Show me that Science proves there is no god

Science is limited to proposing hypotheses and attempting to disprove them.


Of course that always assumes that prayer works. It could easily be the case that God exists but does not give a twopenny damn whether you pray or not.

He just likes to see everyone wasting their time on Sunday mornings.

"Oh ye brothers and sisters bend over that Jeebus may enter you freely - and pass me a load of that butter while you're at it!!!":D:rolleyes::jaw-dropp
 
I agree with fran, science providing natural explanations for everything that was attributed to God is indistinguishable from science proving God doesn't exist. It's the same way that the light being turned on disproves that those shapes in the dark are monsters.

You can say the monsters might be invisible instead but that's moving the goal posts and the entire basis for why you believed in the first place that monsters are there is disproven.
 
What do you mean I have been had? I already pointed out that it was a well known hoax paper.
Come on. I'm pretty sure it was meant to be funny.

Hm. I hope I'm not the one who's been had now.
 
Come on. I'm pretty sure it was meant to be funny.

Hm. I hope I'm not the one who's been had now.
No you are probably right, my humour detector is on the blink (hits side of head with palm).
 
He's probably referring to me?:confused.

If I misunderstood anything it's my fault. But still - the question is the same - and I have heard such claims.

I have heard Richard Dawkins made this claim, but I haven't read his book yet so I'm assuming (and hoping) he meant The Scientific Method. I'm a bit sceptical on how the media portrays these type of books.
 
Come on. I'm pretty sure it was meant to be funny.
"Funny"? What you mean by "funny"?

Look - amongst all those flappdoodle posts in the thread I'm the only one providing serious hermeneutical (=scientifically disproving god) evidence.

And what's the result? Evidence is slandered and called "hoax", my whole post is considered "funny"...

I honestly doubt this board actually deserves me.

:confused:

In diesem oder jenen Sinne und mit vielen Grüssen von

Herzblut
 
Last edited:
If I misunderstood anything it's my fault. But still - the question is the same - and I have heard such claims.

I have heard Richard Dawkins made this claim, but I haven't read his book yet so I'm assuming (and hoping) he meant The Scientific Method. I'm a bit sceptical on how the media portrays these type of books.

So it was me? Ah, OK.
 
I have heard Richard Dawkins made this claim, but I haven't read his book yet so I'm assuming (and hoping) he meant The Scientific Method. I'm a bit sceptical on how the media portrays these type of books.

To say that the majority of the media discussing his book are blatant liars who pretend to speak with authority on a book they have never even read and are so dishonorable as to manage to do a disservice to the already honorless field of journalism would be a massive understatement.
 
"Definable" like "All-good, all-powerful, all-knowing"? Not on the table, apparently...
Nope, sorry, those are characteristics. Those are X's.

Define the being that has those characteristics, then we can talk.
(your main problem after that will be the traditional arguments of 'if "all-powerful, than..." Good luck with all that)
 
I have heard Richard Dawkins made this claim, but I haven't read his book yet so I'm assuming (and hoping) he meant The Scientific Method. I'm a bit sceptical on how the media portrays these type of books.

Richard Dawkins doesn't claim to prove scientifically that there is no god. What he does say is that scientific, rational examination of the evidence leads him to the conclusion that it is extremely unlikely that God exists. One of the chapters of The God Delusion is called "Why there is almost certainly no God".

Dawkins's book is an excellent place to start to get an idea of how the possibility of the existence of God (the "God Hypothesis") can be scientifically studied. You can read the beginning of the first chapter here.
 
Show me that Science proves there is no god


Show me that Science proves there is "a God flying out some Angels
Ass singing that me, the holy Idiot wrote a cool book about me being
the frigging hole commanding you not to ignore me or you are doomed".

Rephrase your question - the way it is makes it sound stupid as hell.
 
Last edited:
I was going to say that science doesn't concern itself with proving or disproving the existence of any god or gods, but that goes without saying.

In any case, the claim that one cannot prove a negative is self-refuting. You can indeed prove a negative, by proving a contradictory positive. The disproofs of God's existence are contingent on there being existing definitions or claims of proof for God's existence. In other words, you need only concern yourself with disproving God if someone comes along and claims that they can prove he exists in the first place.

Therefore if someone were to ask me to prove that God doesn't exist, I would first ask that they provide either a working definition of God or a 'proof' for his existence, then I would be happy to demonstrate why those are logically inconsistent. This doesn't necessarily disprove God, but it's not up to me to disprove him.
 
If we had a theory of everything, would that disprove god. As we can describe everything without using god.

On a bigger note, isn't god a logical fallacy. You know the all powerful paradox. See, god is not scientific and is not logical(mathematical), what is god?

On a bigger bigger note, will having the theory of everything make you godlike. Cause you would have godlike knowledge.

I guess the biggest question is why is their something not nothing?
wouldn't the simplist thing be nothing.
 
Last edited:
I want to know how and where science proves this.

Here's my stab at Yahweh - God of the Jews and Christians (aka Allah - God of the Muslims.):

"Science" has revealed an immense universe at least 156 billion light-years wide.

(If I started counting every second until I reached ONE Million it would take 11.5 days. If I started counting every second until I reached ONE Billion it would take 31.7 years! My point is - there is an exponential jump - unrealized by the laymen - when we say, "Thousand, million, billion, trillion..." By using 'time' as a substitute, we can 'feel' the distance better. So you see "156 billion" is very large.)

So the universe is 156 billion light-years wide. But what is a light-year? A light year is the distance light travels in a year: almost 6 trillion miles! (Counting each second will get you to a trillion in 32,000 years)

The distance is staggering.

There are billions of galaxies - each containing billions of stars and planets.

Why do Christians/Muslims/Jews think this creation was made for them? An old book with - as we know now - laughable explanations of 'historical' events.

Science can't prove there isn't a God - but it can make you realize that you'd make a better God then the one we (supposedly) have! So what kind of God is that?!
 
Last edited:
Science can say we have no more evidence for God existence than Xenu's existence... or Zeus's existence or Satan's existence or the existence of hobgoblins and sprites. ... We have no more evidence for a god than we do for psychic powers or levitation...

As skeptics, we weigh those things and conclude that they are imaginary things-- wrongful inferences that humans tend to make rather easily. Real things generate evidence-- stuff like DNA (which no god thought to tell his inspired friends about)-- When people have believed in stuff for a long time-- like souls or Loch Ness monsters.... and no evidence accumulates--odds are the thing is imaginary... an illusion... Real things are measurable... real claims can be tested. People who were never inculcated with a god belief... don't believe in gods. I don't see how someone can giggle at mythological gods and still conclude that their god is somehow more likely to be true.

There appear to be as many invisible entities as there are imaginations... but there is only one reality-- and the stuff in it all seems real and discoverable through objective means. Subjective truths tend to not hold up well under objective scrutiny. Faith and feelings are not an avenue to truths.
 
Last edited:
Show me that Science proves there is "a God flying out some Angels
Ass singing that me, the holy Idiot wrote a cool book about me being
the frigging hole commanding you not to ignore me or you are doomed".

Rephrase your question - the way it is makes it sound stupid as hell.

Quite right - best response so far on this thread. The OP does not deserve the responses it attracted.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom