
.............
.............
.............

Scientific enough for you, yrreg?

(Also, do you see that I provide sources? That's very common on a sceptics board, to show that you're not just pulling stuff out of your [size=+8]ass[/size].)


[size=+4]pwn'd.[/size]

To Ryokan, Resident Buddhist: I know what is an [size=+4]ass,[/size] but tell me what is the meaning of [size=+4]ETA[/size] which you use at the end of your message to say a last line?

To Mercurycurrent: Tell me what is the meaning of [size=+4]pwn'd?[/size]


------------------


I am planning to call myself here, after my name of Yrreg, Resident Buddhist Critic. This is an experiment.


Yrreg
 
Official teachings and explanations; and I need help!

I am requesting the Buddhists here to refer me to websites where there are official teachings and explanations of Buddhism by recognized teachers or spokesmen of Buddhism. There must be some kind of world body of Buddhists, regional bodies of Buddhists, areal bodies of Buddhists, local bodies of Buddhists.

Epepke, perceptive and experienced critic that the man is, already made the observation early here that sooner than later one Buddhist will call another one NARB, meaning not a real Buddhist.

And I have already noticed early on that Buddhists here claim that the beliefs and practices of other Buddhists are not true Buddhist ones.

And that is why we need official documents from official leaders or spokesmen of Buddhists, and better that these official spokesmen also give us the big picture of Buddhism and deliver that big picture in a short statement.

----------------

I am planning to call myself here, after my name of Yrreg, Resident Buddhist Critic. This is an experiment.

Yrreg


I need help.

How do I put under my name, Yrreg, the additional label of Resident Buddhist Critic? I have been scouting around this forum in search of instructions, but so far to no avail. Who put that label, Scholar, below my name? Can I change that to Resident Buddhist Critic? Is there an office here where I can approach for that addition to my name, instead of Scholar.

I think that is what I understand from Ryokan and others here, that any description below one's name is allowed. Ryokan calls himself here Resident Buddhist; so I like to call myself here Resident Buddhist Critic.


Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom