Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

And, of course, you can prove 'there's nothing there'. And please don't fall back on 'there's no proof of anything else'("Absence of evidence is evidence of absence) or 'can't prove a negative' because you made a declarative statement of what you think of as fact.

I'm 65 and back in the paleo days an atheist was simply one who didn't believe in God(s); that was it. They didn't mock, jeer, insult or attack theists. It was a much more live and let live situation. I once asked my mother why atheists didn't believe in God? She shrugged her shoulders and said, "To each his own. Everybodys' entitled to their opinion." Now, in the neo days, it's very different. It has become an aggressive, in-your-face movement verbally attacks and insults.

Just for the record, I'm not a Christian.

Jake, I'm 66 and an atheist since I was a kid. Apparently we move in different circles because I can recall a whole lot of mockery of church-going God believers.

Notwithstanding that you and I have different recollections, you are also referring to a sub-set of aggressive and demonstrative atheists (many of whom you'll find on these boards) as defining one of the requirements of The New Atheism. Bunch of codswallop, I say!

I'm as Atheist as The Atheist or Leumas. I just keep my own council. I can't be bothered with the god botherers. I know there are a rather large number of people who have the same approach, at least in the personal circles in which I move.
 
I'm 65 and back in the paleo days an atheist was simply one who didn't believe in God(s); that was it. They didn't mock, jeer, insult or attack theists. It was a much more live and let live situation. I once asked my mother why atheists didn't believe in God? She shrugged her shoulders and said, "To each his own. Everybodys' entitled to their opinion." Now, in the neo days, it's very different. It has become an aggressive, in-your-face movement verbally attacks and insults.

This doesn't describe me at all. I do have respect for ministers like Welton Gaddy because he would act as president of the Interfaith Alliance during the week and then go home and give the service at his small church on Sunday. I have respect for the current Pope because he doesn't live in the Vatican palace or eat in the Pope's private dining room or worship in the Pope's private chapel. He lives in a regular room, eats in the common cafeteria, and worships in the same chapel that the other residents do.

I have no respect for any of the "ministers" who have mega-churches. I have no respect for the televangelists who preach the prosperity gospel, pretend to heal people, and pretend to be prophets. This is a long list including Pat Robertson, Oral Roberts, Jerry Falwell, Jim Bakker, Kenneth Copeland, Joel Osteen, Jimmy Swaggert, Creflo Dollar, Benny Hinn, Joyce Meyer, John Hagee, Jack Van Impe, Marcus and Joni Lamb, the whole Crouch family, and a number of others like Dr. Becker. I can't respect anyone whose life is about scamming people.
 
I played your game, now you play mine.

Below are two sentences and I respectfully ask you to answer with any one of the choices:

Sentence 1: Like to be a little more specific? Or does your argument lose traction if you're forced to discuss the facts?

Sentence 2: Hey, Cosmic! Like to be a little bit more specific, or does your argument lose traction if you’re forced to discuss psychology?

Do you think one of these sentences is disrespectful?
•If so, which one and why?

Do you think both sentences are disrespectful?
•If so, why?

Do you think neither sentence is disrespectful?
•Please elaborate.

Thank you for your detailed reply.
I have no idea what kind of game you are playing: I am not playing any kind of game myself. I will choose to assume that this was merely a figure of speech, rather than believe you are opening yourself up to an accusation of being disrespectful. The yak is the most magnanimous of beasts. :D

In that spirit, I will answer your question.

I see nothing remotely disrespectful about either question, nor can I see what point you are trying to make with this apparently insubstantial dichotomy. Why do you think I would find anything about them disrespectful?
Oh, and you can call me "Cosmic" any time- I rather like it!

If you yourself think that neither of these questions is disrespectful, perhaps you could explain why you take such offence when others ask you the same thing? The resistance you, and others like you, have shown to substantiating your grievances with actual posts from this forum indicated that perhaps you object to doing so. Again, this is speculation based on a possible reading of the intent of your questions.
On the other hand, if you are seeing some kind of disrespect here, then would you mind elaborating? This is a skeptics' forum after all, and it seems entirely reasonable to ask for evidence, as that is what scientific skepticism is all about. This evidence is then discussed and debated in the "lively manner" quoted in the forum blurb. If you have an issue with this, could you please explain what it is?

Incidentally, I had a quick skim through some of the quotes you listed. In only one instance so far in my readings have I found an example I agree is disrespectful.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=5202014#post5202014
youre a ufo nut, thats suddenly become very very clear, as such you don't deserve any more time wasted on you, you just deserve contempt
you certainly now have mine and before you start spouting crapola its your attitude and refusal to look at real evidence thats earned it, nothing else
well done, youve proved to everyone here that youre a complete waste of our time
However, this is from a poster who is now banned.
What does that say to you about the "Paradigm Police"?
 
I'd say that it's 100% about the snark.

No matter how ridiculous a claim is, if we don't walk on eggshells while responding, we'll be assailed by psychobabble.

The Gen. Skep/CT forums are a culture of rudeness and lack of civility, something that you wouldn't dare do out in the regular world standing face to face at some kind of social gathering other than TAM. I'd pay to see the see that.

What is your opinion of psychology? Do you think that:
1. for the most part is bunk, not a real science and as such it is worthless
2. their is validity to it even though it is not considered a real science?
3. Which branches of psychology do you think have merit?
4. which branches of psychology do you think have no merit?
 
If you look at the evidence and then make up your mind you're doing it just right.

Not necessarily. It all depends on how slanted and predetermined your thinking processes are. If you've already made your mind up that it's bogus then the confirmation bias kicks in and the structural integrity of your world view/cognitive closure is maintained.

since a thing could be faked, it must be a fake.

It cannot be, therefore, it is not.
 
I suppose I had better also contribute something to the thread, huh.

In general, the given definition of 'pseudoskeptics' here is that of those skeptics who are of the opinion that proponents of 'woo' and alternative media in general are poisonous, toxic creatures, seeking to infect the mind with irrationality. It's a compelling narrative, but ultimately a wrong one.

It's my conjecture that "Irrationality", in its myriad forms, is the product of the human mind's desire to frame things narratively. It's like our default way of processing things, and when details don't fit the story, we change them to fit. So you can't really infect with a concept that is already innate for most, if not all humans.

It's not entirely unheard of for skeptics, particularly on this forum, to be vitriolic toward their erstwhile 'adversaries', but pointing names here isn't going to do anyone much good. We have a sub-forum called "Abandon All Hope". It was full back in 2010 when I was last here, and it's still full now.

To tl;dr : No, not all skeptics are inherently good or even nice people.


As an afterthought, this thread's OP is rather unsubtly aggresive. The "put up or shut up" line, in particular. I can only assume you mean to be sincere in your offer to correct errant behaviour where you accept it to exist, so being adverserial right off the bat seems unnecessary, perhaps even detrimental to whatever it is you are presumably trying to do here.

Well said. One of the points I've been making is the phrase SkeptiBunker which is, of course, a combo of the words 'skeptic' and 'debunker'. When it comes to the sciences and math areas there is straight forward skepticism. When it comes to the woo areas, as they are referred to, rationality tends to fly out the window and is replaced with aggressive and at (many)times rude and snotty behavior.

One of the things I find ironic is that the collective level of intelligence on this whole site in general is very high, especially coming from the first forum I engaged in, Sherdog.com. That was looney toons and some posts were so illiterate it was almost like deciphering a code.
 
The Gen. Skep/CT forums are a culture of rudeness and lack of civility, something that you wouldn't dare do out in the regular world standing face to face at some kind of social gathering other than TAM. I'd pay to see the see that.

What is your opinion of psychology? Do you think that:
1. for the most part is bunk, not a real science and as such it is worthless
2. their is validity to it even though it is not considered a real science?
3. Which branches of psychology do you think have merit?
4. which branches of psychology do you think have no merit?

Please stop trying to derail this thread. If you want to discuss psychology, I suggest you start a thread of your own.
 
The Gen. Skep/CT forums are a culture of rudeness and lack of civility, something that you wouldn't dare do out in the regular world standing face to face at some kind of social gathering other than TAM. I'd pay to see the see that.

I do it all the time without fear. If someone is idiotic enough to make public their belief in claptrap then they are fair game to be publicly mocked.

The deluded have it very easy on this forum. Calling a spade a spade is frowned upon. This is why there are threads full of twaddle that go on forever, because even though the topic of the thread is hogwash we have to tip-toe around so as not to hurt feelings, be big bad meanies or get labelled with some pseudo-psychological gibberish. Or get carded. Look at The Shroud threads.

Some people here are extremely patient. They will carefully explain the hows and whys as to why a particular idea is nonsense. They do this because they might have relevant experience in a related field or because they are too naive to recognise a troll. Sometimes they are just trying to help educate.

No one was being a meanie to you-know-who regarding his "belief" in Bigfoot.
Anyone who is familiar with his troll-like behaviour knows perfectly well that he doesn't believe in such nonsense and is just playing a game. This is why the regulars don't waste time tip-toeing around his playing field.

What is your opinion of psychology? Do you think that:
1. for the most part is bunk, not a real science and as such it is worthless
2. their is validity to it even though it is not considered a real science?
3. Which branches of psychology do you think have merit?
4. which branches of psychology do you think have no merit?

Nice try.

ETA:
Not necessarily. It all depends on how slanted and predetermined your thinking processes are. If you've already made your mind up that it's bogus then the confirmation bias kicks in and the structural integrity of your world view/cognitive closure is maintained.

Magical thinking. If something is bogus it is bogus. Dreaming otherwise doesn't alter that.
There is no such thing as Bigfoot. Fact.
Aliens aren't flying around in our skies. Fact.

Just because I'm not afraid to say these things, doesn't mean you can assign some made-up condition to me.
I prefer reality to believing in claptrap. Reality is more interesting and is, you know.... real.

since a thing could be faked, it must be a fake.

No. No one really says that the reason a fake is a fake is because it can be faked.
They say a fake is a fake because it is a fake.
The Bigfoot myth is a lame hoax believed by the gullible and perpetuated by trolls and conmen. Fact.
Its isn't a hoax because its hoax-able. Its a hoax because its a hoax.
 
Last edited:
It cannot be, therefore, it is not.

No.
It's:
"It cannot be, therefore you'd have to have some bloody good data to show that it is."

That's how science works.
You want to break the paradigm? Then you need to show your workings.

This fits in pretty much all the major CTs and any of the "alternative" medical and science stuff we see posted here.

You want to show your pet is correct? Then you'd better be prepared to down that petri dish. (Note, I know of people who think Barry took a silly risk there, but hey, he was confident! :))
 
Jakesteele, your fascination with psychology is puzzling. Are you a scientologist? You keep talking about wanting to talk about psychology, yet remain steadfast in your refusal to start a thread about psychology. Why is that?

I don't have any strong feelings on psychology. I must admit that I am curious about your choice to derail rather than explore your beloved topic in your own thread. I would certainly read and most likely participate if I thought that I had anything to contribute.
 
What is your opinion of psychology? Do you think that:
1. for the most part is bunk, not a real science and as such it is worthless
2. their is validity to it even though it is not considered a real science?
3. Which branches of psychology do you think have merit?
4. which branches of psychology do you think have no merit?

If you'd've spent the fraction of a minute it would've taken to find out what "psychobabble" is, you'd know what I said. Instead you wasted your time asking irrelevant questions.

Perhaps I could be even more plain: your bloviations here are not psychology.
 
The Gen. Skep/CT forums are a culture of rudeness and lack of civility, something that you wouldn't dare do out in the regular world standing face to face at some kind of social gathering other than TAM. I'd pay to see the see that.

What is your opinion of psychology? Do you think that:
1. for the most part is bunk, not a real science and as such it is worthless
2. their is validity to it even though it is not considered a real science?
3. Which branches of psychology do you think have merit?
4. which branches of psychology do you think have no merit?

5. You'd do better analyzing the bumps on your forehead.
 
jakesteele,
Please in the name of science, tell me what are the two or
more contradictory beliefs, ideas or values being held?

What contradictory action is performed when confronted by new information?

ETA: The beliefs, ideas and values being held by you, jakesteele, are
contradicted with science and/or snark.

When confronted with science (new information) you post more of your
beliefs with pop psychology thrown in.



You go with authority, and then reach to your supreme authority?
Interesting.
Chicken Little is a 19th century folk tale.
It seems odd to pick that story to illustrate your point.

Chicken Little causes a widespread panic when something (an acorn, a leaf)
falls on her and she assumes the sky is falling.
The world is ending.

You, jakesteele, appear to be the one suffering from cognitive dissonance.
Pilots who do not make mistakes (because of their training and the price
of the planes they fly) have seen UFOs.
You seem to assume that these perfect pilots have seen UFOs and only
God can help you with the presumed arrival of extra-terrestial beings, and
the end of the world.
Are you assuming that the posters here believe in God? That is strange.

Look in the mirror Chicken Little.

I can assure you, I do not suffer from cognitive dissonance when it comes
extra-terrestial beings.
You don't suffer from cognitive dissonance, you just didn't read what I said about cognitive closure.

I consider myself very lucky to have found this forum and the posters who deal with
those who truly believe in their own special truth
.

Are you talking about SkeptiBunkers or your dreaded woo opponents? Either way, this still applies:
Law of Immaculate Perception™ – they are the only ones who see reality exactly as it is unhindered by any cognitive biases. So therefore, to disagree with them is to disagree with reality itself

Yeah, I came here for the Bigfoot and stayed for the snark.
:blush::D

I'm truly happy for you.
 
Just extracting this particular brick from the tower of text: Do military pilots ever, for example, make the mistake of attacking the wrong target, up to and including friendly forces? Yes, sometimes they do, though very rarely. Like anyone else, they are prone to the occasional mistake, yet the sky has not yet fallen. And the comparison with astronomers is not one of competence as an observer,
but of availability of superior detection equipment to the unassisted human eyeball
Links?
and superior recording equipment to the fallible and malleable human memory.
Links?
 
In addition, of course, astronomers can stop and think.
So you believe that amateur astronomers are better witnesses than highly skilled, trained and experience military pilots and all the ground crew with millions of dollars worth of state of the are radar, etc.? Do you really think those pros would bow in deference to your Fubar Logic™? If they disagreed with you, then in your world they would be wrong, right?

As I said, by giving the automatic dismissal to a body of highly qualified people that are obviously going to see more 'things' that are flying and are unidentified than the Mitch Stanleys of the world seals off having to deal with an entire area that is disquieting and problematic for a SkeptiBunker.
 
Jake, I'm 66 and an atheist since I was a kid. Apparently we move in different circles because I can recall a whole lot of mockery of church-going God believers.

Notwithstanding that you and I have different recollections, you are also referring to a sub-set of aggressive and demonstrative atheists (many of whom you'll find on these boards) as defining one of the requirements of The New Atheism. Bunch of codswallop, I say!

I'm as Atheist as The Atheist or Leumas. I just keep my own council. I can't be bothered with the god botherers. I know there are a rather large number of people who have the same approach, at least in the personal circles in which I move.

You and I grew up in different areas and there undoubtedly was a lot of mockery in certain circles different than mine. Shaun Hannity, in private, is probably one of the descendants of that. But The basic tenents of atheism haven't changed, it's the new breed of cat that is practicing it now ever since the rise of the ugly spectres of Harris, Dawkins, etc..

Just in case you haven't seen this yet, I'll post the link.

https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=the+trouble+with+atheism
 
This doesn't describe me at all. I do have respect for ministers like Welton Gaddy because he would act as president of the Interfaith Alliance during the week and then go home and give the service at his small church on Sunday. I have respect for the current Pope because he doesn't live in the Vatican palace or eat in the Pope's private dining room or worship in the Pope's private chapel. He lives in a regular room, eats in the common cafeteria, and worships in the same chapel that the other residents do.

I have no respect for any of the "ministers" who have mega-churches. I have no respect for the televangelists who preach the prosperity gospel, pretend to heal people, and pretend to be prophets. This is a long list including Pat Robertson, Oral Roberts, Jerry Falwell, Jim Bakker, Kenneth Copeland, Joel Osteen, Jimmy Swaggert, Creflo Dollar, Benny Hinn, Joyce Meyer, John Hagee, Jack Van Impe, Marcus and Joni Lamb, the whole Crouch family, and a number of others like Dr. Becker. I can't respect anyone whose life is about scamming people.

I agree with you on that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom