Show me that Science proves there is no god

I think your misunderstanding growth in your beliefs with trying to prove something to someone. If I am trying to prove to you something it would be accurate to say I'm moving the goalpasts. But I'm perfectly willing to alter my belief in God if I find out I misunderstood something about him. I guess if that means he's bigger than I thought - well I guess you're right - the goalposts were moved.

So all Sagan is doing is learning more about the dragon? And what then? We point out the God, evidently, is not honest, and you redefine God once more.

You say you want to learn; you say you are a sceptic and open to ideas. But your God is utterly beyond refute, because every refutation necessitates a further shifting of His traits. Essentially, there is not one single thing that would change your mind.

You, Sir, are no sceptic.
 
Last edited:
Are you really not clear what this dilemma is about? If he succeeds he fails. Either way he fails. If he can do anything then he can make big rocks. If he can lift anything then he can lift big rocks. You CANNOT have it both ways. C A N N O T

How can a person who doesn't believe in a god tell someone who does what their god's traits are supposed to be? I'm sure plenty of Christians would argue with me on this too, by the way.
 
Really?

In that case, there really is a dragon in my garage and he really is the god of all.

Now, you wouldn't want to miss out on this opportunity to worship the one true god, would you? Are you going to start praying to the dragon god in my garage?

It sounds like I already believe in him then.
 
So all Sagan is doing is learning more about the dragon? And what then? We point out the God, evidently, is not honest, and you redefine God once more.

What?

You say you want to learn; you say you are a sceptic and open to ideas. But your God is utterly beyond refute, because every refutation necessitates a further shifting of His traits. Essentially, there is not one single thing that would change your mind.

You, Sir, are no sceptic.

No - his traits never shift - my understanding of them do. I don't really no what your saying. I'm sure the misunderstanding is my fault.
 
It sounds like I already believe in him then.

Then surely you're aware that pilgramige and tithing are a necessary part of keeping the one true god happy? If I send you my PayPal account details, you can make regular tributes of 5% of your total earnings - I am the proxy of the one true god for financial matters, something that will be beyond question when you complete your pilgramige.
 
Then surely you're aware that pilgramige and tithing are a necessary part of keeping the one true god happy? If I send you my PayPal account details, you can make regular tributes of 5% of your total earnings - I am the proxy of the one true god for financial matters, something that will be beyond question when you complete your pilgramige.

And now after weighing what I believe about my god with what your telling me about your dragon I decide they aren't the same god. My god is bigger and better so I no longer need to worry about that dragon. And yes - the point you're trying to make applies to Christian doctrines too.
 
I think your misunderstanding growth in your beliefs with trying to prove something to someone. If I am trying to prove to you something it would be accurate to say I'm moving the goalpasts.


If you were being honest in saying you want to learn more about gods and science, you might actually be wanting to prove something to yourself. But you haven't shown that you're willing to be all that honest, especially with yourself.

But I'm perfectly willing to alter my belief in God if I find out I misunderstood something about him.


It's interesting that you've set up a situation where you can't possibly alter your belief in any meaningful way, simply because you won't even define your invisible pal. You can't offer a definition, even to yourself, that isn't subject to change at your whim as necessary to maintain your belief in magic.

I guess if that means he's bigger than I thought - well I guess you're right - the goalposts were moved.


You don't seem to understand, but you are actually making your supernatural pal bigger by the very act of moving the goalposts and for the very purpose of defending its existence. You're caught in a trap, like quicksand, and you can't get out. The more you examine your delusion, the deeper you must sink into it. And exactly because you aren't strong enough (or brave enough or intelligent enough or sane enough or... for whatever other reason) to legitimately, honestly, and critically examine your belief. You, all by yourself, insist on sticking to a set of rules, rules of your very own creation, that won't let you get away from it.
 
That statement was made in reference to the circumstances I posted stuff I take as evidence and was a reply to someone's request for elaboration. At which point I pointed out that any evidence I show isn't going to be considered evidence for God's existence anymore than any evidence anyone shows against will be accepted as being against.
Why not?

And I've stated in many posts that I think God's existence can't be proven to others one way or another.
And everyone here agrees with you. But just because something isn't proven one way or another doesn't mean that both possiblities are equally likely.

But that said, many people used the reason of not believing as "lack of evidence" so I'm curious on what that specifically it is.
Lack of evidence means not having any reason to believe.
Why don't you believe that there is a tea pot orbiting somewhere between mars and jupiter? How about one somewhere out near Pluto? Because you don't have any reason to believe that.
God is the same. The teapot could exist. But, as others pointed out, so could an infinite number of unfalsifiable things. How do we choose between them?

Now, you have said that you do have a reason to believe in god. On the other hand you won't tell us what it is.

In this thread I limited it to scientific evidence and the posts confirmed what I already know - science can't prove or disprove his existence. From some people's response it seems Richard Dawkins is claiming this, which I hope is not the case.
Richard Dawkins goes out of his way to say the opposite. There is no proof.

I hope what he means is "Science might be used to investigate whether he left any traces of him existing." Him existing and him leaving traces would be two seperate things.
Before you judge his opinions, read them for yourself. Or don't concern yourself with him - that's fine too. Anyway, what he says is that God is as likely to exist as any of the other things for which we have no evidence. That is - so close to zero as to make little difference.

So far my conclusion in this aspect of believing or not believing: "God may or may not exist, it can't be proven one way or another, and people come to a conclusion on his existence based on the evidence (however they want to define it) that they receive throughout their life."

Fair enough, except, again, just because something can't be proven one way or the other doesn't mean both options are equally likely. Also, I don't understand where you get "evidence (however they define it)". Just because someone says or thinks they have evidence of something doesn't mean they actually do.
I've been wrong about evidence before. We all are, from time to time.
 
And now after weighing what I believe about my god with what your telling me about your dragon I decide they aren't the same god. My god is bigger and better so I no longer need to worry about that dragon. And yes - the point you're trying to make applies to Christian doctrines too.
Except that the dragon exists, but your god doesn't.

You can't prove that one way or the other. ;)
 
You don't seem to understand, but you are actually making your supernatural pal bigger by the very act of moving the goalposts and for the very purpose of defending its existence. You're caught in a trap, like quicksand, and you can't get out. The more you examine your delusion, the deeper you must sink into it. And exactly because you aren't strong enough (or brave enough or intelligent enough or sane enough or... for whatever other reason) to legitimately, honestly, and critically examine your belief. You, all by yourself, insist on sticking to a set of rules, rules of your very own creation, that won't let you get away from it.

Are you saying if I have a small notion of god I should either keep it or not believe anything instead of realizing I was wrong about him being so small?
 
Are you really not clear what this dilemma is about? If he succeeds he fails. Either way he fails. If he can do anything then he can make big rocks. If he can lift anything then he can lift big rocks. You CANNOT have it both ways. C A N N O T

Two possible answers to the rock question:

If God is bound in some way by logic, then you may as well be asking "can God do something he can't do?". The question is illogical. To quote C.S.Lewis "Can a mortal ask questions which God finds unanswerable? Quite easily, I should think. All nonsense questions are unanswerable."

If God is not bound by logic, then yes, an omnipotent God could make a stone which he couldn't lift, but we wouldn't understand such things because to us it would appear illogical.
 
Except that the dragon exists, but your god doesn't.

You can't prove that one way or the other. ;)

Then you'll be content having that dragon all to yourself as I go back to mine which you don't believe exists. If you find a dragon bigger than my non-existent god or the dragon you currently have then I'll be the first to try to learn more. :)
 
Then you'll be content having that dragon all to yourself as I go back to mine which you don't believe exists. If you find a dragon bigger than my non-existent god or the dragon you currently have then I'll be the first to try to learn more. :)

*sigh*

Is that what theology is for you? A pissing contest?
 
Two possible answers to the rock question:

If God is bound in some way by logic, then you may as well be asking "can God do something he can't do?". The question is illogical. To quote C.S.Lewis "Can a mortal ask questions which God finds unanswerable? Quite easily, I should think. All nonsense questions are unanswerable."

If God is not bound by logic, then yes, an omnipotent God could make a stone which he couldn't lift, but we wouldn't understand such things because to us it would appear illogical.

As does god... all gods. As does C.S. Lewis who declared that "pride is the worse sin of all"-- not torture, not genocide, not pedophilia, not rape, no scamming people-- but PRIDE. Was he speaking for god or pulling info. out of his ass? What sort of God thinks "pride" is the worst sin of all?

Theists can make anything make sense to themselves if it's attached to their god concept. Atheists can't make sense of any of it. The god concept fails from the get go. It never gets beyond the myth stage. And all the platitudes that you find deep and inspirational just sound vapid and childish and geared towards people who already believe.
 
Last edited:
*sigh*

Is that what theology is for you? A pissing contest?

My god is better than your god because I can define it more nebulously than yours and more powerfully... he's a super duper god and he likes me better because he made me find out about the really true god because there is something good and earnest about me-- I win. You, however, have not opened your mind enough to get the great godliness that has been infused into me. Prove me wrong. Or better yet-- wait till the afterlife when you'll be hearing me telling you, "I told you so..."

:p
 
Then you'll be content having that dragon all to yourself as I go back to mine which you don't believe exists. If you find a dragon bigger than my non-existent god or the dragon you currently have then I'll be the first to try to learn more. :)
The Pagans have a response to this. They say, "My Goddess gave birth to your God".

Obviously every relilgion believes their version of God (or gods) is correct, or else they wouldn't believe it. So when you get down to it, how do you decide which version of God is better? For the vast majority of people, they decide because that is the way they were raised. They have a preferred mythology. But if you were going to pit the beliefs against one another in a fair way, how would you do it?
 
OK, here's just one publication on one of the aspects of the God hypothesis: Study of the Therapeutic Effects of Intercessory Prayer (STEP) in cardiac bypass patients. If you're really interested in more information on the scientific investigation of the existence of God, just pick up a copy of The God Delusion.
Pardon? The God assertion says "God created the Universe, Life and all the rest. Oh - and prayers have a therapeutical effect on cardiac bypass patients"? I must have missed that last portion, I'm afraid.

Herzblut
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom