Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

Observation: Anyone who refuses to accept the belief systems[*] asserted[**] by this self-declared skeptical community but demands evidence will get labelled a "troll" or similar.

Conclusion: This skeptical community operates like a cult and should not be taken seriously by anyone.

* They will call their belief system "reality"
** They will call their assertions "explanations"

So rather than saying "we are asserting our belief system" they will say "we are explaining reality" but it means the exact same thing.
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately all your seeing is sincere people attempting to educate someone, until they realize its just a troll they're dealing with...then it just becomes a tit for tat game played out on a very small stage of the trolls mind.
All the while the sincere poster attempts to make valid points while trying to remain within the rules....since apparently ISF is a haven for trolls...shocking I know.
Let the party countinue!!!

Let's rewrite this so that it is truthful:
Unfortunately all your [sic] seeing is self-declared skeptics asserting a belief system, until they realize its [sic] someone who requires evidence they're dealing with...then it just becomes a game for them played out in the very small stage of their minds.
All the while the self-declared skeptic attempts to divert attention from the fact that they have no evidence while trying to remain within the rules...since they can't stand ISF being a haven for people who require evidence...shocking I know.
Let the party countinue [sic] !!!
 
Observation: Anyone who refuses to accept the belief systems[*] asserted[**] by this self-declared skeptical community but demands evidence will get labelled a "troll" or similar.

Conclusion: This skeptical community operates like a cult and should not be taken seriously by anyone.

* They will call their belief system "reality"
** They will call their assertions "explanations"

So rather than saying "we are asserting our belief system" they will say "we are explaining reality" but it means the exact same thing.

The problem is that you're wrong.

I've identified myself as a guy who investigates ghosts a couple of times on this board, and not one person has given me a hard time about it.

Why?

Because I don't post threads making claims that I cannot back up with independent scientific evidence. As with most paranormal subjects, there is almost no evidence beyond eye-witness testimony, and what people see - especially in cases of the paranormal - depends entirely on what they believe.

100% of people who deeply do not believe in ghosts have never seen one. There is no secret to why this is true.
 
The problem is that you're wrong.

I've identified myself as a guy who investigates ghosts a couple of times on this board, and not one person has given me a hard time about it.

Have you refused to accept a belief system they hold in common for which they have no evidence, but insisted on demanding evidence instead? If not, how is your example relevant?

Why?

Because I don't post threads making claims that I cannot back up with independent scientific evidence.

What makes you think that is the reason?

Take for instance Cosmic Yak's claim that if a newspaper publishes something untrue that another will attack it. He can not back this up with independent scientific evidence (in fact the evidence suggests this to be false) yet it is not he who is given a hard time about it, but me who is criticizing that claim.

Take for instance my claim that democracy doesn't exist. I backed this up with independent scientific evidence yet it is not Joey or ComfySlippers - who claimed otherwise - who is given a hard time about it, but me.

How does this lead you to the conclusion that "not being able to back something up with independent scientific evidence" is the basis for being given a hard time, rather than "challenging the orthodoxy of the in-group"?

These two examples are always the most revealing ones, because they are myths held by politically liberal groups, namely the myth of an objective media and of a democratic system of government.
 
Last edited:
You don't have to make unsupported claims to be disrespected here. Just questioning the ideas here or presenting a different opinion is enough for a person to receive insults or false accusations. Anything short of official proof is dismissed here due to the cognitive dissonance that's created by opposing evidence.
 
Last edited:
You don't have to make unsupported claims to be disrespected here. Just questioning the ideas here or presenting a different opinion is enough for a person to receive insults or false accusations. Anything short of official proof is dismissed here due to the cognitive dissonance that's created by opposing evidence.

There is no such thing as "official proof". What you're doing is obvious:


Pretend there is such a thing in science as "proof vs. evidence".

Redefine "proper evidence" (non-anecdotal) as "proof".

Redefine "evidence" as to incorporate anecdotes.

Therefore alien GMO sasquatch.
 
In any kind of research, findings are often made that support a certain theory or idea, but can't prove it conclusively. These sort of findings fall into the category of evidence rather than proof. The difference between evidence and proof is that proof is conclusive while evidence isn't. The denialists here deny evidence and ask for proof that's accepted by mainstream. On top of this, they have a double-standard where they think they can claim the non-existence of whatever they want while shifting the burden of proof.
 
You don't have to make unsupported claims to be disrespected here. Just questioning the ideas here or presenting a different opinion is enough for a person to receive insults or false accusations.

And certainly don't criticize the self-serving biases of their chosen authority figures, that really gets them going.
 
In any kind of research, findings are often made that support a certain theory or idea, but can't prove it conclusively. These sort of findings fall into the category of evidence rather than proof. The difference between evidence and proof is that proof is conclusive while evidence isn't. The denialists here deny evidence and ask for proof that's accepted by mainstream. On top of this, they have a double-standard where they think they can claim the non-existence of whatever they want while shifting the burden of proof.

Just what I said, then. Cool.
 
I claim there are invisible elves in my backyard. Please explain what evidence shows this claim is not true.
Not really applicable if the subject is double standards though. For some more double standards, see Joey's recent juggling with the burden of proof. If I make a claim then I have to provide evidence. If I question his claims then I must provide evidence which contradicts them.
Again, you simply twist the argument so you have something to say. This is literally all you are capable of doing and the only point is to (in vain) get you to see what you are doing. There is no evidence of invisible elves. But there is tons of evidence of open democracy, a free press, Putin being a lying, murderous scumbag, etc etc. You're simply not interested in it. Your confirmation bias is causing you to ignore evidence, then when people point to the evidence, you attack everything about their argument except for the evidence that they provide. Conspiracist recruitment is one long gaslighting operation and it has clearly permanently left it's mark on your mental style.
 
Quotes can be changed without changing their meaning. For instance: "If A then B" can be rewritten as "If not B then not A". That you have to jump on purely syntactic differences to purport "strawmen" shows your desperation quite clearly.

Firstly, it was decent of you to admit that you had changed my quote.
However, claiming it was a 'purely syntactic difference' is to pile misrepresentation (that the effect of the specific changes you made left the original meaning unchanged) upon misrepresentation (your misquoting me in the first place). Adding "whenever" to the quote broadened the scope of my claim beyond what I believe, beyond what I said, and beyond what is reasonable to believe.
My charge of desperation stems from my firm belief that you had to make that change in order to be able to make your point, and to continue your approach of avoiding the evidence and constantly moving the goalposts.
I claimed it happened. I posted evidence of this. You could either have accepted this, or you could have tried to wriggle out of it. It is to your shame that you chose the latter.
 
You have yet to provide actual evidence for a single one of your claims. I see you have trouble with the concept of evidence, so let me spell it out:

For your claim:

you must provide a statistically relevant sample of stories found in RT and PressTV and show that a significant fraction (which can be considered "many") is "obviously biased and laughably false."

For your claim:

you must provide a statistically relevant sample of stories in Western media which are "untrue, unevidenced or slavishly pro-government" and show that these stories have been attacked - on those grounds - in other media.

caveman1917 demands a "statistically relevant sample" as evidence. Single examples are not acceptable.

Not really applicable if the subject is double standards though. For some more double standards, see Joey's recent juggling with the burden of proof. If I make a claim then I have to provide evidence. If I question his claims then I must provide evidence which contradicts them.

caveman1917 lambasts double standards of evidence, and states he provides evidence for his claims.

Have you refused to accept a belief system they hold in common for which they have no evidence, but insisted on demanding evidence instead? If not, how is your example relevant?



What makes you think that is the reason?

Take for instance Cosmic Yak's claim that if a newspaper publishes something untrue that another will attack it. He can not back this up with independent scientific evidence (in fact the evidence suggests this to be false) yet it is not he who is given a hard time about it, but me who is criticizing that claim.

Take for instance my claim that democracy doesn't exist. I backed this up with independent scientific evidence
yet it is not Joey or ComfySlippers - who claimed otherwise - who is given a hard time about it, but me.

The claim made by caveman1917 is that "democracy does not exist". He has supported this claim with ONE study about ONE country.
How does this square with the previous demands for "statistically relevant" data?
The answer, of course, is that it does not.

How does this lead you to the conclusion that "not being able to back something up with independent scientific evidence" is the basis for being given a hard time, rather than "challenging the orthodoxy of the in-group"?

These two examples are always the most revealing ones, because they are myths held by politically liberal groups, namely the myth of an objective media and of a democratic system of government.
caveman1917 claims that it is politically liberal groups that believe in an objective press and a democratic style of government.
I must have missed the "statistically relevant" scientific study of liberal political groups around the world that was provided to support this claim.

caveman1917 claims to have disproved the "myth" of an objective media.
Am I alone in missing the other "statistically relevant" scientific evidence that was provided to support this claim?

It is this kind of approach that is so vexing, and that dogs these kinds of discussions. There is a blatant double standard of proof, coupled with an arrogance (the 'two brain cells' comment, and the other one about high school students are two examples, though, I hasten to add, possibly not "statistically relevant" ones. :D ) and an interest in point-scoring rather than progress. It is possible that caveman1917 is getting his jollies from this, but it is a pointless and hollow kind of pastime.
Yaks, however, are known for their determination, and so I will persevere.
 
In any kind of research, findings are often made that support a certain theory or idea, but can't prove it conclusively. These sort of findings fall into the category of evidence rather than proof. The difference between evidence and proof is that proof is conclusive while evidence isn't. The denialists here deny evidence and ask for proof that's accepted by mainstream. On top of this, they have a double-standard where they think they can claim the non-existence of whatever they want while shifting the burden of proof.

Kinda like the double standard of playing armchair psychologist on the Internet by diagnosing people with cognitive dissonance, as opposed to supporting your argument with facts you can back up.....you mean like that kinda double standard?
 
Aha, so this thread is at the moment not about bigfoot. How refreshing! Oh wait - it's devolved into a "skeptics are pooh-pooh heads" thread? Ugh.

Okay, we can test that assertion. Someone make a claim and we'll see how self-described skeptics respond. Will they respond with a constructive, objective evaluation of the merits of the claim or will they respond with subjective, fallacy-laden derision of the claimant?
 
Anyone reading this can easily determine that the truth is the other way around. I've provided evidence for each one of my claims, while the "skeptic community" has done nothing but present their worldview without one shred of evidence.
Wait - presumably you don't consider yourself part of the 'skeptic community', but who do you think is? are you suggesting that the individuals you've argued with in this thread are, or somehow represent, the 'skeptic community'?

Or is it just rhetorical hyperbole?
 
Again, you simply twist the argument so you have something to say.

There is no twisting, they are your literal words: "If you're questioning a claim, you have to explain what evidence shows this claim is not true". Don't like it? Learn to write properly.

There is no evidence of invisible elves. But there is tons of evidence of open democracy, a free press

Yet you persist in refusing to provide any.
 
Last edited:
Firstly, it was decent of you to admit that you had changed my quote.
However, claiming it was a 'purely syntactic difference' is to pile misrepresentation (that the effect of the specific changes you made left the original meaning unchanged) upon misrepresentation (your misquoting me in the first place). Adding "whenever" to the quote broadened the scope of my claim beyond what I believe, beyond what I said, and beyond what is reasonable to believe.
My charge of desperation stems from my firm belief that you had to make that change in order to be able to make your point, and to continue your approach of avoiding the evidence and constantly moving the goalposts.
I claimed it happened. I posted evidence of this. You could either have accepted this, or you could have tried to wriggle out of it. It is to your shame that you chose the latter.

Here is, yet again, your claim where I have added the highlights and parts in brackets:
if one publishes a story that is, for example, [A] untrue, unevidenced or [C] slavishly pro-government, [then] the papers and channels of other political persuasions [D] can, and [E] will, attack it.


A = "one publishes a story that is untrue"
B = "one publishes a story that is unevidenced"
C = "one publishes a story that is slavishly pro-government"
D = "the papers and channels of other political persuasions can attack it"
E = "the papers and channels of other political persuasions will attack it"

Formally, your quote: (A or B or C) => (D and E)
Define P: (A or B or C) => (D and E)
Define Q: (A or B or C) => E
P => Q
not Q => not P
not Q
therefor, not P

All I have to show is "not Q" to refute your original claim, and hence me changing your quote from P to Q in order to attack it is valid.

In fact I could reduce it a lot more, define R: A => E and do the same thing.

If what you wrote isn't what you mean, then please now write down what you actually do mean.
 
Last edited:
The claim made by caveman1917 is that "democracy does not exist". He has supported this claim with ONE study about ONE country.
How does this square with the previous demands for "statistically relevant" data?
The answer, of course, is that it does not.

Nonsense, the study I referenced is a statistical study. If it were not a statistical study it would merely look at one single government policy that was not supported by the population. If they did that their "evidence" would get equally derided as your "evidence" is.

Your evidence is not statistical, you look at one single example of newspapers disagreeing on something.

Do you understand what a statistical study is?

an interest in point-scoring rather than progress

More nonsense, I've already spelt out in detail the nature of the evidence you should provide for your claims to be accepted. Why do you persist in refusing to provide such evidence? The answer is: because you have none. In which case, why do you hold that belief in the first place? Divine revelation? Gut-feeling? Authority figure?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom