Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

People having no influence on government policy is not just "imperfect democracy" but no democracy at all, it's the basic meaning of the word.
You haven't provided evidence that "people have no evidence on government policy", wishful thinking, interpreting science to your own ends, cherry picking...

And that's an incorrect deduction, too bad, you had a streak going of one correct deduction. If everyone (including economic elites) is against something then it can and likely will get changed. You're also introducing terms which you fail to define, such as "major" or "corrupt."
Nonsense posturing...

But for something that might satisfy your request, perhaps you should look into taxing the rich. I think that is supported by a clear majority, could be considered a "major" issue and just never seems to get around to being changed.
So I think everyone will see that it's clear that you have now made the argument that because "taxing the rich never gets done" therefore the US is not a democracy. This is beyond stupid. You may not have noticed that the Republicans control the house and the senate. Do you honestly believe that Republican voters support taxing the rich? This is logically what you must believe for this to be true... Remember, we don't look at public polls, we look at what voters think. Republicans don't represent their voters, this is what you must believe in order to make this argument! Thank you for proving my point with literally the worst *********** example you could have possibly come up with!

True, if only that "other" were anything but your own strawman. You see, I don't hold that it's particularly "corrupt" - it just, as a political-economic system, does what it is constructed to do, nothing more and nothing less. The difference being that some people actually go out and test the narratives told to children about the "noble powerful people in government working for the good of all" instead of just believing them on faith.
More nonsense posturing. This is how you justify all of your conspiracy theories and stupid theories? That's like truthers telling us they're JAQ dude! You weasel in a conspiracy theory, that the system is designed to be fake democracy, therefore it's not corrupt... uhhh, how does that get you off the hook? Laughable.

Jefferson owned slaves! Your argument is invalid. :rolleyes:

Yours is, yes.
I know you are but what am I?
 
The people have no influence on government policy.
You have no evidence for this claim. You're twisting a study about how money has undue influence into that it has all the influence. Everyone realizes this is stupid but you.

Does that look convoluted to you?
Simply delusional. The arguments you use to get to "no influence" from "money influences politics" are so convoluted they're only possible for believers to rationalize as sane.

You also seem to keep forgetting that it's not up to me to disprove your claim that it's a democracy, it's up to you to prove it. You know, invisible elves and all that.
Again, you know just as well that that people vote in politicians and can vote them out at election time. Either they can't do this, or they can. Your request for evidence is dishonest. You must state what your problem is with the system or there is no debate and you're simply taking a **** on the chessboard.

If you hadn't noticed, I've already got actual evidence for my thesis while you're still stuck with a story you were told as a child in grade-school.
Yeah look, gaslighting me isn't going to work, I guess you're signalling to whoever you think is reading. You are the one who is in the minority, you are the one who has no power in society with these kinds of views, I have nothing to gain by winning this debate. Everyone I care about already agrees with me. You should consider that when trying to insult people... how you sound.

A little beyond you probably...
 
Last edited:
Maybe, maybe not. The authors begin their explanation with multiple caveats about how preliminary their work is and conclude in a similar vein that their one, provocative study is counter to much of the established research in this area.

I'm not convinced that they've adequately captured data that would indicate a majoritarian democracy should one actually exist. I think their description of the methods in characterizing the desires of "ordinary citizens" has been confounded by some kind of regression to a mean that does not exist. I'd need to dig a bit more to parse that out, however.

Sure, but there's a difference between considering the validity of a study and considering the consequences given the assumption that a study is accurate, we were doing the latter in that part of the debate. Hence why I said that your statement contradicted the agreed assumption, not that your statement is necessarily wrong.

I didn't see them stating that it is counter to much - if any - of the established research in this area. What they said is that there is a lot of research supporting all 4 models (perhaps a better term than "theoretical traditions"?) and they explain why this is true. Previous research looked at each model separately. For instance one study looking at the correlation between the median voter and policy, another looking at the correlation between elites and policy etc.

This research both subsumes previous research (if you restrict the findings to one direct correlation you retrieve previous research findings) and explains it. Namely previous research was seeing spurious correlations, because preferences for each of the 4 groups aren't independent. For instance there is a correlation between the median voter and policy, but only because there is a correlation between the median voter and economic elites. It is this that wasn't captured in previous studies, whose methodology couldn't capture this.

There's also the issue of low voter turnout leading to the election of individuals with far less than 50% of support of the electorate.

This doesn't explain the findings though.

Correct. It's an illustration that we should use more information than that contained in a single manuscript to weigh in on a big question like "is democracy dead?"

More like "has it ever been alive"? You're using the implicit assumption of democracy, even though that is itself a claim which requires its own evidence. To me the number of manuscripts isn't particularly important, but the size of the dataset and the methodology used. After all, they could've split up their dataset and wrote two manuscripts, it would still boil down to the same thing.

Anyway, thank you for there apparently being at least one person who will seriously discuss and evaluate evidence.
 
Last edited:
Okay, we can test that assertion. Someone make a claim and we'll see how self-described skeptics respond. Will they respond with a constructive, objective evaluation of the merits of the claim or will they respond with subjective, fallacy-laden derision of the claimant?

Other than yourself, how's the test working out so far?
 
Tax increases on the wealthy under Obama... while it will never be enough for some people, and isn't enough for his supporters and probably him on some level, it happened.

http://money.cnn.com/2015/01/30/pf/taxes/obama-taxes-rich/

It's also a horrible example because it's horribly vague. Uh, how much on which brackets? On income? Capital gains? What do voters support that their representatives are not working on?

So, you cannot make the argument that there hasn't been any tax the rich policies... Hilary is campaigning on tax increases on the super-rich... I look forward to you holding her to those proposals after she handily wins the election.
 
Last edited:
You are correct. When ComfySlippers said "living in reality" I assumed he was from the US, but his location says he's from the UK.



True, but you are missing the most important point. It's up to the people who claim that a system of government has a certain property (democratic) to provide evidence for their claim, not the other way around. That I do provide contradictory evidence does not negate this, it mostly just shows that one should not just belief any old claim one wants without evidence.

In fact, even on a global level the evidence is in my favour - namely none for the belief that democracy exists and some, concerning the US, that it doesn't.



It depends on your definition of democracy. Refer to my earlier statement:




I could respond to those objections but I'm not sure how much it would accomplish. Either way, those objections do not negate my statement above that I asked you to consider.



This is false, it is you (collectively) who apply a double standard of evidence. Namely, no evidence required at all for your own belief (democracy) but even the smallest issue with evidence for a different belief (elite-domination) will get pounded upon.



I've yet to see evidence that contradicts my stated beliefs, all we have is unsupported claims. Can you reference some of that evidence?

Humm.... ask for evidence, ignore all evidence presented, claim no evidence was presented, ask for evidence.

Looks like a recursive loop.
 
Democracy is government by the people. The people have no influence on government policy. Ergo, it is not a democracy.

Does that look convoluted to you?

Nah...just looks like a pile of bull ****, that as usual you can't back up with anything but your ingnorant opinion ;)
 
Last edited:
Other than yourself, how's the test working out so far?
Tough to gauge with people who've already been on this carousel with you earlier in the thread, but I'm seeing a pattern something like this:

~4 objective, constructive responses in addition to my own that addressed the claim and the evidence, snark-free

~7 snarky responses, including 3 accusations of trolling for which the posters provided evidence on which they based their claim

~6 snarky responses from you, either returning snark for snark, or like some of the other posters, replying with indignation toward people who pissed you off somewhere upthread
 
Humm.... ask for evidence, ignore all evidence presented, claim no evidence was presented, ask for evidence.

Looks like a recursive loop.

Don't present evidence, claim evidence was presented, don't present evidence, claim evidence was presented, ...

A recursive loop indeed.

You could easily break that loop by actually presenting that evidence. Cue silence, some more irrelevant stuff, and then another repetition of the loop.
 
Last edited:
Tough to gauge with people who've already been on this carousel with you earlier in the thread, but I'm seeing a pattern something like this:

~4 objective, constructive responses in addition to my own that addressed the claim and the evidence, snark-free

~7 snarky responses, including 3 accusations of trolling for which the posters provided evidence on which they based their claim

~6 snarky responses from you, either returning snark for snark, or like some of the other posters, replying with indignation toward people who pissed you off somewhere upthread

That wasn't the test. The test was "objective evaluation of the claims made" versus "subjective, fallacy-laden derision of the claimant." Snark isn't what we're considering in this test. Also, could you provide actual links to posts you consider in these categories?
 
Last edited:
Nah...just looks like a pile of bull ****

It's not my problem that elementary logic looks like a pile of bull **** to you.

that as usual you can't back up with anything but your ingnorant opinion ;)

Democracy is government by the people.

Democracy is further defined as ( a: ) "government by the people; especially : rule of the majority

The people have no influence on government policy.

the preferences of the average American appear to have only a minuscule, near-zero, statistically non-significant impact upon public policy.
 
Last edited:
^^^^
Yawn...all the same ole same ole...malarkey supporting your worldview...your certainly free to hold whatever distorted opinion/worldview of your choice.
 
Quoting from the link:


Yes. As I said, that is a "no true Scotsman" fallacy. Nicht echte Demokratie. The respondents said that economic interests prevented "true" democracy. They at no point said, as you did, that democracy is not real.
 
Last edited:
Thanks to Gawdzilla who shared this in another thread
Originally Posted by Pyrrho
http://www.psypost.org/2016/02/narcissism-and-low-self-esteem-predict-conspiracy-beliefs-41253

Quote:
Individuals who hold strong beliefs in conspiracies often also score high in narcissism and low in self-esteem, according to 2015 research.

The series of studies, published in Social Psychological and Personality Science, examined individuals to determine whether self-evaluation plays a role in predicting conspiracy beliefs.

“Previous research linked the endorsement of conspiracy theories to low self-esteem,” said Aleksandra Cichocka, principal investigator and corresponding author of the study.

“We propose that conspiracy theories should rather be appealing to individuals with exaggerated feelings of self-love, such as narcissists, due to their paranoid tendencies,” she continued.
The abstract:

http://spp.sagepub.com/content/7/2/157.abstract

Does Self-Love or Self-Hate Predict Conspiracy Beliefs? Narcissism, Self-Esteem, and the Endorsement of Conspiracy Theories
 
This thread is such a whirlwind of word salad, it is an alternate reality.

After 15 pages now we haven't seen what OP asked for. There was a list of seven specific allegations made against skeptics routinely by gamers.

So the answer is no examples. But the thread goes on. I guess the acronym would be LAARGing. Remove bigfoot and make it more generalized. Woo-type Live Action Alternate Reality Gaming.
 
Dear Caveman,

You said I was right, should be areas where public opinion disagrees with policy made and nothing being done. I asked for three examples. Your first one tanked horribly and you've stopped replying which means I've won the debate or perhaps you're trawling the internet looking for a thinktank study to prove reality wrong. I just want to remind you that you have 2 more chances, two more examples. 2 out of 3 ain't bad!

Good luck,

Joey
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom