Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

Let's assume the research is accurate
A big assumption, but okay . . .

. . . and then model the political system based on that. People elect representatives, these representatives enact the policies requested by economic elites. . . . It's at odds with "all people are involved in making decisions about its affairs."

No it's not. I'm involved in making decisions by casting votes and electing representatives who will support the positions I do. If I vote for someone who is not elected, that doesn't mean that I'm not part of a democracy, it just means that my candidate lost the election.

These "elite" who concern you so much seem to have quite a mix of disparate views: The same people in power brought us Citizens United (my opinion not represented), the Affordable Care Act (some of my opinions represented), no action on gun control following Sandy Hook (my opinion not represented), the nuclear deal with Iran (my opinion represented), and legal gay marriage (my opinion represented). Those are not the enacted policies of a monolithic elite class. They're a patchwork of policies that results from people with markedly different ideas experiencing wins and losses, just as one would expect in a democracy.

I agree that moneyed interests have too much power in Washington and that, in some ways, we're more of an oligarchy than a pluralistic democracy. My personal confirmation bias and the article you shared, however, do not support the claim that we do not have a democracy in the United States.
 
I'm expecting evidence, not narratives. You'd think you would've learned the difference in grade school.
You need to explain what kind evidence would convince you that it was true before anyone can have a coherent discussion with you on the matter. What conditions must exist for a country to be called a democracy, where is the line, etc etc.
 
Last edited:
A big assumption, but okay . . .



No it's not. I'm involved in making decisions by casting votes and electing representatives who will support the positions I do. If I vote for someone who is not elected, that doesn't mean that I'm not part of a democracy, it just means that my candidate lost the election.
These "elite" who concern you so much seem to have quite a mix of disparate views: The same people in power brought us Citizens United (my opinion not represented), the Affordable Care Act (some of my opinions represented), no action on gun control following Sandy Hook (my opinion not represented), the nuclear deal with Iran (my opinion represented), and legal gay marriage (my opinion represented). Those are not the enacted policies of a monolithic elite class. They're a patchwork of policies that results from people with markedly different ideas experiencing wins and losses, just as one would expect in a democracy.

I agree that moneyed interests have too much power in Washington and that, in some ways, we're more of an oligarchy than a pluralistic democracy. My personal confirmation bias and the article you shared, however, do not support the claim that we do not have a democracy in the United States.

Do you even understand the research? If you think you do, please explain in your own words what you think it says. You first say "okay" and then immediately make a statement specifically refuted by the study (first highlight) and argue something that is completely irrelevant to the study (second highlight).
 
Last edited:
What conditions must exist for a country to be called a democracy, where is the line, etc etc.

The preferences of the voting public must be independently correlated with government policy. Let's draw the line at Corr >= 0.7
 
Last edited:
The preferences of the voting public must be independently correlated with government policy. Let's draw the line at Corr >= 0.7
:rolleyes: OK. So if there is one issue that public opinion conflicts with policy on, then, no democracy? Or just the preponderance, or, how does that work? Name three areas where public opinion is drastically different than government policy and nothing is being done. This should be easy.
 
It is not my job to teach you elementary statistics.
You missed the point that statistics is a stupid way to look at the subject and really just muddies the waters. I'm starting to realize that you must be spoonfed every rhetorical point. You should be able to point to "three areas where public opinion is drastically different than government policy and nothing is being done" for the sake of discussion.
 
Do you even understand the research?
Condescension noted - by everyone reading here, btw.

Yes, I understand the research.

If you think you do, . . .
Wow, you are a charmer!

. . . please explain in your own words what you think it says.

Only because you used the magic word . . . Gilens and Page examined alignment of enacted government policies with opinions of ordinary citizens and organized interest groups to test predictions from four different "theoretical traditions". (I hope you'll forgive my use of that term from the authors, as I have nothing more descriptive.)

Their analysis - evidently some kind of a mixed model selection - provided little if any support for what most folks would consider a representative democracy. Instead they found that the wishes of those groups with substantial economic power - even when in direct opposition to the wishes of the plurality of US citizens - were highly significant predictors of actual enacted policy.
 
Condescension noted - by everyone reading here, btw.

Apologies for the condescension. It is, however, true that you agreed on an assumption and then immediately made statements contradicting said assumption.

Only because you used the magic word . . . Gilens and Page examined alignment of enacted government policies with opinions of ordinary citizens and organized interest groups to test predictions from four different "theoretical traditions". (I hope you'll forgive my use of that term from the authors, as I have nothing more descriptive.)

Their analysis - evidently some kind of a mixed model selection - provided little if any support for what most folks would consider a representative democracy. Instead they found that the wishes of those groups with substantial economic power - even when in direct opposition to the wishes of the plurality of US citizens - were highly significant predictors of actual enacted policy.

Correct. Given this, and given that we were - for the sake of that piece of debate - assuming the research is accurate, can you explain why you state:
I'm involved in making decisions by casting votes and electing representatives who will support the positions I do.
Does the research not conclude that representatives support the positions of elite interests instead? If they supported the positions of the people who voted them in, and given that they're voted in if a majority of people vote for them, then we should've seen evidence for "majoritarian democracy" in the study, no?

Can you explain why you state:
If I vote for someone who is not elected, that doesn't mean that I'm not part of a democracy, it just means that my candidate lost the election.
You surely understand that that is not the conclusion being made nor is it even relevant to it?
 
Last edited:
When the evidence doesn't go your way just claim it's a "stupid" way to look at the subject.
The fact that you need to resort to convoluted statistical analysis to show that America is not a democracy says volumes about your lack of an argument. If what you are saying is true, then we should expect to see "areas where public opinion is drastically different than government policy and nothing is being done" I'm only asking for 3. Why is this so difficult?
 
You're pushing an open door with all most anyone in America when you say that money has too much influence in politics, and that lobbying is out of control, etc. Imperfect democracy is not no democracy... Saying money has more influence than no money isn't the same thing as saying that there are major issues everyone is against but we can't get changed because the system is corrupt. One does not mean the other. The intellectual laziness is extreme.
 
The fact that you need to resort to convoluted statistical analysis

Convoluted? It's elementary for goodness' sake.

If what you are saying is true, then we should expect to see "areas where public opinion is drastically different than government policy and nothing is being done"

Yes, you've made a correct deduction, congratulations.

I'm only asking for 3. Why is this so difficult?

It's probably not difficult at all. I just don't care to bother, being able to understand the "convoluted" statistics I already know that they exist. If you want to dumb down an argument to the level of "show me some arbitrary number of disagreements between public opinion and government policy" then do the work yourself - you could start with the dataset used in the research. Report back on your findings. Or even better, read an introductory statistics textbook.
 
Imperfect democracy is not no democracy...

People having no influence on government policy is not just "imperfect democracy" but no democracy at all, it's the basic meaning of the word.

Saying money has more influence than no money isn't the same thing as saying that there are major issues everyone is against but we can't get changed because the system is corrupt.

And that's an incorrect deduction, too bad, you had a streak going of one correct deduction. If everyone (including economic elites) is against something then it can and likely will get changed. You're also introducing terms which you fail to define, such as "major" or "corrupt."

But for something that might satisfy your request, perhaps you should look into taxing the rich. I think that is supported by a clear majority, could be considered a "major" issue and just never seems to get around to being changed.

One does not mean the other.

True, if only that "other" were anything but your own strawman. You see, I don't hold that it's particularly "corrupt" - it just, as a political-economic system, does what it is constructed to do, nothing more and nothing less. The difference being that some people actually go out and test the stories told to children about the "noble powerful people in government working for the good of all" instead of just believing them on faith.

The intellectual laziness is extreme.

Yours is, yes.
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes:

The statistical analysis itself may be "elementary" as you say, but the arguments that lead you to deduct that America is not a democracy are what is convoluted. The only simple argument that is makes is that money has too much influence in politics, to get from there to "America is not a democracy" needs some serious ******** piled on top of it.

Something, something else and another thing. There, that's how much time it would take for what you "can't be bothered" to do...
 
The statistical analysis itself may be "elementary" as you say, but the arguments that lead you to deduct that America is not a democracy are what is convoluted.

Democracy is government by the people. The people have no influence on government policy. Ergo, it is not a democracy.

Does that look convoluted to you?
 
You also seem to keep forgetting that it's not up to me to disprove your claim that it's a democracy, it's up to you to prove it. You know, invisible elves and all that.

If you hadn't noticed, I've already got actual evidence for my thesis while you're still stuck with a story you were told as a child in grade-school.
 
Last edited:
Does the research not conclude that representatives support the positions of elite interests instead? If they supported the positions of the people who voted them in, and given that they're voted in if a majority of people vote for them, then we should've seen evidence for "majoritarian democracy" in the study, no?
Maybe, maybe not. The authors begin their explanation with multiple caveats about how preliminary their work is and conclude in a similar vein that their one, provocative study is counter to much of the established research in this area.

I'm not convinced that they've adequately captured data that would indicate a majoritarian democracy should one actually exist. I think their description of the methods in characterizing the desires of "ordinary citizens" has been confounded by some kind of regression to a mean that does not exist. I'd need to dig a bit more to parse that out, however.

There's also the issue of low voter turnout leading to the election of individuals with far less than 50% of support of the electorate.

Be that as it may, it's an interesting analysis that certainly suggests that we're not nearly as "democratic" in the US as most people here assume us to be.

Can you explain why you state:

You surely understand that that is not the conclusion being made nor is it even relevant to it?
Correct. It's an illustration that we should use more information than that contained in a single manuscript to weigh in on a big question like "is democracy dead?"
 
Democracy is government by the people. The people have no influence on government policy. Ergo, it is not a democracy.



Does that look convoluted to you?


Whilst it's obvious to me where this is going and how it will end the humour value is enough for me to watch.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom