Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

I know quite well what it means, it seems to be you who has no idea what it means. "You are wrong because sound refutation, you are also wrong because you're a poopyhead." The second part is an ad-hom and this is independent of the first part. Again, having a sound refutation does not exclude also having an ad-hom.

At last, you've actually got it right. Now, can you see the difference between that and "You are wrong because sound refutation, and you're also a poopyhead," and do you understand why that isn't an ad hominem (as you formerly claimed it was)? Or are you still determined to remain wrong?

Dave
 
At last, you've actually got it right.

I had it right from the start.

Now, can you see the difference between that and "You are wrong because sound refutation, and you're also a poopyhead," and do you understand why that isn't an ad hominem (as you formerly claimed it was)? Or are you still determined to remain wrong?

"Sound refutation and you're a poopyhead"? The latter part is an ad-hom. It's simply your choice to insert "you are wrong because" preceding only the first part. How about showing an actual post on this forum which has both a sound refutation and a personal insult which has this specific form required for you to be right, ie that it says "you are wrong because" before the refutation but not before the insult?
 
I had it right from the start.

No, and everyone can see you didn't.

"Sound refutation and you're a poopyhead"? The latter part is an ad-hom.

No, it isn't. I suggest you look it up. Not all insults are argumentum ad hominem fallacies, and not all argumentum ad hominem fallacies are insults.

It's simply your choice to insert "you are wrong because" preceding only the first part.

No, it isn't. Argumentum ad hominem is a fallacy in logic, so it can only occur if there is a logical construction for it to apply to. "You are wrong because you're a poopyhead" is an argumentum ad hominem and an insult. "You are a poopyhead" is an insult. "You are wrong because you're a carpenter" is an argumentum ad hominem, but not an insult. "You are a carpenter" is neither an insult nor an argumentum ad hominem.

How about showing an actual post on this forum which has both a sound refutation and a personal insult which has this specific form required for you to be right, ie that it says "you are wrong because" before the refutation but not before the insult?

Why would the presence or absence of a specific type of example on this forum have any relevance whatsoever to the definition of the term?

Dave
 
^^^^
Sure sign of desperation when your sent on a informational snipe hunt LOL....the only thing worse is irrelevant information....we see that alot from trolls (Bigfoot proponents).
 
If you see it as separate from the argument then yes you are correct. I don't really see it as separate from the argument though, in reality there is almost never this nice separation between "here is my argument" and "here is something which is separate from my argument" but they are rather mixed in together. And one can certainly be very skeptical of why people would start adding in "you're a poopyhead" in posts on a forum that are supposed to be debating a claim or argument, if not to use it as an ad-hom. It's no more of a leap to reach this conclusion than, say, to conclude someone is JAQing when someone is asking a lot of questions about some fringe claim.
It is not a matter of what I, personally, see as separate or not separate; it is a matter of what the specific fallacy is defined as. While you are correct that it can be difficult to determine when an insult is used (incorrectly) as part of an argument as opposed to when it is made in addition to the argument, that difficulty is beside the point. If the insult is not part of the argument, then there is no ad hom fallacy. One can see your misuse simply by noting that you are quite clearly calling the insult itself an ad hom. If your point is that the presence of an insult -- regardless of its impact or lack of impact on an argument -- is sufficient an indicator that the insulter is likely to be using specious arguments and is therefore not worth engaging, then fine, but that still is not an ad hom fallacy.

And this is why I mentioned pub, labcoat, and business casual. You have demanded precision from JayUtah but exhibit a lack of it yourself.
 
Pretty crappy to come up with bs accusations against someone simply because you can't stand their opinion.

Kinda like playing armchair psychologist on the Internet by diagnosing people with cognitive dissonance, as opposed to supporting your argument with facts you can back up.....you mean like that kinda BS?
 
Last edited:
I meant the study that featured Meldrum, not the one I posted.
Ah. So you confirm you have no response regarding the Monster Quest video. When I make a claim about the Meldrum's video that I refuse even to discuss then, yes, you may excoriate me for it.


Pretty crappy to come up with bs accusations against someone simply because you can't stand their opinion.
Fascinating gamer stuff here. First it was fact. Now it is opinion. At both stages the gamer refuses to discuss it and lashes angrily out at the one who exposes the lies.

It really is both intriguing and disturbing, the degree to which there is no shame in the lies but a vitriolic embarrassment at being caught out.
 
Kinda like playing armchair psychologist on the Internet by diagnosing people with cognitive dissonance, as opposed to suporting your argument with facts you can back up.....you mean like that kinda BS?

Especially alleging cognitive dissonance without being able to name any dissonant cognition.
 
Jesus Christ.

caveman1917, "conspiracy theory" is a figure of speech. It does not derive its definition literally from the two words that compose it.
It's a pejorative, used to indicate that a claim is bogus, usually a claim that requires the existence of a conspiracy to cover up the evidence that would rescue the claim from its bogosity.

Thus the employment of the two-stage, asymmetrical argument that JayUtah describes.

The theory of the assassination of Julius Caesar by a conspiracy including Brutus is not a "conspiracy theory".


What do detectives call it n their line of work?
 
If the insult is not part of the argument, then there is no ad hom fallacy.

Note the importance of "if" here. I'm not disagreeing with your statement, but with the "the insult is not part of the argument."

One can see your misuse simply by noting that you are quite clearly calling the insult itself an ad hom.

With no less reason then where you are only calling the non-insult stuff as "part of the argument." Hence why I asked for actual examples of posts that actually make this distinction between "this is part of my argument" and "this is not part of my argument." In my experience there is never this nice distinction being made between what is or is not part of the argument, it's usually just a bunch of statements where insults are interspersed with non-insults. If you choose to add "you are wrong because" in front of the non-insulting statements then I can choose to also add "your are wrong because" in front of the insulting statements.

Someone makes statements X, Y and Z in response to a claim, where Z is a personal insult and X and Y are not. If you're then interpreting this as "You are wrong because X, you are also wrong because Y. And Z" (ie not putting "you are wrong because" in front of Z) then you're just choosing to interpret the post so as to lead to your conclusion of "not an ad-hom."

And let's not forget that ad-homs aren't limited to insults, they can also work in the other direction - where someone is praised on a personal level as support for accepting someone's argument.
 
Why would the presence or absence of a specific type of example on this forum have any relevance whatsoever to the definition of the term?

Because you and Garrette apparently think you're arguing the definition of an ad-hom fallacy whereas you're really arguing your interpretation of posts where you choose to let only non-insulting statements be "part of the argument." So yes, I'd like an example of an actually existing post where this distinction is made between "part of argument" and "not part of argument" rather then where you put this distinction in - apparently chosen so as to lead to the result you want.
 
Because you and Garrette apparently think you're arguing the definition of an ad-hom fallacy whereas you're really arguing your interpretation of posts where you choose to let only non-insulting statements be "part of the argument." So yes, I'd like an example of an actually existing post where this distinction is made between "part of argument" and "not part of argument" rather then where you put this distinction in - apparently chosen so as to lead to the result you want.

I suggest you quote a few posts in which you can't tell whether an insult is part of an argument or not, and I'll see if I can help you understand them. I'd try to find some, but I fear I'm unable to reproduce the level of incomprehension that would make the question even possible to ask; the whole thing is so obvious to me that I'd probably fail to identify the posts where it's beyond you to work it out.

Dave
 
I had it right from the start.



"Sound refutation and you're a poopyhead"? The latter part is an ad-hom. It's simply your choice to insert "you are wrong because" preceding only the first part. How about showing an actual post on this forum which has both a sound refutation and a personal insult which has this specific form required for you to be right, ie that it says "you are wrong because" before the refutation but not before the insult?
Well, you could try this one, which I would not normally include except for your insistence that a compliment is the same as an insult when it comes to ad hom.

Garrette said:
It looked like only a very short shot to me. A claim is designated as a "conspiracy theory" based on whether there is agreement with the claim or not.
No, not remotely (discarding the fringe elements you can find on any topic and on all sides of any topic).

A claim is designated a conspiracy theory if it involves a conspiracy. From there, however, proceeds confusion, and I suspect you are deliberately helping sow it. I say this because you are obviously highly intelligent and capable of deep analytical thought yet you do not apply it here.
Not everything that is a conspiracy theory is bunkum; there have been legitimate conspiracies, both successful and not.

Some conspiracy theories are indeed bunkum. The 9/11 inside jobbers and the moon landing hoaxers are examples.

What you have done in this conversation is assume that the use of "conspiracy theory" is identically applied by skeptics to all cases when in fact it is quite obvious in context which subset of all CTs JayUtah and others were referring to.
I offered an argument; it may be a weak argument in your mind, but it rests entirely on its own merits and not on the compliment I have highlighted (granted, the compliment ends with a limited retraction of it).

We can discuss, if you like, why I bother to put compliments or insults in if they are not needed for the argument; that's a valid topic, but it is quite clear here that this post of mine is not remotely an ad hom because the argument is separate from the personal comment.

Let's go further, though, and demonstrate another error in your statements here as regards compliments also being ad hom.

You say this:

caveman1917 said:
And let's not forget that ad-homs aren't limited to insults, they can also work in the other direction - where someone is praised on a personal level as support for accepting someone's argument.
which is a restatement of what you said earlier.

It defeats itself.

An ad hominem fallacy is one in which the person committing the fallacy attacks the character of his opponent in order to undermine the opponent's argument. Your comment above reflects the exact opposite: "accept my argument because you are of good character [or have good quality]."

Perhaps you are correct in that such a tactic is a fallacy (I'm not ready to concede such, but I won't discard it yet, either), but it is unequivocally not an ad hominem fallacy, particularly since when I used it I actually offered an argument.
 
Well, you could try this one, which I would not normally include except for your insistence that a compliment is the same as an insult when it comes to ad hom.

I offered an argument; it may be a weak argument in your mind, but it rests entirely on its own merits and not on the compliment I have highlighted (granted, the compliment ends with a limited retraction of it).

We can discuss, if you like, why I bother to put compliments or insults in if they are not needed for the argument; that's a valid topic, but it is quite clear here that this post of mine is not remotely an ad hom because the argument is separate from the personal comment.

Fair enough.

Let's go further, though, and demonstrate another error in your statements here as regards compliments also being ad hom.

Person A: "Claim X"
Person B: "A is poopy-head, therefor X is false."
Person C: "A is a nice person, therefor X is true."

C's argument is equally an ad-hom fallacy as B's argument. I guess you could argue this based on a strict definition, but if you think about why an ad-hom fallacy is fallacious - because it fails to be relevant with regards to the claim, not because it's not nice to be insulting people - then you should see that C's argument has the same problem as B's.
 
Fair enough.



Person A: "Claim X"
Person B: "A is poopy-head, therefor X is false."
Person C: "A is a nice person, therefor X is true."

C's argument is equally an ad-hom fallacy as B's argument. I guess you could argue this based on a strict definition, but if you think about why an ad-hom fallacy is fallacious - because it fails to be relevant with regards to the claim, not because it's not nice to be insulting people - then you should see that C's argument has the same problem as B's.
Your summation at the end is why I said I'm not ready to discard it as a fallacy, yet I will cling to the technicality that it is not an ad hom fallacy because it's not really a technicality. Your scenario has muddied the distinction I made.

Person A: Claim X
Person B: I have no argument, but A is a poopyhead and therefore wrong.
Person C: I have a counter-argument, and A should accept it because he's great.

B offers ONLY the insult.
C offers both the compliment and the counter-argument.
 
This may be a clearer expression of my thoughts on the distinction, but perhaps not:

Ad Hominem as defined is the rejection of an argument based on personal characteristics.

Your extension, however, is the acceptance of a counter-argument based on personal characteristics.

That's why I say it's the complete opposite, even if it is a fallacy in its own right.
 
This may be a clearer expression of my thoughts on the distinction, but perhaps not:

Ad Hominem as defined is the rejection of an argument based on personal characteristics.

Your extension, however, is the acceptance of a counter-argument based on personal characteristics.

That's why I say it's the complete opposite, even if it is a fallacy in its own right.

For some reason "ad hominem" is reserved for negative statements. A positive spin would make it more like an argument from authority (he's right because he's so smart).
 
For some reason "ad hominem" is reserved for negative statements. A positive spin would make it more like an argument from authority (he's right because he's so smart).
Except that the authority (the person you are complimenting) is being handed the position he is expected to accept?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom