Show me that Science proves there is no god

I actually can't think of a response to this so I'll just leave it at ... :jaw-dropp

It was a serious question. Yes, it was presented somewhat flippantly, but asked in all seriousness. Take your time.

You believe in your God because he is powerful. He is powerful because those are the attributes you have assigned to him. You are, Sir, engaging in some rather classic circular reasoning.
 
It was a serious question. Yes, it was presented somewhat flippantly, but asked in all seriousness. Take your time.

After some thought: "No"

You believe in your God because he is powerful. He is powerful because those are the attributes you have assigned to him. You are, Sir, engaging in some rather classic circular reasoning.

I don't think a god that is anything less is worth bothering about.
 
After some thought: "No"



I don't think a god that is anything less is worth bothering about.

Why did you say "No" and then expand with an answer that boils down to "Yes"?

Also: why are you not a Moslem? Allah is conceived as being much greater than the Christian God - he didn't do all that meek and mild stuff, for a start. He didn't take on human form. He isn't divisible into three.

Allah is theologically greater than your God. Why not convert?
 
Why did you say "No" and then expand with an answer that boils down to "Yes"?

No - theology is not a pissing contest.

Also: why are you not a Moslem? Allah is conceived as being much greater than the Christian God - he didn't do all that meek and mild stuff, for a start. He didn't take on human form. He isn't divisible into three.

Allah is theologically greater than your God. Why not convert?

It is? I'll look into it.
 
No - theology is not a pissing contest.
CS, I like your threads but it seems the discussions quickly become shallow, only focussing on "evidence" and why nobody should believe in anything without evidence although everybody does.

May I recommend some philosophical articles with alot more depth, and length :D. You may find some interesting aspects there:

Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Faith and Reason
http://www.iep.utm.edu/f/faith-re.htm

SEP, Religion and Science
http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/religion-science/

SEP, The Epistemology of Religion
http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/religion-epistemology/

Herzblut
 
Last edited:
Here are three more opinions:

I think Mt. Dew is better then Pepsi.

I think Dogs are better than many cats.

I think sunsets are beautiful.

Your posts are not making sense to me.

Different meaning contrasting or contradictory, not different meaning various! You said "No" when I asked you whether you thought theology was a pissing contest.

You then implied in your first post that only the most powerful God was "worth bothering about", and in your second that you're tempted by another God because He is posited as being more powerful than the one you currently subscribe to (aka the one who would win in a pissing contest).

Do I have to spell out to you why that's contradictory?
 
Last edited:
Then I'd think their Goddess is the same as my God. No problem there.
And you'd be wrong. They behave in vastly different ways (according to those who believe in them.) Most pagans, for example, don't believe in the divinity of Christ. There are some similarities of course. Christians pray. Pagans cast spells. They are virtually the same thing.
 
Pardon? The God assertion says "God created the Universe, Life and all the rest. Oh - and prayers have a therapeutical effect on cardiac bypass patients"? I must have missed that last portion, I'm afraid.

Herzblut
If by God you mean "a being who answers prayers" then, yeah, it does include the last portion. If by god you don't mean that, then what exactly do you mean by "god"?
 
And now after weighing what I believe about my god with what your telling me about your dragon I decide they aren't the same god. My god is bigger and better so I no longer need to worry about that dragon. And yes - the point you're trying to make applies to Christian doctrines too.

Not true. Your god is no more than a figment of your imagination, whereas the dragon in my shed is very, very real, and the only god in existence. There are no gods that are 'bigger and better'.

This is the exact scenario you said you would take time to investigate, regardless of what science said. So why are you unwilling to make the pilgrimage to see the one true god for yourself and gaze upon his dragonian majesty?

I'll even let you off the hook for tithing until you have seen the dragon - only once you have investigated and found the truth out for yourself (that my dragon is the one true god), will I start demanding tithes for you to worship him.
 
I'll even let you off the hook for tithing until you have seen the dragon - only once you have investigated and found the truth out for yourself (that my dragon is the one true god), will I start demanding tithes for you to worship him.

I would have demanded the tithing a bit earlier... but I'm in need of money ;)
 
Pardon? The God assertion says "God created the Universe, Life and all the rest. Oh - and prayers have a therapeutical effect on cardiac bypass patients"? I must have missed that last portion, I'm afraid.

The belief that God responds to prayers is an important part of most theist beliefs: examining this belief is thus part of the scientific examination of God's possible existence.

Maybe you'd like to explain why you consider that the question of God's existence is not examinable scientifically?
 
And now after weighing what I believe about my god with what your telling me about your dragon I decide they aren't the same god. My god is bigger and better so I no longer need to worry about that dragon. And yes - the point you're trying to make applies to Christian doctrines too.

But if you don't worship him, the dragon will breathe his fire upon us and we will... errm... ermmm.. Don't worry then.
 
This is the exact scenario you said you would take time to investigate, regardless of what science said. So why are you unwilling to make the pilgrimage to see the one true god for yourself and gaze upon his dragonian majesty?

Because, while he is unwilling to listen to what science says, he is willing to listen to what theology says. And you, as Dragon theologist of the first order, have proved to him how small Sagan's Dragon is.

Did you mention the free piggy-back rides if you're a diligent worshipper?
 
Then I'd think their Goddess is the same as my God. No problem there.


For some pagans, yes. They just take thier normative values and translate them into a wierd sort of neopaganism.

here is what makes some modern paganism different. The dual tricycles and the mythological idea that gods age, die and are reborn. Now Christ is a variation of the Dying Gods.

But it is imporatnt to remember that Innanna dies, that the daughter becomes the mother, the mother the crone and the crone dies. Some pagans like to make some sort of happy disneyland out of the mythological landscape. They ignore the dark side of reality.

The brutatlity, the indifference, the pain and hatred. Strangely they should all be part of the pagan godhead as well. Kali-Durga is kirtled with human skulls and her ear rings are unborn dead babies.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom