Sean Hannity makes the case for NSA under Bush...

They aren't, however, evidence. RayG asked for evidence, you just present a hypothetical. Evidence generally involved citations that support your position.

And you didn't identify them as anything, you just presented a hypothetical.

Christ. I had earlier posted that the whistleblower said yesterday that the surveillance had increased dramatically under Obama. He could not understand how it had increased when it had increased after 9/11.

You know, when you stick your nose in, you could go back and make sure you read the thread.
 
Agreed but it doesn't even work as a "what if?" I don't mind hypotheticals to advance the discussion but this doesn't even do that. Even if we grant the premises for argument sake it wouldn't change anything. We are right back where we started from. What is the point he is trying to make? It looks like desperation to me.

Bwhahahahaha!!!!
 
Christ. I had earlier posted that the whistleblower said yesterday that the surveillance had increased dramatically under Obama. He could not understand how it had increased when it had increased after 9/11.

You know, when you stick your nose in, you could go back and make sure you read the thread.

And yet when asked for evidence, such as your original link, you reply with your hypothetical. It leaves a lot to desire in any sort of, you know, rational conversation.
 
Agreed but it doesn't even work as a "what if?" I don't mind hypotheticals to advance the discussion but this doesn't even do that. Even if we grant the premises for argument sake it wouldn't change anything. We are right back where we started from. What is the point he is trying to make? It looks like desperation to me.

Basically just special pleading to defend his partisan blinders.

I really should have taken my own advice, but answering "my hypothetical" in a request for evidence was just too tempting.
 
Uh, correlation doesn't equal causation. Hello? Anyone home? Jesus Christ, I'm willing to entertain hypotheticals but if your hypothetical is confusing correlation with causation then you've got a problem.

Let's assume 16.5's premise for arguments sake. So the **** what?

Correlation does not imply causation - RationalWiki

This is a skeptics site. Does that really need to be pointed out? Look, I'm happy to entertain a hypothetical. But the hypothetical should not itself be a fallacy.
 
Basically just special pleading to defend his partisan blinders.

I really should have taken my own advice, but answering "my hypothetical" in a request for evidence was just too tempting.
Agreed. It's a very pathetic attempt to save face. It's an epic fail. No evidence for the hypothetical and irrelevant in any case.

If and when 16.5 has evidence that the Obama administration participated in racheting up the monitoring of calls I'll be willing to listen.

Would someone, anyone, let me know when 16.5 has more than speculation and fallacious hypotheticals?

Oh, and if 16.5 finally figures out that correlation does not equal causation I'd like to hear that also.
 
The hypothetical?

And yet when asked for evidence, such as your original link, you reply with your hypothetical. It leaves a lot to desire in any sort of, you know, rational conversation.

Face palm. I really don't understand you people.

You want evidence to support the hypothetical? That doesn't make sense, now does it?

You want evidence to support the fact that Snowden said yesterday that the surveillance expanded under Obama which is what kicked this entire discussion off?

DONE!

http://www.cnn.com/2013/06/17/politics/nsa-leaks/index.html

Thanks for sticking your nose in to show "special pleading."
 
A series of blog posts on Monday purportedly by Edward Snowden said he leaked classified details about U.S. surveillance programs because President Barack Obama worsened "abusive" practices instead of curtailing them as he promised as a candidate.
 
Anyways, back on topic, Hannity is a sore excuse for a news person but behavior like this is pretty much to be expected from him.
 
For arguments sake:

Assuming spying increased under Obama, what proof is there that had anything to do with Obama? Once you've answered that question you still need proof that surveillance increased under Obama.
 
Anyways, back on topic, Hannity is a sore excuse for a news person but behavior like this is pretty much to be expected from him.
I was once a Hannity fan. I've not seen anything to demonstrate an ounce of objectivity on his part. Nothing. Nada. Zip.
 
Here's an idea

Let's rely on speculation and correlation to establish a proposition.

**** skepticism and critical thinking.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom