Skeptical criticism on Buddhist beliefs and observances.

Look, I swear, I don't even know yrreg.

But I've never seen the First Noble Truth translated as "there is suffering" before now. I remind you that I've read translations in both English and German. Usually, what I've seen is translated to (possibly doubly) as "life is suffering," with "existence is suffering" a distant second.

I have seen it translated as such as well. That was what I thought it was at first. And it turned me off big time because my life does involve some moments of suffering, but also many moments of happiness, contentment etc. If I had to believe that all of my life was suffering then this buddhism thing wasn't for me because I was being asked to believe something that was not true to my experience and that is the mark of faith based religions.

In "Buddhism Plain and Simple" it is explained that there is no English word for duhkha so a direct, word for word translation is not possible. The word refers to a wheel out of kilter. Wikepedia says (in part) this: "The term is probably derived from duḥstha, "standing badly," "unsteady," "uneasy.""

So, it helps me to think of the first noble truth as "Life is like a wheel out of kilter". That may not help you, but this explanation might help. This comes from the book I mentioned above. Imagine the technology at the time of Buddha's life. He would have known about wagon wheels, pulled by horses or the like. Imagine riding in a carriage with a wheel out of kilter. It rides fine for awhile and then it rises and falls. Over and over, without end, it rides fine and then 'bump'. This bump, detracts from the smooth portion of the ride and over time those bumps grate on us more and more.

The bad translation is just that, a bad translation. It is an attempt to perform a word for word translation where none is possible. Unfortunately I do agree with you that the bad translation is quite common on the web. Fortunately the books I have read are very helpful in clearing matters up.

So far I have to say the book "Buddhism Plain and Simple" lives up to it's title.
 
I have here two questions which I think Buddhists should answer honestly and without quibbling.


1. From my stock knowledge, I have come to know that Buddha or the Gautama or the person hailed by Buddhists as the founder of their religion called Buddhism, was overwhelmed by the sight of suffering.

Now, we can quibble for ever whether he was saying that all life is suffering or that there is suffering in life, but what I understand is that his dismay with what he saw to be suffering was so intense that in effect he felt that life is all suffering.

If Buddhists here maybe can produce the earliest text of any mention by him of suffering and its description, then we might see that for the man there is so much and so keen of suffering in life that, as I said, the man in effect, that is in his heart and mind, psychologically was devastated so that for him all life is suffering.

And that is why he built his kind of religious philosophy on the cornerstone of suffering.
"Now this, monks, is the noble truth of stress: Birth is stressful, aging is stressful, death is stressful; sorrow, lamentation, pain, distress, & despair are stressful; association with the unbeloved is stressful, separation from the loved is stressful, not getting what is wanted is stressful. In short, the five clinging-aggregates are stressful."

Please note that they have replaced dukkha with the words stress.

http://www.accesstoinsight.org/canon/sutta/samyutta/sn-56-011-tb0.html

2. The way I see Buddhists here representing Buddhism in most quibbling manners in order to convince people who do read plain and quick accounts of Buddhism from encyclopedias and reports of witnesses, in order to show that Buddhism is a most intricate and most subtle system of thought
I am not sure how subtle, I like it because I am a materialist.
-- and ordinary people reading encyclopedias and reports of witnesses can see what simply Buddhism is all about, (sorry for the long sentence, hahaha), I wonder if Buddhists themselves who hope to attain Nirvana will ever attain it at all: since they might end up doubting themselves if they have acquired in their heart and mind the Buddhism that is efficacious in bringing them to Nirvana -- because they might miss some intricacies in it or get any of the intricacies wrongly or imprecisely.

The eightfold path is the reported path to enlightenment, not the quibbling.

BTW have you found any evidence that the eightfold path was in existance before the buddha taught it?
I must apologize for these long sentences; but I guess you get what I am driving at. Anyway, to be succinct:

1. Please, as you are Buddhists and searchers of Buddha's original words, as original as you can find them, please present here his most original or most authentic statement on suffering and its description.

2. If you Buddhists keep on quibbling in order just to sound very profound and to keep on thinking that anyone so much as pointing out the difficulties of Buddhist doctrines and observances should be, shall I use the word? gainsaid; then you might yourselves end up wondering among yourselves who have got the real McCoy of Buddha's most original genuine unadulterated words, which he spoke without any modifications from when he started preaching to when he breathed his last, if at all he ever spoke always uniformly without any changes in the course of his preaching years.
There is a story that the Pali canon was generated by all those who had learned the oral tradition of the buddha(historic) getting together and seeing what they could agree upon.

Then as someone in this thread stated the teachings of the buddha are not limited to the historic buddha, but to those who have found the Bodh-Lite and have drank it.
Again for the second question, what I want to tell the Buddhists here is that it can be most counterproductive for you to keep on making more and more intricate and unwieldy labyrinthine mazes, in order just to satisfy yourselves that observers outside don't get Buddhist beliefs and practices correctly, that you might inevitably get lost inside your own mazes, and never ever get to Nirvana.
The practices are simple, folow the eightfold path, some of the principles like annatta are counter intuitive, and in explaining them more words do mean less.
And that would be truly ironic if not comic. Anyway, shall we all have a hahaha and a hehehe?

Hahaha and hehehe!


Yrreg

Laughter is good!

Titter titter, snort, guffaw.
 
snip
Anyway, I think all of them would rather follow the laughing Buddha, and not the gaunt one with eyes sinking in gloom and doom.

snip
Yrreg

Strangely the gaunt asetic is not the buddha, but the figure of gautama on his way to becoming the buddha, the buddha rejected the path of mortification prior to his enlightenment, although there are many statues of the starving pre-buddha nonetheless.
 
There is much hair splitting even as to the meaning of dukkha!

And isn't this sad?

I mean, look at christianity, a religion that is much better understood in "western" nations than buddhism since it is easier to relate to. We have these teachings of this historical figure known as Jesus.

2000 years later we have 2000+ sects with varying doctrines even on something as basic as the doctrine of salvation. Some sects believe Jesus was God, some believe he was a prophet. There is even quibbling on such a basic matter? Let's not even get into the role of baptism in xianity with all it's variances. Christians quibble about the communion wafer whether it really tranmogrifies into the flesh of Jesus as it goes down the throat! Ridiculous.

Unfortunately it appears that after 2500 years Buddhism has faired no better.

It isn't the fault of the teachings of Jesus or Buddha, it is the fault of the humans who followed who have insisted on formalizing, ritualizing, and codifying simple teachings to the point where they become incomprehensible and those who do follow a tradition may never come to realize that what they are following isn't really all that close to what the originator of the teaching said or meant.

Fortunately Christians have the bible they can read for themselves and make up their own minds and buddhists have the 4 noble truths (often horribly translated) which they can look to.

For me the major breakthrough in understanding came when I realized the word duhkha cannot be translated in a word to word manner into English so any translation which attempts to do so is a translation I ignore.

I just cannot recommend "Buddhism Plain and Simple" enough for anyone who wants to cut through all the crap, bad translations, and all that nonsense. It appears to me (based upon my admittedly limitted research) that trying to learn what buddhism is from reading what the various buddhist sects have to say is like trying to understand what Jesus taught by visiting a Catholic church followed by a Pentacostal church and then trying to figure out what they share in common. It can be done, but fortunately others have already done it and written books one can own for under $10 ;-)
 
So, it helps me to think of the first noble truth as "Life is like a wheel out of kilter". That may not help you, but this explanation might help. This comes from the book I mentioned above. Imagine the technology at the time of Buddha's life. He would have known about wagon wheels, pulled by horses or the like. Imagine riding in a carriage with a wheel out of kilter. It rides fine for awhile and then it rises and falls. Over and over, without end, it rides fine and then 'bump'. This bump, detracts from the smooth portion of the ride and over time those bumps grate on us more and more.

Well, um, OK. But as you describe it, this is a completely trite observation, so it's of a class of statements that I alluded to earlier. It's mildly interesting that Siddhartha Gautama, born in luxury, should have come to such a realization, but I've seen this happen scores of times when the children of doctors and lawyers go to liberal arts colleges. Usually, they don't get to start religions or philosophies, though.
 
Well, um, OK. But as you describe it, this is a completely trite observation, so it's of a class of statements that I alluded to earlier.

I agree it is trite, or as I prefer to say it "plainly seen to be true".

The first 2 noble truths could not be any simpler (assuming a decent translation):

1. In our lives there is suffering, things we will find unpleasant.

2. There is a cause for this and most of it is our own making. We desire reality to be other than it is. Nobody looks forward to dying, but we all will die, this is reality. We don't wish to die, the knowledge that we will die is unpleasant and we spend a great deal of effort not thinking about the fact that we will die, our loved ones will die and during life we and they will experience pain and hardship. That is reality and our suffering is our own making when we desire for reality to be other than what it is.

The third noble truth says that there is a way to end this suffering and the 4th provides the path out of this suffering.

So yes, the first noble truth is quite trite. Perhaps the fact that it is so trite is part of the reason it is so confused? Jesus simply said "Love your neighbor as you do yourself", but since when was xianity presented so "tritely"?

The buddha didn't claim his was an esoteric, difficult to understand path that would require travelling to India to live in a monastery for 20 years to understand. This is what those after the buddha invented. More than likely these buddhist teachers were/are no different than today's xian teachers who have all sorts of complex theologies their adherants quarrel over, but their lives reveal they haven't even gotten the basic "love thy neighbor as thyself" down pat yet.

Yes, buddhism is quite trite as best I can tell. In fact it appears so simple, so "common sense" that most of us miss it entirely for all of our lives. Those who seek it are too busy pursuing "nirvana", "enlightenment" and other religious buzzwords that they spend a lifetime actively seeking it via ritual, superstition, chanting "OM" while sniffing incense and all that other nonsense (although I confess I like incense ;-)

Could it be that being happy is so simple that it sits there under our nose and we never see it because we are looking for the "secret" to be arcane, complex and very difficult to find?

I agree with you that the first noble truth as I have presented it is quite trite. I can't claim credit for how I have presented it, I got it from the author of the book "Buddhism Plain and Simple", a 30 year buddhist with teaching credentials from a recognized authority (Dainin Katagiri).

According to legend the buddha attained enlightenment while sitting under a tree. He struggled for years following various mapped out paths and traditions to no avail, but true enlightenment came to him while siting under a tree.

Go figure.
 
Thanks, but I'm still confused. When Kung Fu Tsu tried to pick up women in bars, did he tell them that his last name meant "hard work" or is it simply homophony of no significance?

My last name sounds like a breakfast cereal (Pepke, the key to pep!), but it isn't one. However, I have to wonder about people named "Strange" or "Whitehead."

My chinese is limitted to what I've picked up via other interests. My understanding is that "fu tse" would be almost run together. So It would be pronounced more Kung futse with the emphasis on the first word. In all phrases which have incuded the term "kung fu" that I've heard chinese people say, the emphasis has been equal on both parts of kung fu.
It's homophony of no significance that I'm aware of.
 
Nitpicking from a while back...

I suggest that you have a bigoted view of aikido. The practise of certain moves is like learning a language, the moves are the alphabet, once one is proficient with the letters , one can learn the words and concepts.

In many practises the forms are not used in the sense of practise. In free practise the thrower is approached by the others and varios attacks are employed, it is up to the thrower to respond or hopefully move prior to the initiation of the attack, the movements in that case are not coregraphed. But hey , if you like to think of things the way you do that is cool.

I could recomend that you practise aikido, but sounds as though you are close minded about it. I do agree that there is a lot of mystical garbage that is taught in aikido, but the practise itself is the key, not the words. My sensei Tohei Akira was not particularly mystical, very practical.

Aikido is actually a very ineffective martial art, even when compared to the other martial arts of its time.

Shotokan, Ninjistu, and Wing Chun, other martial arts around that time, could whup it (out of those three, I'd say Shotokan and Wing Chun, depending on the level of expertise, would be "number 1").

The problem with Aikido is that the martial art assumes the human body can react at a level that equal its opponent's initiative. A person practicing Akido could stop a punch from a street thug, yes, but not a combination from a boxer.

Aikido's core moves-- and core moves are any martial art's nuts and bolts, don't be fooled by any "philosophy"-- have merit that stands today. But its lack of striking, and lofty dissmissal of an aggressive attitude really sets it back.

I've been in a number of Vale Tudo martial arts tournaments. At that level of competition, you don't see the Aikido, or TKD, or Ninjitsu people anywhere. What martial arts you see are there are those that appreciate the best way human bodies can move to conquer other human bodies. True, not the most pleasent to watch ones, but hands-down the best.
 
Last edited:
Nitpicking from a while back...

I've been in a number of Vale Tudo martial arts tournaments. At that level of competition, you don't see the Aikido, or TKD, or Ninjitsu people anywhere. What martial arts you see are there are those that appreciate the best way human bodies can move to conquer other human bodies. True, not the most pleasent to watch ones, but hands-down the best.

That is interesting. I studied ninjitsu for a few years as a teen and it struck me as odd that any student of ninjitsu would ever engage in a sport tournament.

The way I was taught is that these tournaments are innappropriate for students of ninjitsu because these "sport contests" do not reflect ninjitsu's approach to combat. Simply put, the way a ninja is conditioned to respond to a combat situation cannot be applied in a sport contest where the focus is on defeating the opponent with moves designed to score points rather than eliminate the threat, wearing him down, focusing on "safe" areas of the body to attack etc.

If combat is unavoidable then find the nearest object, toss it at the opponents face and then kick out their knees. If the head area is open to attack, don't punch the nose, gouge out the eye or break the windpipe. In other words, end the combat quickly, no toying around was the approach.

Perhaps things have changed since I studied 20 or so years ago and ninjitsu has become more of a sport than it once was.

Prior to ninjitsu I studied an Okinawan form and Kung Fu. The teacher of the Okinawan style was heavily into katas and the KungFu studio primarily trained for full contact competitions. When I began my training in ninjitsu I asked about what tournaments and competitions the studio participated in. My teacher replied with a very apt question: "Do you wish to learn pretty moves that can make you look good in a bar fight that you should have walked away from or do you wish to learn to stay alive and keep your loved ones alive against those who would harm/kill you?"

That was a lesson I took to heart, which is why I was surprised that you would mention ninjitsu in association with sport contests.
 
atheist are pretty close to buddhist

I like to meet with skeptics here who can tell me how Buddhist doctrines like rebirths and Nirvana cannot stand up to skeptical criticism.

And also the usefulness of meditation, specially that of the Zen school.

yrreg



if the 'beliefs' of an athiest is that after death there is nothing...
then, in that respect 'nothing', buddhist and atheis are very much in common with going to 'nothing'

it is just that a 'buddha' lives and pratices to achieve/goto this 'nothing'. it is not really achieving or going to anything or anywhere. just that there is no way of explaining it.

yes.. nervana.. is ... 'nothing'; not heaven, not hell, not space, not conciouseness floating in some emptiness...

just nothing, no you, no spirit, no nothing.


because in buddah's 'eye' even happiness is and leads to suffering.

as for meditation, you will probably have to specify the 'usefulness' bit.. how is it useful? to who? and why do do it?

as for the rebirth...why argue.. we wil die and find out...
some might say then it is too late! so what? you will either live another life reborn as somebeing, somewhere in tis or other universe, wondering the same things all over again or... it really doesnt matter...
 
That is interesting. I studied ninjitsu for a few years as a teen and it struck me as odd that any student of ninjitsu would ever engage in a sport tournament.

The way I was taught is that these tournaments are innappropriate for students of ninjitsu because these "sport contests" do not reflect ninjitsu's approach to combat. Simply put, the way a ninja is conditioned to respond to a combat situation cannot be applied in a sport contest where the focus is on defeating the opponent with moves designed to score points rather than eliminate the threat, wearing him down, focusing on "safe" areas of the body to attack etc.

If combat is unavoidable then find the nearest object, toss it at the opponents face and then kick out their knees. If the head area is open to attack, don't punch the nose, gouge out the eye or break the windpipe. In other words, end the combat quickly, no toying around was the approach.

Perhaps things have changed since I studied 20 or so years ago and ninjitsu has become more of a sport than it once was.

Prior to ninjitsu I studied an Okinawan form and Kung Fu. The teacher of the Okinawan style was heavily into katas and the KungFu studio primarily trained for full contact competitions. When I began my training in ninjitsu I asked about what tournaments and competitions the studio participated in. My teacher replied with a very apt question: "Do you wish to learn pretty moves that can make you look good in a bar fight that you should have walked away from or do you wish to learn to stay alive and keep your loved ones alive against those who would harm/kill you?"

That was a lesson I took to heart, which is why I was surprised that you would mention ninjitsu in association with sport contests.


Though the lesson you learned is certainly one of those hearty martial arts anecdotes, it's accurate of ninjitsu only for the way your instructor taught, and the manner he speaks of Karate, and the effectiveness of sportfighting is downright insulting.

First off, Gung Fu and Karate borth have a large selection of deadly moves. Both martial arts teach eye-gouging, pressure point tactics, going for the throat, and using one's surrounding objects in combat (actually since Karate is a decendant of Gung Fu, most likely anything the one teaches, the other has some form of).

Next, ninjitsu is far, far more than what your instructor taught. Many of the older ways of ninjitsu are lost, and many still are dying out. There were multiple ninjitsu martial arts, some of which relied heavily on weapons, others on poisons, others on different wrestling and striking styles.

Today's ninjitsu schools are made mostly of the same canon stuff of slow-motion pratices, light contact, and basic move formations that add on to each other. They even have their own belt system. I've trained alongside many of these guys. I can tell you that although their old-school masters might scoff at fast-paced fighting, or moving ninjitsu into a sparring setting, my buddies loved to spar against each other.

There's no such thing as a martial art that can't be altered in order to spar. If you told any one of these guys that they can't spar in ninjitsu "because it's far too deadly," they'd laugh at you.

You replace the eye-gouges with strikes, you keep the submission. What you're left with is a branching style of in-fighting that's similar to most of the modern shoot-fighting out there, but relies more on hard-to-see strike tactics rather than strikes used to sneak-in the wrestling.

None of this is even detached from older ninjitsu practices -- it's just that many of the "old school martial arts masters" of today have their heads up their butts (and I'm not just talking ninjitsu here) when it comes to doing something different.
 
Last edited:
Though the lesson you learned is certainly one of those hearty martial arts anecdotes, it's accurate of ninjitsu only for the way your instructor taught, and the manner he speaks of Karate, and the effectiveness of sportfighting is downright insulting.

What lineage does the ninjitsu you are familiar with follow? The only lineage I am aware of being an authentic, surviving one is that of Masaaki Hatsumi.

I think it was the 80s when all those ninja movies became popular and suddenly everyone wanted to be a ninja. The end result was many people renamed their martial art to ninjitsu to make money.

Heck, I even knew one guy who claimed his lineage went back to the illegitimate son of Miyomoto Musashi who was abondoned by his father and raised by ninja. He was devestatingly effective in terms of lethality, but I really doubt his lineage would hold up to scrutiny. He was just a good fighter looking to make some money.

editted to add: the ninja I am familiar with were basically peasants, outcasts from society who were persecuted by the established authority. As such they had to defend themselves against better equiped adversaries. They didn't have the luxury of boxing, or scoring points on non lethal body targets.

Of course we could say the same for all martial arts whose origins were those of a people fighting for survival. The difference is that as the martial arts came to the west the martial forms were converted to sports and the teachers taught in order to make money.

As I was taught ninjitsu was opposed to 'sportifying' their martial way.

Sure, it could be turned into a sport, but is it them the same thing?

I mean you no offense, sincerily.

I just don't see how engaging in a sport prepares one to survive a life and death encounter with an adversary. Physical conditioning, mental toughness and all that sure, but that is just a general benefit of exercise or any sport.

Another way to look at it is that every physical movement we make programs our brain to respond that way. If we condition our mind to respond to a roundhouse punch in a nonlethal way, then when we are in a fight for survival and we can not take time to think about how to respond, our bodies are moved by our minds in the way they were programmed before we think about it. We train our reflexes.

If we train our reflexes in a way that is compatible with being great sports competitors then this is how we will respond reflexively. If we train our reflexes to move in a manner consistent with surviving an attempt on our lives then this is how we reflexively respond.

The two don't seem very compatible to me when faced with a stronger, better equipped adversary whose intent is not to box us, but to kill us and then harm our loved ones.
 
Last edited:
I'm unsure of the lineage, and I'm unsure that my friends would know if I asked them. I could ask them to ask their instructor, if you're really interested.

I don't see what the backing of a soke would prove to how authentic a martial art is. Especially in America (not assuming you are from America, but I am. A prime example of this is the TKD federations stepping on toes, or the JFK making racial disriminations on dan qualifications), what it really comes down to is the quality of what is taught. And just because a soke doesn't want them to spar, he can't stop them.

Ninjitsu artists enter tournaments. I know this because when you put in the application for the tournament, it says "Martial art style(s)". People put Ninjitsu down, and they all fight in a similar matter.


EDIT: It seems you're posting at the same time I am, judging from your EDIT. I'm going to edit this post soon to respond to your edit. Just letting you know that before things get confusing.
 
Last edited:
I'm unsure of the lineage, and I'm unsure that my friends would know if I asked them. I could ask them to ask their instructor, if you're really interested.

I am not particularly interested, I just asked because my understanding is that there is only one lineage still in existence today. It isn't that there weren't others, just that they are traditions which have died out or lack any known teacher today. As such anyone claiming to be a student of ninjitsu would be able to trace their lineage back to Masaaki Hatsumi. Yes, I am an American and I believe that Stephen K. Hayes was the first American to have brought ninjitsu to the US (in Ohio, I believe). Hayes has also served as bodyguard to the Dali Lama, not that it is important, just interesting (to me) trivia. Gary Bussey would be another who studied under Hatsumi and he set up shop in Omaha, Nebraska. Bussey was unique in that he was a born again Christian who blended the ninjitsu with Christianity. Hayes was respectful of him, but one could see he viewed Bussey's way as a perversion. Bussey retained teaching authority from Hatsumi though, so...

I don't see what the backing of a soke would prove to how authentic a martial art is. Especially in America (not assuming you are from America, but I am. A prime example of this is the TKD federations stepping on toes, or the JFK making racial disriminations on dan qualifications), what it really comes down to is the quality of what is taught. And just because a soke doesn't want them to spar, he can't stop them.

Well, it is certainly true that there is no guarantee that lineage means correctness or bestness, only authenticity. Because ninjitsu became extremely popular in the 80s and there was a shortage of teachers many frauds arose to take advantage. As such there are many people who believe they have studied ninjitsu who haven't. Perhaps they get granted teaching authority and believe they are teaching ninjitsu. Are they? Of course not, they were decieved. It is for this reason I regard linegage as important.

Ninjitsu artists enter tournaments. I know this because when you put in the application for the tournament, it says "Martial art style(s)". People put Ninjitsu down, and they all fight in a similar matter.

Well, it has been 15-20 years since I last studied and have not kept up at all with the goings on so this is possible, but if it has happened they are not practicing the ninjitsu I knew or understood. This doesn't mean that they are wrong to do what they do. At the same time, if they cannot ask questions of their teacher to determine who his/her teacher was and so on and get back to Hatsumi then I can't, based upon my present knowledge, regard them as having learned ninjitsu from an actual practictioner of that way.

Even many years ago there were far more people claiming to be studying ninjitsu than there were people actually studying ninjitsu. The lineage is important due to the high degree of fraud in this path.

When you say "People put Ninjitsu down, and they all fight in a similar matter." this leads me to believe they could not possibly be skilled in an authentic tradition because if they were they could not all have a similar style. There is no ninjitsu 'style'. Styles arise when particular, choreographed movements are proscribed for particular situations. This is contrary to the teaching of ninjitsu as I understand it. Among many other things ninjitsu teaches how to cripple the body and how to destroy it with ruthless efficiency. It never teaches that in response to attack a. we choose reponse a. It has no positions, no forms/katas. At least not what I studied.
 
When you say "People put Ninjitsu down, and they all fight in a similar matter." this leads me to believe they could not possibly be skilled in an authentic tradition because if they were they could not all have a similar style. There is no ninjitsu 'style'. Styles arise when particular, choreographed movements are proscribed for particular situations. This is contrary to the teaching of ninjitsu as I understand it. Among many other things ninjitsu teaches how to cripple the body and how to destroy it with ruthless efficiency. It never teaches that in response to attack a. we choose reponse a. It has no positions, no forms/katas. At least not what I studied.

If Ninjitsu began with a wider base of movements, or moved quicker into the deviations and combinations of those movements, I'd agree with you. The thing about ninjitsu, though, is when a number of those practitioners spar in groups, they all begin to develop the same answers to situations. Tuck and rolls, strikes in holds, etc. Ninjitsu, like many other styles, offers a lot of different answers to situations, but sparring and training tend to grind the same 3-4 answers of those questions (what I and others named the "tool kit"), and those movements, because they tend to appear overall more conservative, I would say yes, Ninjitsu when it is sparred out looks to have the same sort of meta-style to its movements. I'm not saying "we all look the same", there are obviously the innovators- the guys who're really martial artists- who fight in unique, powerful ways. But the average guy doesn't- he falls into a pigeonhole, no matter what form of martial art.
 
If Ninjitsu began with a wider base of movements, or moved quicker into the deviations and combinations of those movements, I'd agree with you. The thing about ninjitsu, though, is when a number of those practitioners spar in groups, they all begin to develop the same answers to situations.

It is interesting that this discussion is taking place within a discussion of buddhism. At least to me.

Anyway, to say that ninjitsu practictioners sparring in groups begin to develop the same answers to situations strikes me as being similar to saying 'muslim terrorists, sparring together develop a consistent technique.'

Of course, this is not likely true. The ninja were the terrorists within feudal Japanese society. Terrorist or freedom fighter is simply a matter of perspective. There were no formalized movements.

You *must* understand this. The ninja did not develop any katas, forms, ritualized movements or anything else, at least not as it relates to combat. They learned to survive the best they could by remaining hidden, exploiting the superstitions of their adversaries, striking before they were seen, using disguise to cloak their presence, and when faced with direct combat to go immediately for the most efficient path to killing.

There is nothing about this which yields to stylized movements.

Stylized movements means the martial portion of a martial art has already died and been buried/cremated. There remains only art and sport. This is not wrong or bad, it simply differentiates sport from warfare.

I enjoy paintball and laser tag. Having been a USMC infantry person I apply the tactics I learned for real life combat to both paintball and laser tag. I do not, however, confuse laser tag and paintball with actual combat. I also do not regard the games/sports of either as doing much to better prepare me for combat.

We train our minds and bodies for what we expect to encounter. If we expect to encounter sports competitors we train our minds and bodies to deal with them. If we expect to encounter strong, well equipped adversaries who wish to kill us and harm our families then we train our minds and bodies to deal with them. The training for each type of opponent is *not* going to be the same. The term 'spar' doesn't even enter my consciousness when dealing with a threat to my life or a threat to my family.



Tuck and rolls, strikes in holds, etc. Ninjitsu, like many other styles, offers a lot of different answers to situations, but sparring and training tend to grind the same 3-4 answers of those questions (what I and others named the "tool kit"), and those movements, because they tend to appear overall more conservative, I would say yes, Ninjitsu when it is sparred out looks to have the same sort of meta-style to its movements. I'm not saying "we all look the same", there are obviously the innovators- the guys who're really martial artists- who fight in unique, powerful ways. But the average guy doesn't- he falls into a pigeonhole, no matter what form of martial art.

If the modern practice of ninjitsu is able to be reduced to a "tool-kit" then ninjitsu is dead.
 
Ninjitsu is crap. It's a marketing scheme used to make money off of ancient japanese stories.
 
Nitpicking from a while back...



Aikido is actually a very ineffective martial art, even when compared to the other martial arts of its time.

Shotokan, Ninjistu, and Wing Chun, other martial arts around that time, could whup it (out of those three, I'd say Shotokan and Wing Chun, depending on the level of expertise, would be "number 1").

The problem with Aikido is that the martial art assumes the human body can react at a level that equal its opponent's initiative. A person practicing Akido could stop a punch from a street thug, yes, but not a combination from a boxer.

Aikido's core moves-- and core moves are any martial art's nuts and bolts, don't be fooled by any "philosophy"-- have merit that stands today. But its lack of striking, and lofty dissmissal of an aggressive attitude really sets it back.

I've been in a number of Vale Tudo martial arts tournaments. At that level of competition, you don't see the Aikido, or TKD, or Ninjitsu people anywhere. What martial arts you see are there are those that appreciate the best way human bodies can move to conquer other human bodies. True, not the most pleasent to watch ones, but hands-down the best.


I would place my bets on the street fighter over the boxer, my statements about aikido was about training being to reach a point of action and not reaction. My teachers always taught me that it was best to run away and avoid the fight, the aikido was for when you can't run.

I would asssume that you understand that judo and aikido were from the same roots in aikijitsu, I aknowledge that while a martial art, aikido may not be practical in the fighting sense. But I am not that knowledgeable and so I could not comment on what a 6 dan aikidoka and a sixth dan 'other martial artist' would resolve in a fight. Most likely to drink more beer.
 
Well, um, OK. But as you describe it, this is a completely trite observation, so it's of a class of statements that I alluded to earlier. It's mildly interesting that Siddhartha Gautama, born in luxury, should have come to such a realization, but I've seen this happen scores of times when the children of doctors and lawyers go to liberal arts colleges. Usually, they don't get to start religions or philosophies, though.


I have seen many lifes that are like wheels out of kilter, and they seem to be more dominant than not.

Allegedl the reason that Gautama started on the path is partly because his father provided him with everything and deliberately sheltered him from poverty, old age, death and illness.

BTW I have seen many children reject thier parents teachings who didn't go to a liberal arts college.
 
But I am not that knowledgeable and so I could not comment on what a 6 dan aikidoka and a sixth dan 'other martial artist' would resolve in a fight. Most likely to drink more beer.

And as long as we *all* keep drinking more beers there will be peace on earth and goodwill toward men. Granted there may be the occasional bar fight, but we will be too intoxicated to do any real damage and after we pick ourselves up we will share a laugh and buy each other more beers.

Does life get any better than this?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom