Show me that Science proves there is no god

Shakespeare did it for Julius Ceasar.

Dante did it for hell.

Now AChristianSceptic does it for Jesus.

But see, that would be clever marketing. It would get people's interest. Hopefully they would be bright enough to not judge any further until AFTER they had checked out the product. You keep implying that you do otherwise, and that is disturbing.
 
But see, that would be clever marketing. It would get people's interest. Hopefully they would be bright enough to not judge any further until AFTER they had checked out the product. You keep implying that you do otherwise, and that is disturbing.

Unless I'm claiming a historical analysis of Jesus.

Than they should discount me based on my comparison to a drama and a poem. (Or rather a dramatist/playwright and a poet). Neither Shakespeare or Dante were historians. That's the only point. My impression is that the video makers want to be considered historians but they are comparing themselves to political filmmakers.

Just for the record - I discount Christian videos / writings the same way if they make comparisons like this. I understand people have agendas, etc. and can account for that. But I think at this point I'd consider anything from the History Channel as having more weight than that above linked video. (And that's not saying much. haha) I'll watch it though someday. It sounds interesting.
 
Last edited:
A Christian Sceptic;3256296 Would you take this seriously? - Shakespeare did it for Julius Ceasar. Dante did it for hell. Now AChristianSceptic does it for Jesus. I hope not.[/QUOTE said:
I haven't read Dante, but I do know that Shakespeare bumped off Caesar fairly early on.

Do it for Jesus by all means, but you might be a little late.
 
I haven't read Dante, but I do know that Shakespeare bumped off Caesar fairly early on.

Do it for Jesus by all means, but you might be a little late.

haha. Sorry - I only have a Minor in History so I doubt I'd be qualified. I'll let other unqualified people on both sides fight it out. :)
 
Just for the record - I discount Christian videos / writings the same way if they make comparisons like this.

Then you are discounting the content based on marketing fluff (that often isn't even written or approved by the original content creator).

"Don't judge a book by its cover" leaps to mind.
 
Then you are discounting the content based on marketing fluff (that often isn't even written or approved by the original content creator).

"Don't judge a book by its cover" leaps to mind.

Well - I always judge a book by it's cover. What else do I have to go on?

But in this case - I'll take your word that their website is mis-marketing it, that it is a historical production, and I'll keep an open mind. But the moment they place an opinion on something not based on historical evidence or mock someone (I'm once again judging the DVD by their website here - since they refer to their DVD as "often hilarious") I'll discount it all since I know no historian who wants to be taken seriously would do that. Would that be fair?
 
Last edited:
Well - I always judge a book by it's cover. What else do I have to go on?

But in this case - I'll take your word that their website is mis-marketing it, that it is a historical production, and I'll keep an open mind. But the moment they place an opinion on something not based on historical evidence or mock someone (I'm once again judging the DVD by their website here - since they refer to their DVD as "often hilarious") I'll discount it all since I know no historian who wants to be taken seriously would do that. Would that be fair?

I tend to judge books, by reading the foreword, along with peer recommendations,

as for Hilarious quotes in factual books, why do historians have to be immune to humour, it can be used constructively to convey factual info accross especially if somone is studying it, Humour can also assist in making previously serious ideals more accessible to people who may be pre-programmed to a specific idea,

If the Humour offends you, then the question you should ask yourself is whether it was the style of humour that offended, the subject matter, or the fact that someone dared made light of a specific subject.

A catholic, A protestant, and an atheist walk into a pub,
and by the exageration of a stereotypical belief about one of those factions
mirth is obtained.
 
Well - I always judge a book by it's cover. What else do I have to go on?

If you are going to actually judge it, it better by the contents. The contents are what you have to go on.

Do you mean choose rather than judge? If so, that is a pretty big gaff in meaning.
 
Last edited:
But the moment they place an opinion on something not based on historical evidence or mock someone (I'm once again judging the DVD by their website here - since they refer to their DVD as "often hilarious") I'll discount it all since I know no historian who wants to be taken seriously would do that. Would that be fair?

Depending on your threshold, you could reasonably consider a few situations as mocking. Why don't you try to judge it on its factual basis and the validity of its logical inferences. And I would encourage you to withhold judgment until after you've watched all the extras. As I've mentioned elsewhere, that is where the factual documentation is concentrated.
 
Last edited:
If you are going to actually judge it, it better by the contents. The contents are what you have to go on.

Do you mean choose rather than judge? If so, that is a pretty big gaff in meaning.

No - I mean judge - as in judge whether to even read it. I take other considerations in addition - who recommended it? Have I read something by them before? Is the writing appropriate for what I'm looking for? I'll then read it if I want. I won't judge the meaning of the book by it's cover though if I can help it. But if the cover (or the location in the bookstore) tells me it's a comedy and it's really a horror - then, well, I'll probably be pretty confused. Not that that is anything new.:confused:
 
We are then left with whether we define omnipotent as being constrained by logic or not if we wish to try to answer the question (see my earlier answer).

You don't need to throw away logic. Simply define omnipotence as the ability to do anything logically possible. For an omnipotent being, creating a rock too heavy to lift is logically impossible. Thus, the inability to do it does not remove the omnipotence.

FYI this is the textbook solution that all 200 level philosophy of religion classes arrive at.
 
You don't need to throw away logic. Simply define omnipotence as the ability to do anything logically possible. For an omnipotent being, creating a rock too heavy to lift is logically impossible. Thus, the inability to do it does not remove the omnipotence.

FYI this is the textbook solution that all 200 level philosophy of religion classes arrive at.

So would that also include the creation of the mass/energy by an act of will or word power as a limit of his omniness
 
Hi Skeptigirl,

I appreciate your ideas and posts so this isn't meant as anything towards you. But, I don't care what topic a documentary is about, if the first statement I read on the website is:

Bowling for Columbine did it to the gun culture.

Super Size Me did it to fast food.

Now The God Who Wasn't There does it to religion.


It throws up red flags. But that's just me. I'm sure that movie was interesting but hardly a neutral look into anything. That said -- I did find both Bowling for Columbine and Super Size Me as highly entertaining and a good study on filmmaking and how to edit and bend facts to make your point. Now The God Who Wasn't There sounds like it could be entertaining as well.
Red flags are fine, but they should alert you to look deeper or with an extra dose of skepticism in this case, not to dismiss all the evidence outright. Everything Michael Moore presents in his documentaries is one sided, but in no way is most of it false. And I don't know about the guy in Supersize Me's lab tests but certainly he brought attention to some unhealthy aspects of the fast food industry.

I had previously assumed there must be evidence a real non-god person Jesus existed. I figured the Old Testament wasn't too reliable as far as historical facts go, but the New Testament was developed after written language so there should have been more actual history in it. There are modern equivalents of prophets such as Joesph Smith, and there are certainly charlatans who can convince people they perform miracles, examples are everywhere. And I had heard there was some evidence of Jesus in other historical documents. So I had no reason to question the actual existence of a Jesus. I didn't even bother with the past threads asking if Jesus were a real person. (Though I may resurrect one, one of these days.)

However, the movie, "The God Who Wasn't There", laid out the evidence piece by piece against a real Jesus having existed, and provided a fair amount of evidence the concept of a Jesus was made up. While I do not claim the movie, nor the evidence proves no real person, Jesus, existed, I am no longer convinced he was a real person. And you will notice I use "suggests" or "possibly" or similar language when referring to the subject. Regardless of the evidence for and against, none is conclusive one way or the other.

But it is a moot point. If he existed, there is still no evidence from what is written about Jesus that he was any more than a mortal man.

BTW, in regards to, "this isn't meant as anything towards you", I'm not offended in the least by having a source challenged. For that matter, that's one of the benefits of the discussion. (See sig.)
 
Last edited:
It's not how it's packaged that's the issue - it's the comparison. They compare themselves to two docu-drama's that both have very questionable representations of the facts to make their political points (even if the points themselves are agreeable or true). By simply making that comparison (regardless of how worthy the third movie is) I'm not going to give it much credibility. I really don't feel like debating Bowling For Columbine or Super Size Me - but I'd hope people here would be very sceptical of those two movies too. Because if you're not than you are doing exactly what many Christians do - looking for people to reaffirm what you believe so you can feel good about what you believe (or don't believe in - however you want to look at it.)
[off topic]I just want to point out that the attacks on Moore's documentaries do not present valid evidence themselves and in fact the Right Wing put on a Talking Points blitz just like the Swift Boat attacks assuring those who don't actually look at Moore's 'facts' for themselves could come away with the assumption Moore's works are more fiction than fact. I have looked at those supposed 59 deceits one by one in Moore's 911 documentary, for example, and it appears it is the criticisms which are false, not the facts in the documentary. Yes the documentary is one sided, that's what it was supposed to be. But it was, for the most part, factual. And I might add, revisit those claims Moore was wrong now. There is a lot more evidence proving he was not wrong which has come out since the movie.[/off topic]
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom