Show me that Science proves there is no god

A Christian Sceptic

Master Poster
Joined
Dec 7, 2007
Messages
2,288
OK,

Since this came up unasked for in a different thread it's made me curious and I would like some answers.

The claim was made that science proves there is no god.

Please read the following closely:
Don't bother asking me to prove there is a God, because I can't. I have never claimed I could. In fact, I do not think science can prove that god exists or doesn't exist. All it can do is prove that it "appears" god exists or it "appears" god doesn't exist.

And by god it could be anything beyond the universe outside it or what have you. A First Cause or the God of the Christians. It doesn't matter.

Again I don't want to know why you think god isn't there. I want to know how and where science proves this.

And yes - I really want to know. I'm a sceptic and that means I'm willing to change my beliefs if needed.

*** But again - I'm not looking for things like "There's evil - so god doesn't exist" or anything like that but something like:

Scientist Bill did this experiment and it proved there was no god.

you know - using the scientific method.

NOTE: This obviously is only attended at someone who thinks science can do this one way or another. I DON'T!

ANOTHER NOTE: I do not want to debate this or fight. I will not respond - I will not counter-point - I will read any scientific literature that shows this.
 
Last edited:
Science doesn't even prove Newton's Laws of Motion. It can't prove why aeroplanes don't fall out of the sky, or why boats float.

Why do you think it can prove imaginary stuff if it can't even prove real stuff?
 
Why do you think it can prove imaginary stuff if it can't even prove real stuff?

Gotta love the passive voice. Who made the claim? Ask them to defend it.

If you want to have a fight with someone, take it outside!

Sorry. I've heard the same refrain, "Science proves X..." before. Anyone who does say "Science proves God does not exist" is wrong. People have made that statement, even if I can't come up with an example from the last 5 minutes off the top of my head, MdC.

The appropriate response, of course is much like that made by Henners. The statement, and any religious counters, completely ignore the nature of: science, proof and logic.

ACS: SCIENCE DOES NOT PROVE THAT GOD DOES NOT EXIST. That's not what science does.
 
If by "proof" you mean "100% guarantee" then science cannot prove anything.

Its all a matter of probabilities.

Science can show that the probability of a God is so low that for all practical purposes one shouldn't care. Do you constantly worry about gravity reversing and being flung out into space? That's about how improbable God is.
 
Science doesn't have to disprove the existence of God

OK,

Since this came up unasked for in a different thread it's made me curious and I would like some answers.

The claim was made that science proves there is no god.

Please read the following closely:
Don't bother asking me to prove there is a God, because I can't. I have never claimed I could. In fact, I do not think science can prove that god exists or doesn't exist. All it can do is prove that it "appears" god exists or it "appears" god doesn't exist.

And by god it could be anything beyond the universe outside it or what have you. A First Cause or the God of the Christians. It doesn't matter.

Again I don't want to know why you think god isn't there. I want to know how and where science proves this.

And yes - I really want to know. I'm a sceptic and that means I'm willing to change my beliefs if needed.

*** But again - I'm not looking for things like "There's evil - so god doesn't exist" or anything like that but something like:

Scientist Bill did this experiment and it proved there was no god.

you know - using the scientific method.

NOTE: This obviously is only attended at someone who thinks science can do this one way or another. I DON'T!

ANOTHER NOTE: I do not want to debate this or fight. I will not respond - I will not counter-point - I will read any scientific literature that shows this.

People who believe God exists have to prove that he does.
 
People have made that statement, even if I can't come up with an example from the last 5 minutes off the top of my head, MdC.
I did not claim it was not said. I asked that the question be addressed to the one who said it. Even if you don't have an example ready at hand, CS seems to, else whence this thread? I would just like a pair to be grown. I would just like him to grow a pair.
 
I did not claim it was not said. I asked that the question be addressed to the one who said it. Even if you don't have an example ready at hand, CS seems to, else whence this thread? I would just like a pair to be grown. I would just like him to grow a pair.

I wasn't saying it wasn't a strawman or something, in this case, I felt that it should be addressed that whomever said it was wrong, anyway.

Of course, there's nothing produced by science that could be used to prove God's existence... but that's not the issue...
 
Whoever made that claim, if it was indeed made, is a moron. Science operates on the naturalist assumption that there is only the natural world out there. It would be a tad nonsensical to have it prove its own axioms.
 
I wasn't saying it wasn't a strawman or something, in this case, I felt that it should be addressed that whomever said it was wrong, anyway.
Certainly wrong. I'm just curious as to the identity of that someone.

I'm also curious about the exact nature of the claim. A quote would be nice. I could see myself saying something that could be misconstrued as "science proves there is no god". Science has shown that god is unnecessary as an explanation for speciation, for example. While it is certainly possible someone made such a strong claim as CS presents, it is also possible he has misinterpreted.
 
In order to answer your question properly, then I need to know the following: What is the difference between a universe with a god and a universe without a god?

That all becomes very difficult given the range of possible definitions of "god".

Have you heard of Sagan's Dragon?
http://www.godlessgeeks.com/LINKS/Dragon.htm

The important question: "what's the difference between an invisible, incorporeal, floating dragon who spits heatless fire and no dragon at all?"

But again - I'm not looking for things like "There's evil - so god doesn't exist"....

I still want to quibble with that.
If the definition of god implied that there should be no evil in the world, then discovering evil in the world would be very important data. It would scientifically disprove the existence of a god according to that definition.

....or anything like that but something like:

Scientist Bill did this experiment and it proved there was no god.

I don't know a scientist named Bill. But I did hear of one named Abraham -- he went and smashed a few idols and suffered no harm as a result. Did that prove anything?
 
Last edited:
While science can never prove anything, logic can. A statement or set of statements can be shown to be logically inconsistent. That's the closest you could ever come to a proof of the non-existence of god.

I think the best argument is due to Epicurus:

Either God wants to abolish evil, and cannot; or he can, but does not want to.

If he wants to, but cannot, he is impotent.

If he can, but does not want to, he is wicked.

If God can abolish evil, and God really wants to do it, why is there evil in the world?

So if god were omnipotent and good, there would no evil; ergo, god is either not omnipotent or not good. As those are defining characteristics of god, god does not exist.
 
Last edited:
Certainly wrong. I'm just curious as to the identity of that someone.

I'm also curious about the exact nature of the claim. A quote would be nice. I could see myself saying something that could be misconstrued as "science proves there is no god". Science has shown that god is unnecessary as an explanation for speciation, for example. While it is certainly possible someone made such a strong claim as CS presents, it is also possible he has misinterpreted.

Ooh! Fair play!

That's interesting. It may have been misinterpreted. However, I can give you one example of an atheist who has made the claim, "science proves God does not exist." Me!

That's right, I was a moron. Of course, now I'm still a moron, just not a teenager anymore. :D
 
So if god were omnipotent and good, there would no evil; ergo, god is either not omnipotent or not good. As those are defining characteristics of god, god does not exist.
Those are only defining characteristics of some representations of god. Since CS did not limit the conception of god thus in the OP, you have proved nothing germane.
 
As has been previously stated.

Trying to prove the non-existance of god scientifically is like trying to prove the existance of god scientifically, and as CS stated they cannot offer any evidence to gods existance, likewise I cannot offer any proof of his non-existance.

however the evidence that promotes either idea is so heavily weighted in favour of non existance that I believe in non-existance of a creator or other manifestations of divinity.

I can even entertain the idea of a highly evolved lifeform seeding this planet with genetic stock when they got out of their flying saucer to take a dump as a higher probability for the origins of life than the existance of a god.
 
I did not claim it was not said. I asked that the question be addressed to the one who said it. Even if you don't have an example ready at hand, CS seems to, else whence this thread? I would just like a pair to be grown. I would just like him to grow a pair.

Let me assure you I did ask this to that person - no answer so far. But it got me thinking maybe someone else does have something to show me.

Since you brought up growing a bigger pair - any suggestions? I'm a bit sceptical on some of the male enhancement herbs and drugs that are out there. :D
 
To the OP, just a few thoughts.

1) This sounds a bit like the fallacy of proving a negative. Without seeing the actual claim, I could be wrong.

2) Science can prove that certain aspects or definitions of a god are not true (for example, god is a green walnut living in my glove box). You did leave that a bit open with your comment "And by god it could be anything beyond the universe outside it or what have you. A First Cause or the God of the Christians. It doesn't matter."

3) Be a bit careful with assuming that something posted as hyperbole is exactly what the author intended. Happens a lot on this forum.



I agree with the comments posted so far about what the actual claim was, and who claimed it in the first place.
 
If the definition of god implied that there should be no evil in the world, then discovering evil in the world would be very important data. It would scientifically disprove the existence of a god according to that definition.
First you would have to define "evil". Which is kind of a problem given that religions usually derive morality from god.

I think the argument from evil doesn't get you anywhere logically. However, it's still a fun argument insofar as it sends believers into hot water, since as far as I understand it boils down to the choice of either "god is evil or at least indifferent", or "what we commonly regard as evil is not evil in the eyes of god", or simply "there is no god".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom