Sean Hannity makes the case for NSA under Bush...

Are you capable enough with the English language to understand that it is not "insulting" Hannity or "attacking" Hannity to call him a hypocrite if you are also supplying evidence of that hypocrisy?
Rather than an "insult" or an "attack" such a thing is termed a "fact".
As to your ridiculous attack on RandFan, there are threads aplenty regarding the NSA wiretaps and RandFan has taken part in many if not all of them. This thread is NOT about the NSA wiretaps but about Hannity's hypocrisy regarding them. Therefore it is not a "dodge", an "evasion", or a "distraction".
Apparently your problems with English go far deeper than incorrect fallacy naming.

Tu quoque or the appeal to hypocrisy, is a logical fallacy that attempts to discredit the opponent's position by asserting the opponent's failure to act consistently in accordance with that position; it attempts to show that a criticism or objection applies equally to the person making it. This dismisses someone's point of view based on criticism of the person's inconsistency, and not the position presented, whereas a person's inconsistency should not discredit their position. Thus, it is a form of the ad hominem argument. To clarify, although the person being attacked might indeed be acting inconsistently or hypocritically, this does not invalidate his argument.

Any problems with English in that quote, friend?
 
Are you capable enough with the English language to understand that it is not "insulting" Hannity or "attacking" Hannity to call him a hypocrite if you are also supplying evidence of that hypocrisy?

Utter nonsense. Insults and attacks can be completely true. It's insulting to call a person ugly, even if they are. It's an attack on a person to call them a hypocrite, even if they are. Providing evidence doesn't change that. There's nothing axiomatically wrong with insults or attacks, but it's strange indeed to claim that the truth cannot be either.
 
Say, sport? If you look at the op, there is no "argument." It is just some baffling tu quoque, at best, but I've since learned that it is not a tu quo que at all because it is simply a pointless attack against a tv talking head.

This isn't a tu quoque just because you say so. The argument is not that Obama is alright, or that the NSA tactics are alright because Hannity is a hypocrite. Even if it were that would be an ad hom, not a tu quoque. A tu quoque would be dismissing someone else hypocrisy on this subject because of Hannity's.

If you've 'learned' it isn't one because it's against a tv talking head, then you've not read or understood what others have written here.

What is the argument here? That hannity is a douchebag? Agreed!

Who cares?

Yes, that is the basically the argument. A better way of putting it would be that Sean Hannity is such a partisan or insincere opportunist that the utility of his commentary on politics is basically worthless. The argument is that people shouldn't care what he says. But people do. Thus a thread about his latest value free punditry.

Just another example of distraction against the flaws in the Obama administration.

Typical randfan thread, distract, dodge, evade.

There are other threads about the NSA, but your objection here seems to be that people aren't attacking Obama and only Obama over this. I'm with Ray G on this one, it isn't just a Bush thing, it isn't just an Obama thing. This is a general failure of government because of a basic failure of the people back when we were terrified. Let's take the chance to correct this mistake. But all that is very close to off topic for this thread. Sorry that this thread isn't about what you want it to be about. Actually, I'm not. You can start a thread about Obama being bad on this subject, so there is nothing stopping you from having an argument on the subject you want to.
 
Yes, that is the basically the argument. A better way of putting it would be that Sean Hannity is such a partisan or insincere opportunist that the utility of his commentary on politics is basically worthless. The argument is that people shouldn't care what he says. But people do. Thus a thread about his latest value free punditry.

.

That is easily the finest example of why this thread is fallacious that I can imagine.

Thank you.
 
First one to say, "I was wrong before." wins.

So neither will win. We all lose.

They won't admit to past mistakes, but it would be amusing when one slipped up and started with the Bush era version of their argument and the other followed.
 
Yes, that is the basically the argument. A better way of putting it would be that Sean Hannity is such a partisan or insincere opportunist that the utility of his commentary on politics is basically worthless. The argument is that people shouldn't care what he says. But people do. Thus a thread about his latest value free punditry.
I could not have put it better myself. I've not tried to discredit his arguments or provide cover for Obama. Wrong is wrong. But there is no evidence that I know of that Hannity is anything but an opportunist. I can predict what his position on most controversies will be depending solely on who is in the white house. Many liberals have condemned Obama for failing to close Guantanamo, keeping alive the Patriot Act, supporting faith based initiatives, keeping Holder and other cronies from banking and Wall Street, drone strikes, etc., etc..

If Obama was the basis for the NSA spying I would think it appropriate to have hearings and for people to speak out against that. This isn't about Obama. It's about a man with no moral center. A man who only cares about political expediency. A demagogue.

Those who disagree with me can scream ad hominem and tu quoque until they are blue in the face but that's just a red herring. If and when I try to justify Obama's actions based on the actions of Bush then you can give me that nonsense.

Until then, Hannity is simply a dishonest fraud playing on the ignorance and prejudices of people simply to advance his ideology. IMO the man is morally inconsistent. And there is nothing fallacious about that.
 
Last edited:
Tu quoque or the appeal to hypocrisy, is a logical fallacy that attempts to discredit the opponent's position by asserting the opponent's failure to act consistently in accordance with that position; it attempts to show that a criticism or objection applies equally to the person making it. This dismisses someone's point of view based on criticism of the person's inconsistency, and not the position presented, whereas a person's inconsistency should not discredit their position. Thus, it is a form of the ad hominem argument. To clarify, although the person being attacked might indeed be acting inconsistently or hypocritically, this does not invalidate his argument.

Any problems with English in that quote, friend?

Nope. I guess you can copy and paste just fine. But then again, copy/pasting from Wikipedia doesn't mean you can comprehend it either.
 
Nope. I guess you can copy and paste just fine. But then again, copy/pasting from Wikipedia doesn't mean you can comprehend it either.

Yawn. Gainsaying is not an argument.

And neither are your school yard personal attacks.

Lets take a look at your substantive claim:

"Are you capable enough with the English language to understand that it is not "insulting" Hannity or "attacking" Hannity to call him a hypocrite if you are also supplying evidence of that hypocrisy?"

So it is not a fallacious appeal to hypocrisy if he really is a hypocrite?

Fantastic. I guess Wiki had that wrong.

Go back to the personal attacks, that you are good at.
 
BTW: I actually agree with Hannity's current position about the NSA. I accept his argument that as American citizens we should worry about domestic spying. So, the thread has nothing to do with the man's position or his argument. The thread is about a demagogue and a political opportunist. A man who will change his views at the drop of a hat.

If I were to find out that Obama was directly responsible for spying on American citizens then I would think the American people should know that. But let's not pretend that this all just started. See the 60 minutes report. See the post by RayG. People have been trying to wake up the American people to the problems inherent in the NSA. This is nothing new. Thanks for joining us.

But do us all a favor, if you supported the NSA in the past can you admit that you were wrong to do so? Even if you were ignorant to the truth. Even if you didn't want to hear it because of your bias so you ignored the news stories.

All I ask is that you be morally consistent. Intellectually honest and find out the truth. Whatever it is and stick to that. Sources have been made available on this thread. If you want me to re-post those links I will do that. But the accusation of ad hominem and tu quoque are transparent red herrings.
 
Yawn. Gainsaying is not an argument.

And neither are your school yard personal attacks.

Lets take a look at your substantive claim:

"Are you capable enough with the English language to understand that it is not "insulting" Hannity or "attacking" Hannity to call him a hypocrite if you are also supplying evidence of that hypocrisy?"

So it is not a fallacious appeal to hypocrisy if he really is a hypocrite?[?B]

Fantastic. I guess Wiki had that wrong.

Go back to the personal attacks, that you are good at.


There was no personal attack. Your response was exactly what it says on the Wiki page for tu quoque.
As to the bolded part, I am honestly unsure if English is your first language which is why I asked how capable you are with it.
Fallacious means false.
So, NO it is certainly NOT a fallacious appeal to hypocrisy if he really is a hypocrite. How can it be false to claim he is a hypocrite if he really is one?
 
There was no personal attack. Your response was exactly what it says on the Wiki page for tu quoque.
As to the bolded part, I am honestly unsure if English is your first language which is why I asked how capable you are with it.
Fallacious means false.
So, NO it is certainly NOT a fallacious appeal to hypocrisy if he really is a hypocrite. How can it be false to claim he is a hypocrite if he really is one?
If one follows that chain of logic then the word "hypocrite" is logically fallacious on its face. We could never point out hypocrisy because to do so would be automatically fallacious. But of course that's simply fatuous. I've explained over and over the real meaning of the hypocrisy fallacy. It's to attempt to justify behavior based on the wrong doing of other people.

The Hypocrisy Fallacy: If You Don’t Do What’s Right, I Don’t Have To Either!

See, here is the point, it's my position that we should do what's right REGARDLESS of what other people do or say. We should care about domestic spying irrespective of who is in the White House. I think Obama has been morally inconsistent and I've made that clear many times. One doesn't get a free pass on hypocrisy simply because the charge can be used in a fallacious manner.

So, I'll ask this question of those who claim my thread is fallacious, if the NSA did under Bush exactly what they are doing now, were they wrong then?
 
Last edited:
There was no personal attack. Your response was exactly what it says on the Wiki page for tu quoque.
As to the bolded part, I am honestly unsure if English is your first language which is why I asked how capable you are with it.
Fallacious means false.
So, NO it is certainly NOT a fallacious appeal to hypocrisy if he really is a hypocrite. How can it be false to claim he is a hypocrite if he really is one?

Well that certainly explains a lot. It is clear that you do not understand the fallacy that we have been discussing nor even something so basic as what a logical fallacy is in the first place.
 
So, I'll ask this question of those who claim my thread is fallacious, if the NSA did under Bush exactly what they are doing now, were they wrong then?

"If the NSA did under bush exactly..." So now we are debating whether the NSA is doing exactly the same thing, blah blah blah.

That is why appeals to hypocrisy are so insidious, because it is not only an ad hominem, it also is irrelevant and designed to deflect discussion from the true issue.

So today we know that he whistle blower said that the program had expanded considerably under Obama. So your if/then hypothetical just got blown up.
 
Last edited:
A demagogue.

Quite possibly the very definition of one.
If we follow the logic of 16.5 we couldn't accuse anyone of anything pejorative because that would be simply attacking the arguer and not the argument. You could never judge anyone in a negative light. Hypocrite. Demagogue. These are real words that describe real character flaws. To conclude that one is a demagogue or hypocrite is to simply point out the facts of one's behavior. Now, if I then argue that Hannity's arguments are wrong because he is a hypocrite or a demagogue then THAT'S fallacious. If I try to justify my own behavior or the wrong behavior of others AKA "two wrongs make a right" then that's fallacious.

So yes, the very definition of a demagogue. He's playing to people's passions and fear of government at a politically opportune time.
 
If we follow the logic of 16.5 we couldn't accuse anyone of anything pejorative because that would be simply attacking the arguer and not the argument. You could never judge anyone in a negative light. Hypocrite. Demagogue. These are real words that describe real character flaws. To conclude that one is a demagogue or hypocrite is to simply point out the facts of one's behavior. Now, if I then argue that Hannity's arguments are wrong because he is a hypocrite or a demagogue then THAT'S fallacious. If I try to justify my own behavior or the wrong behavior of others AKA "two wrongs make a right" then that's fallacious.

So yes, the very definition of a demagogue. He's playing to people's passions and fear of government at a politically opportune time.

The amazing thing is that you just said he was correct.

Unbelievable.

By the way, two wrongs make a right fallacy and tu quoque fallacy are two different fallacies.
 
Last edited:
The amazing thing is that you just said he was correct.

Unbelievable.

Why? If he held two opposing positions on the same topic you're more likely to agree with one of them than the other.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom