Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

There are numerous examples of this in both the links. The fact that you appear not to have read them speaks volumes.
Nick Ferrari,Hassan Abdulrahman and Mark Levine from Press TV.
William Dunbar, Liz Wahl and Stacy Bivens, from Russia Today.
All these names are copied from the two links. It would help the strength of your argument if you spoke from a position of knowledge rather than a lack thereof.

Let's take a look:
wiki said:
Journalist Mark Levine says that he was promised editorial control of his show, The American Dream. However, in September 2007, when Levine decided to broadcast a show on Ahmadinejad's UN visit that included noted Persian scholars who had expressed criticism of Ahmadinejad, he alleges that he was blocked from doing the program at the last minute: "One hour before the show was scheduled to air live, the show was cancelled with no explanation given. I was later told that Press TV would not allow me to discuss the topic." Shortly after that, Levine was fired from his job.[58][third-party source needed] Levine alleged that anti-Semitism also may have played a role in his firing: "I also believed my being Jewish may have played a role in the firing, given the shock, surprise, and horror manifested by the producer who hired me when she discovered my religious faith."

Does "not being allowed to discuss a subject in a show" and "alleging anti-Semitism" equate to
Cosmic Yak said:
Journalists from those companies have complained about having to publish government propaganda they know is untrue
?

No it doesn't. So again, provide evidence for your claim.
 
The willful ignorance on display is truly breathtaking. People literally want to believe that you work for the Russians, because no one wants to believe it's possible to remain this willfully ignorant of the facts.

http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2014/03/liz-wahl-quit-russia-today-putins-pawn-104888

He asked me why I did it, as though I had some reason other than the one I had just announced on live TV. I explained that it really was because of the propaganda RT was pushing about Ukraine.

So, please, tell us, Did Liz Wahl quit Russia Today live on air because she wanted to be popular like Russia Today said she did? Or maybe, just maybe, she was telling the truth?

The last few pages of this thread were so painful...
 
Not false at all.

Completely false it is.

Newspaper A: "Iraq has WMD's"
Newspaper B: "Iraq has WMD's"
Newspaper C: "Iraq has WMD's"

Cosmic Yak: Whenever one newspaper publishes something untrue, unevidenced or slavishly pro-government another will attack it

Me: Evidence?

Cosmic Yak: Look, there is something they disagreed on.

You have merely shifted the goalposts.

No, that would be you. You've changed your claim from "if A then B" to "at least once A and B"

Some might call this desperation.

Yes they would. If you don't grasp the concept of evidence, even after I already spelled it out, then just say so.

It is of course not surprising that you'd try to use this particular sleigh-of-hand, it is the same one used by the "local uber-skeptic" in response to a similar accusation of group-think on this forum.
 
People literally want to believe that you work for the Russians

Your paranoid delusions are quite telling for your CT mindset.

So, please, tell us, Did Liz Wahl quit Russia Today live on air because she wanted to be popular like Russia Today said she did? Or maybe, just maybe, she was telling the truth?

Ah, the Foreign Policy Institute (successor to the "Project for a New American Century") stunt, it was quite entertaining indeed. Maybe you haven't noticed, but we're not evaluating the truth of these claims but merely that such claims have been made. If you want to claim that the assertion is true, well, I tend to be skeptical of these sort of organized stunts by organizations such as the Foreign Policy Institute. Anyway, now go find an example of PressTV.
 
No, I actually just believe that you're genuinely that willfully ignorant. However, people would truly rather believe that than to accept it's possible to be that willfully ignorant. Did that joke really go right over your head like that? At no point did I say I believe you're a paid shill. But, I think it's been funny that you've obviously been waiting to throw the accusation of being a delusional, paranoid conspiracy theorist back in the face of someone for a long time.

There's a conspiracy theory about her quitting, it was a stunt! That's priceless! Of course! I mean, I figured that it would just be handwaved away as an unstable woman (as RT did) but no... it was a serious enough episode a believable narrative had to be crafted that it was "from the top"...

Enjoy the fantasies! I certainly find it all very funny.
 
Enjoy the fantasies!

Here is the twitter feed from your neocon think-thank counting down to the live-air resignation:
https://twitter.com/ForeignPolicyI/status/441334090298437634
https://twitter.com/ForeignPolicyI/status/441336436235587584
https://twitter.com/ForeignPolicyI/status/441338530875179009

They really should learn the difference between private tweets to only their contacts and public tweets which can be seen by everyone.

And here is Liz Wahl and Jamie Kirchik (of the Foreign Policy Initiative) celebrating their stunt a couple of hours later.
 
Last edited:
So true....and we have the same behavior fully on display in this thread..same game...different gamer ;)

If the responses in this thread are representative of your "organized skeptical community" then it should be classified as a fraud. Excluding, based on this thread, Garrette and one or two others who have indeed argued rationally and evidence-based, even if we disagreed on things.
 
Last edited:
Here is the twitter feed from your neocon think-thank counting down to the live-air resignation:
https://twitter.com/ForeignPolicyI/status/441334090298437634
https://twitter.com/ForeignPolicyI/status/441336436235587584
https://twitter.com/ForeignPolicyI/status/441338530875179009

They really should learn the difference between private tweets to only their contacts and public tweets which can be seen by everyone.

And here is Liz Wahl and Jamie Kirchik (of the Foreign Policy Initiative) celebrating their stunt a couple of hours later.
This is your evidence that she didn't actually think what she said and it's all a stunt orchestrated by the neocon establishment? Why would they be tweeting that then? Most incompetent hoaxers ever! That's hilarious. Well, it's all right with everyone else but you. Putin could shoot a guy in front of the Kremlin and you'd still vote for him! ;)
 
If the responses in this thread are representative of your "organized skeptical community" then it should be classified as a fraud. Excluding, based on this thread, Garrette and one or two others who have indeed argued rationally and evidence-based, even if we disagreed on things.
Well there's the skeptical community, and then there's the fact that in the civilized word 99% of people in power and places of influence find your views to be insane. So, I'm feeling in pretty good company, not a lot to defend against here. Debating crank theories is just a sick hobby.
 
If the responses in this thread are representative of your "organized skeptical community" then it should be classified as a fraud. Excluding, based on this thread, Garrette and one or two others who have indeed argued rationally and evidence-based, even if we disagreed on things.

Yup it's a shame seeing them waste their time with either disingenuous or willfully ignorant positions. But it is entertaining watching some people embarrass themselves on a regular basis ;)
 
Well there's the skeptical community

One wonders where though, other than the odd individual it doesn't seem to be around here anywhere.

and then there's the fact that in the civilized word 99% of people in power and places of influence find your views to be insane.

Joey you're not supposed to be so open about only being here to mouthpiece for people in power. The crowd might figure it out.
 
Last edited:
Yup it's a shame seeing them waste their time with either disingenuous or willfully ignorant positions.

People make claims. Evidence is asked and counter-evidence is provided. No such evidence is ever forthcoming, so they'll just switch to claiming that you're "willfully ignorant." If these claims are not based on evidence, then what are they based on? Divine revelation? Gut-feeling? Some authority figure?

Bubba and OntarioSquatch, by the standards displayed here you can now simply claim that your critics hold "willfully ignorant positions" regarding whatever assertions you wish to make - and remember, there is no need for any sort of evidence for your claims. When they ask for it just claim they are "disingenuous" and "trolling."
 
Last edited:
One wonders where though, other than the odd individual it doesn't seem to be around here anywhere.
lol, so are they the people out to get you? The skeptic community that stalks you everywhere you post?
Joey you're not supposed to be so open about only being here to mouthpiece for people in power. The crowd might figure it out.
I just happen to agree with them on matters of great importance. The chances of them being right about things is high because of the free press, democracy, and open academia, all things you believe are inherently corrupt.

It must suck living in such a dark, imaginary world.
 
Bubba and OntarioSquatch, by the standards displayed here you can now simply claim that your critics hold "willfully ignorant positions" regarding whatever assertions you wish to make - and remember, there is no need for any sort of evidence for your claims. When they ask for it just claim they are "disingenuous" and "trolling."

That would be the ad hominem tu quoque fallacy, right?

Dave
 
lol, so are they the people out to get you? The skeptic community that stalks you everywhere you post?

You might not have noticed, but this venue is advertised as a skeptic community.

I just happen to agree with them on matters of great importance. The chances of them being right about things is high because of the free press, democracy, and open academia, all things you believe are inherently corrupt.

So where did you get the following beliefs:

1. People in power are likely right about what they claim
2. There is a "free press"
3. There is "democracy"

Is it divine revelation? Gut-feeling? Some authority figure told you so? We already know that we can exclude evidence as a basis, so what would it be?
 
Last edited:
I'd suggest, "Maybe the problem isn't with the rest of the world. Maybe there is something wrong with me."

There is nothing wrong with demanding evidence before adopting beliefs. And, frankly, I don't care what the rest of the world thinks of that.
 
Last edited:
So where did you get the following beliefs:

1. People in power are likely right about what they claim

2. There is a "free press"

3. There is "democracy"



Is it divine revelation? Gut-feeling? Some authority figure told you so?


I believe it's commonly known as "living in reality".
You should visit sometime. It's nice here without the imaginary baddies.
 
There is nothing wrong with demanding evidence before adopting beliefs.

But apparently there's no reason to respond to these demands if the other side in the argument doesn't...

Bubba and OntarioSquatch, by the standards displayed here you can now simply claim that your critics hold "willfully ignorant positions" regarding whatever assertions you wish to make - and remember, there is no need for any sort of evidence for your claims. When they ask for it just claim they are "disingenuous" and "trolling."

...yet that's not an ad hominem tu quoque fallacy. Riiiiiight.

Do you get some kind of perverse pleasure out of making yourself look such a hypocrite?

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom