Your opinion of the man (which you are of course entitled to) has no bearing on whether a particular point he might have made is right or wrong. I'm not sure there could be a much better example of an ad hom. If I use a quote from someone as part of an argument, I would still expect to be judged on the merit of the argument, no matter who I quoted.
I agree that saying, "C.S. Lewis used that argument, therefore that argument is false," would be an ad hominem argument with a hidden premise (it is an implied premise that anything C.S. Lewis says is false).
What I was saying however was not that anything C.S. Lewis said was false, but instead that C.S. Lewis is known to have used a great number of faulty or fallacious arguments. This thread isn't really the place to get into a discussion on the details of that particular premise, but it does importantly change it from being an ad hominem argument to a valid inductive argument: Most of the arguments used by C.S. Lewis were incorrect; That argument [that you have used] was an argument used by C.S. Lewis; Therefore it is highly likely that that argument is incorrect.
Sorry for the misunderstanding.
How is accepting the use of Occam's razor, not recognising Occam's particular viewpoint on using that tool, (ie referencing him) unless you want to call it "Aristotle's rule of thumb" or something?
Firstly, because it was not a heuristic device invented by Occam. Secondly, because the device is reasonably well defined in and of itself - it doesn't matter what we call it, we just happen to call it "Occam's Razor". Thirdly, there is nothing wrong in pointing out inconsistencies in a philosophical system - in order to justify his belief in the Christian god, Occam added a section to the device stating that anything proclaimed by a valid authority (i.e. The Church, the Bible, the Pope, etc.) was to be believed. We now recognise this as a fallacious argument from authority - but that doesn't mean the entire eponymous device needs to be thrown out with the isolated fallacy.
The question is really one about the definition of "omnipotent" in regards to logic. I disagree about the question not being nonsense. Yes, humans create objects which they can't lift, but there is a limit to what they can lift. Something too heavy for a human can exist. Omnipotence assumes there is no such limit. Something too heavy for an omnipotent being cannot exist, therefore the question is really no different from asking "can an omnipotent being create A which is not A?" or "can an omnipotent being do something that logically can't be done?"
So, either omnipotence, by definition, does not include stepping outside the boundaries of logic, in which case we shouldn't expect it to with our propositions, or it can step outside of logic, in which case we can't then complain that it has become illogical and can't do that because it's logically impossible.
Ah, I see where the disagreement is here. You view the omnipotence paradox as asking, "Can god create
x, where
x =
~x?" (Correct me if I'm incorrect in that interpretation, but it seems to be what you have written.)
I don't think that is the question at all. The question to me starts out with the general case: "Can an entity create an object that limits the entity's power?" I would argue that the answer to this is yes - humans can create objects too heavy for them to lift, or anchor themselves in place with handcuffs or some rope, thus demonstrating that this is a possibility in the general case.
The case then becomes specific: "Can an omnipotent entity create an object that limits that entity's power?" We have already established that this is possible in the general case - as such, this should be well within the power of an omnipotent entity. However, if it is within the power of that entity then it means there is a theoretical limit to the power of the entity, and the entity is therefore
not omnipotent.
Because of this contradiction, the concept of an omnipotent entity is self-defeating: If you posit an omnipotent entity you must also logically be positing a limit to the power of that entity (as per above), and therefore the entity is not omnipotent. Douglas Adams would probably say that such an entity would, upon hearing of this paradox, disappear in a puff of logic, and I am more than happy to steal that Babelfish inspired line from him.
Nope, that wasn't my argument.
I see the misunderstanding now, yes. I have seen people argue the, "God laughs at your petty logic," line of non-reasoning before and I thought that was where you were headed. Of course, they tend to phrase things a bit differently.
Goodnight, Moby. Sleep well!
I will, hopefully. It's far too late again...it's always night when I get round to writing responses on the forums. Curse my different timezone!