cyborg
deus ex machina
- Joined
- Aug 12, 2005
- Messages
- 4,981
Completeness. Consistency. Soundness.
Pick two.
The problem is that now a finite being can create a rock he cannot lift - thus achieving something the omnipotent cannot achieve: failure.
Pick two.
You don't need to throw away logic. Simply define omnipotence as the ability to do anything logically possible. For an omnipotent being, creating a rock too heavy to lift is logically impossible. Thus, the inability to do it does not remove the omnipotence.
FYI this is the textbook solution that all 200 level philosophy of religion classes arrive at.
The problem is that now a finite being can create a rock he cannot lift - thus achieving something the omnipotent cannot achieve: failure.