Fine, "democracy in the USA doesn't exist". Happy now? Have you failed to notice that the claim was made in response to claims about the US being democratic?
Also, there is a shift in the burden of proof being made. It is the one who claims that a political system is democratic (or that the press is objective) who should provide evidence, not the other way around. Otherwise, I've got some invisible elves in my backyard.
Actually, I hadn't noticed that. Perhaps you could point out the references to the US in your original posts?
In an evidence-based reality
power corrupts, there is
no free press and there is
no democracy.
No thank you, I'll stick to evidence. I've found gut-feeling to be a lousy indicator of reality.
I'm sure it's nice in your "reality" but I'm not rejecting it for not being nice.
So is gut-feeling the totality of your skepticism or is there something else to add?
Have you refused to accept a belief system they hold in common for which they have no evidence, but insisted on demanding evidence instead? If not, how is your example relevant?
Take for instance my claim that democracy doesn't exist. I backed this up with independent scientific evidence yet it is not Joey or ComfySlippers - who claimed otherwise - who is given a hard time about it, but me.
How does this lead you to the conclusion that "not being able to back something up with independent scientific evidence" is the basis for being given a hard time, rather than "challenging the orthodoxy of the in-group"?
These two examples are always the most revealing ones, because they are myths held by politically liberal groups, namely the myth of an objective media and of a democratic system of government.
Seems to me you made a claim that democracy doesn't exist, and then changed it to a claim that democracy doesn't exist in the US. That is a quite different position. Hence my request for "statistically relevant" evidence. Not "statistically-based" evidence. There is a major difference there. You have only provided evidence for the US, which is not in any way statistically relevant, given that, by some standards at least, there are 123 democracies in the world, out of 192 countries.
Source:
http://www.borgenmagazine.com/many-democratic-nations/
Even allowing you to redefine your original claim, there still remains the issue of the evidence you have provided to support this claim. I will admit I have not read the entirety of the report, but the summary and conclusions do not appear to match the conclusion you are claiming. For example, from the conclusion:
Americans do enjoy many features
central to democratic governance, such as regular elections,
freedom of speech and association, and a widespread
(if still contested) franchise. But we believe that if
policymaking is dominated by powerful business organizations
and a small number of affluent Americans, then
America’s claims to being a democratic society are seriously
threatened.
This is a long way from concluding that democracy does not exist in the US.
Moreover, this study is not, to my understanding, that solid at all. I am no statistician, I will freely admit, but there are objections to the methodology that I will not pretend to understand:
http://www.newyorker.com/news/john-cassidy/is-america-an-oligarchy
You are still, it seems to me, doing everything I asked you not to do: moving the goalposts, and applying a clear double standard of evidence. Add to that your continued insulting and confrontational approach, plus a marked tendency to avoid referring to any points or evidence that contradict your stated beliefs. Net result? You are provoking, or attempting to provoke, reactions in other posters, that are (perhaps understandably) less than kind, and then shouting this from the rooftops. That, to me, is classic troll behaviour. If you were actually serious about addressing the issues at hand, and trying to resolve our differences, you would be doing almost the opposite of this. I am still hopeful that you are not a troll, and wish to engage in a rational and honest conversation.
Do please prove me right, in this at least.