Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

I believe it's commonly known as "living in reality".

I'll count that as gut-feeling.

In an evidence-based reality power corrupts, there is no free press and there is no democracy.

You should visit sometime.

No thank you, I'll stick to evidence. I've found gut-feeling to be a lousy indicator of reality.

It's nice here without the imaginary baddies.

I'm sure it's nice in your "reality" but I'm not rejecting it for not being nice.

So is gut-feeling the totality of your skepticism or is there something else to add?
 
Last edited:
But apparently there's no reason to respond to these demands if the other side in the argument doesn't...

I always present evidence for my claims when asked for. Feel free to point out otherwise. See for instance the post above in which I've directly referenced 2 studies and one wikipedia article which in turn references a whole bunch of studies.

...yet that's not an ad hominem tu quoque fallacy. Riiiiiight.

Do you get some kind of perverse pleasure out of making yourself look such a hypocrite?

I'm the hypocrite for not adopting double standards?
 
Last edited:
...yet that's not an ad hominem tu quoque fallacy. Riiiiiight.

It would be a tu quoque if I called Cervelo "willfully ignorant" or "trolling" or "disingenuous." But that's not what I did, what I did was apply the same standards used for the "in-group" to the "out-group" as well.
 
I'll count that as gut-feeling.

In an evidence-based reality power corrupts, there is no free press and there is no democracy.



No thank you, I'll stick to evidence. I've found gut-feeling to be a lousy indicator of reality.



I'm sure it's nice in your "reality" but I'm not rejecting it for not being nice.

So is gut-feeling the totality of your skepticism or is there something else to add?

Yes. The irony is awesome. Great links.
 
People make claims. Evidence is asked and counter-evidence is provided. No such evidence is ever forthcoming, so they'll just switch to claiming that you're "willfully ignorant." If these claims are not based on evidence, then what are they based on? Divine revelation? Gut-feeling? Some authority figure?

Bubba and OntarioSquatch, by the standards displayed here you can now simply claim that your critics hold "willfully ignorant positions" regarding whatever assertions you wish to make - and remember, there is no need for any sort of evidence for your claims. When they ask for it just claim they are "disingenuous" and "trolling."

Are you really that ignorant?

 
Last edited:
You might not have noticed, but this venue is advertised as a skeptic community.
The "skeptical community" doesn't owe you an explanation of reality. This is something you must take responsibility for yourself. You're begging people to hold your hand, everyone knows you're asking for something you can make strawmen out of. It's your only tactic. You do not engage with facts, you're an emotional reasoner, no one can have a normal conversation with you, you're not rational.

So where did you get the following beliefs:

1. People in power are likely right about what they claim
The people in academia have the highest possibility of being right because there is peer-review, there is open access, there is a tradition of responding to critiques, and people questioning each other, and these people all get paid a lot of money to be consistent and honest, and every graduate student is highly motivated to debunk any claim in any field as such an achievement would guarantee them upward momentum. This environment is why science is so successful. Something close to the same environment exists in politics, except for the fact that the electorate are highly delusional and irrational on average so we have the risk of demagogues and cranks, but on balance, there is a good chance that the people who end up in power will be pretty smart. So this is the most parsimonious explanation for why so many "smart, skeptical, educated" end up supporting and agreeing with them. The logic I have just explained is so obvious it's amazing I have to say it. You must convince everyone that the reason that so many people support Obama is because we're all sheep, amazed by power and prestiege, wanting someone to take care of us... you must convince us that all of these institutions are corrupt. You're basically the Rupert Sheldrake of politics and just as much as a joke.

I might have to spell this out for you... I'm not saying that we can trust the government because of these cultural factors making them likely to be right. I'm saying we come up with our own reasons and evidence when supporting them and the reason so many people agree is the same reason so many people agree on any other thing, it's based on reason and facts and overcoming bias through open debate and sharing information.
2. There is a "free press"
Anyone can start a blog and do their own reporting. No blogs have ever been taken down in America for anti-government speech. The New York Times prints classified details and stays open for business. Yes, there is free press.
3. There is "democracy"
What do you have here, electronic voting machines? Brainwashing ray guns from space?

Is it divine revelation? Gut-feeling? Some authority figure told you so? We already know that we can exclude evidence as a basis, so what would it be?
Talking to such believers is indeed like talking to bigfoot believers. No one knows why we do it. You don't have any evidence, you don't have a narrative with evidence to counter the worldview that you say is insane, why would anyone give you the time of day? I think if we all admit it it's because we feel sorry for you and want to help. Or at least prevent other people from being sucked into the conspiracist cult.
 
Last edited:
The "skeptical community" doesn't owe you an explanation of reality.

Your self-declared "skeptical community" is exempt from providing evidence for its claims? Well, that says enough about the fraudulent nature of that which you try to pass off as a "skeptical community." It's amazing how you're allowed to just keep up this charade.

Other than that, "that which can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence" so, as always, every single one of your claims can just be dismissed.

I'm still interested as to why you hold those beliefs. Divine revelation? Gut-feeling? Authority figure? We already have one person going by gut-feeling, but with you - with such a weakness for people in powerful positions - I'm guessing it'll be "authority figure."

You do not engage with facts, you're an emotional reasoner, no one can have a normal conversation with you, you're not rational.

Rather it's because I am rational and because you don't have any facts that you can't have a "normal conversation" with me.
 
Last edited:
As always, you simply twist everything anything anyone says to your own purposes. Totally pointless. You essentially want to be shown why your claims aren't true, but first, you have to make coherent point, and provide evidence. If you're questioning a claim, you have to explain what evidence shows this claim is not true, not troll people into trying to explain things which you just twist and distort anyways. You have it backwards. lol no wonder you don't like the "skeptic community"
 
Last edited:
As always, you simply twist everything anything anyone says to your own purposes. Totally pointless. You essentially want to be shown why your claims aren't true, but first, you have to make coherent point, and provide evidence. If you're questioning a claim, you have to explain what evidence shows this claim is not true, not troll people into trying to explain things which you just twist and distort anyways. You have it backwards. lol no wonder you don't like the "skeptic community"


It's funny though. It's like watching a teenager who's just discovered they can argue about anything and everything even though there's nothing to actually argue about.

Thankfully they grow up eventually. Usually.
 
Pretty much. Until then it's like playing chess with pigeons. ;)

"Debating creationists on the topic of evolution is rather like trying to play chess with a pigeon; it knocks the pieces over, craps on the board, and flies back to its flock to claim victory."

-Some guy on the internet
 
Last edited:
Let's take a look:


Does "not being allowed to discuss a subject in a show" and "alleging anti-Semitism" equate to

?

No it doesn't. So again, provide evidence for your claim.

Wow. You really should stop embarrassing yourself. It is, I think, obvious to anyone reading this that you are unwilling to engage in honest debate. This kind of desperation does you no credit at all.

Completely false it is.

Newspaper A: "Iraq has WMD's"
Newspaper B: "Iraq has WMD's"
Newspaper C: "Iraq has WMD's"

Cosmic Yak: Whenever one newspaper publishes something untrue, unevidenced or slavishly pro-government another will attack it

You really are quite shameless, aren't you?
This is what I actually said:
Cosmic Yak said:
if one publishes a story that is, for example, untrue, unevidenced or slavishly pro-government, the papers and channels of other political persuasions can, and will, attack it.

I asked you to kindly stop shifting the goalposts, and you come back with this. Changing my quote to make it fit your argument is very naughty indeed. Surely you know this? Did you really not think that I might go back and check my original quote?
Thus, strawman and not worthy of any more comment.

Me: Evidence?

Cosmic Yak: Look, there is something they disagreed on.



No, that would be you. You've changed your claim from "if A then B" to "at least once A and B"

Still utterly without shame, given your deliberate changing of my quote.


Yes they would. If you don't grasp the concept of evidence, even after I already spelled it out, then just say so.

It is of course not surprising that you'd try to use this particular sleigh-of-hand, it is the same one used by the "local uber-skeptic" in response to a similar accusation of group-think on this forum.

This is coming dangerously close to trolling. I did say before that I would not engage in silly point-scoring games. I started this thread with the best of motives: to attempt to clear the air, once and for all, over the multiple accusations levelled at forum members. I am still hoping this will happen, but your approach is not conducive to such a goal. I value communication over confrontation: I suggest you try the same.

BTW, is "sleigh-of-hand" how Santa moves invisibly around the world on Christmas Eve? :D

How's that for a bit of non-productive point-scoring, caveman1917? If you don't like it, don't dish it out. Just saying.
 
I can see why some may feel disillusioned with this debate, so I want to re-assure you that it is useful.

I've read this thread from beginning to end, and really appreciate the effort that many have taken to calmly, rationally address the noise, and tactics of the trolls.

(Please forgive me if this post is less than lucid, as I've had a couple of glasses of wine while reading the thread, so I may be less than at my best.)

In recent times, I've noticed an alarming trend of the trolls to use technical terms like Ad Hominem or group think, or Cognitive Dissonance in ways that are somewhat devoid of understanding of these concepts or the applicability of these concepts to the matter at hand.

Similarly, I see the formal fallacy of reasoning "appeal to (irrelevant) authority" being used to bully people to silence, when they are in fact referring/deferring to relevant authority.

I, personally, really appreciate your efforts to prevent these tactics being used to derail conversations which may otherwise lead people to greater understanding of the things that are going on around them.

Thank you.
 
So I should've just dismissed Joey's, Cosmic Yak's and others' claims rather than bothered providing contradictory evidence?

Heck ya...just as with OS you've done nothing but present your worldview and embarrassingly maligned interpetation of words and concepts. Which are so poorly presented wordsalads, one can only conclude its intentional or your in desperate need of some help....so which is it?
 
I can see why some may feel disillusioned with this debate, so I want to re-assure you that it is useful.

I've read this thread from beginning to end, and really appreciate the effort that many have taken to calmly, rationally address the noise, and tactics of the trolls.

(Please forgive me if this post is less than lucid, as I've had a couple of glasses of wine while reading the thread, so I may be less than at my best.)

In recent times, I've noticed an alarming trend of the trolls to use technical terms like Ad Hominem or group think, or Cognitive Dissonance in ways that are somewhat devoid of understanding of these concepts or the applicability of these concepts to the matter at hand.

Similarly, I see the formal fallacy of reasoning "appeal to (irrelevant) authority" being used to bully people to silence, when they are in fact referring/deferring to relevant authority.

I, personally, really appreciate your efforts to prevent these tactics being used to derail conversations which may otherwise lead people to greater understanding of the things that are going on around them.

Thank you.

Unfortunately all your seeing is sincere people attempting to educate someone, until they realize its just a troll they're dealing with...then it just becomes a tit for tat game played out on a very small stage of the trolls mind.
All the while the sincere poster attempts to make valid points while trying to remain within the rules....since apparently ISF is a haven for trolls...shocking I know.
Let the party countinue!!!
 
Wow. You really should stop embarrassing yourself. It is, I think, obvious to anyone reading this that you are unwilling to engage in honest debate. This kind of desperation does you no credit at all.

The desperation is all yours. Anyone with two brain cells can see that this

Journalist Mark Levine says that he was promised editorial control of his show, The American Dream. However, in September 2007, when Levine decided to broadcast a show on Ahmadinejad's UN visit that included noted Persian scholars who had expressed criticism of Ahmadinejad, he alleges that he was blocked from doing the program at the last minute: "One hour before the show was scheduled to air live, the show was cancelled with no explanation given. I was later told that Press TV would not allow me to discuss the topic." Shortly after that, Levine was fired from his job.[58][third-party source needed] Levine alleged that anti-Semitism also may have played a role in his firing: "I also believed my being Jewish may have played a role in the firing, given the shock, surprise, and horror manifested by the producer who hired me when she discovered my religious faith."

is not evidence of this

Journalists from those companies have complained about having to publish government propaganda they know is untrue

Changing my quote to make it fit your argument is very naughty indeed.

The quote has the same meaning as what I stated. "If A then B" is the same as "Whenever A then B."

Let's take a look at your claim
if one publishes a story that is, for example, untrue, unevidenced or slavishly pro-government, the papers and channels of other political persuasions can, and will, attack it.
and your evidence

Formally, your claim: "If A then B" and your evidence "example of (A and B)"

Another instantiation of this form:
Claim: If a natural number is odd then it is prime.
Evidence: the number 7

Basic logic fail. A high-school kid could figure this out.

Still utterly without shame, given your deliberate changing of my quote.

Quotes can be changed without changing their meaning. For instance: "If A then B" can be rewritten as "If not B then not A". That you have to jump on purely syntactic differences to purport "strawmen" shows your desperation quite clearly.
 
Last edited:
Heck ya...just as with OS you've done nothing but present your worldview

Anyone reading this can easily determine that the truth is the other way around. I've provided evidence for each one of my claims, while the "skeptic community" has done nothing but present their worldview without one shred of evidence.
 
Which is, in fact, part of the definition of ad hominem tu quoque; "It's OK for me to do this because my opponent does it too."

Dave

Not really applicable if the subject is double standards though. For some more double standards, see Joey's recent juggling with the burden of proof. If I make a claim then I have to provide evidence. If I question his claims then I must provide evidence which contradicts them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom