Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

Cosmic Yak

Philosopher
Joined
Feb 19, 2015
Messages
9,158
Location
Breaking the road for the rest.
The 'Mentality of Skeptics' thread was purportedly started to expose the alleged closed-mindedness, cognitive dissonance and denialist approach of many members here.
It quickly became clear that this was not, in fact, the aim of the thread: it was, in fact, another Bigfoot thread.
However, before it was ruled OT, there were a few discussions about alleged examples of this, discussions that I thought were shut down too quickly. Moreover, these kinds of allegations have been made in other threads too, especially in the Conspiracies sub-forum.
I am not alone in repeatedly asking for examples of this, from actual posts by actual members, and so I am starting this thread with this purpose.
I would like to see actual examples of the following, as alleged, repeatedly, by certain members here:
  • Blind obedience to an "Official Story".
  • A refusal to accept evidence for a non-conventional idea or assertion.
  • Cognitive dissonance and/or anxiety caused by a subconscious acceptance of such ideas, coupled by a public disavowal of same.
  • Insulting, aggressive posts that attack the arguer, not the argument. (Probably best to exclude Beachnut from this, really....:) )
  • Pseudo-skepticism.
  • Unqualified, uncritical support for governments, police forces and other establishment organisations.
  • Shilling for corporations or security forces.
If examples are posted here, I and others can look at them. It may be possible that I, and others are doing this without realising how it looks from the other side, in which case I will be perfectly happy to modify my approach and posting style.
On the other hand, if no such examples can be found, then I would like to ask those members responsible to stop making false accusations.
In other words, put up or shut up.
 
Or ignore.

Argument, on the internet, can be won only if one side of the argument admits to defeat. There is nothing which can be done about this, but bans. People are free to repeat nonsenses and other people are free to react to them. And everyone is free to ignore anyone else.
 
Damnation, I've been found out!

*calls Illuminati, waits to be whisked away in a black helicopter*
 
Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple are terms used by kQQks back about 1995.

Enough already.
 
Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple are terms used by kQQks back about 1995.

Enough already.

Yet they are still used now, by members of this forum.
For example:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11035128#post11035128
jakesteele said:
Skeptibunkers
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11009446#post11009446
OntarioSquatch said:
A Bigfoot proponent posts an audio of an alleged Bigfoot. The "skeptic" gets anxious and says its a common forest animal, but it turns out to be just a person pretending to be a Sasquatch.
So again, I have to ask: can anyone post an example of this anxiety or pseudo-skepticism, or can we stop throwing these accusations around?
 
So again, I have to ask: can anyone post an example of this anxiety or pseudo-skepticism, or can we stop throwing these accusations around?
First off, we have a range of skills represented here, so you get skeptics with varying levels of sophistication. Given that we can say that some posters are sometimes mistaken in the way skepticism is used. This can be taken as an honest mistake or a deliberate misuse of the nature of skepticism. This does not rule out people who intentionally use skeptical methodology incorrectly, it just points out that we have to determine why the methodology wasn't apply as it should be.

Second, using words that are intended to attack the poster rather than the poster's argument reflect on the speaker more than on the subject of the statement. Flinging poo devalues one's sapience.

(This from a person who has a sentimental attachment to a machine gun. ;) )
 
I would like to see actual examples of the following, as alleged, repeatedly, by certain members here:
  • Blind obedience to an "Official Story".
  • A refusal to accept evidence for a non-conventional idea or assertion.
  • Cognitive dissonance and/or anxiety caused by a subconscious acceptance of such ideas, coupled by a public disavowal of same.
  • Insulting, aggressive posts that attack the arguer, not the argument.
  • Pseudo-skepticism.
  • Unqualified, uncritical support for governments, police forces and other establishment organisations.
  • Shilling for corporations or security forces.

I don't care if the examples come from ISF members. I just want to see actual evidence of any of these claims.
 
I don't believe in bigfoot.

Just wanted to get that out there early on.
 
First off, we have a range of skills represented here, so you get skeptics with varying levels of sophistication. Given that we can say that some posters are sometimes mistaken in the way skepticism is used. This can be taken as an honest mistake or a deliberate misuse of the nature of skepticism. This does not rule out people who intentionally use skeptical methodology incorrectly, it just points out that we have to determine why the methodology wasn't apply as it should be.

Second, using words that are intended to attack the poster rather than the poster's argument reflect on the speaker more than on the subject of the statement. Flinging poo devalues one's sapience.

(This from a person who has a sentimental attachment to a machine gun. ;) )
These are both good points, and ones which I agree with.
However, the people I am aiming this thread at do not seem to be making the kind of differentiation you talk about in your first point.
Earlier today, in the very thread that gave me the idea for this one, jakesteele posted this:
jakesteele said:
By post 23 the Bigfoot derailing occurs. I got it back on track by pounding on the psychology issues, but the the thread got rejacked by the herd mentality and group think of this forum.

Again, psychology seems to make the majority of people here very uncomfortable.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11059024#post11059024
Where you say 'some posters', jakesteele says 'the majority', along with the depiction of a supposed herd mentality.
OntarioSquatch also posted in the same thread earlier today:
OntarioSquatch said:
[Bigfoot skeptics] lie to themselves, not to others. These are people who are somewhat well-read on the subject, except are trying to convince themselves that Sasquatch aren't real. They lie to themselves about the quality and quantity of evidence. This is to remove the cognitive dissonance that comes with not knowing the answer.

The belief that Bigfoot doesn't exist is supposed to be supported by a lack of evidence, except the evidence isn't really lacking and that's why their belief is so fragile.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11058167#post11058167
So, jakesteele and OntarioSquatch, would you like to comment on Gawdzilla Sama's post? Do you see any differentiation in the kind and sophistication of skeptics here, and would you agree that this does not mean everyone is deliberately using incorrect methods to attack your positions?
Gawdzilla Sama, with regard to your second point, you are of course correct to say that insults reflect badly on those who hurl them. However, the point I was trying to make is that jakesteele has repeatedly claimed he has been insulted and attacked personally:
jakesteele said:
This was my first real taste of shrill, irrational, arrogant, condescending, insulting psuedoskepticism when I started coming to this site.......I’ll just repeat the slurs and insults I've heard so many times; kook, nutter, CTer, woo, Xian, tin foil hatter, Troofer.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11016693#post11016693
However many times I have called him on this, he has avoided citing any posts where this has actually happened. If these epithets have been cast at jakesteele, then this air of outrage and hurt is perhaps justified. Thus far, however, in the absence of substantiation, it just looks like petulant whining. This, in my opinion, reflects badly more on jakesteele rather than on his supposed attackers.
 
It's impossible to prove that someone's in denial if they're denying a possibility and not an established fact, but you can still make an accurate determination based the person's behaviour.


Denialists/Pseudoskeptics

- Reject evidence
- Consider their unproven position to be the default
- React with anger when the opposing view is presented
- Favor things that are official or widely accepted
- Dislike ambiguity


Skeptics

- Are open to any evidence
- Consider all possibilities
- Don't have a default position unless it's proven
- Are willing to question widely held ideas
- Can handle ambiguity


A pseudoskeptic's primary interest is to discredit claims that conflict with their belief. You'll notice that they tend to focus on just one particular subject (e.g 9/11, bigfoot).
 
It's impossible to prove that someone's in denial if they're denying a possibility and not an established fact, but you can still make an accurate determination based the person's behaviour.


Denialists/Pseudoskeptics

- Reject evidence
- Consider their unproven position to be the default
- React with anger when the opposing view is presented
- Favor things that are official or widely accepted
- Dislike ambiguity


Skeptics

- Are open to any evidence
- Consider all possibilities
- Don't have a default position unless it's proven
- Are willing to question widely held ideas
- Can handle ambiguity


A pseudoskeptic's primary interest is to discredit claims that conflict with their belief. You'll notice that they tend to focus on just one particular subject (e.g 9/11, bigfoot).

Which does not even begin to pretend to address the OP.
 
Ontario, you forgot "demand replicable results" under Skeptics. You should add that.

That's the majority of the issue in dealing with OS...either his compelete ignorance of definitions/concepts, creating his own definitions/concepts and/or willfully creating a concept/definition to provoke.

Just watch you'll see ;)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom