Marquis de Carabas
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Dec 5, 2002
- Messages
- 27,071
Well, you've restated an argument that I, at least, have always accepted as proof. Rest away.But I did answer the question in the case of a christian god?
If I have disproven the existence the the christian god (and I think I took two decent shots at it here) I'll happily rest on my laurels.![]()
Correct, yet it is still not proof. That god is unnecessary does not mean it is not there. It does, I think, strike a heavy blow, just not a fatal one.Come to think of it my second argument didn't depend on either omnipotence or goodness... only on the agreement that a universe without an interfering god is conceivable. The existence of an omnipotent god is sufficient for that, but not necessary.