Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

^^^^^
Bravo.....as soon as you see the word salad games, re-definition abuse and endless word smithing nit-picking...your either dealing with the inability to admit one is wrong or a troll.
 
caveman1917:
"Refutation B, replete with data plus valid and sound logic." Well Done.
"Oh, and by the way, you're a poopyhead." Ad-hom.

So what you're saying is, you don't understand what argumentum ad hominem means, and you're confusing it with a personal insult, right?

I think there's some kind of entry test for conspiracy theorists where they're asked what argumentum ad hominem means, and if they get it right then they're not allowed in.

Dave
 
You just seem to be following the 1960's CIA guidelines.

But even in the mutilated form presented on that website - the full document has 9 annexes with clippings from already published press criticisms of Mark Lane et al - the document doesn't mean what you want it to mean.

It relates exclusively to the specific situation of suspicions of the conclusion of the Warren Commission, which investigated the possibility that Lee Harvey Oswald did not act alone, and came down against the notion that there was a conspiracy of more than Oswald.

Since 'Warren Commission critics' typically alleged that there was a conspiracy, they became known as conspiracy theorists, as we see in the CIA memo. This is an appropriate term to describe a group of people who hypothesise/allege/assert a conspiracy when a fact-finding body concluded that there was no conspiracy.

The memo, which was primarily aimed at CIA stations overseas, outlines a quite specific series of rebuttals to various conspiracy-flavoured talking points and suggests that suspicious audiences be reminded of some common-sense observations, such as the total implausibility of LHO working with a conspiracy since he was a loner.

The 5-point characterisation of the critics is with hindsight rather an accurate portrayal of the first wave of JFK theorists: "(I) wedded to theories adopted before the evidence was in, (I) politically interested, (III) financially interested, (IV) hasty and inaccurate in their research, or (V) infatuated with their own theories"

Yet the majority of points a-g in item #4 are about the case and the evidence, not about the critics.

The annexes show that to brief CIA stations overseas and prepare them for this hypothetical task - since it is meant to be reactive as seen in item 3, 'Action' - the CIA culled already written negative reviews and overviews of 'Warren Commission critics', of the type that were also appearing in a few academic journals circa 1966.

The claim that the CIA was the first to 'weaponise' the term conspiracy theory is also flatly wrong, as CSICOP noted a few years back.
 
Following up on the CIA memo, here's something I wrote on it two years ago that has not appeared in public before.


Quellenkritik vs DeHaven-Smith's Conspiracy Theory in America and CIA Document 1035-960

I got hold a copy of political science professor Lance DeHaven-Smith's recent book Conspiracy Theory in America for amusement value, as it seemed to be widely touted by nigh on every single crank on the net as 'proof' that they were not insane - Kevin Barrett has been jumping up and down about the book, Alex Jones had him on the show, etc etc. This is one of several recent university press tomes trying to rehabilitate conspiracy theory as a term by decrying how it has been 'weaponized' against fearless critics of TPTB rather than being used accurately to describe whooping loons.

(Another such flawed attempt is Jack Bratich's Conspiracy Panics: Political Rationality and Popular Culture, which at least has the merit of applying Stanley Cohen's moral panic concept to relevant eras, eg the 90s fuss over the militia, but then fluffs the details, e.g. claiming that critics of 1990s conspiracy culture were now espousing CTs in the 2000s after 9/11 - um, no, Chip Berlet, the ADL etc remained critics of conspiracy theories throughout...)

Anyway, DeHaven-Smith is basically a JFK nut, and for a political science professor is shockingly badly informed about 20th Century US political history as well as intellectual history. A whole chapter is spent extolling Charles Beard while excoriating Karl Popper and Leo Strauss for being the hitmen in 'stigmatising' conspiracy theory as an approach, whereas supposedly it was as American as apple pie from the days of the Founding Fathers through to Beard. This is accompanied by blaming social science for not retaining elite-critical theories after the rise to globalism. Umm... LOLwut? Has this bozo never read C. Wright Mills' The Power Elite from 1956 or paid attention to the emergence of Cold War revisionism at, duh, the end of the 1950s?! Why is he ignoring the involvement en masse of a significant proportion of academic faculty in the anti-war movement in the 60s? Et cetera. Reducing a zeitgeist shift to the remarks of one philosopher of science (since Strauss's views can hardly have played a significant role in shifting majority academic opinion) is the worst kind of intellectual wankery imaginable.

While Hofstadter is mentioned, his article is completely misrepresented and treated as something that it is not, a comment on all political conspiracies. DeHaven-Smith like most special-pleaders on behalf of conspiracy theory as a 'neutral' term ignores how intellectuals were somewhat jaded with conspiracy claims by the early 1960s as a result of McCarthyism and the subsequent antics of the radical right, which was the immediate context for the 'Paranoid Style' lecture and essay by Hofstadter. One might add that when Revilo P. Oliver came out in early 1964 with a NYT-reported conspiracy claim that JFK was assassinated by the communists for not pushing through the communist takeover fast enough.... at least Professor Palindrome got the political identity of the shooter right!

The smoking gun for DeHaven-Smith's imbecility, however, is his treatment of a document declassified and published in 1976 during one of the 1970s CIA/assassination commissions, which is widely spammed across the internet by JFK freaks and other conspiracy nuts. In transcribed form it can be found here.

Take a look and notice that this transcription lacks all headers and paraphernalia associated with a government document. No, it's not a forgery: a scan of the document bundle can be found on Mary Ferrell Foundation website here.

So our intrepid parapolitical paranoid researcher waxes lyrical about how this document, dated ironically 1 April 1967, proves that "the CIA" invented the term conspiracy theory as a "weaponized" meme to neutralise the threat posed by political dissidents who were making mucho noise about JFK. He then elaborates by fingering a White House aide to LBJ named John P. Roche who wrote a letter a year later to The Times Literary Supplement rebutting some British review of a JFK CT book, which then was reported back in the US as 'newsworthy'. We also get several whacked out attempts at 'decoding' Document 1035-960 including wondering whether this wasn't simply a subtraction i.e. it meant '75', which ignores the glaringly obvious fact that the number is a serial from the FOIA process arising from the 1976 declassification, as is immediately apparent from looking at the original document.

If it is not already clear that DeHaven-Smith never looked at the original, then this final point will prove his total imbecility. Needless to say DeHaven-Smith believes this document proves CIA interference and manipulation in domestic affairs. But the document is addressed to 'Chiefs Certain Stations and Bases'. The memo was intended to provide a series of talking points for CIA stations overseas in case they were in a position to influence foreign press coverage. That was the CIA's job! We know that the CIA funded journals and cultural activity in Europe, and we know that the "cultural attaché" cover which was so often used meant that CIA officers would come into contact with journalists and other opinion formers - overseas. The document as transcribed here http://www.jfklancer.com/CIA.html and as reproduced in DeHaven-Smith's book includes a remark in the final paragraph that "Open-minded foreign readers should still be impressed by the care, thoroughness, objectivity and speed with which the Commission worked"- confirming this common-sense reading of the document.

The coup de grace is visible at the bottom of the first page of the document, which states there are 9 attachments h/w of which 1 is secret and 8 are unclassified. The bundle which was sent out to station chiefs overseas included what amounted to a pile of press cuttings of rebuttals of JFK conspiracy theories that had already appeared in print in the US media in 1966, along with a 'secret' analysis of the main CT authors of the day, i.e. Mark Lane and Edward Jay Epstein. The CIA analyst who drafted the talking points was simply cueing off comments that were already in circulation, including a savage criticism of Lane et al from a NY federal circuit judge, as well as an analysis from what seems to be a British lawyer commenting on the abuse and misrepresentation of English law in some remark by Mark Lane.

Also amusing is how the fact that the CIA memo notes that many JFK conspiracists had communist connections is immediately jumped on by DeHaven-Smith as evidence of the CIA playing silly buggers. But it is a matter of record that the first author of a proper JFK CT, Joachim Joesten, was a sometime KPD member and Soviet sympathiser; while the Soviet and East Bloc press kept stirring the pot all the way through the 1960s, while Mark Lane's political sympathies were quite clearly radical. Even if it would be wrong to reduce JFK CTs to communist propaganda, there is little doubt that communist antics played at least some role in getting the whole thing going.

So not only do we find a professor of political science single-sourcing a seismic cultural shift to a 1967 CIA memo, we are given no follow-up evidence to confirm that this led to anything in particular, versus a fairly hefty paper trail already embedded in the full document which shows a vigorous debate around the JFK assassination which played out all the way through the 1970s, and did not really die until the 1980s, by which time the culture and zeitgeist really had changed.

But worst of all, the professor of political science cannot read a document correctly (or doesn't even think to look at the original), and doesn't know how to contextualise it.

Robin Ramsay, editor of Lobster magazine, slammed the book in a review noting that DeHaven-Smith is fixated on 'event' conspiracy theories and totally ignores meta-theories. CSICOP also pointed out that the attempt to date the advent of the supposedly 'weaponized' slogan to 1967 is wrong here.
 
FTFY

Scenario 3

Claimant: Hypothesis A

Skeptic: Refutation B, replete with data plus valid and sound logic.
"Oh, and by the way, you're a poopyhead."

caveman1917:
"Refutation B, replete with data plus valid and sound logic." Well Done.
"Oh, and by the way, you're a poopyhead." Ad-hom.
This would be closer to correct but still wrong.

Here's your relevant comment on the subject:

"Who said anything about being insulted? Saying good things about someone[*] is equally ad-hom as insulting someone. The point isn't about how insulting an ad-hom might be, but that it is fallacious either way."

You point it out as a fallacy in this statement where as in your revised Scenario 3 you do not; you merely point it out as separate from the argument. Your error then is in calling the insult -- separate from any argument -- as an ad hom or as a fallacy. This isn't difficult, yet you are getting it wrong.
 
If you're talking about the video on the study that was done on the biomechanics seen in the PGF, that video wasn't edited at all. It came straight out and unedited from the MonsterQuest documentary, which you can confirm for yourself.

I've already answered your question about what research I did on the study, but it wasn't to your satisfaction. If you're just wondering whether or not I contacted the professor, the answer is no.
Just to emphasize what I have already said, i.e., that you did not in fact answer the question, the response (not answer) in question, is here:

OntarioSquatch said:
I've looked at a variety of sources and one thing I've noticed is that all of them report the same characteristics even though their opinion on whether or not the gait could be replicated differs. The problem appears to be that the amount of difference required to exist between the gait of a regular person and the gait of the PGF subject varies. In other words, whether or not the walk can be replicated depends on how much room you leave for difference. The data itself isn't a problem.

In other words, you completely avoided the actual question about what you did to check the source. The answer -- the one you know is completely damning -- is that you did nothing. And you have nothing.
 
^^^^^
That's always been the case deception, deflection and disingenuous....classic trolling behavior :thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
FTFY

Scenario 3

Claimant: Hypothesis A

Skeptic: Refutation B, replete with data plus valid and sound logic.
"Oh, and by the way, you're a poopyhead."

caveman1917:
"Refutation B, replete with data plus valid and sound logic." Well Done.
"Oh, and by the way, you're a poopyhead." Ad-hom.

I believe sir that horse is dead.
 
I believe sir that horse is dead.
I can smell it from here. Of course, an ad-hom isn't necessarily a fallacy - the argument may well be wrong because you're a poopy head; however, it's clear that you can be called a poopy head and that your argument is wrong without it being ad-hom.

Just sayin' ;)
 
My idea of reality is based on .... reality.

Your idea of reality is fallible just like any other person's.

In other words, you completely avoided the actual question about what you did to check the source. The answer -- the one you know is completely damning -- is that you did nothing. And you have nothing.

It sounds like you want to come up with whatever excuse you can to cast aspersions.

Imagine if I did the same thing

"Did you check with source of the study that claims the walk can be replicated?

No? You didn't? Then you're gaming."
 
Your idea of reality is fallible just like any other person's.



It sounds like you want to come up with whatever excuse you can to cast aspersions.

Imagine if I did the same thing

"Did you check with source of the study that claims the walk can be replicated?

No? You didn't? Then you're gaming."

Your claim....as always you can't back it up and you resort to your typical behavior. It's nothing new or novel your disingenuous arguments are predictable.
 
Your idea of reality is fallible just like any other person's.



It sounds like you want to come up with whatever excuse you can to cast aspersions.

Imagine if I did the same thing

"Did you check with source of the study that claims the walk can be replicated?

No? You didn't? Then you're gaming."
Except that I did check it, as I have said. I emailed the Professor. He was quite polite. Care to know what he said? I can tell you again or you can go back and see where I have already told you.

You have absolutely no credibility here. You are a gamer without remorse except now you have been caught out extremely clearly.
 
Pretty crappy to come up with bs accusations against someone simply because you can't stand their opinion.

Any jackass can come up with a cause for an event, but that doesn’t mean said jackass has won the internet.

An ad hoc hypothesis probably shouldn’t be bandied about as teh obvious explanation.

There is no evidence for bigfoot because the men in black hide the truth.

People refuse to believe in bigfoot because they can’t handle cognitive dissonance.

If you think someone is a gamer, it’s because they can’t stand your opinion.

The reason bigfoot DNA tests come up “human hair” is because footie has DNA that is indistinguishable from human DNA.

Because aliens.


When looking at a claim, I wish I could just go with the first thing that comes to mind and stay with it forever. Instead I am compelled to be objective and follow the evidence. I’m sure you’ll know the reason instantly.
 
This would be closer to correct but still wrong.

Here's your relevant comment on the subject:

"Who said anything about being insulted? Saying good things about someone[*] is equally ad-hom as insulting someone. The point isn't about how insulting an ad-hom might be, but that it is fallacious either way."

You point it out as a fallacy in this statement where as in your revised Scenario 3 you do not; you merely point it out as separate from the argument. Your error then is in calling the insult -- separate from any argument -- as an ad hom or as a fallacy. This isn't difficult, yet you are getting it wrong.

If you see it as separate from the argument then yes you are correct. I don't really see it as separate from the argument though, in reality there is almost never this nice separation between "here is my argument" and "here is something which is separate from my argument" but they are rather mixed in together. And one can certainly be very skeptical of why people would start adding in "you're a poopyhead" in posts on a forum that are supposed to be debating a claim or argument, if not to use it as an ad-hom. It's no more of a leap to reach this conclusion than, say, to conclude someone is JAQing when someone is asking a lot of questions about some fringe claim.
 
So what you're saying is, you don't understand what argumentum ad hominem means, and you're confusing it with a personal insult, right?

I think there's some kind of entry test for conspiracy theorists where they're asked what argumentum ad hominem means, and if they get it right then they're not allowed in.

Dave

If you are dismissing someone's argument and intersperse your refutation with personal insults then yes it is reasonable to conclude you're using an ad-hom. Having a sound refutation does not exclude also having an ad-hom.
 
Thanks for confirming that you have no idea what it means.

Dave

I know quite well what it means, it seems to be you who has no idea what it means. "You are wrong because sound refutation, you are also wrong because you're a poopyhead." The second part is an ad-hom and this is independent of the first part. Again, having a sound refutation does not exclude also having an ad-hom.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom