Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

I've had more posts removed from this thread than anyone else, so I really have no idea what point you're trying to make here.

It's not about whose posts get removed but posts on which subject.

As you can remember I originally introduced the "not democracy" part as an example for your request: "A refusal to accept evidence for a non-conventional idea or assertion." It was originally introduced by "go look at my 'nobody for president' thread" and later appeared again in the discussion.

If an OP asks an example of something, and when such an example is provided it gets removed for being a derail, then naturally you end up with no such examples in the thread.
 
It's not about whose posts get removed but posts on which subject.

As you can remember I originally introduced the "not democracy" part as an example for your request: "A refusal to accept evidence for a non-conventional idea or assertion." It was originally introduced by "go look at my 'nobody for president' thread" and later appeared again in the discussion.

If an OP asks an example of something, and when such an example is provided it gets removed for being a derail, then naturally you end up with no such examples in the thread.

No...it just means you failed to understand what was being asked and revealed your ignorance on multiple astounding levels and countinue to.

Care to attempt to correct that
Edited by Darat: 
Breach of Rule 0 and 12 removed.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It's not about whose posts get removed but posts on which subject.

No, it's about why the posts get removed. They were considered a derail.

I originally introduced the "not democracy" part as an example for your request: "A refusal to accept evidence for a non-conventional idea or assertion."

You offered a bait and switch -- your statement to the effect that there's no such thing as democracy gets some reaction, and then you switch to "well, there's no perfect exemplar based on this simplistic, abstract cherry-picked definition." It's just a word game.

Actually your position when you finally clarify it is not "a non-conventional idea or assertion" at all, and it's puzzling to me that you think that skeptics as a group would find it so.
 
To the OP.

The charges against skeptics cited in the OP are known to be false by the claimant when they are made.

They are selected precisely because they are false. No evidence is going to be submitted, and they know it beforehand. The point is to bait people into responding, and the more unfair the charge is, the more response it is going to get. So you have rich grounds to troll selectively afterwards.

So the sequence is a provacitive statement followed by the hunt for "gotchyas", red herrings, and whatever you can mine out of it. It is a one-step-ahead trolling response mechanism after the "you aren't skeptics" bait so it has no coherent direction. Of course it is going to twist in the wind, go off on derails, etc.

That is it's design. The person making the provocative statement doesn't believe it himself. Why should it be expected to move forward coherently, proving the assertion? Does this person actually believe there is no Democracy? Obviously not. Now, do we expect to hear the reason for trolling people with a belief you do not have?
 
It's not about whose posts get removed but posts on which subject.

As you can remember I originally introduced the "not democracy" part as an example for your request: "A refusal to accept evidence for a non-conventional idea or assertion." It was originally introduced by "go look at my 'nobody for president' thread" and later appeared again in the discussion.

If an OP asks an example of something, and when such an example is provided it gets removed for being a derail, then naturally you end up with no such examples in the thread.

Firstly, it is of course about whose posts are removed if you are trying to argue that I, along with the moderators and other members, are conspiring together. Why would I start a conspiracy to censor myself?

Secondly, if you want to talk about the content of removed posts, please list the posts of mine that were removed, and state their content. You really should have done this before your post, but I'll give you a chance to rectify this error.
 
To the OP.

The charges against skeptics cited in the OP are known to be false by the claimant when they are made.

They are selected precisely because they are false. No evidence is going to be submitted, and they know it beforehand. The point is to bait people into responding, and the more unfair the charge is, the more response it is going to get. So you have rich grounds to troll selectively afterwards.

So the sequence is a provacitive statement followed by the hunt for "gotchyas", red herrings, and whatever you can mine out of it. It is a one-step-ahead trolling response mechanism after the "you aren't skeptics" bait so it has no coherent direction. Of course it is going to twist in the wind, go off on derails, etc.

That is it's design. The person making the provocative statement doesn't believe it himself. Why should it be expected to move forward coherently, proving the assertion? Does this person actually believe there is no Democracy? Obviously not. Now, do we expect to hear the reason for trolling people with a belief you do not have?

Trolls gotta troll!?!
But well stated ABP...we've seen this behavior over and over.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom