Show me that Science proves there is no god

That being said Belz stated that a god would have to break all the rules of physics to exist (as if that would even apply to a god) to which I simply showed an extensive list of some of the crazy things scientists tell me to believe and to which I do believe.

I then said that if my god simply had as a minimum those same attributes he would not be breaking any laws of physics.

These were never used as a proof of anything except as proof that those crazy things are already predicted and proven by science.

Belz said that certain definitions of god would break laws of physics.

And once again, you can't just say, 'There are things in the universe that can do this, therefore if there's a god he's not breaking any laws of physics.' Just because a photon travels at the speed of light, it doesn't mean that I can travel at the speed of light. For me to do that would involve me 'breaking' one of the laws of physics. If you're going to say that your god doesn't break any laws of physics, you're going to need evidence of that, not wild inaccurate extrapolations.
 
If I misunderstood anything it's my fault. But still - the question is the same - and I have heard such claims.

I have heard Richard Dawkins made this claim, but I haven't read his book yet so I'm assuming (and hoping) he meant The Scientific Method. I'm a bit sceptical on how the media portrays these type of books.
Dawkins certainly didn't claim that the existence of God could be disproved by science.
 
Dawkins definitely said that any statements made regarding the existence of God are statements made about our the reality that surrounds us. The reality that surrounds us is amenable to scientific investigation, therefore statements made concerning God are well within the bounds of scientific investigation. Read the book. He doesn't define a "God Hypothesis" because he thinks God ideas are OUTSIDE science.
 
Science can say we have no more evidence for God existence than Xenu's existence... or Zeus's existence...

I think Zeus' is a poor addition to the list because the Olympians were given a precise location. Humans have scaled it to it's peak and not found any bearded deities in togas lounging around.
 
I think Zeus' is a poor addition to the list because the Olympians were given a precise location. Humans have scaled it to it's peak and not found any bearded deities in togas lounging around.

Du'h! they are only visible to the human eye if they want to be, or if it makes for a good story.
 
Dawkins definitely said that any statements made regarding the existence of God are statements made about our the reality that surrounds us. The reality that surrounds us is amenable to scientific investigation, therefore statements made concerning God are well within the bounds of scientific investigation. Read the book. He doesn't define a "God Hypothesis" because he thinks God ideas are OUTSIDE science.

Dawkins does indeed define a "God Hypothesis". In chapter 2 of The God Delusion he defines it thusly:

Instead I shall define the God Hypothesis more defensibly: there exists a superhuman, supernatural intelligence who deliberately designed and created the universe and everything in it, including us.

Dawkins's book is devoted to demonstrating that it is highly improbable that this hypothesis is true.
 
Not to be misunderstood - I have never claimed I have evidence anyone here would consider evidence.

Not to be misunderstood - That's not evidence.

Evidence is not subject to interpretation and considerations. If I say elephants exists and here is the proof and proceed to show you a living elephant, you'd be a damn fool to not consider that evidence.

If you allready know other people will not consider it evidence, you should probably stop calling it evidence, in order to not create a false impression.

Evidence is evidence regardless at who looks at it, that's the beauty of it, that's also why we can even have judical system, science and even (applying reductio ad absurdum the correct way and not logically invalid) why we can make appointments with people at certain times etc etc etc..
(Just like I probably won't consider your evidence against his existence as evidence - I have yet to read Richard Dawkin's book to see what evidence he considers)

You'd be wise to withold your opinions on Dawkin's untill you at least have shown him the courtesy of reading his books.

Trust me, he's read your book(the bible) before offering his opinion.

I specifically state that any Supernatural evidence I may have would only be accepted by me because it can not be tested by science

It's actually the standard everyone uses for everything except for their religious views.

And being testable by science mean little more than "If someone else does the same things they will get the same results"

(which is the standard people here and in that othe thread are using to measure evidence for God by)

How would you have us measure the evidence?

Count the words and than go.. now that's really good evidence..

or experienced by you.

Why not?

I also stated that any natural evidence I accept would probably not be accepted by anyone else.

You deliberately don't give examples again to pretend you have something you do not have, actual natural evidence.

And again, don't call it evidence if you allready know it's not evidence.

That being said Belz stated that a god would have to break all the rules of physics to exist

He added "depending on the defenition for god", which you've chosen to ignore probably because it's inconvenient.

(as if that would even apply to a god)

Why would it not, how can an entity exist or influence a system where laws of physics exist without either sticking to those laws or annihilating the universe.

(this is a serious question with deep implications, please think about it deeply, don't just brush it aside. If you don't understand the problem, please be honest about that too).

to which I simply showed an extensive list of some of the crazy things scientists tell me to believe and to which I do believe.

I'm getting a bit confused, could we either merge the threads or stick to the points brought up in this one?

I then said that if my god simply had as a minimum those same attributes he would not be breaking any laws of physics.

I would say that this statement shows a lack of understanding of physics.

These were never used as a proof of anything except as proof that those crazy things are already predicted and proven by science.

You're not making sense, and I'm not sure you know enough about all of science to make the above statement with any degree of certainty.


Again, please either have the threads merged or keep the two discussions seperate.

I already said if it was you - sorry for misunderstanding. But the question has been raised by other people I know and I want to make sure I'm not missing something.


I have to echo the sentiment of some people here, you seem to have ulterior motives, and aren't really interested in the issue asa presented in the OP.

While I will not yell troll as soon as some others on this board, beware that there's very little tolerance for these kind of underhanded tactics on this board.
 
Last edited:
OK,

Since this came up unasked for in a different thread it's made me curious and I would like some answers.

The claim was made that science proves there is no god.

Please read the following closely:
Don't bother asking me to prove there is a God, because I can't. I have never claimed I could. In fact, I do not think science can prove that god exists or doesn't exist. All it can do is prove that it "appears" god exists or it "appears" god doesn't exist.

And by god it could be anything beyond the universe outside it or what have you. A First Cause or the God of the Christians. It doesn't matter.

Again I don't want to know why you think god isn't there. I want to know how and where science proves this.

And yes - I really want to know. I'm a sceptic and that means I'm willing to change my beliefs if needed.

*** But again - I'm not looking for things like "There's evil - so god doesn't exist" or anything like that but something like:

Scientist Bill did this experiment and it proved there was no god.

you know - using the scientific method.

NOTE: This obviously is only attended at someone who thinks science can do this one way or another. I DON'T!

ANOTHER NOTE: I do not want to debate this or fight. I will not respond - I will not counter-point - I will read any scientific literature that shows this.

Of course science cannot prove god does not exist, any more than it can prove the non-existance of anything else you care to come up with.

I'm not sure how much this matters though. We don't usually believe things just because we can't be 100% sure they are not true. Rationally we should believe things we have have a good reason to believe are true. God doesn't answer to that description.
 
Dawkins definitely said that any statements made regarding the existence of God are statements made about our the reality that surrounds us. The reality that surrounds us is amenable to scientific investigation, therefore statements made concerning God are well within the bounds of scientific investigation.
Then he's definetely wrong.

Read the book. He doesn't define a "God Hypothesis" because he thinks God ideas are OUTSIDE science.
MC says the opposite. Would you clarify, please?

Herzblut
 
Dawkins does indeed define a "God Hypothesis". In chapter 2 of The God Delusion he defines it thusly:

Instead I shall define the God Hypothesis more defensibly: there exists a superhuman, supernatural intelligence who deliberately designed and created the universe and everything in it, including us.

Dawkins's book is devoted to demonstrating that it is highly improbable that this hypothesis is true.
Just that this methodology has absolutely nothing to do with science.

Herzblut
 
Science doesn't even prove Newton's Laws of Motion. It can't prove why aeroplanes don't fall out of the sky, or why boats float.
What DO you mean by that? Those things can be explained conclusively.

Hans
 
The claim is correct.

As a starting point I'd study the scientific paper cited below which gives a concise overview of current investigations in the area of Hermeneutics (=scientific disproval of God):

Transgressing the Boundaries: Towards a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity
Alan D. Sokal, Department of Physics, New York University


<link removed>


Expecting an exciting discussion
Herzblut


I guess I am going to need your help understanding the paper.
I don't know anything about this paper being a hoax or not - but I read it, and all it seems to say is that for more subtle effects even the slight influence of the researcher needs to be addressed because it may actually be the causal variable - but the citation was pretty dense and hurt my brain.
What part addressed the question in the OP?
 
What DO you mean by that? Those things can be explained conclusively.

Hans

Off you go, then. Take all the space you need, and use both sides of the paper if you need to.

"Proof" is not something that science can do. End of story.

It can disprove things till the cows come home. But it has proved nothing at all ever.

Demonstrating something is not the same as proving it.
 
I just didn't want Epicurus' contribution to be rejected as unscientific. It is observation based. Natural science. It's only fault is that it doesn't refute the Flying Spaghetti Monster -- very pro-pirate, therefore very pro-evil.


It also fails to refute Athena's existence. Athena is a limited goddess: She has only a defined portfolio and an amount of personal power. Neither evil nor turtles are under her aspect.
 
Just that this methodology has absolutely nothing to do with science.

Herzblut

I disagree. So does Dawkins. The hypothesis that a God exists is a scientific hypothesis that can be examined and tested. As Dawkins says in Chapter 2 of The God Delusion:
Either he exists or he doesn't. It is a scientific question; one day we may know the answer, and meawhile we can say something pretty strong about the probability.


Later in this same chapter, Dawkins attacks Stephen Jay Gould for stating that scientists cannot comment on God's possible superintendence of nature:
Despite the confident, almost bullying, tone of Gould's assertion, what, actually, is the justification for it? Why shouldn't we comment on God, as scientists? And why isn't Russell's teapot, or the Flying Spaghetti Monster, equally immune from scientific scepticism? As I shall argue in a moment, a universe with a creative superintendent would be a very different kind of universe from one without. Why is that not a scientific matter?


The scientific methodology that Dawkins applies to the "God Hypothesis" is in no way different from the scientific methodology he applies to the theory of evolution.
 
I thought the same thing myself at first, but realized Henners was probably focusing on the word "prove", not suggesting a lack of scientific explanations of those things.

it seems you were correct in that realisation,

I have used science succesfully to prove my bread often, therefore science has proved something rendering the statement "it has proved nothing at all ever" as incorrect.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom