But if Buddhists get to be in power I guess the temptation would be irresistible. I read that in Thailand there was a very serious move to draft a bill prohibiting journalists from any criticism of monks and the Buddhist faith which is a state religion there; but luckily their exposure to the Western ideal of a free and vigorously faultfinding press stopped the legislature from enacting such a law.
I don't know, I do know that a friend of a friend baught a buddha statue in Thailand and before they left the country the custom officials made them agree that they would not keep the statue in the bathroom.
Well, tell me about recurring rebirths and Nirvana:
1. Do you really believe in recurring rebirths as you might believe in extraterrestrial intelligence -- no, not that of the Christian God, but that of astrophysicists speculating on life away from earth?
No. Emotionaly I fend the idea appealing but from my reading the rebirth is only the continuance of megative thoughts and beliefs through the consequences of negative thoughts and beliefs.
I believe that the existance of extraterrestrial life is more likely than the rebirth of any spirit or soul.
2. Do you believe in Nirvana as you might believe in the kind of immortality for man, that science might one day closer than in the next half millennium, achieve -- if man survives in that period?
My understanding is that nirvana means the loss of attitudes and behaviors that lead to increasing suffering.
I do not believe in immortatlity, nor would I seek it.
It seems to me that the human body isn't meant to survive much past a hundred years.
About the man Buddha, do you really believe that he found something so original during his days, that mankind had not already before him arrived at as part of life wisdom, even within his immediate circle of civilization, already ancient during his days and in his terrain?
I would say that some pieces may have existed although the teaching of annatta is very unique in the culture. Also the fact that the benefit the buddha taught can be obtained without the aid of supernatural beings seems to be different. The Tao is similar, and not similar. Since I haven't seen evidence of the idea of the eight fold path in prior existance, I can't comment. So , agnostic would be the answer, according to the accounts written after the fact, it was something different than what was available at the time.
[/quote]
If you really think so, then for ordinary mortals who are not Buddha,
[/quote]
The buddha was a moratal, a human who often discussed thier faults. Somewhere I read that he stated that his sexuality and love of sexual activity was the greatest obstacle to his enlightenment.
tell me what he found to be so original, in the big picture perspectives and within the short statement of one hundred words.
As has been stated he precahed many diffent topics, the eightfold path, the four truths, the virtues and the morals.
I could not say if they are totaly original, agnostic, is the face of the lack of evidence.
Also, if you have not yet lost your equanimity, I understand you do Buddhist meditation of some kind meriting the designation of Buddhist, do you really believe that the psychological benefits you purportedly obtain with meditation are not available with some other simple exercise like strolling quietly, calmly, relaxedly in a park when the crowds have not yet intruded into the scene? -- benefits, that is prescinding your coming to the conviction or enlightenment about suffering, desire, rebirths, and Nirvana.
I have found benefit in the practise of the mindfull breathing. When walking or sitting someplace quiet, I still find that my emotions and thoughts are in turmoil, they reflect the negative thoughts and uncomfortabke situations I have recently experienced, or conversly the positive experiences.
The meditation, as I have been taught is to learn to observe the rise and fall of the thoughts and emotions, and to learn to calm and still them, with the benefit of living in the moment.
Given my contruction of body, thoughts and habits, if I use walking without mindfull breathing it can take about four hours of hiking to reach a point of stillness, or never attain through hiking calmly.
With mindfull beathing is usualy takes less time.
that is prescinding your coming to the conviction or enlightenment about suffering, desire, rebirths, and Nirvana
I would first say that my conviction is more of a belief that they are thoughts that I find have merit or benefit to myself.
Suffering occurs on many levels, some is unavoidabole, like grief or a toothache, but some it caused by our thoughts and actions, or made greater by our thoughts and actions.
Desire is what it is, it can be fun, sometimes unavaoidable, but easier if worked towards and not clung to.
Rebirths, I don't really believe in reincarnation, I think we can create cycles of suffering.
Nirvana, I dont't know. I have learned to suffer less and enjoy more, as for nirvana, agnostic.
I may have beliefs that vary from mainstream buddhism, as I have said I am very influenced by the teaching of Thich Naht Hahn.