Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

Their line of work doesn't involve them investigating Conspiracy Theories. They investigate real life crimes.

True.

In that case, what term(s) describe a detective's theory that Mr. and Mrs. Jones might have conspired to harm Mr. Smith?

Do they call it a working theory?
 
C's argument is equally an ad-hom fallacy as B's argument. I guess you could argue this based on a strict definition, but if you think about why an ad-hom fallacy is fallacious - because it fails to be relevant with regards to the claim, not because it's not nice to be insulting people - then you should see that C's argument has the same problem as B's.

It has the same problem, yes, but the conventionally accepted definition of argumentum ad hominem is an argument where negative statements about the person are claimed to refute the argument. What you're illustrating is more akin to the appeal to authority, where positive statements about the person are claimed to support the argument. It may not have a formal name - the taxonomy of fallacies is as imperfect as anything else - but it's one of the same family, for sure.

And note, of course, that neither of these establishes anything either way about the original argument, and either may even occasionally be justified by circumstances. For example:

Person A: I think it's morally wrong to give money to beggars, because it discourages them from working.
Person B: To my knowledge person A is very generous and moral, therefore I think his argument has merit.
Person C: Person A has always seemed like a tight-fisted git to me, so I'm not interested in his opinion.

In both cases the argument, though based on the personal characteristics of A, has at least some validity, because the characteristic in question is related to the claim in question.

Dave
 
Your summation at the end is why I said I'm not ready to discard it as a fallacy, yet I will cling to the technicality that it is not an ad hom fallacy because it's not really a technicality. Your scenario has muddied the distinction I made.

Person A: Claim X
Person B: I have no argument, but A is a poopyhead and therefore wrong.
Person C: I have a counter-argument, and A should accept it because he's great.

B offers ONLY the insult.
C offers both the compliment and the counter-argument.

That's a different statement from what I said. One could argue whether yours is a fallacy, it might be - because it should be "A should accept it because it's a valid counter-argument." But it's not what I meant by "compliments are equally ad-hom as insults." What I meant is summarized in my example which you changed.
 
Except that the authority (the person you are complimenting) is being handed the position he is expected to accept?

I'm not sure I understand what you mean. I guess it doesn't matter. No one argues that way, through "reverse ad hominem". If the assessment that someone is right is made based on personal characteristics, as opposed to evidence or lack thereof, it is fallacious. Correctly labeling all possible categories of this type of argument doesn't appeal to me at this point.


P.S. I find it quite telling of our times, that the site's spellcheck wants me to replace "hominem" with "Eminem".
 
True.



In that case, what term(s) describe a detective's theory that Mr. and Mrs. Jones might have conspired to harm Mr. Smith?



Do they call it a working theory?


Oh dear. This is turning into another four legged dog merry-go-round.
I've no idea. Ask them.

My guess would be that they would only use the term "Conspiracy Theory" the same way most people do, i.e. to describe a paranoid fantasy based on nonsense.

Like the very nature of this thread's topic your trying too hard to invent reasons as to why not all arguments merit the same attention.

Assuming the harm you mentioned is murder I'd guess that the detectives would be investigating a murder. If the investigation shows that two people were involved and both people knew they were assisting the other the detectives would charge them both with murder. If one of them enabled the murder but didn't commit it... Dunno, different laws for different countries.

Semantics and word games. An old tactic when faced with the undeniable fact that a belief is recognisably stupid.
 
Last edited:
It has the same problem, yes, but the conventionally accepted definition of argumentum ad hominem is an argument where negative statements about the person are claimed to refute the argument. What you're illustrating is more akin to the appeal to authority, where positive statements about the person are claimed to support the argument. It may not have a formal name - the taxonomy of fallacies is as imperfect as anything else - but it's one of the same family, for sure.

The difference with an appeal to authority is that an appeal to authority is usually based on establishing someone as an authority with regards to the claims made.

A: "Physics claim X"
B: "A has taken a physics course, therefor X is true." - appeal to authority
C: "A is a good person who is always nice to others, therefor X is true." - ? (ad-hom?)
 
The difference with an appeal to authority is that an appeal to authority is usually based on establishing someone as an authority with regards to the claims made.

That's an informally valid appeal to authority. An informally invalid appeal to authority is one that tries to apply the appeal outside the area of authority - the classic example being Einstein's opinions on religion, as per Wikipedia. In your case one might argue that someone's moral authority is being extended into a claim of authority in a factual argument, which recovers the classic form of the invalid appeal to authority.

Dave
 

Do you understand the concept of "evidence"?

"John Kerry said so" and similar statements do not constitute evidence.

Also I will ask you again to provide examples of your claim: "Journalists from those companies have complained about having to publish government propaganda they know is untrue"
 
Last edited:
Ah yes, the illusion of competition. Actually 95% of the media in the US is owned by 5 corporations.

And I presume these corporations are in competition with each other. However, I was taking a more global view. There are countries outside of America, you know.


Cosmic Yak said:
if one publishes a story that is, for example, untrue, unevidenced or slavishly pro-government, the papers and channels of other political persuasions can, and will, attack it.
Do you have any evidence for these beliefs?

Again, of course I do. Here you go:

http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/aug/03/best-way-angry-daily-mail

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/a...he-Guardian-paper-helps-Britains-enemies.html

These two newspapers have been at each others' throats for some time now. Well-documented, and provable with a simple Google search. I assume you will now accept this point.
 
And I presume these corporations are in competition with each other. However, I was taking a more global view. There are countries outside of America, you know.

Again, of course I do. Here you go:

http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/aug/03/best-way-angry-daily-mail

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/a...he-Guardian-paper-helps-Britains-enemies.html

These two newspapers have been at each others' throats for some time now. Well-documented, and provable with a simple Google search. I assume you will now accept this point.

False. Two newspapers may be at each others' throats on some subjects yet agree on others.

I have already provided evidence (actual evidence - not "the US government says so") for one example in which all major newspapers agreed to stop calling waterboarding torture when the US was doing it. This is independent of any other "being at each others' throats."

You have yet to provide actual evidence for a single one of your claims. I see you have trouble with the concept of evidence, so let me spell it out:

For your claim:
many of the stories [in RT and PressTV] are obviously biased and laughably false.
you must provide a statistically relevant sample of stories found in RT and PressTV and show that a significant fraction (which can be considered "many") is "obviously biased and laughably false."

For your claim:
if one [Western media publication] publishes a story that is, for example, untrue, unevidenced or slavishly pro-government, the papers and channels of other political persuasions can, and will, attack it.
you must provide a statistically relevant sample of stories in Western media which are "untrue, unevidenced or slavishly pro-government" and show that these stories have been attacked - on those grounds - in other media.
 
Last edited:
I have already provided evidence (actual evidence - not "the US government says so") for one example in which all major newspapers agreed to stop calling waterboarding torture when the US was doing it. This is independent of any other "being at each others' throats."

Could you provide a link to where you pointed to 'actual evidence' of this?

Your claim doesn't match how the story unfolded in the New York Times from 2004, based on re-reading a number via ProQuest. Nor for that matter what I remember from reading The Guardian in the UK to August 2004 and then spending the rest of the year in the States and reading the Washington Post as a daily paper.

The Wiki page on 'waterboarding' links to a student paper that strikes me as deeply flawed after revisiting some of the original NYT stories.

In the wake of Abu Ghraib there was a very extensive public debate in the US over "enhanced interrogation techniques" and whether these could be considered torture, including waterboarding. Precisely because there were so many figures in the Bush administration who insisted these techniques were not torture, news coverage ended up appearing as a neutral recounting of an adversarial conflict between supporters and critics, and many stories quoted critics rather than criticising the practices themselves. The student study excluded this 'criticism by others' category from consideration, which made a mockery of how the story actually unfolded, because there were more than a few public critics to be quoted. From 2004 onwards, John McCain was one of several politicians who returned again and again to this issue and insisted that torture had to be ruled out. The NYT covered this in some depth, writing not only editorials but also publishing extensive feature articles about the subject of interrogations and torture (a very lengthy one appeared on 12 June 2005).

In January 2005, I returned home to the UK from Washington, DC and resumed reading the Guardian as my daily newspaper. There's no question that the Guardian criticised US interrogation techniques including waterboarding as torture. In the latter half of the 2000s, the Guardian website became very widely read in the US. The comment pages and comment section of the website have certainly played host to numerous critics of the war on terror - and I've little doubt that their criticisms have been far harsher than those which appeared in major US newspapers.

It'd also be fair to say that because of the insistence of a variety of Bush administration figures that waterboarding (etc) wasn't torture, the debate in the US danced around the issue far more than was the case in the British press. Yet this mealy-mouthed refusing-to-call-a-spade-a-spade debate still ended with Obama making the practice illegal in 2009, and still ended with a Senate report on CIA torture released in 2014.

Over the ten years between 2004 and 2014 the issue of limits to interrogation was debated extensively, with a lot of lying and circumlocution on one side and countless criticisms thrown at the US on the other. For example, Andrew Sullivan drawing an explicit comparison between 'enhanced interrogation techniques' and the Gestapo practice of 'verschaerfte Vernehmung' in 2007.

Yet such criticisms have evidently not sunk in with the Republican candidates in the current primary, most of whom declared they would bring back waterboarding.

The two rivals for the Democratic nomination have not made such statements. John McCain continues to try to pass a bill to make sure torture is absolutely outlawed for the US government.

Was the public sphere in the US in lockstep over this issue? On the contrary, there was and is a somewhat partisan debate.
 
The Wiki page on 'waterboarding' links to a student paper that strikes me as deeply flawed after revisiting some of the original NYT stories.

In the wake of Abu Ghraib there was a very extensive public debate in the US over "enhanced interrogation techniques" and whether these could be considered torture, including waterboarding. Precisely because there were so many figures in the Bush administration who insisted these techniques were not torture, news coverage ended up appearing as a neutral recounting of an adversarial conflict between supporters and critics, and many stories quoted critics rather than criticising the practices themselves. The student study excluded this 'criticism by others' category from consideration, which made a mockery of how the story actually unfolded, because there were more than a few public critics to be quoted.

The study explicitly includes the category "others calling it torture" so I don't really know why you think there's a problem. Have you actually read the study? On page 12 you can see a section devoted to quoting others calling the practice torture. The study describes the difference in the newspapers' own description of the practice depending on when the US did it, as well as on whether it is the US or another country doing it.
 
Last edited:
Was the public sphere in the US in lockstep over this issue?

The media was in lockstep right up until the point where evidence surfaced of the US using the practice (before 2004 it was consistently called torture) after which they suddenly went in lockstep the other way (after 2004 consistently not calling it torture). This refutes your claim that they were "merely trying to be neutral" but then all this is noted in the study itself.
 
The study explicitly includes the category "others calling it torture" so I don't really know why you think there's a problem. Have you actually read the study? On page 12 you can see a section devoted to quoting others calling the practice torture. The study describes the difference in the newspapers' own description of the practice depending on when the US did it, as well as on whether it is the US or another country doing it.

Yes, I read the study. On p.6 the students argued as follows

“Others calling it torture” was left out because while quoting others is an editorial choice of the paper, it is not directly the narrative voice.

This fails to recognise how reporting works when there is an issue in contention. One side is quoted saying x, critics quoted saying y, the canons of objectivity (which have prevailed since at least the 1920s in the US media) preclude the reporter in a news story from coming down on one side or the other.

From the very first article using the term 'water boarding' - 'Harsh C.I.A Methods Cited In Top Qaeda Interrogations', NYT, 13.5.2004, pp.A1, A13, so a front page story with a hefty follow-through - the issue was flagged as under contention, a matter of debate inside government departments, agencies and the White House. The White House in particular was identified from the outset as arguing for a not-torture interpretation.

There are numerous other problems with the study. Not sure why it took 11 students to do something that could have made a really good senior thesis (or undergraduate dissertation in UK terms) for one of them. There was a distinct lack of qualitative analysis - frankly, when on p.11 they assert that only 1 of 133 stories in the NYT "said or implied that waterboarding was torture" I call BS. The issue was substantially reported in terms of whether it broke the law - even raising the issue of legality implies that waterboarding is torture.

If this study is your 'actual evidence' that the US press 'agreed' to stop calling waterboarding torture then oh dear, is all I can say.
 
This fails to recognise how reporting works when there is an issue in contention. One side is quoted saying x, critics quoted saying y, the canons of objectivity (which have prevailed since at least the 1920s in the US media) preclude the reporter in a news story from coming down on one side or the other.

Yet they have been coming down on one side or the other, namely before 2004 consistently and directly calling it torture and since 2004 consistently having stopped calling it torture, this is demonstrably true.

Also, your "canons of objectivity (which have prevailed since at least the 1920s in the US media)" gets the only answer it deserves: :rolleyes: ... there is so much research debunking this particular myth

From the very first article using the term 'water boarding' - 'Harsh C.I.A Methods Cited In Top Qaeda Interrogations', NYT, 13.5.2004, pp.A1, A13

That is a lie, why are you ignoring all the articles before 2004 that used the term "waterboarding"? Is it because they called it torture?

The White House in particular was identified from the outset as arguing for a not-torture interpretation.

Swiftly and consistently adopted by all major newspapers which immediately changed tack on their reporting on the practice.

There are numerous other problems with the study. Not sure why it took 11 students to do something that could have made a really good senior thesis (or undergraduate dissertation in UK terms) for one of them.

As if the mere fact that a research project was performed by a group of students makes it problematic. It says a lot about the strength of your position that you have to resort to such arguments.

There was a distinct lack of qualitative analysis - frankly, when on p.11 they assert that only 1 of 133 stories in the NYT "said or implied that waterboarding was torture" I call BS.

You can call whatever you want. Feel free refute it by providing evidence. Of course, you have none. Yet it would be so easy, all you have to do is provide a second such story in that set of 133 stories and show that it "said or implied that waterboarding was torture." It's not like the methodology isn't provided.

The issue was substantially reported in terms of whether it broke the law - even raising the issue of legality implies that waterboarding is torture.

What nonsense. By this argument the Bush administration itself, by raising the issue of legality, implied that it was torture.

Have you even noticed that this assertion of yours (raising the issue of legality implies that waterboarding is torture) contradicts your earlier assertion (the canons of objectivity (which have prevailed since at least the 1920s in the US media) preclude the reporter in a news story from coming down on one side or the other)? My guess is you haven't.

If this study is your 'actual evidence' that the US press 'agreed' to stop calling waterboarding torture then oh dear, is all I can say.

I couldn't care less about what you can say. What you can provide evidence for is another matter. But I see you need to restrict yourself to outright lies (the first article on waterboarding was in 2004), non-sequiturs (raising the issue of legality implies that it is torture) and plain silly retorts (but it were students who did the research work).
 
Last edited:
Do you understand the concept of "evidence"?

"John Kerry said so" and similar statements do not constitute evidence.

Also I will ask you again to provide examples of your claim: "Journalists from those companies have complained about having to publish government propaganda they know is untrue"

There are numerous examples of this in both the links. The fact that you appear not to have read them speaks volumes.
Nick Ferrari,Hassan Abdulrahman and Mark Levine from Press TV.
William Dunbar, Liz Wahl and Stacy Bivens, from Russia Today.
All these names are copied from the two links. It would help the strength of your argument if you spoke from a position of knowledge rather than a lack thereof.
 
You have yet to provide actual evidence for a single one of your claims. I see you have trouble with the concept of evidence, so let me spell it out:

For your claim:
Cosmic Yak said:
many of the stories [in RT and PressTV] are obviously biased and laughably false.
you must provide a statistically relevant sample of stories found in RT and PressTV and show that a significant fraction (which can be considered "many") is "obviously biased and laughably false."

For your claim:
Cosmic Yak said:
if one [Western media publication] publishes a story that is, for example, untrue, unevidenced or slavishly pro-government, the papers and channels of other political persuasions can, and will, attack it.
you must provide a statistically relevant sample of stories in Western media which are "untrue, unevidenced or slavishly pro-government" and show that these stories have been attacked - on those grounds - in other media.

Yet more moving of the goalposts. When asked, I provided evidence of my claims, which I have already noted you do not appear to have read. However, rather than acknowledge that I have done so, you are now trying to redefine your terms of what you will consider evidence.
I am not sure what you hope to achieve by this tactic. If it is honest debate you are after, then, although I am happy to oblige you, this tactic will not have that effect. I have no interest in endlessly pursuing you as you constantly shift your requirements and ignore evidence (Your comment about John Kerry saying so is a perfect example: had you scrolled on, you would have come to the names of the journalists I was referring you to. You either did not, or you chose to ignore them.) .
If you simply wish to score internet debating points, that is, of course, your prerogative. However, this is a game I have no desire to play.
I suggest you actually read the two articles I linked to. There are plenty of further links from there if you want to follow that up. If you come back with a reasonable response (and I'll state right now that, as you are free to define evidence in your own terms, then I am also free to define reasonable in mine), we can continue what should be an interesting and stimulating debate. If it's just going to be cheap shots, I'm afraid you'll have to find someone else to interact with.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom