Show me that Science proves there is no god

And you'd be wrong. They behave in vastly different ways (according to those who believe in them.) Most pagans, for example, don't believe in the divinity of Christ. There are some similarities of course. Christians pray. Pagans cast spells. They are virtually the same thing.


My religion, your cult.
 
As does god... all gods. As does C.S. Lewis who declared that "pride is the worse sin of all"-- not torture, not genocide, not pedophilia, not rape, no scamming people-- but PRIDE. Was he speaking for god or pulling info. out of his ass? What sort of God thinks "pride" is the worst sin of all?

Theists can make anything make sense to themselves if it's attached to their god concept. Atheists can't make sense of any of it. The god concept fails from the get go. It never gets beyond the myth stage. And all the platitudes that you find deep and inspirational just sound vapid and childish and geared towards people who already believe.

So, because Lewis said something on an unrelated subject, which you disagree with, any argument he makes or any argument that borrows a quote from him must be illogical or false in some way? If you were consistent with that thinking, then wouldn't that also mean that you should dismiss Occam's razor, since I can't imagine you would agree with Occam's religious views?

Also why do you refer to yourself as "atheists"? If you don't understand something, then speak in the first person, unless you can demonstrate that your view is held by all atheists.

Are you suggesting my argument is merely platitudes or are you talking about something else entirely there? Maybe you're suggesting that because of what you assume I believe that any argument I might make should be dismissed as childish and vapid?

May I suggest that if you wish to reply to my posts that you address the arguments at hand and drop the fallacies lest by your own definition you define yourself out of skepticism?

Were my answers to the rock question illogical or mistaken in some way?
 
This is a little defensive - I can understand that. A few people have called you a "troll" and I don't really know why - the fact that you disagree with many people here and want to have a discussion about that doesn't make you a troll. In my opinion it makes you valuable to these forums.
But some of us really are interested in a genuine discussion.

I called him a troll because he seemed to be starting a bunch of broad threads and then ignoreing them. He seems to be somewhat reducing that, but he still is most interested in asking others about their beliefs but not presenting his.
 
Tricky found some scientific evidence to disprove God -- the concept of God that Tricky believed in, anyway:



That was possible because, according to Tricky's former belief, the world would be different depending on whether God existed.

And, yes, the evidence offered is scientific.
The belief depended on observation, not whim.

Ah but Tricky's problem was defining god so that god does something.
 
So, because Lewis said something on an unrelated subject, which you disagree with, any argument he makes or any argument that borrows a quote from him must be illogical or false in some way?

To be fair though, Lewis was a fair douche. I don't think it would be too great a leap to say that if you rely on his arguments (which were, on the whole, just restatements of other peoples' worn ideas) you're likely to get your butt kicked in an argument.

If you were consistent with that thinking, then wouldn't that also mean that you should dismiss Occam's razor, since I can't imagine you would agree with Occam's religious views?

Occams' Razor was not created by Occam, it was simply named after him many years down the track. Of course, many (most) of Lewis' arguments were not original either, but if you reference him and not another person then you've still referenced Lewis. Using Occams' Razor doesn't force you to recognise Occams' viewpoint, it simply requires you to employ a heuristic philosophical tool.

Were my answers to the rock question illogical or mistaken in some way?

The idea that god is for some reason 'not constrained by logic' is profoundly unsatisfying, and fails to really address the question. The original question ("Could god create a rock so heavy that he could not lift it?") is not itself a nonsense question - humans create objects so heavy that they cannot be lifted by a human all the time. This is a serious issue if one is going to claim that their god is omnipotent - can an omnipotent being, theoretically at least, limit their own powers? If the answer is 'yes', then having created a limit to their powers, they are not omnipotent. If the answer is 'no', then the inability to limit one's power is in itself a limit to the power, and the god is once again not omnipotent.

An answer that amounts to, "God laughs at your petty logic," is not a particularly good answer, in other words.

I think there was more to your original answer than that, but I'm a bit tired right now. I just thought I'd address that bit (which I think you wrote) - if you didn't write it but were planning to, consider it preemptive criticism.

*Yawn* Bed time, methinks.
 
I don't know if anyone has mentioned this, but science cannot prove OR disprove the existence of God. It cannot prove His existence because as others have mentioned, science can't even prove Newton's laws of motion or other laws of nature. It can certainly provide strong evidence, but it cannot PROVE his existence. And in the context of the Christian bible, there is a passage saying that you should not put God to the test. But if biblical passages make you uneasy, then just rely on the fact that if not even Newton's laws of motion can be proved, then we sure as hell can't prove God's existence.

And on the other hand, science cannot DISPROVE God's existence. You can prove that he didn't intervene in certain situations, but that doesn't prove that He didn't exist. If you didn't intervene when a parent yelled at her child over something really stupid and lame, does that mean that YOU don't exist? Maybe you didn't intervene because you wanted the child to learn to fend for himself rather than counting on the help of strangers! You can show that scientific phenomena such as evolution seem to contradict what is written in the bible, but that just shows that the bible shouldn't be interpreted literally. You could still say that the Old Testament is merely a book of parables that suggest how you should live your life in an acceptable way to God. If you conducted an experiment that provided strong evidence that a certain law of nature is most likely true, then the Christian would argue that this is just another facet of God's grand design.

These discussions are nothing but a giant waste of time. All they do is get people pissed off. I still haven't figured out why people devote themselves daily to forums where they just get pissed off. May I quote the film American History X: "life is too short to be pissed off all the time."
 
Last edited:
How would you react to an explanation that "well, you find this flower beautiful because it looks like these other things with which you have positive associations?"

Did anyone else immediately think of a Georgia OKeefe painting?
 
No!

How can it possibly be a waste of time to disprove the existence of an imaginary being?
Because as I made it very clear in my post, you CANNOT disprove the existence of an imaginary being. There are always explanations for the facts you present. Evolution occurred rather than intelligent design? Then evolution is just another one of God's laws of nature in this intricate universe. Evolution contradicts the bible? Then the bible isn't literal; it's full of parables. God allowed the holocaust to happen? Then God simply doesn't have as much of an active role in our lives as we'd like to think. It's the price of free will which we can all exercise. You prayed for something and didn't get it? Because either free will is what made this happen, or God wanted to test you.

It doesn't matter what evidence you present. There is always an argument around it. ALWAYS.

Besides, how are you supposed to disprove God's existence to the entire world from the safe confines of a skeptics forum?
 
Last edited:
It doesn't matter what evidence you present. There is always an argument around it. ALWAYS.

If a politician kept coming up with more and more extravagant excuses like that, though, you would know not to vote for them.

What makes religion different?
 
If a politician kept coming up with more and more extravagant excuses like that, though, you would know not to vote for them.

What makes religion different?
Because it's not a person; it's an entire belief system followed by hundreds of millions of people. Between this ginormous population of Christians, at least one of them can come up with a reasonable explanation.
 
Because as I made it very clear in my post, you CANNOT disprove the existence of an imaginary being. There are always explanations for the facts you present. Evolution occurred rather than intelligent design? Then evolution is just another one of God's laws of nature in this intricate universe. Evolution contradicts the bible? Then the bible isn't literal; it's full of parables. God allowed the holocaust to happen? Then God simply doesn't have as much of an active role in our lives as we'd like to think. It's the price of free will which we can all exercise. You prayed for something and didn't get it? Because either free will is what made this happen, or God wanted to test you.

It doesn't matter what evidence you present. There is always an argument around it. ALWAYS.

Besides, how are you supposed to disprove God's existence to the entire world from the safe confines of a skeptics forum?


The burden is on those who belive god exists. If they can control the confounding factors and demonstrate and effect, then they win.
 
Because it's not a person; it's an entire belief system followed by hundreds of millions of people. Between this ginormous population of Christians, at least one of them can come up with a reasonable explanation.

Unless you are claiming that all those people can wish God into existence, I don't see what bearing that has on the matter.
 
I don't know if anyone has mentioned this, but science cannot prove OR disprove the existence of God. It cannot prove His existence because as others have mentioned, science can't even prove Newton's laws of motion or other laws of nature.

It can not prove newtons laws, but it can prove that stuff falls down. And that when stuff falls down it always seems to follow rules similar to newtons.

Or are you really claiming that as an example Science can not prove that Iron exists?
 
To be fair though, Lewis was a fair douche. I don't think it would be too great a leap to say that if you rely on his arguments (which were, on the whole, just restatements of other peoples' worn ideas) you're likely to get your butt kicked in an argument.
Your opinion of the man (which you are of course entitled to) has no bearing on whether a particular point he might have made is right or wrong. I'm not sure there could be a much better example of an ad hom. If I use a quote from someone as part of an argument, I would still expect to be judged on the merit of the argument, no matter who I quoted.

Occams' Razor was not created by Occam, it was simply named after him many years down the track. Of course, many (most) of Lewis' arguments were not original either, but if you reference him and not another person then you've still referenced Lewis. Using Occams' Razor doesn't force you to recognise Occams' viewpoint, it simply requires you to employ a heuristic philosophical tool.
How is accepting the use of Occam's razor, not recognising Occam's particular viewpoint on using that tool, (ie referencing him) unless you want to call it "Aristotle's rule of thumb" or something?


The idea that god is for some reason 'not constrained by logic' is profoundly unsatisfying, and fails to really address the question. The original question ("Could god create a rock so heavy that he could not lift it?") is not itself a nonsense question - humans create objects so heavy that they cannot be lifted by a human all the time. This is a serious issue if one is going to claim that their god is omnipotent - can an omnipotent being, theoretically at least, limit their own powers? If the answer is 'yes', then having created a limit to their powers, they are not omnipotent. If the answer is 'no', then the inability to limit one's power is in itself a limit to the power, and the god is once again not omnipotent.

The question is really one about the definition of "omnipotent" in regards to logic. I disagree about the question not being nonsense. Yes, humans create objects which they can't lift, but there is a limit to what they can lift. Something too heavy for a human can exist. Omnipotence assumes there is no such limit. Something too heavy for an omnipotent being cannot exist, therefore the question is really no different from asking "can an omnipotent being create A which is not A?" or "can an omnipotent being do something that logically can't be done?"

So, either omnipotence, by definition, does not include stepping outside the boundaries of logic, in which case we shouldn't expect it to with our propositions, or it can step outside of logic, in which case we can't then complain that it has become illogical and can't do that because it's logically impossible.

An answer that amounts to, "God laughs at your petty logic," is not a particularly good answer, in other words.

I think there was more to your original answer than that, but I'm a bit tired right now. I just thought I'd address that bit (which I think you wrote) - if you didn't write it but were planning to, consider it preemptive criticism.

*Yawn* Bed time, methinks.
Nope, that wasn't my argument.

Goodnight, Moby. Sleep well! :)
 
The burden is on those who belive god exists. If they can control the confounding factors and demonstrate and effect, then they win.

I know many people are not going to like this statement but:

I think the burden on proof is on God, not his followers. Unless, and this is an important detail,unless those followers demand you believe. I might add this goes for people who also demand someone doesn't believe. Once you demand some belief from someone the burden of proof now shifts onto you.

I'm content letting God handle the proof. ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom