Then you'll note that a few of us engaged with the paper you linked and the definition you provided, and evaluated the claim. The disagreements (and snark) I saw seem to mostly relate to some earlier bickering.
True to some extent. The people who engaged with the evidence are you, Dave Rogers and Cosmic Yak.
Cosmic Yak acknowledged not being able to objectively evaluate the evidence for lack of prior knowledge, but did indeed make a good-faith attempt in providing a link to some objections. So I'm counting that as neutral, neither in "objective evaluation of the claims made" nor in "subjective, fallacy-laden derision of the claimant."
Dave Rogers engaged once with the claim in an incorrect way. I didn't catch the error back then but rather acquiesced to changing my claim. On the one hand me not being objective in my response doesn't make his evaluation objective, but on the other hand I fell for the error equally well as he did. So I'm going to count his contribution as 0.5 towards "objective evaluation of the claim."
The error made was that my claim "democracy doesn't exist" doesn't require evidence, since I'm asserting the null. It's "democracy exists" which requires evidence. I (and he) was conflating "democracy doesn't exist" with "elite-domination exists." These are in fact two separate claims, democracy is an alternative model to elite-domination, it may very well be that neither of those two models reflects reality. Cosmic Yak also went with this error after Dave Rogers and myself.
The disagreements (and snark) I saw seem to mostly relate to some earlier bickering.
Disagreement with a claim and evidence should be independent of "earlier bickering" (read: "earlier subjective, fallacy-laden derision of the claimant") hence I reject this excuse.
On the "subjective, fallacy-laden derision of the claimant" side we have Joey McGee, Cervelo, ComfySlippers, John Nowak, AlaskaBushPilot and novaphile.
It hence seems that the evidence supports the claim being tested. If someone who is considered a member of the "out-group" challenges a belief held by the "in-group", even if the in-group can not provide evidence for their belief and the claimant does provide evidence for his challenging of that belief, he or she should primarily expect "subjective, fallacy-laden derision" as a response. It does so even more when we count by number of posts rather than number of people.
Just dropping by to point out that at this moment, Donald J Trump is in the driver's seat to win the GOP Presidential nomination.
This has happened through the democratic process.
Democracy.
The GOP and the forces behind the GOP have been very public in their distaste for Trump, and the party machinery has been working hard to drive him out with no success.
The DNC has had the same problem with Bernie Sanders, and they've been even more ham-handed in their attempts to kick him out of the election.
These are the people who supposedly control everything, and right now they are in control of Jack ****.
Why? Democracy, that's why.
People are voting, people are turning their backs on the power structure, and the results should be on your screens tonight and the rest of the week. Real numbers too, not some silly psychotic theory, and all based on real people voting.
The election boils down to Clinton and Trump in the fall (weird to type this), and nothing is set in stone.
Nothing.
Edited by kmortis:
Edited to let the autocensor do its thing.
Do not mask swear words incompletely. Let the autocensor do its job.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic Posted By: kmortis
I might have missed someone calling out the fallacy that major media position = skeptic position.
OP calls for proof that skeptics, not the major media, are in some kind of lock-step with an official position. (Along with a list of other accusations leveled at skeptics.)
The majority of Americans do not trust the major media. Here's a long term tracking poll by Gallup for example:
It shows that as the deceptions over Iraq, including torture, were being peddled by mainstream media as per the Propaganda Model of Chomsky, trust in the press fell by 15 percentage points to its current 40%. It is at historic lows for good reason.
Skeptics aren't the media dupes in this sample. They're the ones demanding evidence in support of claims. Skeptics are not the people calling something torture today and tomorrow not. That's the mainstream media we don't trust doing it.
I followed the Guardian a lot during that time, Antiwar dot com, Juan Cole, lots of alternative media that called it aggressive war against Iraq. The supreme crime according to Nuremburg, let alone the torture, but that too. They tortured people to try linking Iraq to 9/11. It's incredible, really.
For a troll, just snaring people into your little web is power. It is a curiosity for me so I do have a morbid interest in it.
Just dropping by to point out that at this moment, Donald J Trump is in the driver's seat to win the GOP Presidential nomination.
This has happened through the democratic process.
Democracy.
The GOP and the forces behind the GOP have been very public in their distaste for Trump, and the party machinery has been working hard to drive him out with no success.
The DNC has had the same problem with Bernie Sanders, and they've been even more ham-handed in their attempts to kick him out of the election.
These are the people who supposedly control everything, and right now they are in control of Jack ****.
Why? Democracy, that's why.
People are voting, people are turning their backs on the power structure, and the results should be on your screens tonight and the rest of the week. Real numbers too, not some silly psychotic theory, and all based on real people voting.
The election boils down to Clinton and Trump in the fall (weird to type this), and nothing is set in stone.
Nothing.
Edited by kmortis:
Edited to let the autocensor do its thing.
Do not mask swear words incompletely. Let the autocensor do its job.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic Posted By: kmortis
If you did not understand the argument which was made then you could just say so. In fact a simplified version of the argument was provided
[*] which requires no knowledge of statistics. You should be able to tell that none of your statements above negate the argument. Given the highlight, I conclude now adding you as well to the "subjective, fallacy-laden derision of the claimant" group.
* "Let's assume the research is accurate and then model the political system based on that. People elect representatives, these representatives enact the policies requested by economic elites. So the people are limited in choosing who they want to represent elite interests, will it be Sanders or Trump or Clinton who gets to represent elite interests?"
This fallacy was not made. The OP asserted that major media attack each other if they publish stories which are untrue, unevidenced or slavishly pro-government. This assertion was challenged, based on the propaganda model and the research underlying it, and the reaction by the in-group to this challenge was observed. Nothing more and nothing less.
Wrong. You were stupid enough to claim a negative, and then found that you couldn't back it up because a negative can't be proven. But it's very amusing to see you try to explain why it's my fault, again, that you screwed up your claim.
This thread is such a whirlwind of word salad, it is an alternate reality.
After 15 pages now we haven't seen what OP asked for. There was a list of seven specific allegations made against skeptics routinely by gamers.
So the answer is no examples. But the thread goes on. I guess the acronym would be LAARGing. Remove bigfoot and make it more generalized. Woo-type Live Action Alternate Reality Gaming.
Quite. And it's not for want of trying. I have tried to steer the conversation back on-topic, but to no avail. Don't get me wrong- it's an interesting discussion, but one I think that perhaps should be continued elsewhere- split thread, maybe?
I invited caveman1917 here to provide evidence for my OP, so I should take some responsibility for what has happened.
Still, 16 pages in, and still no evidence of what I originally asked for. The idea as to put an end to the bickering that mars so many of the threads here, by examining the specific claims and the evidence for them. Can't say it's been an overwhelming success...
Still, I am ever optimistic. Either the evidence can be posted, or those making the accusations should simply admit there is none. This would constitute progress, and would help to foster debate rather than argument, point-scoring and name-calling. Which would be nice.
I have already provided evidence (actual evidence - not "the US government says so") for one example in which all major newspapers agreed to stop calling waterboarding torture when the US was doing it.
Quite. And it's not for want of trying. I have tried to steer the conversation back on-topic, but to no avail. Don't get me wrong- it's an interesting discussion, but one I think that perhaps should be continued elsewhere- split thread, maybe?
I invited caveman1917 here to provide evidence for my OP, so I should take some responsibility for what has happened.
Still, 16 pages in, and still no evidence of what I originally asked for. The idea as to put an end to the bickering that mars so many of the threads here, by examining the specific claims and the evidence for them. Can't say it's been an overwhelming success...
Still, I am ever optimistic. Either the evidence can be posted, or those making the accusations should simply admit there is none. This would constitute progress, and would help to foster debate rather than argument, point-scoring and name-calling. Which would be nice.
It has been interesting, regardless of the subject matter, Bigfoot, UFOs, "there is no democracy"....we see the same abhorrent, anti-social, disingenuous behavior displayed by the proponents of such unsubstantiated delusional thinking.
That may be true, but your link certainly doesn't support it. The only thing you might be referring to in that survey would be a "no true democracy" argument, which is obviously a "No True Scotsman" fallacy in the question asked.
Yes. As I said, that is a "no true Scotsman" fallacy. Nicht echte Demokratie. The respondents said that economic interests prevented "true" democracy. They at no point said, as you did, that democracy is not real.
The above exchange is just one of many that we can all see here. I too don't know why this behavior fascinates me. I try to ignore it but it pulls me back in.
On the "subjective, fallacy-laden derision of the claimant" side we have Joey McGee, Cervelo, ComfySlippers, John Nowak, AlaskaBushPilot and novaphile.
No, no. Truthseeking is like a game of badminton. When a claim-maker lobs something at you, you must diligently return it, since the burden of proof is now on you. Of course there's no net in this game, but it's not as if anyone can ever win anyway.
Given that this is your response to my answer to a question as to where my evidence could be found, forgive me for being critical of your claim to be a "good critical thinker."
The above exchange is just one of many that we can all see here. I too don't know why this behavior fascinates me. I try to ignore it but it pulls me back in.
Probably because you, at some level, realize the error in your argument. Just because a statement has the form "X is not a true Y" does not make it a "No True Scotsman" fallacy. If I show you a car body without internals, no engine, no transmission belt etc, and you say "that is not a true car" does that make your determination a fallacy? No, of course it doesn't. I'm concluding that you're just doing some sort of pattern recognition where any statement of the form "X is not a true Y" gets you to proclaim "aha, No True Scotsman fallacy!" This approach is utterly void of actual thinking.
Another error, negatives can sometimes be proven. The claim "democracy doesn't exist" could, for instance, be proven by showing that all governments in the scope under consideration are dictatorships.
But it's very amusing to see you try to explain why it's my fault, again, that you screwed up your claim.
Another error, negatives can sometimes be proven. The claim "democracy doesn't exist" could, for instance, be proven by showing that all governments in the scope under consideration are dictatorships.
Rather than be amused perhaps you should think instead.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.