Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

Ontario already tried that with his Mentality thread and look what happened. It was quickly derailed into Bigfoot Bashing™. At some point down the line I rejacked™ the thread and got it back on track only to have it derailed again.
This is exactly why I started this thread. I don't know why you're having such difficulty understanding that.
Indeed, I don't know why you're being so resentful and difficult about this. As I have explained before, this thread is a perfect opportunity for you to prove your case. Instead, you keep slamming this door in your own face. So why don't you stop whining about being persecuted and shut down and get on with it?

<snipped irrelevant content>

Here is another link to a thread on SGU which is most telling in that it is coming from your own brethren:
http://sguforums.com/index.php/topic,33029.0.html
How often do you visit the JREF forums?

This one is quite interesting in that it is a less than glowing review of this site and its peoples. I recommend reading the thread in its entirety to get a look at how other like-minded people view you. It is doing something that you cannot paint with a broad brushstroke and dismiss as most people here doo with woo.
And yet here you are. :rolleyes:

<more snipped monomaniac irrelevance.>

These SkeptiBunkersTM, are they the skeptics or the pseudo-skeptics?

What I mean about SkeptiBunkers is that I see people wearing two hats. One is the skeptic hat on other forums such as science and math. Good logical thinking and reasoning. No woo bashing, no insults, no snarkyness.

The other hat is a debunker's hat. Someone who already has their mind made up beforehand and is just looking for a way to justify their predetermined mindset.

Are you saying that the majority of the posters in this thread (SkeptiBunkersTM?) are in fact the real skeptics and not the pseudo-skeptics?

That question is a bit confusing. Yes, IMO most posters in this thread are SkeptiBunkers The next part of your question doesn’t compute.

I can see that you're taking a good long run-up at this, and fair play to you, but do you think you could estimate when you are likely to be able to actually address my OP and post some evidence of this?
 
examples

- If someone claims to have encountered a UFO or a ghost, the pseudo-skeptic will try hard to dismiss it as a misidentification. If that doesn't work to their satisfaction, they'll accuse the witness of lying or hallucinating.

- A pseudoskeptic will tell you that psychic phenomenon doesn't exist because no one has ever proven it exists.

- Pseudoskeptics consider all "woo" to be the same. They'll argue that the Loch Ness Monster and Sasquatch are no more plausible than Santa Claus.

- They'll attempt to make fun of you for suggesting that there could be a conspiracy.

- They ask for studies published in scientific journals, but when you show it to them, they'll raise the bar or come up with whatever excuse they can to dismiss it.

- Anything that falls short of proof is dismissed by pseudoskeptics. Footprints, audio, film/video, geographical patterns across reports and hair samples are all dismissed as not being evidence because none of it has ever been proven.

Maybe not as significant, but IMO '[*] accusing someone of lying' could fit in the OP's list of supposed plaints.

IMO it seems related to cognitive dissonance where the accused knows the accusation is wrong.
 
It's no different than OS's game....same **** different day.
It's not about a genuine discussion... It's about them and the glorification of their own blatherings for their own entertainment.
How's that for some armchair psychology.
 
Last edited:
It's no different than OS's game....same **** different day.
It's not about a genuine discussion... It's about them and the glorification of their own blatherings for their own entertainment.
How's that for some armchair psychology.

Analyzing armchairs seems counterproductive they have so few conflicts.:):eye-poppi
 
The 'Mentality of Skeptics' thread was purportedly started to expose the alleged closed-mindedness, cognitive dissonance and denialist approach of many members here.
It quickly became clear that this was not, in fact, the aim of the thread: it was, in fact, another Bigfoot thread.
However, before it was ruled OT, there were a few discussions about alleged examples of this, discussions that I thought were shut down too quickly. Moreover, these kinds of allegations have been made in other threads too, especially in the Conspiracies sub-forum.
I am not alone in repeatedly asking for examples of this, from actual posts by actual members, and so I am starting this thread with this purpose.
I would like to see actual examples of the following, as alleged, repeatedly, by certain members here:
  • Blind obedience to an "Official Story".
  • A refusal to accept evidence for a non-conventional idea or assertion.
  • Cognitive dissonance and/or anxiety caused by a subconscious acceptance of such ideas, coupled by a public disavowal of same.
  • Insulting, aggressive posts that attack the arguer, not the argument. (Probably best to exclude Beachnut from this, really....:) )
  • Pseudo-skepticism.
  • Unqualified, uncritical support for governments, police forces and other establishment organisations.
  • Shilling for corporations or security forces.
If examples are posted here, I and others can look at them. It may be possible that I, and others are doing this without realising how it looks from the other side, in which case I will be perfectly happy to modify my approach and posting style.
On the other hand, if no such examples can be found, then I would like to ask those members responsible to stop making false accusations.
In other words, put up or shut up.

I was in a bunker with skeptics, they were all manly men and the sheeple were anxious.
 
Analyzing armchairs seems counterproductive they have so few conflicts.:):eye-poppi

Arrrggggggghhhhh...I knew I was doing something wrong, but I was so apprehensive about my deniability of cognitive dissonances of the temporal lobe.
I've got to replace a muffler bearing now!
 
It's an old tactic. If your favourite woo-belief gets laughed at start a new thread about your woo-belief but try to disguise it as a different topic.
O.S. is incredibly bad at peddling his nonsense, one of the worst in fact.
Anyone who's been here longer than five minutes knows this, and is aware that the "Mentality of Skeptics" nonsense was his childish attempt to discuss why his pretend Figboot belief is real and that anyone who calls him silly is just a big bad meanie.

"Skeptibunkers", "Sheeple" ? .... Throw in "False Flag", "MSM" and "Tyranny" just to make us meanies more anxious :D
 
Your King of Questions amounts to no more than a child's cry in the night for their mommy and daddy.

The rest of your post is pure projection.

And yet you have most probably embraced neo-atheism and a mechanistic view of the universe as the reality tunnel that you are most comfortable with. And like almost all reality tunnels you think yours doesn't stink but everyone else's stinks.

I could be wrong, so correct me if I am.
 
And yet you have most probably embraced neo-atheism and a mechanistic view of the universe as the reality tunnel that you are most comfortable with. And like almost all reality tunnels you think yours doesn't stink but everyone else's stinks.

I could be wrong, so correct me if I am.

I haven't heard the term Neo-Atheism before, so got curious what worldview Tsig was being associated with:

Neo-atheism is the acerbic, shrill polemics of writers like Richard Dawkins, Sam Harris or Christopher Hitchens who disparage and refute the truth of the Bible.

Thank you, Conservapedia... but there are some better and more cogent definitions out there. This just happened to appear at the top of my search results. It also appears the label is extremely elastic.

I also had to look up "reality tunnel":

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality_tunnel
 
Last edited:
And yet you have most probably embraced neo-atheism and a mechanistic view of the universe as the reality tunnel that you are most comfortable with. And like almost all reality tunnels you think yours doesn't stink but everyone else's stinks.

I could be wrong, so correct me if I am.
What distinguishes neo-atheism from paleo-atheism or just plain atheism? It's common here, it seems, for mystics (or perhaps neo-mystics) to attribute qualities to nothingness, but no matter what dialect you use to say "there's nothing there," it's always the same nothing.
 
I haven't heard the term Neo-Atheism before, so got curious what worldview Tsig was being associated with:



Thank you, Conservapedia... but there are some better and more cogent definitions out there. This just happened to appear at the top of my search results. It also appears the label is extremely elastic.

I also had to look up "reality tunnel":

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality_tunnel

I had to change my location after reading about the reality tunnel.

Might even request the title pixies change my title to something neo-atheistic.
Hmmmm

Neo-Atheist SkepticatTM?
SkeptiboobyTM?

@jakesteele,
And like almost all reality tunnels you think yours doesn't stink but everyone else's stinks.

I could be wrong, so correct me if I am.

This is really interesting.
What is the world view you hold in your reality tunnel?

PS
Please present evidence of the cognitive dissonance SkeptibunkersTM experience.
 
And yet you have most probably embraced neo-atheism and a mechanistic view of the universe as the reality tunnel that you are most comfortable with. And like almost all reality tunnels you think yours doesn't stink but everyone else's stinks.

I could be wrong, so correct me if I am.

If you can't answer the post, attack the poster.

If you are in a stinking tunnel I suggest you move to the light.:):D
 
I haven't heard the term Neo-Atheism before, so got curious what worldview Tsig was being associated with:



Thank you, Conservapedia... but there are some better and more cogent definitions out there. This just happened to appear at the top of my search results. It also appears the label is extremely elastic.

I also had to look up "reality tunnel":

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality_tunnel

A common tactic:

Place the other poster in a group, then beat up on the group.

Tsig sniffs, smells like fresh flowers mixed with bull leavings.
 
I haven't heard the term Neo-Atheism before, so got curious what worldview Tsig was being associated with:



Thank you, Conservapedia... but there are some better and more cogent definitions out there. This just happened to appear at the top of my search results. It also appears the label is extremely elastic.

I also had to look up "reality tunnel":

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality_tunnel


Reality tunnel is a term, akin to the idea of representative realism, coined by Timothy Leary (1920-1996). It was further expanded on by Robert Anton Wilson (1932-2007), who wrote about the idea extensively in his 1983 book Prometheus Rising. The theory states that, with a subconscious set of mental filters formed from his or her beliefs and experiences, every individual interprets the same world differently, hence "Truth is in the eye of the beholder".


No Steele I am not a solipsist.
 
Last edited:
- If someone claims to have encountered a UFO or a ghost, the pseudo-skeptic will try hard to dismiss it as a misidentification.
If the claimants tried at all to do that, we'd all be a lot better off.

If that doesn't work to their satisfaction, they'll accuse the witness of lying or hallucinating.
This is a problem because no one ever lies about things or suffers hallucinations?

- A pseudoskeptic will tell you that psychic phenomenon doesn't exist because no one has ever proven it exists.
If I add the phrase "As far as we know" to the beginning of my sentence that concludes with "psychic phenomena do not exist," is that sufficient to make me a real skeptic?

- Pseudoskeptics consider all "woo" to be the same. They'll argue that the Loch Ness Monster and Sasquatch are no more plausible than Santa Claus.
I've heard it argued that Santa is more likely to exist than is God, because Santa would violate fewer laws of physics.

That said, I have always approached cryptids as independent claims and evaluated them independently. My evaluation suggests that they are folklore and, thus, quite similar to the mythical Santa Claus.

- They'll attempt to make fun of you for suggesting that there could be a conspiracy.
If your conspiracy is pointless and untenable then consider the scorn well-earned.

- They ask for studies published in scientific journals, but when you show it to them, they'll raise the bar or come up with whatever excuse they can to dismiss it.
Frustrating, huh? Can you imagine what it's like to share actual peer-reviewed, scientific journal articles only to have them be completely ignored by bigfooters?

- Anything that falls short of proof is dismissed by pseudoskeptics. Footprints, audio, film/video, geographical patterns across reports and hair samples are all dismissed as not being evidence because none of it has ever been proven.
I've evaluated evidence for everything you list, openly and honestly. If something isn't evidence for bigfoot then it's not evidence for bigfoot, and no amount of you wishing that it were can make it so.


So . . . you still haven't presented any evidence for actual people having the actual personality disorder you claim. Again, however, you outlined an impossibility for someone to honestly evaluate purported evidence for bigfoot and conclude it to be without merit. Anyone who rejects a claim for something like bigfoot is a pseudoskeptic according to your criteria.

That is a large, stinking pile of alien Loch Ness footie poo.
 
I read the whole thread and I don't see what you claim to see. Now how on earth could that be?
Apparently you didn't read the fine print:

« Reply #6 on: January 20, 2011, 10:57:39 AM »
• Quote
I pop in from time to time, but only actually registered a couple of months ago. I think I'll lurk for another year or so before posting anything.

This place seems much nicer, if you ask me, though.



« Reply #8 on: January 20, 2011, 12:38:08 PM »
• Quote
Quote from: Beleth on January 19, 2011, 07:36:13 PM
I used to post there all the time. I even wrote the original Million Dollar Challenge FAQ, although it's gone through some major revisions since then.

Then the moderation got out of hand, so I stopped.

What he said. I still read a few topics, but the 'atmosphere' is so toxic I just can't enjoy posting much. The anal rape of intellect there, in regards to one of the most contentious and fun topics for skeptics to discuss, is like the pall of death hanging over the place.


Entropydave
Re: How often do you visit the JREF forums?
« Reply #27 on: June 15, 2011, 03:31:48 PM »
• Quote
I visit frequently, but very rarely comment - they take no prisoners and are a bit too unfriendly and hardcore for my tastes. Plus they have their resident cranks there too - which really they should just ignore with their crazy ideas like "the whole of physics over the past 200 years is wrong and I am right" - threads like that can go on for 30 or 40 pages - IMO this is such a waste of time and intellect...


« Reply #32 on: September 17, 2011, 12:39:37 AM »
• Quote
None, since those forums are run by hypocrites that use the same techniques and pseudosciences that they criticize others for.



Re: How often do you visit the JREF forums?
« Reply #35 on: September 17, 2011, 12:29:05 PM »
• Quote
That is the site of never-ending threads.

Some topics are quite hot and people do want to discuss things, but jeebus, the elevatorgate thread is still going, Amanda Knox thread is going to never close (unless for a brief moderation period).

People just seem to never want to stop arguing or concede a point, it gets boring.


Re: How often do you visit the JREF forums?
« Reply #38 on: October 10, 2011, 10:40:17 AM »
• Quote
Quote from: ♫♪ FX ♪♫ on September 17, 2011, 12:31:29 PM
It's beyond stupid. They have ONE "Global Warming" thread, and it's moderated.

One thread. And every last issue concerning climate, weather or earth science gets classified as "global warming". It's stupid cubed.

Some ways of handling controversial topics are better than others. I like the way it is here a lot better. I think you do too.



Re: How often do you visit the JREF forums?
« Reply #45 on: April 28, 2012, 01:34:58 PM »
• Quote
It is also the site of the dramatic farewell threads when people have some issue with how some issue is dealt with or how they are dealt with.

I haven't kept stats, but I am aware of at least one drama queen now returning to the site after the indignant departure.

It is also the site where people like to beat others with their big sceptical stick.

It really sucks sometimes, and I can see why people leave
, but I don't understand the public departure threads.


Re: How often do you visit the JREF forums?
« Reply #46 on: April 28, 2012, 02:39:29 PM »
• Quote
Quote from: Tatyana on April 28, 2012, 01:34:58 PM
It is also the site of the dramatic farewell threads when people have some issue with how some issue is dealt with or how they are dealt with.

I haven't kept stats, but I am aware of at least one drama queen now returning to the site after the indignant departure.

It is also the site where people like to beat others with their big sceptical stick.

It really sucks sometimes, and I can see why people leave, but I don't understand the public departure threads.


I think everyone thinks their contributions to a forum are worth something, but some people think their contributions are worth more than others. I can't imagine me ever having a disagreement with someone on a forum that affected me so much that I felt I had to make some dramatic departure. From my few attempts, I find JREF website to be very unaccommodating to feedback, so I'm not going to use it to interact with others. I find SGU forum more intellectually stimulating and frankly more open and welcome.



Re: How often do you visit the JREF forums?
« Reply #47 on: April 28, 2012, 04:29:31 PM »
• Quote
There is definitely more of a sense of community on this site than on the JREF.

I do think that people who have been posting there for ten years + and been to numerous TAMs have their own little cliques, but there is no overall community.



Re: How often do you visit the JREF forums?
« Reply #57 on: August 05, 2012, 06:57:13 AM »
• Quote
I think the JREF is also full of old, miserable, self-righteous people.

There are some really lovely people there, but the lack of community and compassion is palpable.

There is one young poster on that site who has been very open about their medical and mental health issues, and it is his birthday.

People will not wish him a happy birthday because they probably have had a disagreement with him.

55 views on his birthday threads and 7 replies.

What miserable twats.

I want to start a thread on JREF if it is a site full of mean old people, because it really seems that way.

I have never seen a forum be so flipping stingy with basic human considerations.



Most of the posts were about the Stundies(thumbs up)

Second most posts were about bad moderation(thumbs down)

Then you have some that are luke warm(a wash)

Then you have the highlighted(big thumbs down)

How on earth could you read that whole thread and not see the above highlighted?


Well, don't hold your breath. From what I've seen, the psycholomahjizing you and OS are doing is simply worthless psychobabble. Why would we need a whole new category for this? No one else has needed a special place to park their whining lapses in logic, so why do you?
This last part doesn't surprise me at all because if I remember correctly, this site has a very low opinion of psychology, especially Jung, etc.. because it's not a 'real science'. The only good rating was CBT(Cognitive Behavioral Therapy) which the claim was that it somehow 'was proven' to have replicative results, something like that.

The incredible irony is that all of us have psychology as an intrinsic part of the human mind; some people don't want to go there and instead try to poo hoo it and rip it to shreds.

EDIT: I forgot to add these from Straight Dope:

Strait Dope

http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=780624

jakesteele
Guest Join Date: Jun 2007

Sane Skeptic Site
________________________________________
I have been posting of the JREF skeptic site, now International Skeptic site for a while and I have found that on subjects such as math or science there are some real Brainiacs while are somewhat daunting to me in that I've never been good at either. I learn a lot. But when it comes to the General Skepticism and Conspiracy sites it seems like night and day. There is a lot of insults, name calling and a general tone of condescendtion and arrogance. I'm wondering if others have been there and experienced the same or similar.

Also, could I get some recommendations as to more rational skeptics that you might know of?

p.s. I've been to the Skeptics Guide to the Universe and like it better because it much more calm and laid back and not the in-your-face agressiveness on the JREF site.


#2
Yesterday, 06:44 PM

Princhester
Charter Member Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Brisbane, Australia
Posts: 12,415

JREF is like that. I'm a skeptic but stopped posting there because the place was (at least at that time) dominated by several posters who were as dogmatic as any fundamentalist, and who had a mindset that said "if you are not part of the JREF groupthink, you must be a feeble minded believer in woo".

It's too long ago to recall the precise details but I remember participating in debates in which I was trying to at least debate purveyors of woo fairly and was instantly attacked for "taking their side".



Dinsdale
Guest Join Date: May 2000

We subscribed to the Skeptical Inquirer for a few years, but lost interest after a while. So much of it seemed repetitious. As this site says, the fight is taking longer than expected.

Some (a LOT of) folk simply have limited interest in rationalism. Once you acknowledge that, what is there to do?
 
Last edited:
Apparently you didn't read the fine print:

I said I read the whole thread because that's what I did. I saw a mix of subjective opinions on JREF/ISF similar to what I can see almost daily on FMF. So what? You failed to show that this means anything in particular.

This last part doesn't surprise me at all because if I remember correctly, this site has a very low opinion of psychology, especially Jung, etc.. because it's not a 'real science'. The only good rating was CBT(Cognitive Behavioral Therapy) which the claim was that it somehow 'was proven' to have replicative results, something like that.

The incredible irony is that all of us have psychology as an intrinsic part of the human mind; some people don't want to go there and instead try to poo hoo it and rip it to shreds.

You're not using psychology, though. You're improperly using technical terms from psychology to attack people who don't agree with you. This is a good example of what is called psychobabble.

What's so wrong with requiring evidence for problematic claims? That's the bottom line of what's encouraged here. It's not always perfect, but what is?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom