Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

The personal attacks and false accusations made it obvious to me that these so-called skeptics are actually motivated by fear. For a while I thought it might be the existence of the unknown that they fear, but the fact that some of them are former "woo" believers is evidence against that. When I examined the timeline of their switch in belief, I noticed that there was never a moment where they accepted the fact that they just don't know the answer. The reason for it seems to be that being in a position where they have to experience cognitive dissonance causes them a high level of discomfort and I can't think of topics that cause more cognitive dissonance than 9/11 and Bigfoot.

CD is the explanation for the behavior of many here, but since interpretations of behavior are subjective, one can easily disagree with it. I already gave examples of behavior that I think is indicative of cognitive dissonance in the thread I started, but my interpretation of it was dismissed and the thread was bombarded by people who possess the mentality that I've been describing.

....

What is this, stand-up comedy? (that is a rhetorical question; what this is, is classic projection.)
 
The personal attacks and false accusations made it obvious to me that these so-called skeptics are actually motivated by fear. For a while I thought it might be the existence of the unknown that they fear, but the fact that some of them are former "woo" believers is evidence against that. When I examined the timeline of their switch in belief, I noticed that there was never a moment where they accepted the fact that they just don't know the answer. The reason for it seems to be that being in a position where they have to experience cognitive dissonance causes them a high level of discomfort and I can't think of topics that cause more cognitive dissonance than 9/11 and Bigfoot.

CD is the explanation for the behavior of many here, but since interpretations of behavior are subjective, one can easily disagree with it. I already gave examples of behavior that I think is indicative of cognitive dissonance in the thread I started, but my interpretation of it was dismissed and the thread was bombarded by people who possess the mentality that I've been describing.

It's worth mentioning that not everyone here who claims to be a skeptic possesses this mentality. There are legitimate skeptics here in this section of the forum, but they're few and far between.

Could you remind us all, please, who are the former woo believers?
 
Students of Dark Triad Psychology and trolling are keen on the published checklists.

You have to make it in all three categories: Narcissism, Machiavellianism, and Psychopathy. To score full-on Dark Triad.

These will do it, just my instant observation of the candidate poster:

Glibness.
Grandiosity.
Deception.

You can add to this, but it's sufficient as is.
 
The personal attacks and false accusations made it obvious to me that these so-called skeptics are actually motivated by fear. For a while I thought it might be the existence of the unknown that they fear, but the fact that some of them are former "woo" believers is evidence against that. When I examined the timeline of their switch in belief, I noticed that there was never a moment where they accepted the fact that they just don't know the answer. The reason for it seems to be that being in a position where they have to experience cognitive dissonance causes them a high level of discomfort and I can't think of topics that cause more cognitive dissonance than 9/11 and Bigfoot.

CD is the explanation for the behavior of many here, but since interpretations of behavior are subjective, one can easily disagree with it. I already gave examples of behavior that I think is indicative of cognitive dissonance in the thread I started, but my interpretation of it was dismissed and the thread was bombarded by people who possess the mentality that I've been describing.

It's worth mentioning that not everyone here who claims to be a skeptic possesses this mentality. There are legitimate skeptics here in this section of the forum, but they're few and far between.


Playground tactics. Ironic as you are the one pretending to believe in a non existent magic monkey man. You can't assign fancy-soundin' labels to people just because they won't play pretend with you.
 
The 'Mentality of Skeptics' thread was purportedly started to expose the alleged closed-mindedness, cognitive dissonance and denialist approach of many members here.
It quickly became clear that this was not, in fact, the aim of the thread: it was, in fact, another Bigfoot thread.
However, before it was ruled OT, there were a few discussions about alleged examples of this, discussions that I thought were shut down too quickly. Moreover, these kinds of allegations have been made in other threads too, especially in the Conspiracies sub-forum.
I did consider commenting because I'm perhaps the only poster here who has been on both sides of this issue. However, the bar is so much lower for proving bigfoot than it is for me that this would be like discussing paper airplanes and hypersonic flight in the same thread.
 
What distinguishes neo-atheism from paleo-atheism or just plain atheism? It's common here, it seems, for mystics (or perhaps neo-mystics) to attribute qualities to nothingness, but no matter what dialect you use to say "there's nothing there," it's always the same nothing.

And, of course, you can prove 'there's nothing there'. And please don't fall back on 'there's no proof of anything else'("Absence of evidence is evidence of absence) or 'can't prove a negative' because you made a declarative statement of what you think of as fact.

I'm 65 and back in the paleo days an atheist was simply one who didn't believe in God(s); that was it. They didn't mock, jeer, insult or attack theists. It was a much more live and let live situation. I once asked my mother why atheists didn't believe in God? She shrugged her shoulders and said, "To each his own. Everybodys' entitled to their opinion." Now, in the neo days, it's very different. It has become an aggressive, in-your-face movement verbally attacks and insults.

Just for the record, I'm not a Christian.
 
However, you appear to support OntarioSquatch's complaint about cognitive dissonance.

Where is the cognitive dissonance that OntarioSquatch complains about?
He's not showing it.
You're not showing it.
You post a bombastic definition but do not show where the claimed actual cognitive dissonance is.

Where is the cognitive dissonance OntarioSquatch complains about?

The hard line Fundamentalism, exhibited by the Fundies™, that is taken on all matters of what this site has labeled as 'woo'. Black and white, all or nothing thinking.

If you open your mind too far your brains will fall out.
If you close your mind too tight, you'll cut off the circulation.
 
And, of course, you can prove 'there's nothing there'. And please don't fall back on 'there's no proof of anything else'("Absence of evidence is evidence of absence) or 'can't prove a negative' because you made a declarative statement of what you think of as fact.

I'm 65 and back in the paleo days an atheist was simply one who didn't believe in God(s); that was it. They didn't mock, jeer, insult or attack theists. It was a much more live and let live situation. I once asked my mother why atheists didn't believe in God? She shrugged her shoulders and said, "To each his own. Everybodys' entitled to their opinion." Now, in the neo days, it's very different. It has become an aggressive, in-your-face movement verbally attacks and insults.

Just for the record, I'm not a Christian.

Yea, we stayed in the back of the bus and attended our own schools and did our best to not let the world know we exist.
 
The hard line Fundamentalism, exhibited by the Fundies™, that is taken on all matters of what this site has labeled as 'woo'. Black and white, all or nothing thinking.

If you open your mind too far your brains will fall out.
If you close your mind too tight, you'll cut off the circulation.

If you look at the evidence and then make up your mind you're doing it just right.
 
...
Where is the cognitive dissonance OntarioSquatch complains about?
The hard line Fundamentalism, exhibited by the Fundies™, that is taken on all matters of what this site has labeled as 'woo'. Black and white, all or nothing thinking.

If you open your mind too far your brains will fall out.
If you close your mind too tight, you'll cut off the circulation.


The cognitive dissonance OntarioSquatch complained about, it's not here:
The hard line Fundamentalism, exhibited by the Fundies™, that is taken on all matters of what this site has labeled as 'woo'. Black and white, all or nothing thinking.
...
..... it's also not here:
...
If you open your mind too far your brains will fall out.
...
..... and it's not even here:
...
If you close your mind too tight, you'll cut off the circulation.

It looks like the cognitive dissonance OntarioSquatch complained about is nowhere to be found, it doesn't appear to exist at all .....
 
I have a strong sense of channeling a poster whose main identity was insisting skeptics do not acknowledge anything but lying where bigfoot is concerned - no pareidolia, no misidentification, no power of suggestion, etc. (all the things we have acknowledged for years before he joined the board).

The fallacy of the golden middle ad nauseam: Yes, yes of course we are all black and white except for his highness who is in the golden middle. Nobody's ever played that record before so we're just stumped on how to deal with it.

Two very interesting features though that students of manipulation should appreciate: first, the use of Chiasms. Chiasms are a literary structure that various con-men deploy to fake gravitas. Preachers are famous for chiasms like "The Bible says Adam and Eve, not Adam and Steve." It has the structure A-B-A-C and it rhymes.

The most powerful form to the least intelligent among us is A-B-B-A and can be made up with total nonsense like "Control your mind before your mind controls you." There is nothing of substance being said, just a form of poetry or song that is pleasing to the brain.

The question is who uses them. The answer is anyone who has this elevated sense of grandeur. This is not a definition or feature of skepticism. Some individuals self-identifying as skeptics may have this personality trait, but that's just the individual, not anything that has to do with skepticism.

Neologisms: extremely interesting for its insight into psychopathy.

In psychiatry, the term neologism is used to describe the use of words that have meaning only to the person who uses them, independent of their common meaning. This tendency is considered normal in children, but in adults it can be a symptom of psychopathy

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neologism

A great example of this is L. Ron Hubbard's Scientology, his invention of this entire spurious vocabulary. In Hubbard it was a strong signal on his psychopathy and in his followers the pretense that they had secret knowledge: the insiders, the cool kids.
 
Y'know for a thread that has supposedly nothing to do about bigfoot, there's a whole lot of bigfoot here.
 
I suppose I had better also contribute something to the thread, huh.

In general, the given definition of 'pseudoskeptics' here is that of those skeptics who are of the opinion that proponents of 'woo' and alternative media in general are poisonous, toxic creatures, seeking to infect the mind with irrationality. It's a compelling narrative, but ultimately a wrong one.

It's my conjecture that "Irrationality", in its myriad forms, is the product of the human mind's desire to frame things narratively. It's like our default way of processing things, and when details don't fit the story, we change them to fit. So you can't really infect with a concept that is already innate for most, if not all humans.

It's not entirely unheard of for skeptics, particularly on this forum, to be vitriolic toward their erstwhile 'adversaries', but pointing names here isn't going to do anyone much good. We have a sub-forum called "Abandon All Hope". It was full back in 2010 when I was last here, and it's still full now.

To tl;dr : No, not all skeptics are inherently good or even nice people.


As an afterthought, this thread's OP is rather unsubtly aggresive. The "put up or shut up" line, in particular. I can only assume you mean to be sincere in your offer to correct errant behaviour where you accept it to exist, so being adverserial right off the bat seems unnecessary, perhaps even detrimental to whatever it is you are presumably trying to do here.
 
Last edited:
I suppose I had better also contribute something to the thread, huh.

In general, the given definition of 'pseudoskeptics' here is that of those skeptics who are of the opinion that proponents of 'woo' and alternative media in general are poisonous, toxic creatures, seeking to infect the mind with irrationality. It's a compelling narrative, but ultimately a wrong one.

It's my conjecture that "Irrationality", in its myriad forms, is the product of the human mind's desire to frame things narratively. It's like our default way of processing things, and when details don't fit the story, we change them to fit. So you can't really infect with a concept that is already innate for most, if not all humans.

It's not entirely unheard of for skeptics, particularly on this forum, to be vitriolic toward their erstwhile 'adversaries', but pointing names here isn't going to do anyone much good. We have a sub-forum called "Abandon All Hope". It was full back in 2010 when I was last here, and it's still full now.

To tl;dr : No, not all skeptics are inherently good or even nice people.


As an afterthought, this thread's OP is rather unsubtly aggresive. The "put up or shut up" line, in particular. I can only assume you mean to be sincere in your offer to correct errant behaviour where you accept it to exist, so being adverserial right off the bat seems unnecessary, perhaps even detrimental to whatever it is you are presumably trying to do here.

Indeed, I think we are wired to jump to conclusions and to make narratives out of experience. Our brains are well designed to form useful conclusions from scanty information. We can solve puzzles, figure out complex things, arrive at flashes of insight, make art, and also imagine things that are not there. From a purely utilitarian standpoint, in a world of dangers and ravenous beasts, it's far safer to imagine many that aren't there than to miss one that is. The question comes down to what you do with that information later.

One of the ironies of all this is the introduction of cognitive dissonance and the inability to accept doubt to the discussion. Belief in imaginary beasts and phenomena is seen by some as open mindedness about what is out there, but it can be seen by others as an inability to admit to how easy it is to perceive what does not exist at all. When you come back from the woods with the creepy feeling that something was out there, if you're the kind of "skeptic" that OntarioSquatch is, you might say "I don't know what was out there, but it might have been a hipphalosamus." If you're the kind of skeptic that OS considers a "pseudoskeptic" you might say "wow, the mind sure plays tricks in the woods at night. It's a good thing there aren't any hipphalosami."

I think skepticism consists mainly in recognizing when that is happening and calling it what it is, and the label of "pseudoskeptic" is applied mainly by those who disapprove of the process where it refers to a certain range of things they cannot let go of.

The question for me, at least, is not whether one is "infected" with the concept, but whether one recognizes it for what it is and recognizes faulty evidence for what it is.
 
Very low signal to noise ratio in that smoke-blowing that ended up scolding skeptics for asking where the evidence is.

Yeah, that's hate right there. Not just aggressive - it's clearly violent.

Skeptics are violent terrorists.

There isn't a BLAARGer yet who fails to tell skeptics how they should stop asking for evidence. We're blowing it with the public - all this violent extremism about evidence. If we'd just be reasonable, as per the definition of skepticism, and compromise on needing evidence then more of the public will be skeptics.
 
Very low signal to noise ratio in that smoke-blowing that ended up scolding skeptics for asking where the evidence is.

Yeah, that's hate right there. Not just aggressive - it's clearly violent.

Skeptics are violent terrorists.

There isn't a BLAARGer yet who fails to tell skeptics how they should stop asking for evidence. We're blowing it with the public - all this violent extremism about evidence. If we'd just be reasonable, as per the definition of skepticism, and compromise on needing evidence then more of the public will be skeptics.

Uh, what is this in response to?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom