Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

It sounds like you get angry when someone causes you to doubt your idea of reality.

Not at all. My idea of reality is based on .... reality.

In reality Figboot does not exist. It never has existed and never could exist.
Why would I get angry just because some people are too stupid to accept that reality is.... reality?

The only effect believers of such nonsense has on me is to make me point and laugh. Unless they're of the conman variety, then they are cockwombles and earn my wrath.

ETA: The only people who "get angry" are the ones who cry and have a temper tantrum when others wont play their silly games.
Getting upset and inventing psycho-babble labels for anyone who wont play along with their fantasy.
Pretending to analyse the motives of the big bad meanies who wont take their claptrap seriously.
 
Last edited:
If you're talking about the video on the study that was done on the biomechanics seen in the PGF, that video wasn't edited at all. It came straight out and unedited from the MonsterQuest documentary, which you can confirm for yourself.
More equivocation. It was unedited in respect to what was aired; it was highly edited before airing. I confirmed that. You did not.


OntarioSquatch said:
I've already answered your question about what research I did on the study, but it wasn't to your satisfaction. If you're just wondering whether or not I contacted the professor, the answer is no.
No, you did not; you ignored the question repeatedly. If you did not research the film, then your other claims about being the one who has researched everything is a lie. If you did research it, then you know that Dr. Konczak who conducted the studies considers the results inconclusive, yet for some reason you posted the film as evidence from an expert that human cannot replicate the gait of Patty in the PGF.

This is not the only time you have been caught out, OS, but it's the latest, and it is irrefutable. You are a gamer, and your posts lack credibility.
 
Jesus Christ.

caveman1917, "conspiracy theory" is a figure of speech. It does not derive its definition literally from the two words that compose it.

It's a pejorative, used to indicate that a claim is bogus, usually a claim that requires the existence of a conspiracy to cover up the evidence that would rescue the claim from its bogosity.

Thus the employment of the two-stage, asymmetrical argument that JayUtah describes.

The theory of the assassination of Julius Caesar by a conspiracy including Brutus is not a "conspiracy theory".

Merriam Webster

Merriam Webster said:
Simple Definition of conspiracy theory

a theory that explains an event or situation as the result of a secret plan by usually powerful people or groups

Full Definition of conspiracy theory

a theory that explains an event or set of circumstances as the result of a secret plot by usually powerful conspirators

You just seem to be following the 1960's CIA guidelines.
 
Last edited:
I don't think you know what the term demonstration means.



(P AND Q) => (P => Q) is a tautology. What do we call a "demonstration" which denies a tautology?[*]



No demonstration occurred. Or rather, there was one demonstration, which was me demonstrating how I was right. Notice the difference in form: I started at the premise, applied a sequence of logical transformations, and arrived at the conclusion. Notice the form of yours and Jay Utah's "demonstrations": it doesn't start with any premise, doesn't apply any sort of logical transformations, but simply declared that I was wrong.

Let me add another one for the pseudo-skepticism part: If a designated authority figureTM makes a false claim then the group will accept any sort of argument or assertion, flawed or otherwise, to declare that the claim is not false (such as saying that "without exception" really means "there are exceptions", or that answering a direct request for a definition of CT with a statement about a property that all CTs have in common does not constitute providing a definition, or making an unsupported assertion that a "context" exists as if this were a magic word that makes any claim true) yet when someone outside the group makes a false claim any of these arguments get rejected.

* The answer is: it depends on who is doing it. If the person doing it is part of the designated set of authority figures then pointing this out gets dismissed as "pedantry" (authority figures can not be wrong, they are authority figures because they are never wrong...brilliant system) but if the person doing it is part of the designated set of "CTers" then pointing this out gets accepted as a valid counterargument.
And yet you continue to misrepresent what the ad hom fallacy is, unable to admit error. Then you nicely side step into accusations of Argument from Authority But Only When the Authority is the Desired/Approved One. I did not discuss that, yet you misapply that here, too. Your failure to see disagreements and corrections within the group you dislike is not refutation of the fact they exist.

Here's what I see as happening: you are demanding scientifically precise language from those you label pseudoskeptics, and if it falls short of the precision found in journals and well regarded papers then you pounce. Yet you fall short of that standard yourself while acting as if you do not.

It's what I fancy as the Pub and Labcoat Tactic.

Discussions among those whose knowledge and/or interests limit them to pub level wrangling are perfectly fine and can be perfectly fun. These are the discussions in which snark and in which guffaws accompany distilled -- and probably highly imperfect -- versions of better research get bandied about. One side might claim victory, but ultimately neither side should change its mind based on these discussions; at best, both sides should come away with an idea of where to look for competing information to either confirm or refute. Most discussions on this forum fall into Pub Talks.

Then there are the Labcoat Discussions. These are when both sides attempt actual rigor, probably falling short quite often but still attempting it and open to corrections when they do fall short. Most people are not qualified for these discussions at all or are qualified for only a few.

Of course, most discussions are a mix of the two. In my experience, most are Pub discussions that get periodically elevated with injections of Labcoat stuff. Such is the nature of most Bigfoot threads.

What should not happen is a dishonesty regarding one's attire. If you put on your greasy overalls and trucker cap then swear to the scientists that your Labcoat is lily white, you will get deservedly spanked. Likewise, if complain that others are wearing cowboy hats and spilling beer on your Labcoat, you better be sure that your Labcoat really was white to begin with. I'm afraid that your attire is mostly business casual despite your insistence otherwise.
 
Are we about Bigfoot again? I can't keep up, which is too bad because I would love to earn a complimentary bacon sandwich.

This liars, trolls, and fools thing is interesting, though. I want to make it liars, tools, and fools for poetic effect, but that's another story. The linear ranking of woo is a cool idea, perhaps deserving of a separate thread?
 
...
If you put on your greasy overalls and trucker cap then swear to the scientists that your Labcoat is lily white, you will get deservedly spanked. Likewise, if complain that others are wearing cowboy hats and spilling beer on your Labcoat, you better be sure that your Labcoat really was white to begin with. I'm afraid that your attire is mostly business casual despite your insistence otherwise.

:thumbsup:
Excellent job sir.
 
Are we about Bigfoot again? I can't keep up, which is too bad because I would love to earn a complimentary bacon sandwich.

This liars, trolls, and fools thing is interesting, though. I want to make it liars, tools, and fools for poetic effect, but that's another story. The linear ranking of woo is a cool idea, perhaps deserving of a separate thread?


Yes, I'm afraid Bigfoot rears his massive, yet invisible, ugly head again. It would seem that the Bigfoot issue led to the creation of this thread, i.e. why skeptics must be assigned silly names because they won't have serious discussions about something so stupid.

As I mentioned above discussing WHY dimwitted individuals feel it necessary to pretend to believe in such crap is worthy of discussion, as you hinted at. However discussing the possibility of magic monkey men being real is just silly.

For suggesting a new song title I award you a bacon sandwich.

ETA: A graphic of the linear woo ranking would be good. After my bath and ISF catch-up, (I'm a good multitasker), I had a Photoshop session planned anyway.....


Sent from my iNsomniPad using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
And yet you continue to misrepresent what the ad hom fallacy is

A: "X is true"
B: "A has bad property Y. X is false"

According to you B is not making an ad-hom argument merely because of the lack of the word "because" between those sentences.

unable to admit error.

A common tactic here. Just because someone will not accept some specific claim does not mean that person is "unable to admit error." If you took a look at my history on this forum you will find that I am readily able to admit error, but only if something is actually shown to be in error. By your standards OntarioSquatch can now assert that his/her critics are unable to admit error. I will leave it to you to find a name for this tactic.

Then you nicely side step into accusations of Argument from Authority But Only When the Authority is the Desired/Approved One. I did not discuss that

I've been discussing these sort of double standards here for a while now in this thread.

Your failure to see disagreements and corrections within the group you dislike is not refutation of the fact they exist.

Yet another so-called "error" that isn't an error, the existence of disagreements within a group does not refute that the group applies double standards towards those outside of the group.

Here's what I see as happening: you are demanding scientifically precise language

Not scientifically precise, just intelligible.

from those you label pseudoskeptics

I demand intelligible language from everyone, it is because I apply this to everyone that I can easily notice that the response of the group is different depending on whose inaccurate language I point out.

Yet you fall short of that standard yourself while acting as if you do not.

Feel free to point out any of these and you will indeed see how readily able I am to admit to error. For instance, I noticed that I misrepresented Jay Utah's statement earlier. I claimed that it said "invariably" whereas it said "without exception." See how it works? Actual error -> admitting to error, not an actual error -> not admitting to error.

What should not happen is a dishonesty regarding one's attire.

I make no claim about my attire. I will however note that you are arguing based on what type of clothing someone wears. But let me guess, that won't be an ad-hom either?
 
Caveman,
Your post are starting to sound a lot like this....
Edited by jsfisher: 
Image removed for compliance with Rule 12 of the Membership Agreement.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Caveman,
Your post are starting to sound a lot like this....
Edited by jsfisher: 
Image removed for compliance with Rule 12 of the Membership Agreement.

I suppose we can add this in with the "so not an ad-hom since the word 'because' isn't used"?

Also, refer to OntarioSquatch's equivalent claims about his/her critics psychological state, for the "so not double standards" part.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
A: "X is true"
B: "A has bad property Y. X is false"

According to you B is not making an ad-hom argument merely because of the lack of the word "because" between those sentences.



A common tactic here. Just because someone will not accept some specific claim does not mean that person is "unable to admit error." If you took a look at my history on this forum you will find that I am readily able to admit error, but only if something is actually shown to be in error. By your standards OntarioSquatch can now assert that his/her critics are unable to admit error. I will leave it to you to find a name for this tactic.



I've been discussing these sort of double standards here for a while now in this thread.



Yet another so-called "error" that isn't an error, the existence of disagreements within a group does not refute that the group applies double standards towards those outside of the group.



Not scientifically precise, just intelligible.



I demand intelligible language from everyone, it is because I apply this to everyone that I can easily notice that the response of the group is different depending on whose inaccurate language I point out.



Feel free to point out any of these and you will indeed see how readily able I am to admit to error. For instance, I noticed that I misrepresented Jay Utah's statement earlier. I claimed that it said "invariably" whereas it said "without exception." See how it works? Actual error -> admitting to error, not an actual error -> not admitting to error.



I make no claim about my attire. I will however note that you are arguing based on what type of clothing someone wears. But let me guess, that won't be an ad-hom either?
Let's stick to the Ad Hom bit to demonstrate the error.


Scenario 1

Claimant: Hypothesis A

Skeptic: Refutation B, replete with data plus valid and sound logic.

caveman1917: Well done.

Scenario 2

Claimant: Hypothesis A

Skeptic: Refutation B, replete with data plus valid and sound logic.
"Oh, and by the way, you're a poopyhead."

caveman1917: Nasty pseudoskeptic relies on Ad Hom, and the refutation is therefore invalid


See the difference?
 
I suppose we can add this in with the "so not an ad-hom since the word 'because' isn't used"?

Also, refer to OntarioSquatch's equivalent claims about his/her critics psychological state, for the "so not double standards" part.

I have no idea what your blathering on about now but it sounds like this....

Edited by jsfisher: 
Image removed for compliance with Rule 12 of the Membership Agreement.


Keep up the good work!!!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Let's stick to the Ad Hom bit to demonstrate the error.


Scenario 1

Claimant: Hypothesis A

Skeptic: Refutation B, replete with data plus valid and sound logic.

caveman1917: Well done.

Scenario 2

Claimant: Hypothesis A

Skeptic: Refutation B, replete with data plus valid and sound logic.
"Oh, and by the way,
you're a poopyhead."

caveman1917: Nasty pseudoskeptic relies on Ad Hom, and the refutation is therefore invalid


See the difference?

FTFY

Scenario 3

Claimant: Hypothesis A

Skeptic: Refutation B, replete with data plus valid and sound logic.
"Oh, and by the way, you're a poopyhead."

caveman1917:
"Refutation B, replete with data plus valid and sound logic." Well Done.
"Oh, and by the way, you're a poopyhead." Ad-hom.
 
Am I the only one who has noticed how so many of those on the unconventional end of the bell curve are utterly lacking a sense of humour?

This post is one example: Lopesito and Alan Lowey are two more.

I'm wondering if this is where they get the idea that they are being insulted. If you take humourous asides as ad hominem attacks, you might imagine insults everywhere. Caveman1917 seems to think that he is being given literal travel and sartorial advice. Alan Lowey's apparently irony-free use of the term "pogo mofo" again displays this po-faced literalism.
I don't want to go down the road of thinking that CT-ers are socially-inept loners, but I think there may be a grain of truth in the idea. Perhaps these posters are simply misinterpreting what everyone else (or I at least) sees as good-humoured joshing?


….it is blatantly naïve to (invariably) dismiss this stuff as ‘good-humored-joshing’. I’ve been on the receiving end of this kind of thing numerous times (no surprise…I don’t subscribe to much of the skeptic gospel). To put it simply, it is (frequently) malicious ridicule (or some variation thereof). The intention behind it (typically) is anything but good-humored.

OTOH…it surprises me not in the least. If you’re not prepared to deal with that kind of thing in a place like this, then don’t come to a place like this.

Nick Terry was kind enough to answer for me. I agree with him mostly and have therefore left a bacon sandwich on the doorstep for him.

In real life we don't devote time to debating whether a piece of blatantly untrue pile of codswallop is true or not. Harsh? Tough.

Getting upset about this won't change that. It doesn't mean that people calling the codswallop out for being what it is are big bad poopy heads. It simply means that there is no point debating baloney.

It's a waste of everyone's time. A pointless exercise.


I recall a thread some while back where quite a number of skeptics were (typically) trashing the views of a new poster (an ER nurse) who was arguing the case for NDE’s (this kind of thing seems to draw skeptics like flies to fly droppings). The skeptics were laying down the laws of physics …presuming that the nurse was ignorant (which she, quite understandably, was)…and would be cowed (which she was not…her views were as substantive as she was). The skeptics were very impressed with their superiority and the superiority of their arguments…until I sent their arguments to a friend of mind who is a theoretical physicist. He very quickly demolished every single one of them.

Moral #1 of the story: One man’s baloney is another man’s science.

Moral #2 of the story: Debating the 'baloney' was not a waste of time since it turned out there was much more of it than expected.

Discussing why people insist on being so gullible or in knowingly lying, however, is a different kettle of fish.

Sent from my iNsomniPad using Tapatalk


…yeah I guess the typical skeptic position on NDE’s does tick a bunch of the boxes in the OP. Don’t know if I’d call it ‘gullible’ or ‘lying’ given the massive complexity of the issues. Skeptics, after all, are human too. They want safety, security, familiarity, intelligibility. The warm and fuzzies. Unfortunately, if your philosophy is the exclusive function of rational materialism…you’re gonna fail!
 

Wikipedia

Since the mid-1960s, the phrase has denoted explanations that invoke conspiracies without warrant, often producing hypotheses that contradict the prevailing understanding of historical events or simple facts.


And yes, the CIA's guidelines seem to be much closer to how the term is used around here. Good for them for keeping up with the evolution of the term. It looks like they adopted the new usage almost immediately ("mid-1960s"). I don't fault Merriam-Webster, though. It's the nature of dictionaries to change very slowly, and rightly so.

In any case, dictionaries are descriptive, not prescriptive. I don't need a dictionary to describe to me how I use a word, or how those around me use it. Around here, it's a pejorative description indicating a fringe claim. If you insist that it can only be used without the fringe claim connotations, you'll waste a lot of time being misunderstood. If you insist on interpreting it without the fringe connotations, even after being told by the person using it that this is how they mean it, then you'll waste a lot of time being seen as a troll, rather than as a good-faith contributor to meaningful discussion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom