Skeptical criticism on Buddhist beliefs and observances.

I am requesting the Buddhists here to refer me to websites where there are official teachings and explanations of Buddhism by recognized teachers or spokesmen of Buddhism. There must be some kind of world body of Buddhists, regional bodies of Buddhists, areal bodies of Buddhists, local bodies of Buddhists.

I did so at the start of the thread, you refused to read them.

Why should I do it again?

Epepke, perceptive and experienced critic that the man is, already made the observation early here that sooner than later one Buddhist will call another one NARB, meaning not a real Buddhist.

And has anyone done so, or have I actually refused to call anyone who labels himself Buddhist NARB?

And I have already noticed early on that Buddhists here claim that the beliefs and practices of other Buddhists are not true Buddhist ones.

No one has claimed such, although some people observed that some denominations of Buddhism contains a lot of superstition and belief in the supernatural (to which I agree).

And that is why we need official documents from official leaders or spokesmen of Buddhists, and better that these official spokesmen also give us the big picture of Buddhism and deliver that big picture in a short statement.

There are no official leaders or spokesmen of Buddhism. Study the teachings and make up your own mind.

I need help.

How do I put under my name, Yrreg, the additional label of Resident Buddhist Critic? I have been scouting around this forum in search of instructions, but so far to no avail. Who put that label, Scholar, below my name? Can I change that to Resident Buddhist Critic? Is there an office here where I can approach for that addition to my name, instead of Scholar.

You can use this thread, or go to the 'Forum Help & Member Support' subforum and start your own thread.


I think that is what I understand from Ryokan and others here, that any description below one's name is allowed. Ryokan calls himself here Resident Buddhist; so I like to call myself here Resident Buddhist Critic.

Wow, my own Nemesis.
 
Last edited:
To Ryokan, Resident Buddhist: I know what is an [size=+4]ass,[/size] but tell me what is the meaning of [size=+4]ETA[/size] which you use at the end of your message to say a last line?

To Mercurycurrent: Tell me what is the meaning of [size=+4]pwn'd?[/size]


------------------


I am planning to call myself here, after my name of Yrreg, Resident Buddhist Critic. This is an experiment.


Yrreg

Why are you shouting? Are you offended by the word ass? Everyone has one, you know. But not everyone is able to pull words out of it.

ETA means 'Edited To Add', and it's customary to make a note when you edit what you have editted. There's no rule about it, though, and I don't always do it although I try.

Pwn'd is slang for 'pwned' which is slang for 'owned'.

As you refused to answer my very simple questions, this is my last post in this thread.

Have a merry yule, yrreg.

ETA : Corrected some spelling.
 
Last edited:
I am requesting the Buddhists here to refer me to websites where there are official teachings and explanations of Buddhism by recognized teachers or spokesmen of Buddhism. There must be some kind of world body of Buddhists, regional bodies of Buddhists, areal bodies of Buddhists, local bodies of Buddhists.
As in many organizations of humans, buddhists tend to the mish mosh approachs and are very independant in a lot of ways.

Theravada is the oldest stream of buddhism in many ways and represents the 'traditional' buddhist approach.

Mahayana is the great accumulator of traditions and beliefs, it is a huge variety of different kinds of traditions and beliefs.

In Japan there are many almost unique buddhist traditions , like the Amida. In Tibet there is also a very old tradition that predates the 'yellow robes' of the Dalai Lama, called the "red robes". In Chaina there is a tradition called Chan , which in some ways is said to be a precursor of Zen.

I have mentioned at least two of the more popular teachers the Dalai Lama and Thich Naht Hahn.

Each area where there are buddhists usualy has a 'bretahing group' where people get together to meditate.

I am not aware of any monolithic authority that would equate to the catholic church or the episcopeleans, buddhists seem to learn individualy from chosen teachers.

I believe that there are web organizationts like buddhanet and buddha web rings.
And I have already noticed early on that Buddhists here claim that the beliefs and practices of other Buddhists are not true Buddhist ones.
My statement was that many of the magical and metaphysical beliefs are not associated with the teachings of the buddha, you also gave the standard misconceptions about mainstream buddhism.

There is no 'True Scotsman" clause in the teachings of the buddha, anyone who feels that they are a buddhist is a bhuddist, this is the biggest schism between the Teravada and the mahayana schools, Theravada holds to a very old tradition, Mahayana schools teach that any practise that leads to the buddha is a good practise and so they are receptive to magic and ritual.

There is no defining body to sanction what a buddhist is, just a bunch of diverse people who follow different aspects of the buddha's teachings.
And that is why we need official documents from official leaders or spokesmen of Buddhists, and better that these official spokesmen also give us the big picture of Buddhism and deliver that big picture in a short statement.
I am afraid that you will be disappointed there, when I have looked a the teachings, they relate upon the uniqueness and interdependant nature of reality and therefore they tend to go on a bit.

The four truths and the eightfold path , the virtues are probably the shortest explanation. Then a teacher will say something like "The four noble truths should not be explaineed until the other cocepts are understood".
----------------




I need help.

How do I put under my name, Yrreg, the additional label of Resident Buddhist Critic? I have been scouting around this forum in search of instructions, but so far to no avail. Who put that label, Scholar, below my name? Can I change that to Resident Buddhist Critic? Is there an office here where I can approach for that addition to my name, instead of Scholar.
I believe that you can join the JREF for that privilege.
 
Now this is what we like to call an "empirical claim" around here.

Is there any evidence for it?

Forget mysticism, forget the theory, forget the straw men. Is there any evidence for this that is stronger, say, than the evidence for homeopathy (which, I remind you, some people adhere to rather strongly for personal reasons)?

I would say that the buddha felt it was up to the individual to decide that the teachings had merit , and then I will state that a lot of the more useful psychobabble , like cognitive behavioral therapy and dialectic based therapy has some similarities to the teachings of the buddha.

The only empirical evidence would be in a controlled quality of life survey.
And if it is necessary to explain it, then what is it? How can I distinguish someone who is awake from someone who is simply awake?
Gosh, this is a very good rejoinder I was begining to contemplate the p-buddha and p-elightenment for a moment! Maybe a p-zombie can follow the p-buddha to p-enlightenment!
 
Merry Yule to all, and my experiment, and Stoicism compared to Buddhism.

Ryokan said:
As you refused to answer my very simple questions, this is my last post in this thread.

Have a merry yule, yrreg.

And a merry yule to you also, good Ryokan.

------------------

Well, I just added a graphic image thus Resident Buddhist Critic, to my name as an Avatar -- there seems to be no other way as of now for me to effect what Ryokan has below his name. Let's see how it turns out when I post this message.

--------------

Someone here told me that Stoicism is not really a naturalistic philosophy and lifestyle, because in the article I cited he showed me the words like soul, God, divine, logos, etc. I told him I would check on it, doing more reading of Stoicism in reference websites.

So, at this point in time, I still have for a big picture and in a short statement, this impression of Stoicism as compared to Buddhism.

Stoicism is a naturalistic world-view, a rationalistic system as rationalism is distinct from or different from mysticism; everything for Stoicism is matter, even soul and God. The soul is material though the invisible constituent of man, God is the material though invisible agent in charge of the material universe -- and that's the only one.

So, as a big picture and in a short statement, Stoicism is again naturalistic, rationalistic, and definitely not a mystical order of the universe, life, man, and man's pursuit of happiness; Buddhism compared to Stoicism is a mystical system, not naturalistic and not rationalistic.

Anyway, as the Romans say: "est brevitate opus, ut currat sententia." So, please bear with me, and tell me where I am wrong, but again the big picture in the short statement.


Yrreg
 
I would say that the buddha felt it was up to the individual to decide that the teachings had merit , and then I will state that a lot of the more useful psychobabble , like cognitive behavioral therapy and dialectic based therapy has some similarities to the teachings of the buddha.

Well, this is why people consider Freudian psychoanalysis pseudoscience, because after decades of doing it, and despite oodles of anecdotes, there was no evidence that it works.

The only empirical evidence would be in a controlled quality of life survey.

Which is why psychologists are supposed to do longitudinal studies. They don't like to do it, but they're supposed to.

Where I am right now (which physicians affectionately refer to as "God's Waiting Room"), you can't throw a stone without hitting half a dozen "pain management" clinics. You'd think they'd be interested in something that could be empirically demonstrated to reduce suffering, don't you?

Gosh, this is a very good rejoinder I was begining to contemplate the p-buddha and p-elightenment for a moment! Maybe a p-zombie can follow the p-buddha to p-enlightenment!

One of the possible conclusion of the p-zombie arguments results in the idea that, no, you really cannot tell the difference, so it's a distinction without a difference.

But, basically, what I've seen so far is just piling more undefined terms on top of each other.
 
Wishing Buddhists here a Merry Yuletide!

I found this Kadampa website and I am reproducing here their number one inspiration and founder, Mr. Gyatso. And in line with the Christmas season I am giving you the account of Buddha's birth as told to us in this website.


​


(The following excerpts about the life of Buddha are taken from Geshe Kelsang Gyatso's book, Introduction to Buddhism.)

The Buddha who is the founder of the Buddhist religion is called Buddha Shakyamuni. "Shakya" is the name of the royal family into which he was born, and "Muni" means "Able One."

Buddha Skakyamuni was born as a royal prince in 624 BC in a place called Lumbini, which was originally in northern India but is now part of Nepal. His mother's name was Queen Mayadevi and his father's name was King Shuddhodana.

One night, Queen Mayadevi dreamed that a white elephant descended from heaven and entered her womb. The white elephant entering her womb indicated that on that very night she had conceived a child who was a pure and powerful being. The elephant's descending from heaven indicated that her child came from Tushita heaven, the Pure Land of Buddha Maitreya.

Later, when she gave birth to the child, instead of experiencing pain the queen experienced a special, pure vision in which she stood holding the branch of a tree with her right hand while the gods Brahma and Indra took the child painlessly from her side. They then proceeded to honor the infant by offering him ritual ablutions.

When the king saw the child he felt as if all his wishes had been fulfilled and he named the young prince "Siddhartha." He invited a Brahmin seer to make predictions about the prince's future. The seer examined the child with his clairvoyance and told the king, "There are signs that the boy could become either a chakravatin king, a ruler of the entire world, or a fully enlightened Buddha.

However, since the time for chakravatin kings is now past it is certain that he will become a Buddha, and that his beneficial influence will pervade the thousand million worlds like the rays of the sun.

(snip snip snip )​


Have a Happy Holiday!


Yrreg

*No worry about copyright because this website encourages telling a friend about the materials in it.
 
Well, this is why people consider Freudian psychoanalysis pseudoscience, because after decades of doing it, and despite oodles of anecdotes, there was no evidence that it works.
Definite agreement there, I follow the schools of 'problem solving' and CBT(cognitive behavioral therapy), both of which theoreticaly are goal directed and outcome based.
Frued himself realized that many of his abservations no longer applied after the societies around him changed, most of his followers ignore that.
Which is why psychologists are supposed to do longitudinal studies. They don't like to do it, but they're supposed to.
Many do , and gee funders now demand outcome proof, like an improvement in scores on assesment tools.
 
I found this Kadampa website and I am reproducing here their number one inspiration and founder, Mr. Gyatso. And in line with the Christmas season I am giving you the account of Buddha's birth as told to us in this website.

Yeah, way cool, usualy celebrated in May.
One night, Queen Mayadevi dreamed that a white elephant descended from heaven and entered her womb. The white elephant entering her womb indicated that on that very night she had conceived a child who was a pure and powerful being. The elephant's descending from heaven indicated that her child came from Tushita heaven, the Pure Land of Buddha Maitreya.
As I said earlier i am very sceptical of the white elephant story, and the Maitreya indicates this is Amida buddhism.
Later, when she gave birth to the child, instead of experiencing pain the queen experienced a special, pure vision in which she stood holding the branch of a tree with her right hand while the gods Brahma and Indra took the child painlessly from her side. They then proceeded to honor the infant by offering him ritual ablutions.
Sounds like they were Dr.s Bramha and Indra and they preformed a cesarean. With anesthetic.
;)
When the king saw the child he felt as if all his wishes had been fulfilled and he named the young prince "Siddhartha." He invited a Brahmin seer to make predictions about the prince's future. The seer examined the child with his clairvoyance and told the king, "There are signs that the boy could become either a chakravatin king, a ruler of the entire world, or a fully enlightened Buddha.
The other story which I am also sceptical of is that the buddha as a yound man was walking down a road and a seer looked at his footprint and saw the 'ten thousand spoked wheel' which idicated he would become a mighty king or religous leader.
However, since the time for chakravatin kings is now past it is certain that he will become a Buddha, and that his beneficial influence will pervade the thousand million worlds like the rays of the sun.
I guess they left out the part where Suhdanna is so smitten that he decides his son will never become a religous leader and reaises him to be a great king.
(snip snip snip )[/indent]


Have a Happy Holiday!


Yrreg

*No worry about copyright because this website encourages telling a friend about the materials in it.
Happy Holiday!

There is an alleged follower of the buddha who took all his alms to give presents to children, he is protrayed as a smiling man with a sack of toys!
 
No need to lose one's equanimity, and moments of truth..

Thanks, Dancing David, for that reference to Critic of Buddhism in the web; now I am getting to read critiques of Buddhism, and I am not feeling anymore so lonely, not to flatter myself though, as the only skeptical critic of Buddhism.

I thought you lost your Buddhist equanimity earlier in this thread at the start, but more recently I noticed a change in you, less frenetical but more "just the facts, ma'am" attitude.

That's good, for I would not want to get the impression that Buddhists possess the same ardor as some Muslims who would issue what they call? a fatwa, exhorting every Muslim to take it upon himself as his duty to Islam, to Allah and Mohammad, to kill someone for criticizing and thereby blaspheming their religion and their prophet and their God (think Salman Rushdie -- that man still in hiding? and what a name, Rushdie).

But if Buddhists get to be in power I guess the temptation would be irresistible. I read that in Thailand there was a very serious move to draft a bill prohibiting journalists from any criticism of monks and the Buddhist faith which is a state religion there; but luckily their exposure to the Western ideal of a free and vigorously faultfinding press stopped the legislature from enacting such a law.

You appear now to be more and more what I think you said once that you are a philosophic Buddhist, even to the extent of maybe lapsing into a kind of Buddhism without Buddha.

Well, tell me about recurring rebirths and Nirvana:

1. Do you really believe in recurring rebirths as you might believe in extraterrestrial intelligence -- no, not that of the Christian God, but that of astrophysicists speculating on life away from earth?

2. Do you believe in Nirvana as you might believe in the kind of immortality for man, that science might one day closer than in the next half millennium, achieve -- if man survives in that period?


About the man Buddha, do you really believe that he found something so original during his days, that mankind had not already before him arrived at as part of life wisdom, even within his immediate circle of civilization, already ancient during his days and in his terrain?

If you really think so, then for ordinary mortals who are not Buddha, tell me what he found to be so original, in the big picture perspectives and within the short statement of one hundred words.


Also, if you have not yet lost your equanimity, I understand you do Buddhist meditation of some kind meriting the designation of Buddhist, do you really believe that the psychological benefits you purportedly obtain with meditation are not available with some other simple exercise like strolling quietly, calmly, relaxedly in a park when the crowds have not yet intruded into the scene? -- benefits, that is prescinding your coming to the conviction or enlightenment about suffering, desire, rebirths, and Nirvana.


Yrreg
 
Who would agree that, before we even get as far and in-depth as the topics above, Buddhism is in itself a contradiction?

Buddha was not a preacher, did not proclaim hisself a messiah or second coming or whatever. He purported removal of the shackles of isms and schisms to achieve enlightenment.
Now those who "follow" him defy his very words before they've taken another step, eh?

[/first post in years]
*prepares to be flamed into next century*

This is a telling post. We have to remember that Buddhism is possibly one of the most "human" religions ever. By that I mean it is a human construction, and carries flaws and such that other religions do. But it is also most human without the worship of any god or other such deities.

The thing is, Buddhism has BECOME a deity-worshipping religion for the masses. As a Chinese, I can tell you that it is embedded deeply in many Chinese to pray to Buddha and wish for luck, protection and prosperity. This is a practice that extends itself in China, Hong Kong, Taiwan, Singapore and Thailand. In modern terms it has become really, something like a parallel of Christianity, with the main distinction of modern Christianity being of Chrisitans having a "closer" relationship with god. Also consider how Buddhism in India started with the practice of not eating cows, which were considered sacred (because of their contribution to agriculture and such). When the religion spread to the chinese nations, it changed.

So we might consider "modern" Buddhism to really be quite warped. So let's take a couple of steps back and look at Buddha and his time.. the problem is, we only have recorded text that was written LONG after Buddha's death. I have read that it was one of his disciples, with allegedly superb memory, who was in charge of writing the Sutras. Who knows what degree of accuracy is presented, and this could explain the embellishment of gods and such, who communicated to Buddha from time to time (in reality, they were part of the cultural and religious fabric in that contemporary Indian era). So we know that what we have is an incomplete picture, and we must be skeptical.

In some texts, after Gautama (Buddha) achieved enlightenment, he walked to the nearest town to start spreading his teachings and wisdom. Along the way, he meets a man who asks Gautama who he was. Gautama replied, "I am Buddha." (Remember that in those terms, he meant, "I am enlightened" or "I am the awakened one") The man laughed, and walked right by him. Buddha didn't have any mystical, supernatural power or aura. He was man, like you and I. In fact, his death also led to the splitting of Buddhism into its two main sects; Theravada and Mahayana. This was something that pained him, and the politics within the organization was also a source of trouble.

As such the picture seems to be that Buddha really was human, like you and I. He steps on things and bleeds as well (recorded in texts), and possesses no special aura that could convert the passing man. I guess maybe in all, he was really just a wise man. Buddhism *is* a philosophy more than a religion, and you are right in the sense that Buddha did not want an "ism" and other established organizations/cultures that presents only dogmas. These were limitations. But without them, information becomes very, very difficult to disseminate. I think he was aware of this cost, and went ahead anyways.

The lesson seems to be, read Buddhist texts but never take them as truths just because they're texts. Be skeptical, be a critical thinking person. Be less mindful of worldly desires and items. I am sure there will be much one can learn from the texts, and then incorporate into your life. This is difficult -- change requires practice and patience. But in all, I think there is a multitude of ways one can construe Buddhism, and what's most important is critical thinking, a willingness to adopt such principles and incorporate them into your life, and ultimately have a sense of calm, a sense of purpose, and a sense of "knowing".
 
But if Buddhists get to be in power I guess the temptation would be irresistible. I read that in Thailand there was a very serious move to draft a bill prohibiting journalists from any criticism of monks and the Buddhist faith which is a state religion there; but luckily their exposure to the Western ideal of a free and vigorously faultfinding press stopped the legislature from enacting such a law.
I don't know, I do know that a friend of a friend baught a buddha statue in Thailand and before they left the country the custom officials made them agree that they would not keep the statue in the bathroom.
Well, tell me about recurring rebirths and Nirvana:

1. Do you really believe in recurring rebirths as you might believe in extraterrestrial intelligence -- no, not that of the Christian God, but that of astrophysicists speculating on life away from earth?
No. Emotionaly I fend the idea appealing but from my reading the rebirth is only the continuance of megative thoughts and beliefs through the consequences of negative thoughts and beliefs.
I believe that the existance of extraterrestrial life is more likely than the rebirth of any spirit or soul.
2. Do you believe in Nirvana as you might believe in the kind of immortality for man, that science might one day closer than in the next half millennium, achieve -- if man survives in that period?
My understanding is that nirvana means the loss of attitudes and behaviors that lead to increasing suffering.
I do not believe in immortatlity, nor would I seek it.
It seems to me that the human body isn't meant to survive much past a hundred years.
About the man Buddha, do you really believe that he found something so original during his days, that mankind had not already before him arrived at as part of life wisdom, even within his immediate circle of civilization, already ancient during his days and in his terrain?
I would say that some pieces may have existed although the teaching of annatta is very unique in the culture. Also the fact that the benefit the buddha taught can be obtained without the aid of supernatural beings seems to be different. The Tao is similar, and not similar. Since I haven't seen evidence of the idea of the eight fold path in prior existance, I can't comment. So , agnostic would be the answer, according to the accounts written after the fact, it was something different than what was available at the time.
[/quote]

If you really think so, then for ordinary mortals who are not Buddha,
[/quote]
The buddha was a moratal, a human who often discussed thier faults. Somewhere I read that he stated that his sexuality and love of sexual activity was the greatest obstacle to his enlightenment.
tell me what he found to be so original, in the big picture perspectives and within the short statement of one hundred words.
As has been stated he precahed many diffent topics, the eightfold path, the four truths, the virtues and the morals.
I could not say if they are totaly original, agnostic, is the face of the lack of evidence.
Also, if you have not yet lost your equanimity, I understand you do Buddhist meditation of some kind meriting the designation of Buddhist, do you really believe that the psychological benefits you purportedly obtain with meditation are not available with some other simple exercise like strolling quietly, calmly, relaxedly in a park when the crowds have not yet intruded into the scene? -- benefits, that is prescinding your coming to the conviction or enlightenment about suffering, desire, rebirths, and Nirvana.
I have found benefit in the practise of the mindfull breathing. When walking or sitting someplace quiet, I still find that my emotions and thoughts are in turmoil, they reflect the negative thoughts and uncomfortabke situations I have recently experienced, or conversly the positive experiences.
The meditation, as I have been taught is to learn to observe the rise and fall of the thoughts and emotions, and to learn to calm and still them, with the benefit of living in the moment.
Given my contruction of body, thoughts and habits, if I use walking without mindfull breathing it can take about four hours of hiking to reach a point of stillness, or never attain through hiking calmly.
With mindfull beathing is usualy takes less time.

that is prescinding your coming to the conviction or enlightenment about suffering, desire, rebirths, and Nirvana

I would first say that my conviction is more of a belief that they are thoughts that I find have merit or benefit to myself.
Suffering occurs on many levels, some is unavoidabole, like grief or a toothache, but some it caused by our thoughts and actions, or made greater by our thoughts and actions.
Desire is what it is, it can be fun, sometimes unavaoidable, but easier if worked towards and not clung to.
Rebirths, I don't really believe in reincarnation, I think we can create cycles of suffering.
Nirvana, I dont't know. I have learned to suffer less and enjoy more, as for nirvana, agnostic.

I may have beliefs that vary from mainstream buddhism, as I have said I am very influenced by the teaching of Thich Naht Hahn.
 
A sense of self-importance.

snip snip snip

In some texts, after Gautama (Buddha) achieved enlightenment, he walked to the nearest town to start spreading his teachings and wisdom. Along the way, he meets a man who asks Gautama who he was. Gautama replied, "I am Buddha." (Remember that in those terms, he meant, "I am enlightened" or "I am the awakened one") The man laughed, and walked right by him. Buddha didn't have any mystical, supernatural power or aura. He was man, like you and I.

snip snip snip

As such the picture seems to be that Buddha really was human, like you and I. He steps on things and bleeds as well (recorded in texts), and possesses no special aura that could convert the passing man. I guess maybe in all, he was really just a wise man.

snip snip snip

The way I see it, the man had a terrific sense of self-importance, what we might say with certainty, saturated with a grand messianic complex.

He does not say so, but he feels so. Or he says the opposite but feels himself so very important, chosen by destiny to give mankind the answer to the most important question they must ask, and the the answer they must have.

And who knows the question and the answer? Who else but he, Buddha.

Well, he is not alone among the innumerable self-important guys who know the question and the answer.

What is the most challenging probe is how he succeeded like as other founders of religion succeeded, for example, Moses, Jesus Christ, Mohammad, and one L. Ron Hubbard.

The secret is in his personality, in his times, and in his audience.

Anyone the way I see it can succeed also with founding a religion or a system like that similar to Buddha's.

If you can see ahead to fifty years of good health, you can start today preaching your particular kind of philosophico-religious system; but first you have got to be perplexed yourself by the question of what is existence and all the caboodle and then fashion your own answer.

Start convincing people that your question is what they should be most preoccupied with, and the answer they want is what you have found out to be the one.

Work at that for five years, ten, twenty, twenty-five, and you will succeed. Why? Because there's a sucker born every minute looking for a teacher and leader to follow.

Then you can start living fabulously on your followers.

Did Buddha live fabulously on his followers, not carnally but oh so psychically, what a high he was on all the time; he would not exchange that for a harem of houris, a mansion like that of Bill Gates, and luxurious jet liners; no, not for him the lifestyle of the rich and famous, but yes recognition as the what, last of the Buddha and the ultimate one, after him no more greater and better.

And even before he died and against his feigned protestations, he was already recognized as a god and treated and prayed to as one.

[Cynical hahaha and hehehe.]

I almost forget, whatever philosophico-religious order you go into, never, never, ever, go against but instead recognize and advocate the universal moral and civilized values of mankind, like the eightfold path and the ten commandments, sanctity of home and family, marriage, peace and order in society.


Yrreg
 
Start convincing people that your question is what they should be most preoccupied with,

Hmm, I guess you have a point. If the Buddha had never said anything about life being suffering, no one would have be preoccupied with it. :rolleyes:
 
...And that is why we need official documents from official leaders or spokesmen of Buddhists, and better that these official spokesmen also give us the big picture of Buddhism and deliver that big picture in a short statement.
Here is an approximation of that 'in a nutshell':
Buddhists of Sri Lanka
http://www.accesstoinsight.org/lib/authors/kariyawasam/wheel402.html#pre

The theme of this study, Buddhist ceremonies and rituals, may not appeal to the self-styled Buddhist purist who wishes to restrict the designation "Buddhism" exclusively to the teachings of the Buddhist scriptures, which he usually interprets in a narrowly intellectualist manner. The fact remains, however, that the practices and observances to be described here justly claim an integral place within the stream of living Buddhism as practiced by its adherents. Because these practices form an intimate part of the religious life for the vast majority of devout Buddhist followers, they cannot be lightly dismissed as mere secondary appendages of a "pristine" canonical Buddhism.

It has been an inevitable phenomenon in the history of religion that whenever a religion was newly introduced to a culture, its adherents assimilated it and adapted it in ways that harmonized with their own social and cultural needs. In the case of Buddhism this has happened in every country to which it spread, and Sri Lanka is no exception. The core doctrines of Buddhism, such as the Four Noble Truths, the Noble Eightfold Path, dependent arising, etc., often proved too abstruse and elevated for the ordinary populace to apply to their own religious lives. To satisfy their devotional and emotional needs, they required a system of outward acts, communally shared, by which they could express their devotion to the ideals represented by the Dhamma and absorb these ideals into the texture of their daily experience. This was how the "great tradition" of canonical Buddhism came to be complemented by the "small tradition" of popular Buddhism consisting of the rituals and ceremonies discussed in this booklet.

The purpose of the present study is to highlight this often neglected face of popular Buddhism. Though the study focuses on Buddhism as practiced in Sri Lanka, the same basic round of rituals and ceremonies, with minor variations, can be found in the other countries following Theravada Buddhism, such as Burma and Thailand. I also hope that this survey will demonstrate that the expression of Buddhist piety in devotional forms is a necessity if Buddhism is to survive at the popular level as a vital and vibrant force in the daily life of its adherents. Thus the votaries of a "pristine pure Buddhism" posited on the basis of the canonical texts should not ignore or devalue this aspect of Buddhism as an alien encroachment on the Buddha's original doctrine. Rather, they should come to recognize the devotional manifestation of Buddhism as an essential feature of the tradition, needed to mediate between its exalted ideals and the everyday concerns of the vast majority of its followers.

A.G.S. Kariyawasam

I need help.

How do I put under my name, Yrreg, the additional label of Resident Buddhist Critic? I have been scouting around this forum in search of instructions, but so far to no avail. Who put that label, Scholar, below my name? Can I change that to Resident Buddhist Critic? Is there an office here where I can approach for that addition to my name, instead of Scholar.

I think that is what I understand from Ryokan and others here, that any description below one's name is allowed. Ryokan calls himself here Resident Buddhist; so I like to call myself here Resident Buddhist Critic.


Yrreg

There is a thread under the area of "forum help and member support" called "Custom title please". You can request a label there. This might be less conspicuous than text in an avatar, which tends to look like you need help.
A link to the thread is here:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=45138

If I were prone to give advice (which I'm not), I would take the advice of several earlier posters and narrow your criticism. Buddhism is very broad, and some of what you post is mistaken, similar to accusing Protestants of worshiping the Pope. I suspect that most Buddhists would welcome answering specific criticisms (well, once anyway), but asking them how many times they beat their wives is not likely to provoke a response.
 
The thing is, Buddhism has BECOME a deity-worshipping religion for the masses. As a Chinese, I can tell you that it is embedded deeply in many Chinese to pray to Buddha and wish for luck, protection and prosperity. This is a practice that extends itself in China, Hong Kong, Taiwan, Singapore and Thailand.

Well, I know a few self-proclaimed Buddhists from Thailand, and they seem to me to use the Three Earthly Kings (or is it four?) as something akin to saints.

More problematic to me is Karma. As it is usually presented, although there may be no explicit mention of a supernatural entity, this seems to presuppose somebody to make the so-called cause-and-effect work out. I've seen apologia where it's just internal and some sort of conflict with the conscience, but that has a problem: it doesn't work with sociopaths. Sociopaths are like the Terminator; they're just programmed that way (or have programmed themselves that way) and don't have a conscience. So is the ultimate goal of Buddhism to become a sociopath? If that be so, then it would be frightening.

There's a similar problem that I've had with many animistic ideas. Let's take lycanthropy. OK, let's assume that there's some psychic power that allows one to change form (although I presume that mass is conserved). That would still require some knowledge on how to make a wolf. The heart of a wolf is chambered differently, and the liver of a wolf can't handle Tylenol, and so on and so forth. Someone or something has to know that, and if not a supernatural entity, then what?
 
The way I see it, the man had a terrific sense of self-importance, what we might say with certainty, saturated with a grand messianic complex.

The way I see it, prima facie, is a bit different. The Buddha was pretty privileged. Then he gets to experience something that makes him realize that the world isn't so easy for everybody as it was for him growing up.

I've seen a similar thing happen with children of doctors and lawyers who go to college. They generally become communists or socialists. I haven't met many wo have come from a working-class background, as I did. Mostly they seem to be privileged.

Also, I have to say that while attributing suffering to something inside the individual might result from a genuine desire to help, it is also a brilliant invention for someone who wishes to maintain a class-based society. If suffering is inside the individual and should properly be addressed with meditation and so forth and so on, well, that's quite a handy idea for a ruling class that wants to live well in a low-calorie-per-capita society. Ultimately, though, in Nietzschean terms, it's based on ressentiment, a process by which people who have no power to effect change claim their lack of power as a moral strength.

I distrust this. I know that I would be a lot happier with more money. I know that I am happier right now because I got some money for Christmas. I get to pay my medical bills for a couple of months, and I get to have my broken wisdom tooth pulled. This makes me feel a lot better. Surely, those who say that "money does not buy happiness" are missing the point. It may not, but lack of money definitely buys unhappiness, and the bills are always paid.
 
Well, I know a few self-proclaimed Buddhists from Thailand, and they seem to me to use the Three Earthly Kings (or is it four?) as something akin to saints.

Yes, and I know this one self-proclaimed christian who runs this 'god hates fags' website. I know another one who seems to believe having this rosary around the rear view mirror in her car somehow brings her good luck. Have I said anything at all about Christianity or the teachings of Jesus or have I simply said some things about the man who runs the website and the woman who hangs the rosary in her car?

More problematic to me is Karma. As it is usually presented, although there may be no explicit mention of a supernatural entity, this seems to presuppose somebody to make the so-called cause-and-effect work out. I've seen apologia where it's just internal and some sort of conflict with the conscience, but that has a problem: it doesn't work with sociopaths.

That's interesting. I am not buddhist, but I have been reading a bit on it from a few books and practicing meditation. I don't really know what anyone else thinks of karma in this tradition or that and I am not even fully certain what I think of it(because I don't know what anyone other than the teachers whose books I have read say it is. However, the way things have been explained to me, if any buddhist teaching requires faith to believe, it isn't buddhist in nature and the buddha himself is said to have taught others to not believe him or anyone else if they couldn't determine the truth of the teachings themselves.

My understanding from the books I have read (I linked to 2 of them previously in this thread if interested in the source) is that all the 'truths' of buddhism can be seen for oneself. In other words if you test it and are unable to see it for yourself then there is no reason whatsoever that you should opt to believe or have faith that it is true. Buddhism, as I understand, it is about direct experience, not beliefs, rituals, faith or anything else.

Anyway, karma as I presently understand it can be seen. One very simple example that you could test out if so inclined would be to go and experiment with negativity to see if it comes back to you. Go find someone and give them a good dose of scorn and contempt. What comes back to you?

Again, a patheticly simple and obvious example, but so far in my reading I have not been asked to accept anything as true that I cannot see for myself.

A less direct example would be allowing the negative 'energy' (sorry, can't think of a better term off the top of my head) someone exposes you to to pass through you and do not direct it back at them. Instead view the angry person as hurting. The anger isn't coming from evil, it is coming from pain. So respond not to an angry person, but a hurting person who will benefit from compassion and love. Give that back instead of following the natural tendency to return the negativity with negativity and see what happens.

As I understand it both examples I gave demonstrate karma. I see no reason to believe karma any further than you can test it and confirm it. Any claims made of it beyond what you are able to test should simply be put into the untested, unconfirmed category. At present I do 'believe' karma, but only insofar as I have explained it which is the full extent to which I understand it and have tested it as of this moment. But, I am not asking you to believe me, I am inviting you to test it for yourself and see what happens.
 
The way I see it, the man had a terrific sense of self-importance, what we might say with certainty, saturated with a grand messianic complex.

Yrreg

What, now you project yourself onto religious figures?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom