Sean Hannity makes the case for NSA under Bush...

Oh dear, I thought the OP was posting something, anything, that had to do with "USA Politics."
Sean Hannity is a political commentator. He is also a demagogue.

  1. A political leader who seeks support by appealing to popular desires and prejudices rather than by using rational argument.
 
I'd just let it go. You've made your point clear and continuing this is, as I think we all know, unproductive.
Agreed. I've got a chip on my shoulder this morning. Thanks. I'm putting 16.5 back on ignore.

ETA: If anyone thinks he (16.5) has made a substantive argument just quote it and I'll respond. If it's more of the same silly rhetoric and claims then I'll ignore it.
 
Last edited:
This is not an attempt to establish a definite proposition (logically valid argument). It's just rhetoric. Do you have something substantive or is being snarky and attacking me the only play you have? Sport?

Yes, RandFan, i just pointed out that you did not attempt to establish a definite proposition (logically valid argument). Hell. it is not even rhetoric.

So you think that Hannity's argument is sound, but you think that he's a hypocrite.

OK, gotcha. Of course, whether or not he's "hypocritical" is totally irrelevant to his argument regarding the Obama administration.

Solid thread, I just said that. Whatcha want to talk about now? I'm guessing sports, right?

/oh wait, he just made a big show about putting me on ignore. Classy.
 
Last edited:
BTW: I actually agree with Hannity's current position about the NSA. I accept his argument that as American citizens we should worry about domestic spying. So, the thread has nothing to do with the man's position or his argument.

Sean Hannity is a political commentator. He is also a demagogue.

  1. A political leader who seeks support by appealing to popular desires and prejudices rather than by using rational argument.

Can a brother get a laughing dog?
 
Originally Posted by eeyore1954
I don't recall people being aware of such widespread collection of information.
Are you intentionally ignoring the links that demonstrate that other people were aware?

No (although I did not read all of the links) but are any of those links more than speculation or someone says there is such a program.

When this was released it was treated as a shocking revelation by a broad spectrum of the media. The collection of broad data had been denied by top authorities in testimony.
 
Originally Posted by eeyore1954
I don't recall people being aware of such widespread collection of information.

No (although I did not read all of the links) but are any of those links more than speculation or someone says there is such a program.

When this was released it was treated as a shocking revelation by a broad spectrum of the media. The collection of broad data had been denied by top authorities in testimony.
I don't believe this is true for one momemnt. Hell, there have been movies made (Enemy of the State). I don't think anyone who has watched the news (60 minutes report) or is at all cognizant of the controversy over the NSA has a single ounce of shock. I honestly don't. I remember listening to Rush Limbaugh during the Clinton administration urging people to use certain words in our emails or no cell phones to **** with the NSA.

So I honestly don't know if your bias made you ignore what was well known or if you are just now in denial. At any point others have provided significant evidence of what was known a long time ago by other whistle blowers. You have only argued by assertion. That's fine. You are entitled to an opinion but it's in the face of a mountain of evidence to the contrary.

BTW: It's no more speculative now than it was then. Whistle blowers making accusations. Snowden is no more credible than any of the other whistle blowers. You just happen to agree with this one this time because it supports a preconceived belief.

One last thing, that the media is interested in a story doesn't validate the story or invalidate claims made during the Bush administration. That's a fallacious line of argument. It fits your preconceived bias so you offer it ad hoc. I utterly dismiss it. If the fallacious nature of the argument isn't enough for you then let me say that it is NOT my perception of the facts. So, if you are trying to be compelling I think you are failing. Do you have something substantive? Something more than "he said, he said" or, hey, the media is suddenly interested in shark attacks or Jodi Arias as if media interest has any importance whatsoever.
 
Suddenly, white people care about privacy incursions

Salon said:
There appears to be a discrepancy in our anger and protest against such measures. For years now, and well before the discovery of these leaked documents, we have been complacently living with the public knowledge of certain truths. Rights to privacy have been systematically and openly violated for years, without much fuss. The rule of law has been suspended indefinitely, in places like Guantánamo Bay, for example, with barely a peep. Lack of transparency? We’ve gotten used to it in certain cases, it seems. Severe violations of these and other rights targeted against innocent people have become so normalized, that we now discuss them simply in terms of efficiency, stripped of any considerations for legal protections.

...

In spite of this sensitivity, let me outline the case: The issue of excessive surveillance is not new – the only new aspect here is that it now encompasses a larger population; specifically, white America. It needs to therefore be asked as to whether this is the real reason for all the spontaneous outrage of late.
 
I don't believe this is true for one momemnt. Hell, there have been movies made (Enemy of the State). I don't think anyone who has watched the news (60 minutes report) or is at all cognizant of the controversy over the NSA has a single ounce of shock. I honestly don't. I remember listening to Rush Limbaugh during the Clinton administration urging people to use certain words in our emails or no cell phones to **** with the NSA.

So I honestly don't know if your bias made you ignore what was well known or if you are just now in denial. At any point others have provided significant evidence of what was known a long time ago by other whistle blowers. You have only argued by assertion. That's fine. You are entitled to an opinion but it's in the face of a mountain of evidence to the contrary.

BTW: It's no more speculative now than it was then. Whistle blowers making accusations. Snowden is no more credible than any of the other whistle blowers. You just happen to agree with this one this time because it supports a preconceived belief.

One last thing, that the media is interested in a story doesn't validate the story or invalidate claims made during the Bush administration. That's a fallacious line of argument. It fits your preconceived bias so you offer it ad hoc. I utterly dismiss it. If the fallacious nature of the argument isn't enough for you then let me say that it is NOT my perception of the facts. So, if you are trying to be compelling I think you are failing. Do you have something substantive? Something more than "he said, he said" or, hey, the media is suddenly interested in shark attacks or Jodi Arias as if media interest has any importance whatsoever.

Huh, RandFan was QUITE insistent a few hours ago that this is all about Sean Hannity. My, my, my, things have changed.

eeyore, ask RandFan about the Congressional Investigation, although you'll probably get an accusation of bias, a false dichotomy, a bunch of straw men, and a dismissive claim of being fallacious in response.
 
Thank you Ray. Of course nothing in your post is at all inconsistent with my post.

Ok, you lost me.

You seemed to be saying that you believe that things at NSA have expanded considerably under Obama, yet evidence shows that things at NSA expanded considerably right after 9/11.

How is my assertion consistent with yours?

RayG
 
Ok, you lost me.

You seemed to be saying that you believe that things at NSA have expanded considerably under Obama, yet evidence shows that things at NSA expanded considerably right after 9/11.

How is my assertion consistent with yours?

RayG

A simple hypothetical example to elucidate:

Before 9/11, they were monitoring 1 billion calls a year, after it doubled to 2 billion, and then when Obama took over they doubled that to 4 billion a year.
 
I don't recall people being aware of such widespread collection of information.

It's certainly been no secret. (pun fully intended)

No (although I did not read all of the links) but are any of those links more than speculation or someone says there is such a program.
Yes, unless you consider Senate Select Committee investigations/studies mere speculation.

Before 9/11, they were monitoring 1 billion calls a year, after it doubled to 2 billion, and then when Obama took over they doubled that to 4 billion a year.

What evidence do you have of this?

RayG
 
Last edited:
A simple hypothetical example to elucidate:

Before 9/11, they were monitoring 1 billion calls a year, after it doubled to 2 billion, and then when Obama took over they doubled that to 4 billion a year.


Sometimes it seems like a lot of people are just saying the same thing over and over again. Are these redundant transmissions re-monitored?

I suppose in the course of saying the same thing over and over and over somebody might, what, sneeze or something, making that particular monitored transmission non-identical to the others.
 
Hypotheticals aren't evidence. They're sort of the opposite of evidence.
I have him on ignore but I don't understand the point. If it doubled under Obama does that prove anything other than it doubled under Obama (hypothetical or not)?

Correlation does not prove causation. Is there a point being made?
 
I have him on ignore but I don't understand the point. If it doubled under Obama does that prove anything other than it doubled under Obama (hypothetical or not)?

Correlation does not prove causation. Is there a point being made?

Attention! rand fan has me on ignore! Attention!

/but he still felt compelled to post about how he is baffled by the discussion. Lolz
 
Uh, they are typically used to elucidate topics and issues.

Particularly when they are SPECIFICALLY IDENTIFIED AS SUCH!

They aren't, however, evidence. RayG asked for evidence, you just present a hypothetical. Evidence generally involved citations that support your position.

And you didn't identify them as anything, you just presented a hypothetical.
 
I have him on ignore but I don't understand the point. If it doubled under Obama does that prove anything other than it doubled under Obama (hypothetical or not)?

Correlation does not prove causation. Is there a point being made?

He didn't even provide evidence that it does that, he just said that it happened in a hypothetical situation. I mean, it's not too hard, if evidence exists he should just present that instead of trying to confuse the issue.
 
He didn't even provide evidence that it does that, he just said that it happened in a hypothetical situation. I mean, it's not too hard, if evidence exists he should just present that instead of trying to confuse the issue.
Agreed but it doesn't even work as a "what if?" I don't mind hypotheticals to advance the discussion but this doesn't even do that. Even if we grant the premises for argument sake it wouldn't change anything. We are right back where we started from. What is the point he is trying to make? It looks like desperation to me.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom