Show me that Science proves there is no god

But I did answer the question in the case of a christian god?

If I have disproven the existence the the christian god (and I think I took two decent shots at it here) I'll happily rest on my laurels. :)
Well, you've restated an argument that I, at least, have always accepted as proof. Rest away.

Come to think of it my second argument didn't depend on either omnipotence or goodness... only on the agreement that a universe without an interfering god is conceivable. The existence of an omnipotent god is sufficient for that, but not necessary.
Correct, yet it is still not proof. That god is unnecessary does not mean it is not there. It does, I think, strike a heavy blow, just not a fatal one.
 
ps when people stopped posting on your last thread, you started a new one, again with pre-prepared arguments. This doesn't sound like someone with an open mind. Suggest you remove sceptic from your name for accuracy?

If people stop posting a thread you start you can't start a new thread? I really don't understand what having an open mind and being a sceptic have anything to do with starting a new thread. I'm sorry - you lost me on what the issue is here.
 
I guess I am going to need your help understanding the paper.
I don't know anything about this paper being a hoax or not -

Read about The Sokal Affair.

Consider this quote:

In 1996, Sokal, a professor of physics at New York University, submitted a paper of nonsense camouflaged in jargon for publication in Social Text, as an experiment to see if a journal in that field would, in Sokal's words: "publish an article liberally salted with nonsense if (a) it sounded good and (b) it flattered the editors' ideological preconceptions."[1]
 
That paper was a big honking nuclear bomb, dropped off right into the heart of postmodernist philosophy.
 
Last edited:
Can you give an example? I'm not suggesting that such things can't or don't exist, but at the moment I'm coming up short in thinking of any.

I've never once said all I have is scientific evidence only. But what would be the point of posting anything else if scientific evidence is all people will consider? Especially since my only purpose here is to learn - not prove or convert or anything. Like I posted somewhere else since I've posting here I've had more people tell me that what I believe is wrong. I've never once posted that anyone here or elsewhere has to believe anything. I have simply been responding to peoples questions and requests of me.

But one example just off the top of my head (so for all I know it might not be a great example): Beauty of a flower. Science can never prove to me the beauty of a flower. But I have plenty of evidence in my life that there are beautiful flowers. Science has limitations. I've accepted that. And really - what would someone whose only measurement on things was science really be like? I can't really imagine since I don't know anyone like that.

The fact that you would interpret it differently doesn't suggest, however, that your interpretation is valid. For instance, if you showed me a red sweater, I could say it was blue all I wanted, I might even beleive it to be blue (maybe I had some weird sort of brain damage, or colour-blindness, etc) but that wouldn't change the fact that it was red, and my conclusion was simply wrong.

I agree. I've never said anything against that. I understand that.
 
Last edited:
But one example just off the top of my head (so for all I know it might not be a great example): Beauty of a flower. Science can never prove to me the beauty of a flower.

Can't it? There's actually a lot of research going on about the psychology of human aesthetics. I think that science has come a lot closer to understanding the physical basis of "beauty", the social basis, and the psychological basis than you give it credit for.

The simple fact that you talk about scientific measurements of "the beauty of the flower" suggests an unawareness of the relevant research; one of the things that these psychologists have found is that much of "beauty" is indeed in the eyes (and in the cultural background) of the beholder.

How would you react to an explanation that "well, you find this flower beautiful because it looks like these other things with which you have positive associations?"
 
Can't it? There's actually a lot of research going on about the psychology of human aesthetics. I think that science has come a lot closer to understanding the physical basis of "beauty", the social basis, and the psychological basis than you give it credit for.

The simple fact that you talk about scientific measurements of "the beauty of the flower" suggests an unawareness of the relevant research; one of the things that these psychologists have found is that much of "beauty" is indeed in the eyes (and in the cultural background) of the beholder.

How would you react to an explanation that "well, you find this flower beautiful because it looks like these other things with which you have positive associations?"

I'm aware of alot of this type of research. But isn't all this is showing is why I think it's beautiful or that I think it's beauriful.? How can it prove it's beautiful. and again - I'm sure this isn't a good example.
 
But one example just off the top of my head (so for all I know it might not be a great example): Beauty of a flower. Science can never prove to me the beauty of a flower.

To start with, as people have been telling you through out this thread, science doesn't prove anything.

So we'll ditch the word `prove' for something that has less baggage associated with it. Let's use `demonstrate' instead.

Now science, as you so rightly said, can not demonstrate the beauty of a flower. However, nothing can demonstrate the beauty of a flower, and people have argued for centuries about what the "the beauty of __" actually means without getting anywhere.

What science can be used to demonstrate, however, is that:
(1) a flower exists
and
(2) X% of people from the population of Y say they find it beautiful.


We can apply science to the god question in a similar way to say:

(A) X% of people from the population of Y say they think he exists.

and that's it.

Now the existence of something isn't like its beauty, we don't agree that something exists if enough people think it exists,but that it only exists if it is really there.
 
Can't it? There's actually a lot of research going on about the psychology of human aesthetics. I think that science has come a lot closer to understanding the physical basis of "beauty", the social basis, and the psychological basis than you give it credit for.

The simple fact that you talk about scientific measurements of "the beauty of the flower" suggests an unawareness of the relevant research; one of the things that these psychologists have found is that much of "beauty" is indeed in the eyes (and in the cultural background) of the beholder.

How would you react to an explanation that "well, you find this flower beautiful because it looks like these other things with which you have positive associations?"

Yes, for example, it seems as if one thing that most people find beautiful is symmetry (such as people's faces). It's a complex thing with many individual variations, but it is not a subject that is entirely impossible to study scientifcally.

The flower example reminds me of a pen friend I had as a kid who was a pentecostal. She wrote me once saying that flowers had been put on earth by god, so that humans would have something of beauty to appreciate. I remember thinking that was the most stupid thing I have ever heard. I wrote back telling her flowers evolved to beckon insects to aid them in their reproduction not to amuse humans (or something like that, I was like 12 :)). I know this wasn't what you said ACS, it just reminded me of it.
 
I'm aware of alot of this type of research. But isn't all this is showing is why I think it's beautiful or that I think it's beauriful.? How can it prove it's beautiful.

That's kind of my point.

I can't prove that it's beautiful, because it isn't beautiful.

You find it beautiful, but that's altogether different. Someone else finds it hideous, and there is no way to resolve the fundamental difference. Science cannot prove something to be a property of the flower that is not, in fact, a property of the flower.
 
To start with, as people have been telling you through out this thread, science doesn't prove anything.

So we'll ditch the word `prove' for something that has less baggage associated with it. Let's use `demonstrate' instead.

We did this in a physics laboratory (for freshman survey students). We mandated that they could not use the word 'prove' in their conclusions. There were a couple of reasons. The first being that they were unlikely to discover any new principles in freshman labs, but also because of the larger philosophical principles.

However, that was from the senior instructor. Unfortunately, I've seen the word 'prove' in various articles, and have heard it said by more than one practicing scientist. I think it boils down to different contexts and the fuzziness of the English language (can't speak for the others, but will assume it's a similar sit.), more than the philosophy that science can or cannot prove something.

I accept that 'proof' is a mathematical or philosophical (symbolic logic) term, and that anything else is not. However, that leaves me with a problem, because I consider what science shows to be real (due solely to practical application, what else?)... hence my idea that reality repeatedly trumps proof! Probably not a popular position, but then, I'm only one person...

:o
 
Don't bother asking me to prove there is a God, because I can't. I have never claimed I could. In fact, I do not think science can prove that god exists or doesn't exist. All it can do is prove that it "appears" god exists or it "appears" god doesn't exist.

Good, good. Because science also can only show that it "appears" that gravity exists.
 
I accept that 'proof' is a mathematical or philosophical (symbolic logic) term, and that anything else is not. However, that leaves me with a problem, because I consider what science shows to be real (due solely to practical application, what else?)... hence my idea that reality repeatedly trumps proof! Probably not a popular position, but then, I'm only one person...

:o

Well that's as it should be, things you can prove true should be a subset of things which are true.

There are a couple of ways round this.

You can accept things as being provisionally true; there's a fair bit of this in both maths and computer based research where interesting papers are written which rely on the Riemann hypothesis or P!=NP for their conclusions.

Another alternative, is to view everything through Bayesian framework, and assign values between 0 and 1 rather than just true and false to express how valid you think statements are.
 
That being said Belz stated that a god would have to break all the rules of physics to exist

Did I, now ?

There is no evidence whatsoever that a god exists. In fact, the existence of a god would be contrary to the laws of physics we know, at least under several definitions of "god". It's quite reasonable to assume, therefore, that no god exists until evidence to the contrary is shown.

My opinion ? There are no gods. There is no God. There are no spirits, souls, fairies or anything supernatural.

Gee, I really wish people stopped making up what other people say. It's such a common trait.
 
There are a couple of ways round this.

You can accept things as being provisionally true; there's a fair bit of this in both maths and computer based research where interesting papers are written which rely on the Riemann hypothesis or P!=NP for their conclusions.

Another alternative, is to view everything through Bayesian framework, and assign values between 0 and 1 rather than just true and false to express how valid you think statements are.

For the minor tasks in life, the first approach has practical value. It is (provisionally) true that if I put gasoline in my gas tank, my vehicle will run. However, rigorous work usually requires something closer to the second approach. Written documents are much more amenable to this than walking around saying something is 0.987 true! :D
 
Did I, now ?



Gee, I really wish people stopped making up what other people say. It's such a common trait.

someone else pointed this out and I responded here:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3243748#post3243748

In this very thread.

And if you don't want me to misunderstand then make a statement that makes sense. Otherwise, my assumption that the first part of your statement meant my idea of god (since that's what we were talking about) and that the last part is irrelevant was correct.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by A Christian Sceptic
If people stop posting a thread you start you can't start a new thread? I really don't understand what having an open mind and being a sceptic have anything to do with starting a new thread. I'm sorry - you lost me on what the issue is here.

Yes, obviously.

Then tell me what he meant. If you can't or won't than these type of posts are not helpful and are going to dilute this thread and kill it.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom