Not to be misunderstood - That's not evidence.
Evidence is not subject to interpretation and considerations. If I say elephants exists and here is the proof and proceed to show you a living elephant, you'd be a damn fool to not consider that evidence.
This is a good point, and CS should think carefully about it.
There is a way in which you go a little too far though. The idea that the evidence of "personal experience" is stronger for the person experiencing it than for those hearing about it is of course true. For example:
Say that Mike watches Jim murder Kim. Mike is afraid and runs off. A week later, he gets up the nerve to tell you about it. But by this point Jim has had a chance to clean up, and neither you or Mike can find any other evidence of the murder than his testimony.
Now, from Mike's perspective he had good evidence that Jim killed Kim - he saw him do it. But there are other hypothesis that explain this evidence as well:
- Mike misremembers the events and didn't actually
see the kiling, he just saw things that he interpreted that way, and his memory has filled in the details.
- Mike had a halucination.
- Mike dreamed this, but remembers it as if it happened.
You, on the other hand, have one more possible hypothesis that explains the evidence just as well, but which isn't available to Mike - Mike is lying.
Of course there are many reasons why he might lie, but this is the extra hypothesis that is available to you. In that sense, because it eliminates this hypothesis for Mike, but not for you, Mike's evidence
is stronger for him than you.
Now, CS, here's the thing, if your evidence is something of this sort, I will admit that it is stronger for you. But it's also true that many of the possible explanations that I have, which don't include god, are also available to you.
And being testable by science mean little more than "If someone else does the same things they will get the same results"
I don't really see how that's true. Being testable means that there is some test we can run, or thing we can look at, wherein if the claim is true we expect result X whereas if the claim is false we expect result Y.
Why would it not, how can an entity exist or influence a system where laws of physics exist without either sticking to those laws or annihilating the universe.
(this is a serious question with deep implications, please think about it deeply, don't just brush it aside. If you don't understand the problem, please be honest about that too).
I don't understand the problem. Could you explain it?