Show me that Science proves there is no god

Hmm this thread does seem to go toward proving that ACS is a troll.

Why else start a new thread so full of based on an exaggeration or logical fallacy?

ACS the best way of putting it is that a belief in god is unscientific because there is no evidence for god and any suggested evidence for god has been shown to have non god explanations. As there is an infinite number of possible beliefs that have no supporting evidence, it is unscientific to believe in god.
 
Hmm this thread does seem to go toward proving that ACS is a troll.
Why is this necessary? I find A Christian Sceptic's openness and willingness to engage in discussion admirable. I wish more religious people were like him.

Why else start a new thread so full of based on an exaggeration or logical fallacy?
One dumb thread doesn't make one a troll, unless perhaps if that's the only contribution.
 
First you would have to define "evil".

In my experience, very few people will argue that there is no evil in the world.

But, as already pointed out, the OP leaves god pretty much undefined. Which is why my main answer is stolen from Sagan.

I just didn't want Epicurus' contribution to be rejected as unscientific. It is observation based. Natural science. It's only fault is that it doesn't refute the Flying Spaghetti Monster -- very pro-pirate, therefore very pro-evil.
 
Why is this necessary? I find A Christian Sceptic's openness and willingness to engage in discussion admirable. I wish more religious people were like him.

It is starting this thread after abandoning his previous thread asking athiests to define the god that they want to believe in that is what I base that assertion on.

I might be wrong, but it does seem odd to create such thread, it does seem like trolling.
 
While science does not prove that there is no Imaginary Bearded Sky Daddy, it is also true that there is no evidence whatsoever that any such imaginary super-pals exist.

In the total absence of evidence for the existence of an invisible self aware and bad tempered item with no mass or energy, a rational person might be expected to refrain from asserting that it exists.
 
Last edited:
Science does not deal with the disproving of a god. If anything, it would try to prove that there is a god because science deals with proving things theoretically & empirically. With the aid of science we may end up with a conclusion that there is no need for a god in order for nature to be as it is (as Richard Dawkins says).
In fact, as Hokulele has said, trying to prove there is no god is trying to prove a negative which is impossible as it is impossible to prove that lettuce has no feelings or that there is no flying spaghetti monster: http://www.venganza.org/

Regards,
Yair
 
A First Cause or the God of the Christians. It doesn't matter.
Nothing to do with science, but I think logic shows the God of the Christians doesn't exist. Most Christians would define him as being (1) All good, (2) All powerful, and (3) All knowing.

I'm not looking for things like "There's evil - so god doesn't exist" or anything like that
Oops, never mind.
 
It is starting this thread after abandoning his previous thread asking athiests to define the god that they want to believe in that is what I base that assertion on.

I might be wrong, but it does seem odd to create such thread, it does seem like trolling.


I wanted to know what people thought. People posted. People stopped posting. It died - why is that me abandoning it? But I understand.

I might add - I appreciated peoples responses - it was very interesting. I have many other ideas for posts, but now I'm thinking maybe theres no point if all people will post is questions of why I posted it, etc.

I did appreciate the Carl Sagan link although not directly related. I enjoy his writings and loved COSMOS.
 
Last edited:
I'm in a pretty good mood right now, so I'll take the question as it is. I'm thinking that ACS is referencing Dawkins' latest book, where Dawkins says that Science can weigh in on the "god" question. ACS' statement seems to be a roundabout way of expressing Dawkins' point; at the same time, his statement is one that that gets put forth by theists as an 'atheist' belief (which always tends to rile a few feathers here).

It is possible to prove a negative, if you show that certain things that must accompany something else are not present; then it is shown: that particular something does not exist. As long as we're careful with our definitions, extremely careful that.

"There is no (normal) elephant in this room." Very easy. Normal (breathing) elephants, produced by currently understood biological means, leave obvious clues to their presence. We can see them. We can weigh the room I'm in on a scale, and then weight an completely identical room on a different scale, and compare weights. We can look for crushed furniture, smell the air, and check the bowl of peanuts to see if any are missing. All point to: no elephant in the room.,

The trouble for 'there is no god' is right off the bat, 'god' is an un-definable entity. All we can say is "if (un-definable entity) exist, with characteristic X, then Y should be present". All that leaves us with is an endless series of X's, with Y's to check for them. Since there are an infinite number of (un-definable entities), the whole exercise begins to get a little silly.

"How can you say that (un-definable entity) doesn't exist?" is thus a nonsensical question from the POV of inductive logic. Pragmatically speaking, it's not there until evidence begins to suggest it does. And the evidence would only speak towards the existence of definable entities, never undefined ones.
 
I did appreciate the Carl Sagan link although not directly related. I enjoy his writings and loved COSMOS.
Cosmos is going to be re-broadcast in January.

"How can you say that (un-definable entity) doesn't exist?" is thus a nonsensical question from the POV of inductive logic. Pragmatically speaking, it's not there until evidence begins to suggest it does. And the evidence would only speak towards the existence of definable entities, never undefined ones.
"Definable" like "All-good, all-powerful, all-knowing"? Not on the table, apparently...
 
He's probably referring to me?:confused: I said the following things in another thread (in a discussion with ACS, see quotes below). It might have been worded badly. I was trying to say that I am an atheist because what I know of the world comes from science and that I don't see a need for a god to explain things about the natural world with. I didn't actually mean that science has disproved god, only that what is claimed that a god can do with our world, science has natural explanations for. Such as evolution to explain the life that we can see around us, hence a creator is not needed and so on. All that scientific knowledge put together has removed a deity as a possible explanation for an impressive amount of things. Enough things for me to think that a god is not likely. For things that we don't know yet how they function, there is a gap in our knowledge, and I'd rather not fill it with god (or other supernatural explanations), but would rather wait for science to fill in the gaps. Experience tells me that science is far more likely to some day bring the answers to the remaining gaps. The more we know through scientific means, the less we need a deity as an explanation for anything. People then talk of a deity that pretty much does nothing, but then, to me, such a deity becomes quite hard to separate from something that don't exist.

I might be wrong about everything, but that was in all honesty how I meant to reason.

I don't think there is a god because all what science says contradicts supernatural beings such as a god. Science knows enough about, and have explained enough about how our world functions, and how our minds works for god to be highly unlikely and totally unnecessary.

I have all of science pointing to the likelihood of a deity being virtually 0

For a sufficiently large amount of the claims that are made about what a god supposedly can do, and does, science can show that there is a natural explanation instead, and a god is therefore not necessary as an explanation for anything.
 
Last edited:
The claim was made that science proves there is no god.
The claim is correct.

As a starting point I'd study the scientific paper cited below which gives a concise overview of current investigations in the area of Hermeneutics (=scientific disproval of God):

Transgressing the Boundaries: Towards a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity
Alan D. Sokal, Department of Physics, New York University


http://www.physics.nyu.edu/faculty/sokal/transgress_v2/transgress_v2_singlefile.html


Expecting an exciting discussion
Herzblut
 
Last edited:
The claim is correct.

As a starting point I'd study the scientific paper cited below which gives a concise overview of current investigations in the area of Hermeneutics (=scientific disproval of God):

Transgressing the Boundaries: Towards a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity
Alan D. Sokal, Department of Physics, New York University


http://www.physics.nyu.edu/faculty/sokal/transgress_v2/transgress_v2_singlefile.html


Expecting an exciting discussion
Herzblut
Excuse me, what is the purpose of posting a cite to a well-known hoax paper?

Just what does it add to the discussion???
 
I wanted to know what people thought. People posted. People stopped posting. It died - why is that me abandoning it? But I understand.

Science is limited to proposing hypotheses and attempting to disprove them.

So, for example, a feasible hypothesis might be: If God exists then prayer will be better than a placebo.

It's perfectly testable.

Is prayer better than a placebo?

I've never seen any evidence that it is.

Therefore there is no God.

QED.

Of course that always assumes that prayer works. It could easily be the case that God exists but does not give a twopenny damn whether you pray or not.

He just likes to see everyone wasting their time on Sunday mornings.
 
Gotta love the passive voice. Who made the claim? Ask them to defend it.
I note that this has still not been answered.

Theists are, of course, always keen to draw attention away from the complete absence of evidence for their thesis by moving the discussion in this direction.

But if this claim has been made, let us see the claim in the poster's own words.

Otherwise there is a suspicion, CS, that you just made him up as pretext to start this thread.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom