Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

But why is there disagreement or agreement? It all depends on whether there is evidence. Skepticism as a method emphasises evidence, and where evidence is absent or insufficient, or where evidence contradicts the fringe claim, then skeptics reject the fringe claim, including conspiracy theories.

I am aware of that.
 
I did indeed. Someone commented that they found it unnecessarily aggressive, so to err on the side of caution I didn't repost it.




I read the first 100 or so posts, as you asked. The only hyping of amateur astronomers that I could see was your repeated claims that they were being hyped. Astrophotographer stated explicitly that both pilots and amateur astronomers make mistakes. You appeared then, as now, to be arguing against strawmen.

#40, #70, #96, #

Apparently you didn't read the above posts from Astro nor any of the others in the first 100 that also commented on pilots, and you certainly didn't read past 100. 100 seems to be your lucky number. Don't bother asking for more examples in the first 100 because you didn't see any. I'm tired of doing your homework for you only to shrug your shoulder and be the Irish cop on the beat in New York that says, "Nothing to see here, folks, move along."

Also, did you see how many times I had to keep pounding away at the Joe Nickel vid before somebody would finally address it? Of course, you'd have to keep reading past the first 100 to do that.

I think this is a case of the Law of Intentionally Ignoring the Obvious™ or the

Law of Inability to Perceive the Obvious™

Enough of your denialism that masquerades as skepticism.
 
Last edited:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=145251&highlight=shamless+nickell
Start at post 13 and see an ongoing back and forth on pilots vs. A. astronomers between me and a guy called Astrophotographer.


Why not ask me to start reading at #40? I have a job, you know: posting here isn't a full-time occupation for me.

#40, #70, #96, #

Apparently you didn't read the above posts from Astro nor any of the others in the first 100 that also commented on pilots, and you certainly didn't read past 100. 100 seems to be your lucky number. Don't bother asking for more examples in the first 100 because you didn't see any. I'm tired of doing your homework for you only to shrug your shoulder and be the Irish cop on the beat in New York that says, "Nothing to see here, folks, move along."

In my view, reading 100 posts of a thread that you claim to be full of examples of whatever behaviour you are complaining about, should be enough.
I read posts commenting on pilots. I did not see any dismissing or brushing aside claims by pilots, which was your assertion. Let's see, shall we?

#40:
Astrophotographer said:
Pilots are just susceptible to errors in judgement for objects in the sky as anybody else. If a pilot can make a mistake flying a plane, he certainly can mistake a star, meteor, balloon for a UFO.
#70:
Astrophotographer said:
You missed my point about "pilot error" then. Pilots make mistakes just like any other human.......
We can dance around this all day but pilots and policemen are not much better at observations than most other people. When Dr. Hynek (sometimes called the "Galileo" of modern UFOlogy) looked at the bluebook data, he discovered that pilots made more mistakes than other types of observers. He stated:

"What we have here is a good example of a well-known psychological fact: "transference" of skill and experience does not usually take place. That is, an expert in one field does not necessarily "transfer" his competence to another one" (Hynek The UFO report p. 261).


If you want to describe a specific event we can go into that. However, the generic claim of pilots being infallible observers is not accurate. It has been shown time and time again to be false.
#96:
Astrophotographer said:
There are good pilots and there are bad pilots but there is no such thing as a pilot who can't make a mistake.....
Pilots are great at flying and I do not doubt their skills at this. However, looking at the past history of pilot error, it does not mean they are great at identifying an unknown.....
No, it is you who seems to be stuck in the mindset of not recognizing issues associated with these reports. You have made blanket statements without being familiar with the case histories. I have actually looked at some of these case histories. Have you? Have you read about all these mistakes made by military pilots (i.e. chasing stars, swerving to avoid re-entering debris/meteors, confusing the setting moon peaking out of some clouds, etc. etc.)? It is you who have not bothered to even look at these histories and see if they can be explained.

I think these quotes speak for themselves in utterly refuting your claim that Astrophotographer is dismissing or brushing aside pilot testimony, and hyping amateur astronomers.

Also, did you see how many times I had to keep pounding away at the Joe Nickel vid before somebody would finally address it? Of course, you'd have to keep reading past the first 100 to do that.

I did. Possibly it was because of this:

Astrophotographer said:
If you want to start a thread on human levitation, go right ahead.I started to watch the clip and could not figure out what it had to do with UFOs. Stay on topic.

Another quote which speaks for itself.

I think this is a case of the Law of Intentionally Ignoring the Obvious™ or the

Law of Inability to Perceive the Obvious™

Enough of your denialism that masquerades as skepticism.

On the contrary, I think this is yet another example of your tendencies to try to hijack threads, misinterpret (deliberately or not I do not know) the posts of those debating with you, and to create your own "laws" in an attempt to add some scientific underpinning to your apparent inability to address what is actually being said to you, your inability to address the evidence presented to you, and your unwillingness to even consider the possibility that others who disagree with you may have a point.
 
As for "attacking the arguer instead of the argument" there is, in this thread alone:

1. Your claim where you imagine some sort of "fence" to then put me on the other side of, as well as your advice who I should or should not go into an alley with.
2. Carlitos who argues whether he should take me seriously (as opposed to my argument).
3. tsig and abaddon who are talking about some sort of t-shirt I should or should not get.
4. abaddon's statement about "cranks and their ilk."

All of which are ad-homs which do not address the arguments.

Am I the only one who has noticed how so many of those on the unconventional end of the bell curve are utterly lacking a sense of humour?

This post is one example: Lopesito and Alan Lowey are two more.

I'm wondering if this is where they get the idea that they are being insulted. If you take humourous asides as ad hominem attacks, you might imagine insults everywhere. Caveman1917 seems to think that he is being given literal travel and sartorial advice. Alan Lowey's apparently irony-free use of the term "pogo mofo" again displays this po-faced literalism.
I don't want to go down the road of thinking that CT-ers are socially-inept loners, but I think there may be a grain of truth in the idea. Perhaps these posters are simply misinterpreting what everyone else (or I at least) sees as good-humoured joshing?
 
Am I the only one who has noticed how so many of those on the unconventional end of the bell curve are utterly lacking a sense of humour?

This post is one example: Lopesito and Alan Lowey are two more.

I'm wondering if this is where they get the idea that they are being insulted. If you take humourous asides as ad hominem attacks, you might imagine insults everywhere. Caveman1917 seems to think that he is being given literal travel and sartorial advice. Alan Lowey's apparently irony-free use of the term "pogo mofo" again displays this po-faced literalism.
I don't want to go down the road of thinking that CT-ers are socially-inept loners, but I think there may be a grain of truth in the idea. Perhaps these posters are simply misinterpreting what everyone else (or I at least) sees as good-humoured joshing?


These days it might be deemed racial slurring or hate speech if CT-ers were purple people.

Bearing in mind this is a skeptic forum, this type of joshing generally IMO can be almost as harmless as joshing about oneself.
 
Am I the only one who has noticed how so many of those on the unconventional end of the bell curve are utterly lacking a sense of humour?

I didn't see you ask for "non-humorous" examples. It's a simple fact that the statements are arguing the arguer rather than the argument.

I'm wondering if this is where they get the idea that they are being insulted.

Who said anything about being insulted? Saying good things about someone[*] is equally ad-hom as insulting someone. The point isn't about how insulting an ad-hom might be, but that it is fallacious either way.

* Hence why I'll equally reject as an ad-hom Garrette's statement that I'm "highly intelligent and capable of deep analytic thought" as your statements regarding where you think I am in relation to some fence you think exists.
 
Last edited:
Am I the only one who has noticed how so many of those on the unconventional end of the bell curve are utterly lacking a sense of humour?



This post is one example: Lopesito and Alan Lowey are two more.



I'm wondering if this is where they get the idea that they are being insulted. If you take humourous asides as ad hominem attacks, you might imagine insults everywhere. Caveman1917 seems to think that he is being given literal travel and sartorial advice. Alan Lowey's apparently irony-free use of the term "pogo mofo" again displays this po-faced literalism.

I don't want to go down the road of thinking that CT-ers are socially-inept loners, but I think there may be a grain of truth in the idea. Perhaps these posters are simply misinterpreting what everyone else (or I at least) sees as good-humoured joshing?


It's baffling isn't it? Getting upset for the sake of getting upset.
However, continue reading and I'm sure more of the same will be presented.


Sent from my iNsomniPad using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
Personally speaking, I've gotten some extreme veiled insults and insinuations masked as joke from at least 3 different people here and it's always the same people.


It's baffling isn't it? Getting upset for the sake of getting upset.
However, continue reading and I'm sure more of the same will be presented.

Your own posts in AAH tell a very different story.
 
Personally speaking, I've gotten some extreme veiled insults and insinuations masked as joke from at least 3 different people here and it's always the same people.




Your own posts in AAH tell a very different story.


If you're referring to the fact that I don't tiptoe around on eggshells when liars lie, BSers BS, conmen con and Trolls Troll....... So what?

It doesn't alter the fact that there is a certain type of person around here who wouldn't recognise sarcasm, irony or humour if it slapped them in the face with a moist kipper while they were complaining about people being big bad meanies for not discussing their gibberish.

Watch, I'll do it again:
Anyone who pretends to believe in FigBoot is either a liar, a troll or a deluded fool.
Slapping as much pseudo-psych-babble as you like on that doesn't make me wrong.


Sent from my iNsomniPad using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
If you're referring to the fact that I don't tiptoe around on eggshells when liars lie, BSers BS, conmen con and Trolls Troll....... So what?

It doesn't alter the fact that there is a certain type of person around here who wouldn't recognise sarcasm, irony or humour if it slapped them in the face with a moist kipper while they were complaining about people being big bad meanies for not discussing their gibberish.

Watch, I'll do it again:
Anyone who pretends to believe in FigBoot is either a liar, a troll or a deluded fool.Slapping as much pseudo-psych-babble as you like on that doesn't make me wrong.


Sent from my iNsomniPad using Tapatalk



Could you please add whichever other beliefs merit the same or similar assessment in your view ?
 
Could you please add whichever other beliefs merit the same or similar assessment in your view ?

This is actually a good question. Clearly, there is a continuum of proven to plausible to possible to unlikely to highly implausible to utterly impossible phenomena. Where a belief sits on that continuum can and does change over time. If believers have been caught or have admitted fabricating evidence, then that might well make the belief as a whole less credible.

Ranking beliefs by plausibility could be tough. Here's a quick go for some popular ones, the left hand side is least plausible, the right hand side more plausible.

Flat-earthism > Shroud of Turin > Bigfoot > Jesus bloodline theories > alien abductions > Roswell alien spacecraft crash > UFOs-in-general actually being visitors from another world > 9/11 conspiracy theories > JFK assassination conspiracy theories

I'd personally rank anything through to Roswell as believable only by "liars, trolls or deluded fools", with deluded fools making up by far the greatest proportion of believers.

Since UFOs are a real phenomenon, as in many people have sighted unidentified flying objects over the past 70 years, then by definition investigating them cannot be entirely deluded. Believing that they are alien spacecraft from another world is potentially more deluded, but the delusions really start with the famous cases, like Roswell. Anyone claiming to have been abducted by aliens is certainly suffering from a delusion or implanted suggestion.

A number of hardcore believers in 9/11 or JFK assassination conspiracy theories are also deluded fools, liars or trolls, depending on their precise claims, many of which are physically impossible. But they're not really on the same level as flat-earthers, right?
 
Could you please add whichever other beliefs merit the same or similar assessment in your view ?


Nick Terry was kind enough to answer for me. I agree with him mostly and have therefore left a bacon sandwich on the doorstep for him.

In real life we don't devote time to debating whether a piece of blatantly untrue pile of codswallop is true or not. Harsh? Tough.

Getting upset about this won't change that. It doesn't mean that people calling the codswallop out for being what it is are big bad poopy heads. It simply means that there is no point debating baloney. It's a waste of everyone's time. A pointless exercise.

Discussing why people insist on being so gullible or in knowingly lying, however, is a different kettle of fish.


Sent from my iNsomniPad using Tapatalk
 
Personally speaking, I've gotten some extreme veiled insults and insinuations masked as joke from at least 3 different people here and it's always the same people.




Your own posts in AAH tell a very different story.
Yours repeatedly tell the same. Still no comment on the highly edited video. The reason is obvious.
 
Last edited:
--snip--

* Hence why I'll equally reject as an ad-hom Garrette's statement that I'm "highly intelligent and capable of deep analytic thought" as your statements regarding where you think I am in relation to some fence you think exists.
Ah a different topic, but that demonstrates my point.

An insult (or praise) is not an ad hom by virtue of being an insult (or praise). It is only an ad hom if one says "Your argument is invalid BECAUSE of [insult]." It is not an ad hom if one says "Your argument is invalid AND ALSO [insult].

Since the things you erroneously call ad homs were ancillary to the demonstration of how you were wrong, they are not ad homs at all. Your further erroneous denials that such demonstration occurred are as irrelevant as your misrepresentation of the ad hom fallacy.
 
Watch, I'll do it again:
Anyone who pretends to believe in FigBoot is either a liar, a troll or a deluded fool.

Well if those are my only options, I guess I'll go with deluded fool. At least there is some pizzazz associated with that label. I have added it to my signature so I don't ever forget.
 
Ah a different topic, but that demonstrates my point.

I don't think you know what the term demonstration means.

An insult (or praise) is not an ad hom by virtue of being an insult (or praise). It is only an ad hom if one says "Your argument is invalid BECAUSE of [insult]." It is not an ad hom if one says "Your argument is invalid AND ALSO [insult].

(P AND Q) => (P => Q) is a tautology. What do we call a "demonstration" which denies a tautology?[*]

Since the things you erroneously call ad homs were ancillary to the demonstration of how you were wrong, they are not ad homs at all. Your further erroneous denials that such demonstration occurred are as irrelevant as your misrepresentation of the ad hom fallacy.

No demonstration occurred. Or rather, there was one demonstration, which was me demonstrating how I was right. Notice the difference in form: I started at the premise, applied a sequence of logical transformations, and arrived at the conclusion. Notice the form of yours and Jay Utah's "demonstrations": it doesn't start with any premise, doesn't apply any sort of logical transformations, but simply declared that I was wrong.

Let me add another one for the pseudo-skepticism part: If a designated authority figureTM makes a false claim then the group will accept any sort of argument or assertion, flawed or otherwise, to declare that the claim is not false (such as saying that "without exception" really means "there are exceptions", or that answering a direct request for a definition of CT with a statement about a property that all CTs have in common does not constitute providing a definition, or making an unsupported assertion that a "context" exists as if this were a magic word that makes any claim true) yet when someone outside the group makes a false claim any of these arguments get rejected.

* The answer is: it depends on who is doing it. If the person doing it is part of the designated set of authority figures then pointing this out gets dismissed as "pedantry" (authority figures can not be wrong, they are authority figures because they are never wrong...brilliant system) but if the person doing it is part of the designated set of "CTers" then pointing this out gets accepted as a valid counterargument.
 
Last edited:
Yours repeatedly tell the same. Still no comment on the highly edited video. The reason is obvious.

If you're talking about the video on the study that was done on the biomechanics seen in the PGF, that video wasn't edited at all. It came straight out and unedited from the MonsterQuest documentary, which you can confirm for yourself.

I've already answered your question about what research I did on the study, but it wasn't to your satisfaction. If you're just wondering whether or not I contacted the professor, the answer is no.
 
If you're referring to the fact that I don't tiptoe around on eggshells when liars lie, BSers BS, conmen con and Trolls Troll....... So what?

It doesn't alter the fact that there is a certain type of person around here who wouldn't recognise sarcasm, irony or humour if it slapped them in the face with a moist kipper while they were complaining about people being big bad meanies for not discussing their gibberish.

Watch, I'll do it again:
Anyone who pretends to believe in FigBoot is either a liar, a troll or a deluded fool.
Slapping as much pseudo-psych-babble as you like on that doesn't make me wrong.


Sent from my iNsomniPad using Tapatalk

It sounds like you get angry when someone causes you to doubt your idea of reality.
 
Last edited:
Jesus Christ.

caveman1917, "conspiracy theory" is a figure of speech. It does not derive its definition literally from the two words that compose it.

It's a pejorative, used to indicate that a claim is bogus, usually a claim that requires the existence of a conspiracy to cover up the evidence that would rescue the claim from its bogosity.

Thus the employment of the two-stage, asymmetrical argument that JayUtah describes.

The theory of the assassination of Julius Caesar by a conspiracy including Brutus is not a "conspiracy theory".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom