Sean Hannity makes the case for NSA under Bush...

For those who can't watch the video this is basically what was said.

994774_551885164853672_1566905938_n.jpg
 
What we knew about the NSA surveillance years ago was it was only international calls from war zones that were monitored. Now it's every call, international and domestic.

I didn't have issues with the former, I do with the latter. And I don't think I'm being hypocritical.
 
What we knew about the NSA surveillance years ago was it was only international calls from war zones that were monitored. Now it's every call, international and domestic.
What we knew about NSA surveillance years ago is just about the same as now, namely, damn little. Unless you have a top secret clearance.

I didn't have issues with the former, I do with the latter. And I don't think I'm being hypocritical.
Under your assumption, I would agree. Under more realistic assumptions, I wouldn't.
 
[citation missing]
The link is dead, but Lurker quoted from the story here: "That year, following the Sept. 11 attacks, President Bush authorized the NSA to monitor the international phone calls and international e-mails of hundreds — perhaps thousands — of people inside the United States, the Times reported."


[citation missing]
:confused:

Do you not know the subject of your own thread? It's been discussed here in at least 3 threads.

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887324904004578539790648199194.html
 
What we knew about NSA surveillance years ago is just about the same as now, namely, damn little. Unless you have a top secret clearance.
Please cite a source dating from the Bush era where it was revealed the NSA was collecting the metadata for every phone call made in the USA.
 
Gee the jref lib horde suffering from a combined case of the Bushies and Fox News derangement syndrome?

Of course this thread was posted by Captain tu Quoque, one should expect nothing less.
 
Gee the jref lib horde suffering from a combined case of the Bushies and Fox News derangement syndrome?

Of course this thread was posted by Captain tu Quoque, one should expect nothing less.

So, no argument then?
 
So, no argument then?

Great point! An appeal to hypocrisy involving a reporter is almost by definition "no argument." In fact, it is worse, it is an intentional attempt to divert attention from the real issue, namely the on going revelations regarding the NSA.

Tu quoque fallacies are fallacies for a reason, folks.
 
Great point! An appeal to hypocrisy involving a reporter is almost by definition "no argument." In fact, it is worse, it is an intentional attempt to divert attention from the real issue, namely the on going revelations regarding the NSA.

Tu quoque fallacies are fallacies for a reason, folks.

Well that might be a valid criticism had this been in the thread on the NSA tapping itself. As it isn't being used as an argument for the NSA program, it can't be considered a tu quoque.

The argument in this thread is that Sean Hannity is a partisan talking head hack. This argument is supported by his hypocrisy with regards to the NSA. It isn't an 'appeal to hypocrisy' either, because his hypocrisy isn't being used as a defense for the NSA program, again that being discussed in another thread.
 
Well that might be a valid criticism had this been in the thread on the NSA tapping itself. As it isn't being used as an argument for the NSA program, it can't be considered a tu quoque.

The argument in this thread is that Sean Hannity is a partisan talking head hack. This argument is supported by his hypocrisy with regards to the NSA. It isn't an 'appeal to hypocrisy' either, because his hypocrisy isn't being used as a defense for the NSA program, again that being discussed in another thread.

What an odd concept. It is a classic tu quoque ad hominem attack. It is an appeal to hypocrisy, hell it is right in your post.

It is suggested that his criticism of the present program is not valid because he took an inconsistent position when bush was president.

It is of course not a direct defense of the act, because it is simply a fallacious attack on a critic, which is very much why it is a fallacy in the first place!
 
The link is dead, but Lurker quoted from the story here: "That year, following the Sept. 11 attacks, President Bush authorized the NSA to monitor the international phone calls and international e-mails of hundreds — perhaps thousands — of people inside the United States, the Times reported."
This is a skeptics site. There is nothing wrong with asking for a citation. And that doesn't come close to proving your case.

:confused: Look, either cite your source or don't. Question marks aren't sources.

[/quote]I've no idea what the hell this is. Next time you might want to provide a pull quote and a little less attitude. You've yet to provide a source for your claims and I'm guessing all I'm going to get are dead links, right?
 
Please cite a source dating from the Bush era where it was revealed the NSA was collecting the metadata for every phone call made in the USA.
He didn't make that claim. He said we knew damn little then and we know damn little now.

Look, it's simple WC, it's YOUR claim that has not been sourced.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom