Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

Wait - presumably you don't consider yourself part of the 'skeptic community', but who do you think is?

I don't consider myself part of this "skeptic community" nor would I consider myself part of any organized "skeptic community."

are you suggesting that the individuals you've argued with in this thread are, or somehow represent, the 'skeptic community'?

It's what they seem to be suggesting. They are using skepticism as a cover for asserting ideological belief systems.

Or is it just rhetorical hyperbole?

Partially perhaps.
 
Okay, we can test that assertion.

We are testing that assertion.

Will they respond with a constructive, objective evaluation of the merits of the claim or will they respond with subjective, fallacy-laden derision of the claimant?

Have you even read the thread?

Here is but one of the claims: "democracy doesn't exist." Define democracy, as per Oxford English Dictionary: "a system of government in which all the people of a state or polity ... are involved in making decisions about its affairs" Here is the evidence.

What is the response? Is it a constructive, objective evaluation of the merits of the claim or subjective, fallacy-laden derision of the claimant? They're just butthurt that their stupid ideology doesn't fit the evidence which makes it all the more obvious that they're just abusing the notion of skepticism for pushing ideological claims.
 
Last edited:
Here is but one of the claims: "democracy doesn't exist." Define democracy, as per Oxford English Dictionary: "a system of government in which all the people of a state or polity ... are involved in making decisions about its affairs" Here is the evidence.

Your evidence consists of a single analysis concluding that the USA is not a democratic, but either an economic elite dominated or a biased pluralistic, political system. To extend this conclusion, even if true, to a conclusion that "democracy doesn't exist" commits the logical fallacy of denying the antecedent. Spelling it out in detail:

P1: If the USA is democratic, then democracy exists.
P2: The USA is not democratic.
C: Therefore, democracy does not exist.

Without even evaluating your source, your claim is not supported by it.

Happy now?

Dave
 
Your evidence consists of a single analysis concluding that the USA is not a democratic, but either an economic elite dominated or a biased pluralistic, political system. To extend this conclusion, even if true, to a conclusion that "democracy doesn't exist" commits the logical fallacy of denying the antecedent. Spelling it out in detail:

P1: If the USA is democratic, then democracy exists.
P2: The USA is not democratic.
C: Therefore, democracy does not exist.

Without even evaluating your source, your claim is not supported by it.

Happy now?

Dave

Fine, "democracy in the USA doesn't exist". Happy now? Have you failed to notice that the claim was made in response to claims about the US being democratic?

Also, there is a shift in the burden of proof being made. It is the one who claims that a political system is democratic (or that the press is objective) who should provide evidence, not the other way around. Otherwise, I've got some invisible elves in my backyard.
 
Last edited:
Fine, "democracy in the USA doesn't exist". Happy now? Have you failed to notice that the claim was made in response to claims about the US being democratic?

It's not my fault if you can't state your own claim correctly, is it? So we have one study which claims that the USA is not democratic. At this point it would be appropriate to examine the validity of that study, and consider what other evidence exists.

Also, there is a shift in the burden of proof being made. It is the one who claims that a political system is democratic (or that the press is objective) who should provide evidence, not the other way around. Otherwise, I've got some invisible elves in my backyard.

Again, it's not my fault if you chose to mis-state your own claim.

Dave
 
Have you even read the thread?
No. I find the mercurial nature of this thread frustrating despite snippets of it that could be rather interesting. I check in every few days to see what it's about now. Today, it appears to be about skeptic pooh-pooh heads.

Here is but one of the claims: "democracy doesn't exist."
Political science claim as opposed to more typical paranormal stuff, but it's provocative and interesting. Let's go with it.

Define democracy, as per Oxford English Dictionary: "a system of government in which all the people of a state or polity ... are involved in making decisions about its affairs"

I wrote a couple of paragraphs about shortcomings with this definition leading to problems in interpretation before we even collect any data to evaluate the question. Then I realized that the OED wasn't being vague, you were. Here's a more complete version of the OED definition:

"Government by the people; esp. a system of government in which all the people of a state or polity (or, esp. formerly, a subset of them meeting particular conditions) are involved in making decisions about its affairs, typically by voting to elect representatives to a parliament or similar assembly; (more generally) a system of decision-making within an institution, organization, etc., in which all members have the right to take part or vote. In later use often more widely, with reference to the conditions characteristically obtaining under such a system: a form of society in which all citizens have equal rights, ignoring hereditary distinctions of class or rank, and the views of all are tolerated and respected; the principle of fair and equal treatment of everyone in a state, institution, organization, etc. Cf. majority rule n. at majority n.1 Compounds 2, people n. 3a, 3c."

There is, of course, an entire page of explanations, qualifications, etymology, etc. that is also relevant.


Here is the evidence.
Great - here's a scholarly article that makes the case that we don't have democracy (at least in the United States). Here's a line from the Abstract to summarize their case:

"Multivariate analysis indicates that economic elites and organized groups representing business interests have substantial independent impacts on U.S. government policy, while average citizens and mass-based interest groups have little or no independent influence."

The researchers found evidence in one study that some people have more influence over policy decision than others. Okay, but I don't see that as at odds with the OED definition.
 
Great - here's a scholarly article that makes the case that we don't have democracy (at least in the United States). Here's a line from the Abstract to summarize their case:

"Multivariate analysis indicates that economic elites and organized groups representing business interests have substantial independent impacts on U.S. government policy, while average citizens and mass-based interest groups have little or no independent influence."

The researchers found evidence in one study that some people have more influence over policy decision than others. Okay, but I don't see that as at odds with the OED definition.

Let's assume the research is accurate and then model the political system based on that. People elect representatives, these representatives enact the policies requested by economic elites. So the people are limited in choosing who they want to represent elite interests, will it be Sanders or Trump or Clinton who gets to represent elite interests? Do you consider such a political system a democracy? It's at odds with "all people are involved in making decisions about its affairs."

ETA: it's not just some people having more influence than others, it's a small group having all the (measurable) influence with the large majority having none at all (to the limits of measurement).
 
Last edited:
Fine, "democracy in the USA doesn't exist". Happy now? Have you failed to notice that the claim was made in response to claims about the US being democratic?

Also, there is a shift in the burden of proof being made. It is the one who claims that a political system is democratic (or that the press is objective) who should provide evidence, not the other way around. Otherwise, I've got some invisible elves in my backyard.

Actually, I hadn't noticed that. Perhaps you could point out the references to the US in your original posts?

In an evidence-based reality power corrupts, there is no free press and there is no democracy.



No thank you, I'll stick to evidence. I've found gut-feeling to be a lousy indicator of reality.



I'm sure it's nice in your "reality" but I'm not rejecting it for not being nice.

So is gut-feeling the totality of your skepticism or is there something else to add?

Have you refused to accept a belief system they hold in common for which they have no evidence, but insisted on demanding evidence instead? If not, how is your example relevant?

Take for instance my claim that democracy doesn't exist. I backed this up with independent scientific evidence yet it is not Joey or ComfySlippers - who claimed otherwise - who is given a hard time about it, but me.

How does this lead you to the conclusion that "not being able to back something up with independent scientific evidence" is the basis for being given a hard time, rather than "challenging the orthodoxy of the in-group"?

These two examples are always the most revealing ones, because they are myths held by politically liberal groups, namely the myth of an objective media and of a democratic system of government.

Seems to me you made a claim that democracy doesn't exist, and then changed it to a claim that democracy doesn't exist in the US. That is a quite different position. Hence my request for "statistically relevant" evidence. Not "statistically-based" evidence. There is a major difference there. You have only provided evidence for the US, which is not in any way statistically relevant, given that, by some standards at least, there are 123 democracies in the world, out of 192 countries.
Source: http://www.borgenmagazine.com/many-democratic-nations/

Even allowing you to redefine your original claim, there still remains the issue of the evidence you have provided to support this claim. I will admit I have not read the entirety of the report, but the summary and conclusions do not appear to match the conclusion you are claiming. For example, from the conclusion:
Americans do enjoy many features
central to democratic governance, such as regular elections,
freedom of speech and association, and a widespread
(if still contested) franchise. But we believe that if
policymaking is dominated by powerful business organizations
and a small number of affluent Americans, then
America’s claims to being a democratic society are seriously
threatened.
This is a long way from concluding that democracy does not exist in the US.
Moreover, this study is not, to my understanding, that solid at all. I am no statistician, I will freely admit, but there are objections to the methodology that I will not pretend to understand:
http://www.newyorker.com/news/john-cassidy/is-america-an-oligarchy

You are still, it seems to me, doing everything I asked you not to do: moving the goalposts, and applying a clear double standard of evidence. Add to that your continued insulting and confrontational approach, plus a marked tendency to avoid referring to any points or evidence that contradict your stated beliefs. Net result? You are provoking, or attempting to provoke, reactions in other posters, that are (perhaps understandably) less than kind, and then shouting this from the rooftops. That, to me, is classic troll behaviour. If you were actually serious about addressing the issues at hand, and trying to resolve our differences, you would be doing almost the opposite of this. I am still hopeful that you are not a troll, and wish to engage in a rational and honest conversation.
Do please prove me right, in this at least.
 
The stories in Western media and governments about Ukraine would be a prime example here, but it holds for about every geopolitical hotspot discussed in the politics section. The forum simply reflects the bias inherent in its primarily Western and liberal membership. This is heavily exacerbated by the usual "the conservatives are making flawed assumptions" argument which, by restricting attention to conservatives, induces a failure to challenge the assumptions held in common by both liberals and conservatives. See the next point for an example of such. This also holds for the failure to critically approach mainstream media narratives by pointing at Fox News whenever media bias comes up, again restricting attention to only Fox News and leading to a failure to critically approach the common assumptions underlying both Fox News and liberal mainstream media.

I have already told you where to find it, you are free to check it. You will easily see that unevidenced claims by Western governments/media are considered as a priori true, where evidence is required so as to not be considered true, whereas equally unevidenced claims by non-Western governments/media are considered as a priori false, where evidence is required so as to consider them true.

<snip for focus>

Why should I care about that? I came to this thread because you suggested in another thread to me that I should do so after I agreed with a statement by JihadJane saying "there is a strong irrational trust in mainstream authority evident on these pages."

I would like, at this stage, to link this back to my OP. caveman1917's original point was in response to my request, in another thread, for evidence of uncritical support for governments or other mainstream authority figures.
Looking back at the exchanges in the last few days, I think we may be in danger of losing our focus on the original topic. If I may be so bold, I would like to redirect a little.
In order to do this, I would like to ask caveman1917 to clarify his (?- I am assuming you are male. Correct me if I am wrong.) position on this. RT and Press TV are known to be owned and funded by their respective governments ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Press_TV , https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RT_(TV_network) ), and so constitute mainstream authority, in their own spheres of influence at least. Caveman, you appear to have been defending these two channels. What exactly is your position here? You have stated your belief that there is no objective media. Does this also apply to Press TV and RT? If so, why are you so resistant to criticism of their output? If not, why are you defending government-owned media channels, so far without criticism?
The reason I ask is that you were asked to provide evidence of "strong irrational trust in mainstream authority", and so far, it appears the only person doing that is you.
 
Have you refused to accept a belief system they hold in common for which they have no evidence, but insisted on demanding evidence instead? If not, how is your example relevant?

Because I'm an adult.

I went back to college at the age of 44 to take science classes (Oceanography, Marine Biology, Chemistry, Geology, and Environmental Science). Their "Belief System", better known as the Scientific Method, works...every time.

I know this to be true from the eradication of Small Pox, the elimination of Polio from North America and most of Europe, the atomic bomb, and the seven American flags fading to white on the surface of the moon. All of those things happened thanks to the scientific method.

My ideas about ghosts have evolved after all of that classroom and lab work. I don't see them as manifestations of the dead anymore, and instead view them as a psychotic malfunction induced by a combination of immediate environmental factors combined with belief. This is so much more interesting to me as it poses more fascinating questions about the mind, the brain, and the central nervous system.

Since I'm working within the "system" I will have access to smarter people who can help me with research. Also beats freezing my butt off.
 
Oh I get it, because lobbyists have too much power in Washington, democracy doesn't exist. Because big business owns most of the press, there is no free press. I see that this is literally the claim. So the question has to be asked, what does a truly democratic state look like? What does a truly free press look like? Because it's obvious that there is a bizzare either or argument being set up, the point isn't to demonstrate that there is no democracy and there is no free press, it's obvious that there is so at least some degree. No the point of saying these things is to get a foot in the door. Oh you admitted that democracy isn't perfect, the press isn't perfect, therefore, my worldview is a little bit true, hence I'm not such a useless crank after all!

Or did I miss something?
 
Actually, I hadn't noticed that. Perhaps you could point out the references to the US in your original posts?

You are correct. When ComfySlippers said "living in reality" I assumed he was from the US, but his location says he's from the UK.

Seems to me you made a claim that democracy doesn't exist, and then changed it to a claim that democracy doesn't exist in the US. That is a quite different position. Hence my request for "statistically relevant" evidence.

True, but you are missing the most important point. It's up to the people who claim that a system of government has a certain property (democratic) to provide evidence for their claim, not the other way around. That I do provide contradictory evidence does not negate this, it mostly just shows that one should not just belief any old claim one wants without evidence.

In fact, even on a global level the evidence is in my favour - namely none for the belief that democracy exists and some, concerning the US, that it doesn't.

This is a long way from concluding that democracy does not exist in the US.

It depends on your definition of democracy. Refer to my earlier statement:
caveman1917 said:
Let's assume the research is accurate and then model the political system based on that. People elect representatives, these representatives enact the policies requested by economic elites. So the people are limited in choosing who they want to represent elite interests, will it be Sanders or Trump or Clinton who gets to represent elite interests? Do you consider such a political system a democracy?

Cosmic Yak said:
Moreover, this study is not, to my understanding, that solid at all. I am no statistician, I will freely admit, but there are objections to the methodology that I will not pretend to understand:
http://www.newyorker.com/news/john-cassidy/is-america-an-oligarchy

I could respond to those objections but I'm not sure how much it would accomplish. Either way, those objections do not negate my statement above that I asked you to consider.

You are still, it seems to me, doing everything I asked you not to do: moving the goalposts, and applying a clear double standard of evidence.

This is false, it is you (collectively) who apply a double standard of evidence. Namely, no evidence required at all for your own belief (democracy) but even the smallest issue with evidence for a different belief (elite-domination) will get pounded upon.

Add to that your continued insulting and confrontational approach, plus a marked tendency to avoid referring to any points or evidence that contradict your stated beliefs.

I've yet to see evidence that contradicts my stated beliefs, all we have is unsupported claims. Can you reference some of that evidence?
 
You are correct. When ComfySlippers said "living in reality" I assumed he was from the US, but his location says he's from the UK.

Reality is reality everywhere and we all live in it.
The warped imaginary version you describe has a population of one.
 
I would like, at this stage, to link this back to my OP. caveman1917's original point was in response to my request, in another thread, for evidence of uncritical support for governments or other mainstream authority figures.

True.

In order to do this, I would like to ask caveman1917 to clarify his (?- I am assuming you are male. Correct me if I am wrong.) position on this.

I don't care for (binary) gender classifications.

RT and Press TV are known to be owned and funded by their respective governments ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Press_TV , https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RT_(TV_network) ), and so constitute mainstream authority, in their own spheres of influence at least. Caveman, you appear to have been defending these two channels.

Pointing out flawed evidence does not equate to "defending these two channels."

What exactly is your position here? You have stated your belief that there is no objective media. Does this also apply to Press TV and RT?

Of course it does, I'm not the one with double standards problems here.

If so, why are you so resistant to criticism of their output?

I am not resistant to criticism of their output, I'm resistant to double standards (criticism leveled only on those channels but not Western ones, even though it applies equally) and BS criticism in general.

If you remember, I gave you an explicit method by which you could criticize those - and any other - channels. May I suggest that rather than trying to get me to lower my standards of evidence, or accept your double standards, you simply provide such evidence instead or admit you have none? It would save us both a lot of time.

And no, some claim by a disgruntled, recently-demoted employee who organized a dramatic on-air exit with a neocon think-thank does not constitute evidence.

The reason I ask is that you were asked to provide evidence of "strong irrational trust in mainstream authority", and so far, it appears the only person doing that is you.

With this I simply have to stop taking you seriously. Here is one quote of someone showing "strong irrational trust in mainstream authority"
there's the fact that in the civilized word 99% of people in power and places of influence find your views to be insane

Care to quote me showing "strong irrational trust in mainstream authority"?
 
Last edited:
Sticking with my theme that your output is one long gaslighting attempt (as most conspiracist recruitment is) I'm simply pointing out that there is no risk of your views ever influencing policy or the minds of anyone in power, so people who find them insane and dangerous really have nothing to worry about, and are simply interested in debunking these delusions a) Because we feel sorry for the afflicted and b) they tend to successfully recruit the young and mentally feeble which bothers people... that's not what kids and people with mental problems need OK, radical, paranoid, infuriating beliefs about the world, so this is why people bother debating you otherwise, most of us wouldn't even be here. This is in your response to your rants about why we shill for the government and why we're scared to go down the rabbit hole, it's food for thought.
 
Last edited:
Everyone here knows you know what the arguments are that we live in a democracy

Finally admitting that you have no evidence but only (self-serving) narratives? That's unexpected. It's going to be a story about those white slave-owners, right? What do you call them, Founding Fathers or something?

We can't debate you on the subject unless we somehow accept your logical premises of the debate and define terms.

Since you made the claim, why didn't you define your terms then?
 
Finally admitting that you have no evidence but only (self-serving) narratives? That's unexpected. It's going to be a story about those white slave-owners, right? What do you call them, Founding Fathers or something?
No self-awareness at all! There we go with that "admitting" stuff again.

Do you really expect people to give you a grade-school explanation of why the United States is a democracy?

And do you really think that the fact that Thomas Jefferson owned slaves means that the United States isn't a democracy? And that's an argument?

Since you made the claim, why didn't you define your terms then?
No no no, how about you simply make a coherent point, and tell us what we should think about the world and why, instead of baiting people to say things which you then distort to your own twisted ends... Intellectual honesty is a real thing, with a real definition. You don't learn about it in grade school like we do democracy, but, most people know it when they see it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom