Show me that Science proves there is no god

*groan*

I thought I had escaped Oliver. But no, someone had to quote one of his little rants.
 
Hi, ACS. What evidence would convince you that your god doesn't exist?
 
Last edited:
"Science" has revealed an immense universe at least 156 billion light-years wide.
Wow! That's huge. But, well, I believe that with a proper vehical one might cross the whole universe within, say, one hour. What do you think?

There are billions of galaxies - each containing billions of stars and planets.
Says who? What I mean is the planets, have we not discovered just a few of them?

Why do Christians/Muslims/Jews think this creation was made for them?
Why do you think they think so?

Science can't prove there isn't a God - but it can make you realize that you'd make a better God then the one we (supposedly) have! So what kind of God is that?!
I'm sorry but, why should I realize that?

Herzblut
 
There's all kinds of things that would convince a skeptic exists... And god would certainly know what those are-- but measurable specific and clear evidence would be nice-- something to distinguish god from delusions of gods we don't believe in.

But can anyone convince a believer there are no gods? Anything? Any amount of evidence? What if they've really been inculcated with the meme that faith is necessary for faith, morality, and salvation? I think there's a time when the brain just is "unable" to think certain thoughts-- and it causes you to feel defensive and hateful to anyone who says anything that threatens your pet delusion.

I try to ask believers the following questions, but even the questions piss them off.

1. If there was no god, would you want to know?
2. How do you suppose you'd find out if there was no god?
 
Last edited:
At last count, 268 (a bit more than a few, a lot less than billions). However, we have only just begun to apply technologies capable of looking at nearby systems, and may soon be able to extrapolate further.

http://exoplanet.eu/catalog.php

There are more stars in the universe than grains of sand on the beach... and who knows how many of them are part of a solar system with multiple orbiting planets like our own star, the sun.
 
Come on. I'm pretty sure it was meant to be funny.

Hm. I hope I'm not the one who's been had now.

"Funny"? What you mean by "funny"?

Look - amongst all those flappdoodle posts in the thread I'm the only one providing serious hermeneutical (=scientifically disproving god) evidence.

And what's the result? Evidence is slandered and called "hoax", my whole post is considered "funny"...

I honestly doubt this board actually deserves me.

:confused:

In diesem oder jenen Sinne und mit vielen Grüssen von

Herzblut

My word, I think he thinks it's real! danielk, I think you have been had.
 
It seems that, if this is an indicator:

-Fran- said:
He's probably referring to me?:confused.
A Christian Sceptic said:
If I misunderstood anything it's my fault. But still - the question is the same - and I have heard such claims.

that this whole thread WAS started by ACS because of what was discussed on the thread linked here (starting from my involvement in ACS's arguments, on page 36 and the following pages.)

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=99188&page=36

ACS actually does claim several times that he has evidence that god exists. I asked to be shown what they were. He didn't want to, saying I wouldn't accept them anyway. Finally he did explain what he meant by evidence and I argued that I didn't think they were evidence at all. Somewhere in that discussion he seems to say that I claim science has disproven god. Though I have explained earlier in this thread what I meant. I admit that in the earlier discussion we had in the other thread I may have said some things wrong, I'm not very good at debating such things :o. But, yeah, it definitely seems to me that he did claim evidence of god's existence, and I did think he wasn't able to back that claim up.
 
Last edited:
Wow! That's huge. But, well, I believe that with a proper vehical one might cross the whole universe within, say, one hour. What do you think?

...you mean like...a rocket car? I'm in!! OK, we're gonna need to get XM radio, because I'm not traveling across the universe with you griping about the sores on your feet. (You know how I hate that) We'll make sandwiches for the trip to save money. (Cause...you know...the gas is going to be out of this world.) Maybe we should get a gas card.

Says who? What I mean is the planets, have we not discovered just a few of them?

I think with a universe that big I'm allowed to extrapolate a little.


Why do you think they think so?

Their stupid ancient books tell them to.


(Am I doing alright?)


I'm sorry but, why should I realize that?

Would you eliminate pain and suffering if you were god?
 
Last edited:
Somewhere in that discussion he seems to say that I claim science has disproven god. Though I have explained earlier in this thread what I meant. I admit that in the earlier discussion we had in the other thread I may have said some things wrong, I'm not very good at debating such things :o.
Of course not. :cool: But did you spot Belzies post

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3238017&postcount=1492

where he publicized the kind of nonsense we might be looking for:

In fact, the existence of a god would be contrary to the laws of physics we know, at least under several definitions of "god".

Herzblut
 
Last edited:
Those are only defining characteristics of some representations of god. Since CS did not limit the conception of god thus in the OP, you have proved nothing germane.

Don't be silly. First of all, his name has christian in it, and goodness and omnipotence are certainly defining characteristics of the christian god. Second, if we're not allowed to assume even the most basic attributes, the question becomes even stupider than ever - it's like asking someone to disprove the existence of aslknaklfnaf, never mind what it is.

There is another way science and logic can weigh in on this question. Suppose we imagine a world in which there is no god, and life on earth has come into being through a process similar to the one our science believes really happened. Or if you can't conceive of that, imagine a world god set in motion and then left utterly untouched (which an omnipotent god could do if she wanted).

Now, in that world people have come into being. Question: would those people come to believe in god? If the answer is yes, it should make us very suspicious of that belief in our own world. If people will believe in something no matter what the truth is, then the fact of their belief provides no support whatsoever for the truth of that something. And if there's no support for the existence of god it is merely one of an infinite number of possible mutually exclusive beliefs. And since there are an infinite number, the probability that one particular one is correct is zero.

So the only question is whether people would come to believe in god in such a world. That's hard to answer definitively, but I think most people would agree it's highly likely. Ergo, god does not exist.

EDIT - oh, and by the way, the size of the universe is not a very well-defined concept because the spacetime is curved. However 156 billion lightyears is too large by any definition. The age is between 13 and 14 billion years, and the radius in lightyears (by the standard estimates) is about 3 times that.
 
Last edited:
...you mean like...a rocket car? I'm in!!
I actually recommend to leave the technical details to next generations of engineers and scientists.

Their stupid ancient books tell them to.
Hold a minute, these books say that God created the world as an exclusive service to the respective group of adherents? Where did you find this detail if I may ask?

Would you eliminate pain and suffering if you were god?
Yes. I'd first focus my selfless efforts on resolving the most severe suffering: the sexual frustration of those millions of sharp, gorgeous chicas around the world, especially in Brazil. :D

Herzblut
 
Last edited:
ACS actually does claim several times that he has evidence that god exists. I asked to be shown what they were. He didn't want to, saying I wouldn't accept them anyway. Finally he did explain what he meant by evidence and I argued that I didn't think they were evidence at all.

Not to be misunderstood - I have never claimed I have evidence anyone here would consider evidence. (Just like I probably won't consider your evidence against his existence as evidence - I have yet to read Richard Dawkin's book to see what evidence he considers) I specifically state that any Supernatural evidence I may have would only be accepted by me because it can not be tested by science (which is the standard people here and in that othe thread are using to measure evidence for God by) or experienced by you. I also stated that any natural evidence I accept would probably not be accepted by anyone else.

That being said Belz stated that a god would have to break all the rules of physics to exist (as if that would even apply to a god) to which I simply showed an extensive list of some of the crazy things scientists tell me to believe and to which I do believe.

I then said that if my god simply had as a minimum those same attributes he would not be breaking any laws of physics.

These were never used as a proof of anything except as proof that those crazy things are already predicted and proven by science.

You can read that post here:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3239317#post3239317


Somewhere in that discussion he seems to say that I claim science has disproven god.

I already said if it was you - sorry for misunderstanding. But the question has been raised by other people I know and I want to make sure I'm not missing something.
 
Last edited:
I already said if it was you - sorry for misunderstanding. But the question has been raised by other people I know and I want to make sure I'm not missing something.

That's OK. And I do understand that this is not only about me. Just wanted to show the thread that I thought you were referring to in this thread's OP. I do see though that other things also are behind your question here.
 
Not to be misunderstood - I have never claimed I have evidence anyone here would consider evidence. (Just like I probably won't consider your evidence against his existence as evidence - I have yet to read Richard Dawkin's book to see what evidence he considers) I specifically state that any Supernatural evidence I may have would only be accepted by me because it can not be tested by science (which is the standard people here and in that othe thread are using to measure evidence for God by) or experienced by you. I also stated that any natural evidence I accept would probably not be accepted by anyone else.

That being said Belz stated that a god would have to break all the rules of physics to exist (as if that would even apply to a god) to which I simply showed an extensive list of some of the crazy things scientists tell me to believe and to which I do believe.

I then said that if my god simply had as a minimum those same attributes he would not be breaking any laws of physics.

These were never used as a proof of anything except as proof that those crazy things are already predicted and proven by science.

You can read that post here:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3239317#post3239317

I know, I remember well your reasoning from the other thread, and I understand what you are saying. What I don't understand is why you would use the word "evidence" at all? :confused:
 
The claim is correct.

As a starting point I'd study the scientific paper cited below which gives a concise overview of current investigations in the area of Hermeneutics (=scientific disproval of God):

Transgressing the Boundaries: Towards a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity
Alan D. Sokal, Department of Physics, New York University


http://www.physics.nyu.edu/faculty/sokal/transgress_v2/transgress_v2_singlefile.html


Expecting an exciting discussion
Herzblut

FAIL
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom