So, because Lewis said something on an unrelated subject, which you disagree with, any argument he makes or any argument that borrows a quote from him must be illogical or false in some way?
To be fair though, Lewis was a fair douche. I don't think it would be too great a leap to say that if you rely on his arguments (which were, on the whole, just restatements of other peoples' worn ideas) you're likely to get your butt kicked in an argument.
If you were consistent with that thinking, then wouldn't that also mean that you should dismiss Occam's razor, since I can't imagine you would agree with Occam's religious views?
Occams' Razor was not created by Occam, it was simply named after him many years down the track. Of course, many (most) of Lewis' arguments were not original either, but if you reference him and not another person then you've still referenced Lewis. Using Occams' Razor doesn't force you to recognise Occams' viewpoint, it simply requires you to employ a heuristic philosophical tool.
Were my answers to the rock question illogical or mistaken in some way?
The idea that god is for some reason 'not constrained by logic' is profoundly unsatisfying, and fails to really address the question. The original question ("Could god create a rock so heavy that he could not lift it?") is not itself a nonsense question - humans create objects so heavy that they cannot be lifted by a human all the time. This is a serious issue if one is going to claim that their god is omnipotent - can an omnipotent being, theoretically at least, limit their own powers? If the answer is 'yes', then having created a limit to their powers, they are not omnipotent. If the answer is 'no', then the inability to limit one's power is in itself a limit to the power, and the god is once again not omnipotent.
An answer that amounts to, "God laughs at your petty logic," is not a particularly good answer, in other words.
I think there was more to your original answer than that, but I'm a bit tired right now. I just thought I'd address that bit (which I
think you wrote) - if you didn't write it but were planning to, consider it preemptive criticism.
*Yawn* Bed time, methinks.