Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

It computes, but OntarioSquatch has already said that the title for the other thread was wrong and it's still not right. His choice of words appears to be wrong more than only once.

Also, he is unable to show the dissonance he talked about. I asked you as well up in this page, but no answer from you yet.

Which thread(s) did he say that? I missed that.
 
After investigation do you make your mind up about things or are you perpetually on the fence?

It all depends on the situation and what it's about. I can certainly say in some some cases that the preponderance of the available data/evidence makes it more likely or not, but I don't have a predetermined agenda with my mind snapped shut like a steel trap. Who says you can only believe or disbelieve? Why is it you think there are only two choice available and not the possibility of undetermined or 'not known at this time?
 
Which thread(s) did he say that? I missed that.
I am not going to bother to find the post, but OS has said, somewhere in the "Mentality of Skeptics" thread, that the title should have said "pseudoskeptics." Unfortunately, since the definition of that word is very flexible, and seems in the minds of some to include anyone who disagrees with one's pet theories, the change is of small consequence, except to make clear that there is, at least in theory, something that OS would accept as appropriate skepticism.
 
Which thread(s) did he say that? I missed that.

Oh, you mean OntarioSquatch mentioning a thread title being wrong:
Right here, in the "Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge." thread:
The thread title is incorrect. It should've been "The Mentality of Pseudoskeptics" for accuracy, but since nearly everyone who claims to be a hardcore skeptic fits the profile of a pseudo, I'm not so sure if it's incorrect from a non-technical point of view. In the end, "Skeptic" is just a highly subjective label. Everyone uses skepticism to some extent in their life.
 
Oh, you mean OntarioSquatch mentioning a thread title being wrong:

He even told me he'd asked the mods to change the title, in the Mentality of Skeptics thread. I see that the title hasn't been changed, though the mods are usually quite accommodating to requests like this. He may of course have been lying when he said he'd asked them to change it, but as a good skeptic I'm willing to accept other possible explanations.

Dave
 
He even told me he'd asked the mods to change the title, in the Mentality of Skeptics thread. I see that the title hasn't been changed, though the mods are usually quite accommodating to requests like this. He may of course have been lying when he said he'd asked them to change it, but as a good skeptic I'm willing to accept other possible explanations.

Dave

It would still not fit with the term "pseudo-skeptic". Pseudo-skeptics are the believers who attempt to cloak their irrational belief and lack of data with skeptical sounding rhetoric.

He should really not use the word "skeptic" at all. But he still wants to rail against what are generally known as "skeptics" even though he thinks of himself as "skeptic".

"skeptics are always right, I am a skeptic so my bigfoot thing is true".
:rolleyes:
 
I sent a PM to kmortis on December 18th asking if he could change it, but haven't gotten a reply yet.
That's not the way to do it. Do it this way... report your own OP and write in the box what you would like to change the title to. That's the way the forum management wants that kind of thing done and it's called "Housekeeping".
 
Who says you can only believe or disbelieve? Why is it you think there are only two choice available and not the possibility of undetermined or 'not known at this time?

I give up, who does say that?

Do you have an example of a phenomenon for which the best skeptical approach is "undetermined pending necessary information"? How about examples of phenomena for which we do know enough to conclude that the thing doesn't exist?
 
That's lovely, but, where is the dissonance in OntarioSquatch's post?


Originally Posted by Daylightstar View Post
However, pseudo-skepticism is when you cloak your existing irrational belief(s) or irrational mindset in skeptically sounding rhetoric.
Which irrational belief/mindset do your pseudo-skeptics have?
They're wired in a way that they can't handle even the slightest amount of cognitive dissonance. Denial of evidence and biased thinking are the tactics used to restore consistency in their minds.


Are you referring to this? Ummm, Not sure if you I would call that CD. You made a claim which is sort of an inversion of the defininition of psuedoskepticism(turn about is fair play), on its merits, would be considered as a valid point in a court of law. Ontario makes a counterclaim which, on its merits, would also be considered a valid point. It's point counter point.

I haven't been following that part of the posting so I would need a context surrounding the whole exchange. I'm occupied with leisurely responding to responses to my posts.

With that being said, obviously, Ontario are on the same side of the fence in regards to the psychology aspect and youz guyz are on the other.
 
This is the first of several separate posts I will be putting out in response to Cosmic Cat’s Challenge thread. I’m going to roll them out slowly so as to try to justice to all reasonable responses.

Thanks

Jake Steele
InterGalactic Repo Man™



Cognitive dissonance​

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_dissonance

In psychology, cognitive dissonance is the mental stress or discomfort experienced by an individual who holds two or more contradictory beliefs, ideas, or values at the same time, performs an action that is contradictory to one or more beliefs, ideas or values, or is confronted by new information that conflicts with existing beliefs, ideas, or values.

A good way to explain cognitive dissonance is to use this movie as an example:
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0140352/?ref_=fn_tt_tt_1

It stars Russell Crowe ....

....

you might want read one of the first detailed actual academic investigations and accounts of what the author, Leon Festinger, a prof at Stanford, described as cognitive dissonance. The book is entitled "When Prophecy Fails," and it concerns a group who believed they would be picked up by a flying saucer:
When Prophecy Fails: A Social and Psychological Study of a Modern Group That Predicted the Destruction of the World is a classic work of social psychology by Leon Festinger, Henry Riecken, and Stanley Schachter which studied a small UFO religion in Chicago called the Seekers that believed in an imminent Apocalypse and its coping mechanisms after the event did not occur. Festinger's theory of cognitive dissonance can account for the psychological consequences of disconfirmed expectations. One of the first published cases of dissonance was reported in this book.
...
4:00 am. The group has been sitting in stunned silence. A few attempts at finding explanations have failed. Keech begins to cry.
4:45 am. Another message by automatic writing is sent to Keech. It states, in effect, that the God of Earth has decided to spare the planet from destruction. The cataclysm has been called off: "The little group, sitting all night long, had spread so much light that God had saved the world from destruction."
Afternoon, December 21. Newspapers are called; interviews are sought. In a reversal of its previous distaste for publicity, the group begins an urgent campaign to spread its message to as broad an audience as possible.
....
I don't know all the ways that irrational believers reduce their cognitive dissonance when, for example, bigfoot turns out to be all Rick Dyer, Melba Ketchum, Todd Standing, Dr. Matthew Johnson, and the reality of Roger Patterson; and no sasquatch. One method is, as noted above, to proselytize, and here you are, doing that. But I suspect that one other mechanism is to blame, in some sense, those who have always doubted the "dogma." And here you are, doing that.
 
Originally Posted by Daylightstar View Post

They're wired in a way that they can't handle even the slightest amount of cognitive dissonance. Denial of evidence and biased thinking are the tactics used to restore consistency in their minds.


Are you referring to this? Ummm, Not sure if you I would call that CD. You made a claim which is sort of an inversion of the defininition of psuedoskepticism(turn about is fair play), on its merits, would be considered as a valid point in a court of law. Ontario makes a counterclaim which, on its merits, would also be considered a valid point. It's point counter point.

I haven't been following that part of the posting so I would need a context surrounding the whole exchange. I'm occupied with leisurely responding to responses to my posts.

With that being said, obviously, Ontario are on the same side of the fence in regards to the psychology aspect and youz guyz are on the other.

That's what I thought, no identifiable cognitive dissonance as far as OntarioSquatch claims it to exist in skeptics.
 
Originally Posted by Daylightstar View Post

They're wired in a way that they can't handle even the slightest amount of cognitive dissonance. Denial of evidence and biased thinking are the tactics used to restore consistency in their minds.


Are you referring to this? Ummm, Not sure if you I would call that CD. You made a claim which is sort of an inversion of the defininition of psuedoskepticism(turn about is fair play), on its merits, would be considered as a valid point in a court of law. Ontario makes a counterclaim which, on its merits, would also be considered a valid point. It's point counter point.

I haven't been following that part of the posting so I would need a context surrounding the whole exchange. I'm occupied with leisurely responding to responses to my posts.

With that being said, obviously, Ontario are on the same side of the fence in regards to the psychology aspect and youz guyz are on the other.

What psychology aspect?
 
The personal attacks and false accusations made it obvious to me that these so-called skeptics are actually motivated by fear. For a while I thought it might be the existence of the unknown that they fear, but the fact that some of them are former "woo" believers is evidence against that. When I examined the timeline of their switch in belief, I noticed that there was never a moment where they accepted the fact that they just don't know the answer. The reason for it seems to be that being in a position where they have to experience cognitive dissonance causes them a high level of discomfort and I can't think of topics that cause more cognitive dissonance than 9/11 and Bigfoot.

CD is the explanation for the behavior of many here, but since interpretations of behavior are subjective, one can easily disagree with it. I already gave examples of behavior that I think is indicative of cognitive dissonance in the thread I started, but my interpretation of it was dismissed and the thread was bombarded by people who possess the mentality that I've been describing.

It's worth mentioning that not everyone here who claims to be a skeptic possesses this mentality. There are legitimate skeptics here in this section of the forum, but they're few and far between.
 
Last edited:
The personal attacks and false accusations made it obvious to me that these so-called skeptics are actually motivated by fear. For a while I thought it might be the existence of the unknown that they fear, but the fact that some of them are former "woo" believers is evidence against that. When I examined the timeline of their switch in belief, I noticed that there was never a moment where they accepted the fact that they just don't know the answer. The reason for it seems to be that being in a position where they have to experience cognitive dissonance causes them a high level of discomfort and I can't think of topics that cause more cognitive dissonance than 9/11 and Bigfoot.

CD is the explanation for the behavior of many here, but since interpretations of behavior are subjective, one can easily disagree with it. I already gave examples of behavior that I think is indicative of cognitive dissonance in the thread I started, but my interpretation of it was dismissed and the thread was bombarded by people who possess the mentality that I've been describing.

It's worth mentioning that not everyone here who claims to be a skeptic possesses this mentality. There are legitimate skeptics here in this section of the forum, but they're few and far between.

What is the sound of one goalpost moving?
 
The personal attacks and false accusations made it obvious to me that these so-called skeptics are actually motivated by fear. For a while I thought it might be the existence of the unknown that they fear, but the fact that some of them are former "woo" believers is evidence against that. When I examined the timeline of their switch in belief, I noticed that there was never a moment where they accepted the fact that they just don't know the answer. The reason for it seems to be that being in a position where they have to experience cognitive dissonance causes them a high level of discomfort and I can't think of topics that cause more cognitive dissonance than 9/11 and Bigfoot.

CD is the explanation for the behavior of many here, but since interpretations of behavior are subjective, one can easily disagree with it. I already gave examples of behavior that I think is indicative of cognitive dissonance in the thread I started, but my interpretation of it was dismissed and the thread was bombarded by people who possess the mentality that I've been describing.

It's worth mentioning that not everyone here who claims to be a skeptic possesses this mentality. There are legitimate skeptics here in this section of the forum, but they're few and far between.

Yes, of what you think (or redefine it to be) is indicative of cognitive dissonance.
For you it's just an impressive sounding term which will surely intimidate these 'so called skeptics'.


Anyways, if only you could produce one bigfoot. Just one.




But you can't.
 
CD is the explanation for the behavior of many here,
My cross-dressing has nothing to do with my interest in bigfoot. Usually . . .

I already gave examples of behavior that I think is indicative of cognitive dissonance in the thread I started, . . .

I think you might have laid out what you think you think you mean by cognitive dissonance, but what I'm seeking from you is an actual example of an actual person who has behaved in the manner you describe. If you've provided that, then I ain't seen it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom