Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

To tl;dr : No, not all skeptics are inherently good or even nice people.
So what?

As an afterthought, this thread's OP is rather unsubtly aggresive. The "put up or shut up" line, in particular. I can only assume you mean to be sincere in your offer to correct errant behaviour where you accept it to exist, so being adverserial right off the bat seems unnecessary, perhaps even detrimental to whatever it is you are presumably trying to do here.
Asking for specific evidence/examples of pseudoskeptical behavior is aggressive?
 
Last edited:
Asking for specific evidence/examples of pseudoskeptical behavior is aggressive?

Anything that threatens their hallucination is "aggressive." The new justification is that we don't believe undiscovered 9-foot apes live in Chicago because we're mean.
 
Anything that threatens their hallucination is "aggressive." The new justification is that we don't believe undiscovered 9-foot apes live in Chicago because we're mean.

Sometimes I am mean. And I mean to be mean.
 
The 'Mentality of Skeptics' thread was purportedly started to expose the alleged closed-mindedness, cognitive dissonance and denialist approach of many members here.
It quickly became clear that this was not, in fact, the aim of the thread: it was, in fact, another Bigfoot thread.
However, before it was ruled OT, there were a few discussions about alleged examples of this, discussions that I thought were shut down too quickly. Moreover, these kinds of allegations have been made in other threads too, especially in the Conspiracies sub-forum.
I am not alone in repeatedly asking for examples of this, from actual posts by actual members, and so I am starting this thread with this purpose.
I would like to see actual examples of the following, as alleged, repeatedly, by certain members here:
  • Blind obedience to an "Official Story".
  • A refusal to accept evidence for a non-conventional idea or assertion.
  • Cognitive dissonance and/or anxiety caused by a subconscious acceptance of such ideas, coupled by a public disavowal of same.
  • Insulting, aggressive posts that attack the arguer, not the argument. (Probably best to exclude Beachnut from this, really....:) )
  • Pseudo-skepticism.
  • Unqualified, uncritical support for governments, police forces and other establishment organisations.
  • Shilling for corporations or security forces.
If examples are posted here, I and others can look at them. It may be possible that I, and others are doing this without realising how it looks from the other side, in which case I will be perfectly happy to modify my approach and posting style.
On the other hand, if no such examples can be found, then I would like to ask those members responsible to stop making false accusations.
In other words, put up or shut up.

<snip for focus>

As an afterthought, this thread's OP is rather unsubtly aggresive. The "put up or shut up" line, in particular. I can only assume you mean to be sincere in your offer to correct errant behaviour where you accept it to exist, so being adverserial right off the bat seems unnecessary, perhaps even detrimental to whatever it is you are presumably trying to do here.

This kind of response is exactly why I started this thread, and I welcome it.
That is not to say that I agree, but this is something that I think is worth discussing. I am interested in conversation, not confrontation.
That said, I am forthright in expressing myself. I consider this to be direct, not aggressive, and I make no apology for this. Without trying to sound too grandiose, what we discuss on this forum matters. The issues we debate have far-reaching consequences, in all sorts of ways, and the way we approach them, and resolve ( or attempt to resolve) our differences is also of consequence. Although this may be a small forum, there is a certain ripple effect that will reach friends of family of forum members, and so this small stone may well create waves that will eventually break on the ( in my view) growing shores of a rising mass of uncritical acceptance of unevidenced, or even soundly disproved, ideas, and so perhaps erode the sands of falsehood.

My aim is this: to avoid debates getting bogged down in side-issues about individual approaches and methods. No-one is going to be convinced by mere browbeating, from either side. If we are going to make some progress in the direction of truth, we need to be able to communicate with each other. If one side of the debate feels that the other is not following a properly scientific skeptical approach (i.e. pseudo-skepticism), is closed-minded, arguing against a person rather than an idea, or shilling for some agency or other, this communication will not happen. So, I have asked those posters who have made such complaints to demonstrate that their complaints have merit. By doing that, we can resolve this, either by those posters who are shown to be doing this making some acknowledgement of this, and perhaps softening their tone, or by the accusers admitting that there has been a miscommunication, and that they had perchance misread or misinterpreted what was being said to them.

Going back to my OP, I have reread it in light of your comments, and I'm afraid I don't see it. The 'put up or shut up' final sentence, I can see being read as strong, but, again, I see this as direct as opposed to aggressive. I welcome the input of other posters regarding this sentence, as I will happily apologise if it has ruffled feathers.
The rest of the post seems perfectly polite and reasonable to me. Correct me if you think I'm wrong.
Despite comparisons with walls of diverse composition, I am perfectly happy to adapt and modify if circumstances require it. If I cannot do this myself, it would be hypocritical of me to expect others to do so as well.
Ideally, if we can get this sorted out to some reasonable level of mutual satisfaction, we can then get on with dealing, in our small way, with the issues at hand. It's all about learning and understanding, which I assume is what we're all here for.
 
The hard line Fundamentalism, exhibited by the Fundies™, that is taken on all matters of what this site has labeled as 'woo'. Black and white, all or nothing thinking.

So you keep saying, yet you have still to demonstrate this.
A request for evidence is not "all or nothing thinking".
If something has been shown impossible by, for example, scientific research, and is thus rejected, then maybe it is, where "all" is reality, and "nothing" is fantasy. I fail to see any possible argument against this. Facts are facts- nothing ideological ( which 'fundamentalism' is) about that at all.
Once again, I invite you to post- from this forum, I emphasise- examples of such thinking.
 
Sometimes I am mean. And I mean to be mean.

It's a curious thing. So often I find that "He's mean" turns out to be code for "He's right, and I don't agree with him." Not always, of course. But I'm struck by how frequently credules hide behind "mean."
 
There seems to be some confusion about the cognitive dissonance thing that I would like to try to make clearer. Ontario and I are on separate but similar tracks. I don’t necessarily answer for what Ontario says and vice versa.

Also, it seems that a lot of people aren’t getting what I’m conveying about cognitive dissonance/cognitive closure and Need for Closure Scale. Just to refresh memories and hopefully bring some clarity, here it is again.

cognitive dissonance is the mental stress or discomfort experienced by an individual who holds two or more contradictory beliefs, ideas, or values at the same time, performs an action that is contradictory to one or more beliefs, ideas or values, or is confronted by new information that conflicts with existing beliefs, ideas, or values.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_closure
Cognitive closure (psychology), the human desire to eliminate ambiguity and arrive at definite conclusions (sometimes irrationally)

Closure or need for closure are psychological terms that describe an individual's desire for a firm answer to a question and an aversion toward ambiguity. The term "need" denotes a motivated tendency to seek out information.

And that brings us to the Need for Closure Scale
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Closur..._Closure_Scale

A person with a high need for closure prefers order and predictability, is decisive and closed-minded, and is uncomfortable with ambiguity.[3]


I would also point out that neither high or low need for cognitive closure are intrinsically good or bad by nature. There are positive and less positive traits associated with both. To sum that up neatly, again, I repost this little ditty.
“If you open you mind too far, your brains will fall out.”
“If you close your mind too tightly, you’ll cut off the circulation.”

Cognitive dissonance is uncomfortable. It can occur on different levels; conscious, subliminal, unconscious. The way I’m writing about it, not necessarily in total alignment with Ontario’s postings, is more about the way members of this ‘group think’ are the ways it has been dealt with and continues to be dealt with, i.e., cognitive closure.

In the context of this forum’s cognitive closure it manifests in a number of different ways. A huge one is the automatic dismissal of entire areas(anything labeled woo). The one that I find is the most egregious is, “(UFOs)Airplane pilots are unreliable witness, they are prone to mistakes.”. By dismissing an entire body of arguably some of the most critical sightings one doesn’t have to deal with it. To make matters worse, amateur astronomers are considered to be some of the best ones who “look at the skies” Now we’re not just talking about novice pilots in single engine planes, but very skilled and experienced commercial pilots for major Airlines companies up to highly skilled, trained, experienced military pilots who are in charge of protecting the nation. These pilots are trained in airplane silhouette identification and are in charge of $20-30,000,000 state of the art war planes. If these types of pilots are “unreliable witnesses and are prone to mistakes”, only God can help us. Literally, “Chicken Little, the sky is falling.”

I'm wondering if anyone can tell me the source of the SkeptiBunker™ Memology™?

“Who’s looking at the sky all the time? Some random guy on the street looks up and sees something he doesn’t understand, that’s not surprising, right, because he doesn’t spend a lot of time looking up. The link below is Phil Plait giving an absurd take on UFOs and amateur astronomers.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c75N4reUpHs(2:23)
Amateur astronomers spend more time looking up than anybody. They’re all the time looking up at this stuff, and yet they never report UFOs. Why? Because they know what they’re looking at. They know when they’re seeing Venus, the Moon, swap gas, the Araura, satellites, the reflections off things. And so the fact of the matter is, if UFOs were real, if these were really aliens visiting us, overwhelming the most number of reports would be from amateur astronomers, and yet they never seem to report ‘em. And I think that indicates that, you know - - it doesn’t indicate there are no aliens visiting us, but it certainly indicates that the overwhelming number of cases reported
are just simple things being misunderstood.”


Below are links that show real-time air traffic 24/7. So how come all of these pilots, with 24/7 coverage of the air are somehow not in the same category of amateur astronomers like Mitch Stanley, of the Phoenix Lights, the young man with the golden ‘scope?

https://www.flightradar24.com/20.6,-21.29/2

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...-Real-time-map-shows-plane-air-right-now.html

What will happen next is the SkeptiBunkers will want to pull this down into, “Go ahead, pick a UFO incident and we will debunk it.” This is not a post about any specific incident, but rather, a post looking at the overview of the logic and reasoning that the Defender of the Orthodox and the Paradigm Police use to maintain cognitive closure.

Also, as a side bonus, this one’s for you, Cosmic. Your insistence that I provide examples(plural, more than one) of the kook, nutter, troofer, etc., claims I made. I wasted time and energy and binary code and bandwidth to show you what is self evident. Anyone who has posted on this forum and the CT forum for any length of time knows these things to be self evident.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=10973034&highlight=kook#post10973034
Re-Discovering the Mind
Views: 2,104
Posted By Joey McGee
No one in the world has a poster of Richard...

No one in the world has a poster of Richard Dawkins on their wall, honestly.

More crank psychology nonsense to explain what is wrong with skeptics who can't accept kook theories. This has been...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=10950860&highlight=kook#post10950860
Merged: The "Many Worlds Theory" General Thread
Views: 20,067
Posted By Alexander1304
And on this forum it was clearly and patiently...

And on this forum it was clearly and patiently explained that Rhawn Joseph is a kook who deliberately misrepresented - well pretty much everything.

Ok:). I will post one Russian physicist from...


14th August 2015, 07:10 PM
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=10829787&highlight=nutter#post10829787

Replies: 2,431
Dr. Jeffrey Meldrum - America's "Bigfoot Professor"
Views: 251,599
Posted By Jodie
I bet one dollar that there is nothing but a...

I bet one dollar that there is nothing but a story to be found when you track down database reports.

The witness will not have anything to verify the story at all. They won't act like a "nutter"...


Dr. Jeffrey Meldrum - America's "Bigfoot Professor"
Views: 251,599
Posted By Jodie
Where else does one properly analyse the...

Where else does one properly analyse the ramblings of nutters, then? How does one actually test the BFRO database by leaving his house? I can literally sit with my arse planted in a chair, laptop on...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=10749784&highlight=nutter#post10749784
The Valley of the Wood Apes
Views: 111,332
Posted By Resume
These bozos can't collect scientific evidence on...

These bozos can't collect scientific evidence on a 10 acre site where they claim frequent interactions and they're gonna expand operations to include half the frikken country?

Or is it this?


The Valley of the Wood Apes
Views: 111,332
Posted By Drewbot
The NAWAC HAS EXPANDED OPERATIONS!! Thank...

The NAWAC HAS EXPANDED OPERATIONS!!

Thank god they are not coming to Michigan, I can still walk and hike without a Nutter Footer unloading a 10 Round Shotgun Magazine on me and my kids.
...


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=302116&highlight=TROOFER
Dubai Address hotel fire
Views: 6,992
Posted By Seymour Butz
He has no counter argument to this. So he'll...

He has no counter argument to this.

So he'll just ignore it and plow on with his belief about diesel fires, etc.

Just like a troofer....


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=10900294&highlight=TROOFER#post10900294
"Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence"
Views: 1,957
Posted By Allen773
"Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence"

Ever heard a Tr00fer (or CT cultist in general) use this line? It's one of my favorites, right after "JAQ (ust Asking Questions)" and right before "All I'm asking for is a new investigation!"
...
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=153911&highlight=shamless&page=2
#60 - I hate it when UFO nuts ask skeptics "you really think we are alone?", just because the skeptic does not accept anecdotal evidence as proof.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=153911&highlight=shamless&page=2
#64 – UFO Nut

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=153911&highlight=shamless&page=2
#69 – antirational

http://www.internationalskeptics.co...50&highlight=Jenny+McCarthy+Body+Count+Online
#9 – fool, #17 – pic of guy in tin foil hat(‘toid, ‘tard, take your pick), #23 – conspiranoid, #68 - anti-pharma nuts, #89 - a crank you are, a crank you are, #119 - Are you dense or just an ass?, 126 - you are too lazy to actually click on the links or too dense to understand what Ms. Seidel wrote?, #142 - someone without a clue pretending to be a victim.,

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=156375&highlight=Cter&page=2
#46 – read whole post - only taints the conversation with a hostile mood?/ I'm starting to get so fed up on this malice
#48 - just watch others being bullied.,
#56 - Who's this Timothy Good guy? Oh, I see. He's a UFO enthusiast...(killing the messenger),
#93 - Bruce Maccabee is a believer. I'll certainly read reports from believers, but they have considerably less credibility, imo. I'd rather read reports from unbiased sources.(killing the messenger)
#98 - youre a ufo nut
#112 - The unscientific ones are the Maccabees, who's default setting is it's an Alien Craft until someone proves us wrong. Hoagland, Art Bell, Dilettoso, Meier, Lazar, Maussan, Linda Moulton Howe, the list goes on.(killing the messenger)
#114 - aren't UFOlogists just experts at sensationalism?(killing the messenger)
#115 - However, there is other witness testimony that supports this observation so Stanley's observations are not the sole reason this conclusion is reached (see my website on the subject).(anecdotal evidence)
#116 - by any UFO 'nut'(killing the messenger)
On and on and on…


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=190794&page=8

#283 - From the few fundie forums


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=292109
#4 - The people who should be seeing these UFOs are not - Amateur astronomers
Law of the amateur astronomer™

Why do I get the feeling that the goal posts will be:
MOVED FROM HERE…………………………..TO HERE?

I played your game, now you play mine.

Below are two sentences and I respectfully ask you to answer with any one of the choices:

Sentence 1: Like to be a little more specific? Or does your argument lose traction if you're forced to discuss the facts?

Sentence 2: Hey, Cosmic! Like to be a little bit more specific, or does your argument lose traction if you’re forced to discuss psychology?

Do you think one of these sentences is disrespectful?
•If so, which one and why?

Do you think both sentences are disrespectful?
•If so, why?

Do you think neither sentence is disrespectful?
•Please elaborate.
 
Last edited:
Little bump to ask if the results of our attitudes to closure are ready for publication? I think they will make for interesting reading.

Sorry about that, chief - I've been waylayed by some unexpected work in the real world. I've got 10 sets of results, will produce a summary this week.
 
There seems to be some confusion about the cognitive dissonance thing that I would like to try to make clearer. Ontario and I are on separate but similar tracks. I don’t necessarily answer for what Ontario says and vice versa.

Also, it seems that a lot of people aren’t getting what I’m conveying about cognitive dissonance/cognitive closure and Need for Closure Scale. Just to refresh memories and hopefully bring some clarity, here it is again.

cognitive dissonance is the mental stress or discomfort experienced by an individual who holds two or more contradictory beliefs, ideas, or values at the same time, performs an action that is contradictory to one or more beliefs, ideas or values, or is confronted by new information that conflicts with existing beliefs, ideas, or values.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_closure
Cognitive closure (psychology), the human desire to eliminate ambiguity and arrive at definite conclusions (sometimes irrationally)

Closure or need for closure are psychological terms that describe an individual's desire for a firm answer to a question and an aversion toward ambiguity. The term "need" denotes a motivated tendency to seek out information.

And that brings us to the Need for Closure Scale
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Closur..._Closure_Scale

A person with a high need for closure prefers order and predictability, is decisive and closed-minded, and is uncomfortable with ambiguity.[3]


I would also point out that neither high or low need for cognitive closure are intrinsically good or bad by nature. There are positive and less positive traits associated with both. To sum that up neatly, again, I repost this little ditty.
“If you open you mind too far, your brains will fall out.”
“If you close your mind too tightly, you’ll cut off the circulation.”

Cognitive dissonance is uncomfortable. It can occur on different levels; conscious, subliminal, unconscious. The way I’m writing about it, not necessarily in total alignment with Ontario’s postings, is more about the way members of this ‘group think’ are the ways it has been dealt with and continues to be dealt with, i.e., cognitive closure.

In the context of this forum’s cognitive closure it manifests in a number of different ways. A huge one is the automatic dismissal of entire areas(anything labeled woo). The one that I find is the most egregious is, “(UFOs)Airplane pilots are unreliable witness, they are prone to mistakes.”. By dismissing an entire body of arguably some of the most critical sightings one doesn’t have to deal with it. To make matters worse, amateur astronomers are considered to be some of the best ones who “look at the skies” Now we’re not just talking about novice pilots in single engine planes, but very skilled and experienced commercial pilots for major Airlines companies up to highly skilled, trained, experienced military pilots who are in charge of protecting the nation. These pilots are trained in airplane silhouette identification and are in charge of $20-30,000,000 state of the art war planes. If these types of pilots are “unreliable witnesses and are prone to mistakes”, only God can help us. Literally, “Chicken Little, the sky is falling.”

I'm wondering if anyone can tell me the source of the SkeptiBunker™ Memology™?

“Who’s looking at the sky all the time? Some random guy on the street looks up and sees something he doesn’t understand, that’s not surprising, right, because he doesn’t spend a lot of time looking up. The link below is Phil Plait giving an absurd take on UFOs and amateur astronomers.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c75N4reUpHs(2:23)
Amateur astronomers spend more time looking up than anybody. They’re all the time looking up at this stuff, and yet they never report UFOs. Why? Because they know what they’re looking at. They know when they’re seeing Venus, the Moon, swap gas, the Araura, satellites, the reflections off things. And so the fact of the matter is, if UFOs were real, if these were really aliens visiting us, overwhelming the most number of reports would be from amateur astronomers, and yet they never seem to report ‘em. And I think that indicates that, you know - - it doesn’t indicate there are no aliens visiting us, but it certainly indicates that the overwhelming number of cases reported
are just simple things being misunderstood.”


Below are links that show real-time air traffic 24/7. So how come all of these pilots, with 24/7 coverage of the air are somehow not in the same category of amateur astronomers like Mitch Stanley, of the Phoenix Lights, the young man with the golden ‘scope?

https://www.flightradar24.com/20.6,-21.29/2

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...-Real-time-map-shows-plane-air-right-now.html

What will happen next is the SkeptiBunkers will want to pull this down into, “Go ahead, pick a UFO incident and we will debunk it.” This is not a post about any specific incident, but rather, a post looking at the overview of the logic and reasoning that the Defender of the Orthodox and the Paradigm Police use to maintain cognitive closure.

Also, as a side bonus, this one’s for you, Cosmic. Your insistence that I provide examples(plural, more than one) of the kook, nutter, troofer, etc., claims I made. I wasted time and energy and binary code and bandwidth to show you what is self evident. Anyone who has posted on this forum and the CT forum for any length of time knows these things to be self evident.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=10973034&highlight=kook#post10973034
Re-Discovering the Mind
Views: 2,104
Posted By Joey McGee
No one in the world has a poster of Richard...

No one in the world has a poster of Richard Dawkins on their wall, honestly.

More crank psychology nonsense to explain what is wrong with skeptics who can't accept kook theories. This has been...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=10950860&highlight=kook#post10950860
Merged: The "Many Worlds Theory" General Thread
Views: 20,067
Posted By Alexander1304
And on this forum it was clearly and patiently...

And on this forum it was clearly and patiently explained that Rhawn Joseph is a kook who deliberately misrepresented - well pretty much everything.

Ok:). I will post one Russian physicist from...


14th August 2015, 07:10 PM
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=10829787&highlight=nutter#post10829787

Replies: 2,431
Dr. Jeffrey Meldrum - America's "Bigfoot Professor"
Views: 251,599
Posted By Jodie
I bet one dollar that there is nothing but a...

I bet one dollar that there is nothing but a story to be found when you track down database reports.

The witness will not have anything to verify the story at all. They won't act like a "nutter"...


Dr. Jeffrey Meldrum - America's "Bigfoot Professor"
Views: 251,599
Posted By Jodie
Where else does one properly analyse the...

Where else does one properly analyse the ramblings of nutters, then? How does one actually test the BFRO database by leaving his house? I can literally sit with my arse planted in a chair, laptop on...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=10749784&highlight=nutter#post10749784
The Valley of the Wood Apes
Views: 111,332
Posted By Resume
These bozos can't collect scientific evidence on...

These bozos can't collect scientific evidence on a 10 acre site where they claim frequent interactions and they're gonna expand operations to include half the frikken country?

Or is it this?


The Valley of the Wood Apes
Views: 111,332
Posted By Drewbot
The NAWAC HAS EXPANDED OPERATIONS!! Thank...

The NAWAC HAS EXPANDED OPERATIONS!!

Thank god they are not coming to Michigan, I can still walk and hike without a Nutter Footer unloading a 10 Round Shotgun Magazine on me and my kids.
...


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=302116&highlight=TROOFER
Dubai Address hotel fire
Views: 6,992
Posted By Seymour Butz
He has no counter argument to this. So he'll...

He has no counter argument to this.

So he'll just ignore it and plow on with his belief about diesel fires, etc.

Just like a troofer....


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=10900294&highlight=TROOFER#post10900294
"Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence"
Views: 1,957
Posted By Allen773
"Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence"

Ever heard a Tr00fer (or CT cultist in general) use this line? It's one of my favorites, right after "JAQ (ust Asking Questions)" and right before "All I'm asking for is a new investigation!"
...
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=153911&highlight=shamless&page=2
#60 - I hate it when UFO nuts ask skeptics "you really think we are alone?", just because the skeptic does not accept anecdotal evidence as proof.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=153911&highlight=shamless&page=2
#64 – UFO Nut

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=153911&highlight=shamless&page=2
#69 – antirational

http://www.internationalskeptics.co...50&highlight=Jenny+McCarthy+Body+Count+Online
#9 – fool, #17 – pic of guy in tin foil hat(‘toid, ‘tard, take your pick), #23 – conspiranoid, #68 - anti-pharma nuts, #89 - a crank you are, a crank you are, #119 - Are you dense or just an ass?, 126 - you are too lazy to actually click on the links or too dense to understand what Ms. Seidel wrote?, #142 - someone without a clue pretending to be a victim.,

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=156375&highlight=Cter&page=2
#46 – read whole post - only taints the conversation with a hostile mood?/ I'm starting to get so fed up on this malice
#48 - just watch others being bullied.,
#56 - Who's this Timothy Good guy? Oh, I see. He's a UFO enthusiast...(killing the messenger),
#93 - Bruce Maccabee is a believer. I'll certainly read reports from believers, but they have considerably less credibility, imo. I'd rather read reports from unbiased sources.(killing the messenger)
#98 - youre a ufo nut
#112 - The unscientific ones are the Maccabees, who's default setting is it's an Alien Craft until someone proves us wrong. Hoagland, Art Bell, Dilettoso, Meier, Lazar, Maussan, Linda Moulton Howe, the list goes on.(killing the messenger)
#114 - aren't UFOlogists just experts at sensationalism?(killing the messenger)
#115 - However, there is other witness testimony that supports this observation so Stanley's observations are not the sole reason this conclusion is reached (see my website on the subject).(anecdotal evidence)
#116 - by any UFO 'nut'(killing the messenger)
On and on and on…


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=190794&page=8

#283 - From the few fundie forums


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=292109
#4 - The people who should be seeing these UFOs are not - Amateur astronomers
Law of the amateur astronomer™

Why do I get the feeling that the goal posts will be:
MOVED FROM HERE…………………………..TO HERE?

I played your game, now you play mine.

Below are two sentences and I respectfully ask you to answer with any one of the choices:

Sentence 1: Like to be a little more specific? Or does your argument lose traction if you're forced to discuss the facts?

Sentence 2: Hey, Cosmic! Like to be a little bit more specific, or does your argument lose traction if you’re forced to discuss psychology?

Do you think one of these sentences is disrespectful?
•If so, which one and why?

Do you think both sentences are disrespectful?
•If so, why?

Do you think neither sentence is disrespectful?
•Please elaborate.

Argument by data dump?
 
I'm afraid I still don't get the point here. Is it this?

1. Sometimes, folks post snarky comments on the ISF.
2. They do this because it provides closure to the cognitive dissonance of considering that some unexplained phenomenon might, in fact, be real.
 
I'm afraid I still don't get the point here. Is it this?

1. Sometimes, folks post snarky comments on the ISF.
2. They do this because it provides closure to the cognitive dissonance of considering that some unexplained phenomenon might, in fact, be real.

I'd say that it's 100% about the snark.

No matter how ridiculous a claim is, if we don't walk on eggshells while responding, we'll be assailed by psychobabble.
 
cognitive dissonance is the mental stress or discomfort experienced by an individual who holds two or more contradictory beliefs, ideas, or values at the same time, performs an action that is contradictory to one or more beliefs, ideas or values, or is confronted by new information that conflicts with existing beliefs, ideas, or values.

jakesteele,
Please in the name of science, tell me what are the two or
more contradictory beliefs, ideas or values being held?

What contradictory action is performed when confronted by new information?

ETA: The beliefs, ideas and values being held by you, jakesteele, are
contradicted with science and/or snark.

When confronted with science (new information) you post more of your
beliefs with pop psychology thrown in.

In the context of this forum’s cognitive closure it manifests in a number of different ways.
<snip>
These pilots humans are trained in airplane silhouette identification and are in charge of $20-30,000,000 state of the art war planes. If these types of pilots humans are “unreliable witnesses and are prone to mistakes”, only God can help us. Literally, “Chicken Little, the sky is falling.”

You go with authority, and then reach to your supreme authority?
Interesting.
Chicken Little is a 19th century folk tale.
It seems odd to pick that story to illustrate your point.

Chicken Little causes a widespread panic when something (an acorn, a leaf)
falls on her and she assumes the sky is falling.
The world is ending.

You, jakesteele, appear to be the one suffering from cognitive dissonance.
Pilots who do not make mistakes (because of their training and the price
of the planes they fly) have seen UFOs.
You seem to assume that these perfect pilots have seen UFOs and only
God can help you with the presumed arrival of extra-terrestial beings, and
the end of the world.
Are you assuming that the posters here believe in God? That is strange.

Look in the mirror Chicken Little.

I can assure you, I do not suffer from cognitive dissonance when it comes
extra-terrestial beings.

I consider myself very lucky to have found this forum and the posters who
deal with those who truly believe in their own special truth.

Yeah, I came here for the Bigfoot and stayed for the snark.
:blush::D
 
I'm afraid I still don't get the point here. Is it this?

1. Sometimes, folks post snarky comments on the ISF.
2. They do this because it provides closure to the cognitive dissonance of considering that some unexplained phenomenon might, in fact, be real.
Yes. This is it exactly. Most of what jakesteele posted has nothing to do with cognitive dissonance and rather more to do with the fact that he doesn't agree with what is said. Other parts are straw men, e.g., the claim that skeptics claim that pilots are never reliable witnesses.

It amounts to what has been said before: "Skeptics ask for evidence, therefore they have problems."
 
The one that I find is the most egregious is, “(UFOs)Airplane pilots are unreliable witness, they are prone to mistakes.”. By dismissing an entire body of arguably some of the most critical sightings one doesn’t have to deal with it. To make matters worse, amateur astronomers are considered to be some of the best ones who “look at the skies” Now we’re not just talking about novice pilots in single engine planes, but very skilled and experienced commercial pilots for major Airlines companies up to highly skilled, trained, experienced military pilots who are in charge of protecting the nation. These pilots are trained in airplane silhouette identification and are in charge of $20-30,000,000 state of the art war planes. If these types of pilots are “unreliable witnesses and are prone to mistakes”, only God can help us. Literally, “Chicken Little, the sky is falling.”

Just extracting this particular brick from the tower of text: Do military pilots ever, for example, make the mistake of attacking the wrong target, up to and including friendly forces? Yes, sometimes they do, though very rarely. Like anyone else, they are prone to the occasional mistake, yet the sky has not yet fallen. And the comparison with astronomers is not one of competence as an observer, but of availability of superior detection equipment to the unassisted human eyeball and superior recording equipment to the fallible and malleable human memory.

Dave
 
Just extracting this particular brick from the tower of text: Do military pilots ever, for example, make the mistake of attacking the wrong target, up to and including friendly forces? Yes, sometimes they do, though very rarely. Like anyone else, they are prone to the occasional mistake, yet the sky has not yet fallen. And the comparison with astronomers is not one of competence as an observer, but of availability of superior detection equipment to the unassisted human eyeball and superior recording equipment to the fallible and malleable human memory.

Dave
In addition, of course, astronomers can stop and think.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom