I have already provided evidence (actual evidence - not "the US government says so") for one example in which all major newspapers agreed to stop calling waterboarding torture when the US was doing it. This is independent of any other "being at each others' throats."
Could you provide a link to where you pointed to 'actual evidence' of this?
Your claim doesn't match how the story unfolded in the New York Times from 2004, based on re-reading a number via ProQuest. Nor for that matter what I remember from reading The Guardian in the UK to August 2004 and then spending the rest of the year in the States and reading the Washington Post as a daily paper.
The
Wiki page on 'waterboarding' links to a
student paper that strikes me as deeply flawed after revisiting some of the original NYT stories.
In the wake of Abu Ghraib there was a very extensive public debate in the US over "enhanced interrogation techniques" and whether these could be considered torture, including waterboarding. Precisely because there were so many figures in the Bush administration who insisted these techniques were not torture, news coverage ended up appearing as a neutral recounting of an adversarial conflict between supporters and critics, and many stories quoted critics rather than criticising the practices themselves. The student study excluded this 'criticism by others' category from consideration, which made a mockery of how the story actually unfolded, because there were more than a few public critics to be quoted. From 2004 onwards, John McCain was one of several politicians who returned again and again to this issue and insisted that torture had to be ruled out. The NYT covered this in some depth, writing not only editorials but also publishing extensive feature articles about the subject of interrogations and torture (a very lengthy one appeared on 12 June 2005).
In January 2005, I returned home to the UK from Washington, DC and resumed reading the Guardian as my daily newspaper. There's no question that the Guardian criticised US interrogation techniques including waterboarding as torture. In the latter half of the 2000s, the Guardian website became very widely read in the US. The comment pages and comment section of the website have certainly played host to numerous critics of the war on terror - and I've little doubt that their criticisms have been far harsher than those which appeared in major US newspapers.
It'd also be fair to say that because of the insistence of a variety of Bush administration figures that waterboarding (etc)
wasn't torture, the debate in the US danced around the issue far more than was the case in the British press. Yet this mealy-mouthed refusing-to-call-a-spade-a-spade debate still ended with Obama making the practice illegal in 2009, and still ended with a
Senate report on CIA torture released in 2014.
Over the ten years between 2004 and 2014 the issue of limits to interrogation was debated extensively, with a lot of lying and circumlocution on one side and countless criticisms thrown at the US on the other. For example,
Andrew Sullivan drawing an explicit comparison between 'enhanced interrogation techniques' and the Gestapo practice of 'verschaerfte Vernehmung' in 2007.
Yet such criticisms have evidently not sunk in with the Republican candidates in the current primary, most of whom declared they would bring back waterboarding.
The two rivals for the Democratic nomination have not made such statements. John McCain
continues to try to pass a bill to make sure torture is absolutely outlawed for the US government.
Was the public sphere in the US in lockstep over this issue? On the contrary, there was and is a somewhat partisan debate.