Hi Skeptigirl,
I appreciate your ideas and posts so this isn't meant as anything towards you. But, I don't care what topic a documentary is about, if the first statement I read on the website is:
Bowling for Columbine did it to the gun culture.
Super Size Me did it to fast food.
Now The God Who Wasn't There does it to religion.
It throws up red flags. But that's just me. I'm sure that movie was interesting but hardly a neutral look into anything. That said -- I did find both Bowling for Columbine and Super Size Me as highly entertaining and a good study on filmmaking and how to edit and bend facts to make your point. Now The God Who Wasn't There sounds like it could be entertaining as well.
Red flags are fine, but they should alert you to look deeper or with an extra dose of skepticism in this case, not to dismiss all the evidence outright. Everything Michael Moore presents in his documentaries is one sided, but in no way is most of it false. And I don't know about the guy in Supersize Me's lab tests but certainly he brought attention to some unhealthy aspects of the fast food industry.
I had previously assumed there must be evidence a real non-god person Jesus existed. I figured the Old Testament wasn't too reliable as far as historical facts go, but the New Testament was developed after written language so there should have been more actual history in it. There are modern equivalents of prophets such as Joesph Smith, and there are certainly charlatans who can convince people they perform miracles, examples are everywhere. And I had heard there was some evidence of Jesus in other historical documents. So I had no reason to question the actual existence of a Jesus. I didn't even bother with the past threads asking if Jesus were a real person. (Though I may resurrect one, one of these days.)
However, the movie, "The God Who Wasn't There", laid out the evidence piece by piece against a real Jesus having existed, and provided a fair amount of evidence the concept of a Jesus was made up. While I do not claim the movie, nor the evidence
proves no real person, Jesus, existed, I am no longer convinced he was a real person. And you will notice I use "suggests" or "possibly" or similar language when referring to the subject. Regardless of the evidence for and against, none is conclusive one way or the other.
But it is a moot point. If he existed, there is still no evidence from what is written about Jesus that he was any more than a mortal man.
BTW, in regards to,
"this isn't meant as anything towards you", I'm not offended in the least by having a source challenged. For that matter, that's one of the benefits of the discussion. (See sig.)