Show me that Science proves there is no god

Completeness. Consistency. Soundness.

Pick two.

You don't need to throw away logic. Simply define omnipotence as the ability to do anything logically possible. For an omnipotent being, creating a rock too heavy to lift is logically impossible. Thus, the inability to do it does not remove the omnipotence.

FYI this is the textbook solution that all 200 level philosophy of religion classes arrive at.

The problem is that now a finite being can create a rock he cannot lift - thus achieving something the omnipotent cannot achieve: failure.
 
And once again, if you cannot support the belief, fudge the definitions. Or in other words, if you can't answer the question, make up your own that you can answer.
 
Last edited:
Here we go again, evil right wingers bashing poor Michael Moore... Bah, this isn't the politics subforum.
 
Don't you find it interesting that nobody, out of all those hundreds of millions, has yet come up with a reasonable explanation?

Have you checked out the Trinity? That alone puts Mandelbrot to shame, and it's central to many Christians' belief. Very many. Catholic and Orthodox for starters, and those are big hitters in the numbers game.

Of course, those guys have been at this very successfully for many centuries. They've survived, whereas the Elmer Gantry revivalists and creationists with the Bible as a text-book make the mistake of defining their god - it's there in the textbook - which can then be demolished. Not to believers' satisfaction of course, but to ours :).
 
Here we go again, evil right wingers bashing poor Michael Moore... Bah, this isn't the politics subforum.
I said it was OT. But if you insist on replying, then yes, as a matter of fact, there was a concerted campaign to discredit Moore, because Moore threatens the right wing's position. It's all marketing, however, no evil needed.

My issue is people's failure to think for themselves or to actually investigate claims and counterclaims. That's why people like Kevin Trudeau are millionaires. Marketing is successful because people fall for it.
 
Last edited:
True, that's not an ad hom in that case, but that would leave you to examine everything he ever argued (or at least a significant, scattered portion) to determine how much can be objectively proven to be correct/incorrect. Assuming that such a thing was even possible to do, we could then have a basis to say that a quote picked at random is has x% chance of being incorrect. Since I chose the particular quote because I considered it to be correct and not at random, you then have another factor to account for (in fact a whole load more) before you can decide the likelihood of the argument being incorrect. If I made sure that the argument which I selected was correct, it wouldn't matter if he was only ever correct once out of a million times.

My bad - I came into this particular conversation late, and didn't realise you had been talking about a specific quote. I thought it was a discussion on Lewis in general.

I think we may have lost track of the point of why I mentioned Occam in the first place. Your last point here makes the point I was trying to get across, which is basically that of disagreeing with one point someone said (whether original or not) doesn't necessarily mean other things they said are wrong.

Then we're actually in agreement. Goodo.

I don't think your general case is relevant to the proposition because people are not omnipotent and different rules apply. Things that people cannot lift exist, but there is no such thing as something which an omnipotent entity cannot lift. That rock in itself cannot logically exist. The rock being proposed is both a rock that can be lifted by an omnipotent being (by definition of omnipotence) and a rock which cannot be lifted by an omnipotent being (as defined by the question). It is x and ~x.

I'll put it another way. The x in the "x and ~x" in this case is "omnipotent being". By proposing that an omnipotent being creates something that limits his power, we are proposing something that makes him not an omnipotent being while still being an omnipotent being. In other words, we are proposing he create something which makes him x and ~x (omnipotent and not omnipotent). The contradiction is in the question, ie the question is illogical.

We are then left with whether we define omnipotent as being constrained by logic or not if we wish to try to answer the question (see my earlier answer).

I would say that the fact that you end up in a contradiction would make the entity a nonsense entity, rather than the question being a nonsense question.
 
Completeness. Consistency. Soundness.

Pick two.



The problem is that now a finite being can create a rock he cannot lift - thus achieving something the omnipotent cannot achieve: failure.
You miss the point of the example (which was devised by theologists to illustrate one of the characteristics of omnipotence).

An omnipotent being can create an unliftable rock but can't lift it. Or he could never create an unliftable rock in which case he could lift any rock.

But he can't do both since it is logically impossible, so an omnipotent being is still able to do anything that is logically possible.
 
Considering there have already been *checks* 286 posts, I'm sure of two things:

-Someone has already said this.
-No one will pay any attention.

However, for those brave few that are paying attention: There is, by definition, no way to disprove the existence of an omnipotent being. Anyone who claims there is such a way is a moron. If you don't understand why, this topic may not be for you.

Thank you.
 
There is, by definition, no way to disprove the existence of an omnipotent being.
Generally, I agree. However, said being is often also assigned other properties besides omnipotence. There's the rub.
 
There is, by definition, no way to disprove the existence of an omnipotent being.


Unless, of course, the supposed omnipotent being decides that it wants its existence to be disproven, right?
 
Last edited:
You miss the point of the example (which was devised by theologists to illustrate one of the characteristics of omnipotence).

An omnipotent being can create an unliftable rock but can't lift it. Or he could never create an unliftable rock in which case he could lift any rock.

But he can't do both since it is logically impossible, so an omnipotent being is still able to do anything that is logically possible.

But that's not omnipotence, Robin. By definition, he MUST be able to create any rock AND lift any rock.
 
But he can't do both since it is logically impossible, so an omnipotent being is still able to do anything that is logically possible.

Both are logically possible.

Pick one. Fail the other.

Completeness fails.
 
Both are logically possible.

Pick one. Fail the other.

Completeness fails.

The typical response to the "Could God create a rock so heavy that he cannot lift it?" is "Yes, if he wanted to"

You seem to want him to be able to:
a) Create a rock so heavy that he cannot lift it
AND
b) Lift it.

This is obviously a logical impossibility.

It really comes down to how you define omnipotence. If you define it as "able to do anything logically possible", then there is no issue with the above.

If you define it as "able to do anything (including the logically impossible)", then there is no point in attempting to discuss it logically as such a being is by definition, beyond logic.
 
How are you defining omnipotence, Belz?

I define omnipotence as a logical impossibility: the ability to do anything.

The problem is, some of those "things" are mutually exclusive.

Even if we define omnipotence to mean "the ability to do anything possible", well, that raises two serious questions:

1) How is that godly or divine, since the various processes of the universe can pretty much do anything possible ?

2) How about the "rock he can't lift" paradox ? We have to pick which one of the two choices we prefer, really. Does it make more sense to say that he can create a rock he can't lift, or that he can't create it ? Ultimately, it's an arbitrary decision, so it doesn't really solve the issue.
 
2) How about the "rock he can't lift" paradox ? We have to pick which one of the two choices we prefer, really. Does it make more sense to say that he can create a rock he can't lift, or that he can't create it ? Ultimately, it's an arbitrary decision, so it doesn't really solve the issue.

Indeed. And as someone (you?) pointed out earlier, if it's the latter, it makes God less powerful than humans, because we can create objects too heavy for us to lift, which makes no sense when considering omnipotence.
 
Do you mean both are logically possible together (ie. it's logically possible to do both)?

As you will see below I mean both are logically possible on their own. It is the joining that is the problem - an irreconcilable one if you wish to be logically consistent, complete and sound.

The typical response to the "Could God create a rock so heavy that he cannot lift it?" is "Yes, if he wanted to"

You seem to want him to be able to:
a) Create a rock so heavy that he cannot lift it
AND
b) Lift it.

This is obviously a logical impossibility.

This is not about what I want - this is about the consequences of how you define these things.

It really comes down to how you define omnipotence. If you define it as "able to do anything logically possible", then there is no issue with the above.

If omnipotence is defined as, "the ability to do anything logically possible," and the problem area is, "you cannot create an entity which defies your ability to manipulate it," then either:

1) You are omnipotent if you can create any entity
2) You are omnipotent if you can manipulate any entity

And then you can retain, "the ability to do anything logically possible," but you can't do both for all cases - and the choice of which one you drop is arbitrary.

Hence you are incomplete in your omnipotence either way you slice it - we could have a god that can create rocks too heavy to move and another god who can't create them but can move the - but they cannot be the same god and be a consistent god.

If you define it as "able to do anything (including the logically impossible)", then there is no point in attempting to discuss it logically as such a being is by definition, beyond logic.

Or simply inconsistent - yesterday he could create a rock heavier than he could lift, today he can lift that rock.
 
Last edited:
I never found the who 'rock so heavy he couldn't lift it" question to be very difficult. If god created the earth and put it in place circling the sun, obviously there isn't going to be any rock on earth god couldn't lift. If we go outside the earth, then 'weight' is variable and the word 'lift' becomes meaningless. Did god create black holes? Could god lift a black hole? What would it mean to 'lift' a black hole?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom