Sean Hannity makes the case for NSA under Bush...

Why? If he held two opposing positions on the same topic you're more likely to agree with one of them than the other.
:D Yes, given the dichotomy it's highly likely I would think Hannity correct at one point. Is that really so difficult for people to understand? I'm not attacking Hannity for his position. I'm attacking him for his moral inconsistency. I'm claiming that he is 1.) A demagogue and 2.) a hypocrite.

  1. That Hannity is correct about the NSA doesn't mean that he isn't playing to people's fears for political purposes or that he even cares about the NSA. I suspect he doesn't care beyond the rhetorical advantage.
  2. I've said on at least one occasion that if Hannity had addressed his past position and admitted that people had been warning us of the NSA since long before his current position I WOULDN'T CALL HIM A HYPOCRITE. I believe that people should be able to change their minds about things. Even if it is politics that gets them to recognize the problem. It's hypocrisy to pretend that you never held a different position.
 
So today we know that he whistle blower said that the program had expanded considerably under Obama. So your if/then hypothetical just got blown up.

The NSA has been doing what it does long before Snowden or Obama arrived on the scene.

There is ample evidence that the NSA massively expanded its programs right after 9/11. I suggest you download and read The Shadow Factory.

There is further (and quite public) evidence that the NSA has been engaged in domestic surveillance going back to at least the mid 70's.

RayG
 
The NSA has been doing what it does long before Snowden or Obama arrived on the scene.

There is ample evidence that the NSA massively expanded its programs right after 9/11. I suggest you download and read The Shadow Factory.

There is further (and quite public) evidence that the NSA has been engaged in domestic surveillance going back to at least the mid 70's.

RayG
I've said many times I'm unhappy with things Obama has done. If there is evidence of wrong doing on the current administration I want the American people to know it. That changes nothing as it relates to Hannity. I'm willing to concede that Obama has made mistakes. To excuse Hannity for the wrongs of Obama would be the very definition of the hypocrisy fallacy.

I'm sorry but Hannity's behavior must stand or fall on its own. There is no magic get out of hypocrisy card here.
 
Well that certainly explains a lot. It is clear that you do not understand the fallacy that we have been discussing nor even something so basic as what a logical fallacy is in the first place.
Be careful with all that digging you don't wear yourself out.
 
The NSA has been doing what it does long before Snowden or Obama arrived on the scene.

There is ample evidence that the NSA massively expanded its programs right after 9/11. I suggest you download and read The Shadow Factory.

There is further (and quite public) evidence that the NSA has been engaged in domestic surveillance going back to at least the mid 70's.

RayG

Thank you Ray. Of course nothing in your post is at all inconsistent with my post.
 
Be careful with all that digging you don't wear yourself out.
He won't address my arguments. He is just gainsaying. By his logic the very use of the word "hypocricy" is always fallacious to use. And instead of addressing my argument he attacks me personally. Ad hominem.

Irony abounds. It's strong with this one.
 
16.5, is it or is it not always fallacious to use the word hypocrisy to describe the behavior of another?

The way you have been using fallacy, The Hypocrisy fallacy, is an error in logic. To discount one's arguments based on their behavior is a fallacy.

I HAVE NOT DONE THAT.

You have your fingers in your ears and you are humming loudly. I've explained over and over why your use of the word fallacy is wrong. I've given you the definitions. I've told you about two wrongs don't make a right. A fallacy of hypocrisy occurs when you try to dismiss another persons argument because they are being inconsistent or if you try to justify behavior based on another person's behavior.

I've done neither of those and all you can do is accuse me of fallacy. That's ad hominem poisoning the well. You are attacking me and not my arguments.

It's pretty glaring to anyone who reads this thread that you refuse to engage me and instead rhetorically gain say and argue by assertion.

Look in the mirror my friend.
 
I was hopeful that we would have seen a more thoughtful discussion of the nature of the fallacious reasoning herein. In any event, here is a helpful primer that also discusses what i have been saying all along:

Even if all of the accusations are true, they have nothing to do with the question, and thus are irrelevant.
It's MY op. I'm the one who decide what the question is. The question I've asked is whether or not Hannity is a hypocrite. I've not tried to justify behavior based o Hannity. I've not tried to attack his argument based on Hannity.

The point is Hannity. The premise is this: Hannity is a hypocrite.

Is that premise fallacious on it's face? You won't answer questions. I'll answer any question you have but you won't answer mine. Why?

The Hypocrisy Fallacy: If You Don’t Do What’s Right, I Don’t Have To Either!
 
"If the NSA did under bush exactly..." So now we are debating whether the NSA is doing exactly the same thing, blah blah blah.

That is why appeals to hypocrisy are so insidious, because it is not only an ad hominem, it also is irrelevant and designed to deflect discussion from the true issue.

So today we know that he whistle blower said that the program had expanded considerably under Obama. So your if/then hypothetical just got blown up.

16.5, is it or is it not always fallacious to use the word hypocrisy to describe the behavior of another?

The way you have been using fallacy, The Hypocrisy fallacy, is an error in logic. To discount one's arguments based on their behavior is a fallacy.

I HAVE NOT DONE THAT.

You have your fingers in your ears and you are humming loudly. I've explained over and over why your use of the word fallacy is wrong. I've given you the definitions. I've told you about two wrongs don't make a right. A fallacy of hypocrisy occurs when you try to dismiss another persons argument because they are being inconsistent or if you try to justify behavior based on another person's behavior.

I've done neither of those and all you can do is accuse me of fallacy. That's ad hominem poisoning the well. You are attacking me and not my arguments.

It's pretty glaring to anyone who reads this thread that you refuse to engage me and instead rhetorically gain say and argue by assertion.

Look in the mirror my friend.

Looks in the mirror, bumps my earlier post.

protip: you are not the only person posting in this thread.
 
This thread is about Hannity not Obama.

"If the NSA did under bush exactly..." So now we are debating whether the NSA is doing exactly the same thing, blah blah blah.

That is why appeals to hypocrisy are so insidious, because it is not only an ad hominem, it also is irrelevant and designed to deflect discussion from the true issue.

So today we know that he whistle blower said that the program had expanded considerably under Obama. So your if/then hypothetical just got blown up.
I started the thread. I get to decide what the true issue is. The "true issues" is this, Premise: Hannity is a hypocrite. That's it "sport".

So, your post is simply an ad hominem attack on me. You are poisoning the well and moving the goal posts. You don't want to discuss the OP so you are throwing out red herrings to change the subject to something else you want to discuss. Obama is OT in this thread. Attacking me personally is a breach of the forum rules.

Can you address the premise of the thread? Sean Hannity is a hypocrite?

Now you can either agree that it's always fallacious to use the word hypocrite when describing the behavior of another or you can take the position that it's not fallacious to point out when another person is being a hypocrite (or something else but you will need to explain what that something is).

This thread is about Hannity not Obama. I know you would like to change the subject. I get the desire to but you didn't start the thread. Why don't you start a thread to discuss Obama? This thread isn't about him or prism or the NSA or the CIA or anything else. Hannity. The question stands, is Hannity a hypocrite?

So, please to focus on the premise of the OP or go to another thread, "sport".

This thread is about Hannity not Obama.

The Hypocrisy Fallacy: If You Don’t Do What’s Right, I Don’t Have To Either!
 
Last edited:
I was hopeful that we would have seen a more thoughtful discussion of the nature of the fallacious reasoning herein. In any event, here is a helpful primer that also discusses what i have been saying all along:

Even if all of the accusations are true, they have nothing to do with the question, and thus are irrelevant.
Discussing fallacious reasoning is OT. but I've explained over and over why you are wrong. Dead wrong. It would be fallacious to claim two wrongs make a right. I've not done that. It would be fallacious to claim that Hannity's hipocracy is reason to dismiss his position or argument. I've not done that.

The premise of the OP is: Sean Hannity is a hypocrite.

Now, that premise is either fallacious on it's face or it is not. Here's a hint, it's not fallacious on its face to call another a hypocrite.
 
Looks in the mirror, bumps my earlier post.

protip: you are not the only person posting in this thread.
This is not an argument.

An argument is a series of statements (premises) intended to establish a definite proposition.

Pro Tip: Stay on topic (hint, the topic is Sean Hannity and not me). Don't attack me personally or try to change the subject. Which you are doing. The OP is to demonstrate that Hannity is a hypocrite. Is it fallacious on its face to use the word hypocrite to describe the behavior of another? Why won't you answer that question? You can't because it's not and that would leave you without any rhetorical ammunition.
 
I was hopeful that we would have seen a more thoughtful discussion of the nature of the fallacious reasoning herein. In any event, here is a helpful primer that also discusses what i have been saying all along:

Even if all of the accusations are true, they have nothing to do with the question, and thus are irrelevant.
Your fatal error is to presume the OP isn't the question. That's fallacious on it's face. The OP IS the question. Is Sean Hannity a hypocrite? Yes or no?

YOUR LINK said:
Tu Quoque is a very common fallacy in which one attempts to defend oneself or another from criticism by turning the critique back against the accuser. This is a classic Red Herring since whether the accuser is guilty of the same, or a similar, wrong is irrelevant to the truth of the original charge. However, as a diversionary tactic, Tu Quoque can be very effective, since the accuser is put on the defensive, and frequently feels compelled to defend against the accusation.
That's EXACTLY what you are doing. You are trying to turn the critisicm back on me. That's fallacious. The premise of this thread is this: Sean Hannity is a hypocrite.

  • I'm not trying to defend myself against Hannity (hint: this isn't about me).
  • I'm not trying to defend the CIA against Hannity (hint: this isn't about the CIA).
  • I'm not trying to defend Obama against Hannity (hint: this isn't about Obama).
Anyone reading this thread needs to ask one question, what is "the premise of the OP?"

Once you figure that out you will realize that you are doing precisely what you accuse me of doing. You are attacking me personally which has nothing what so ever to do with the question at hand, is Hannity a hypocrite?
 
Last edited:
The subject of the thread is Hannity.

Your Link said:
Tu Quoque is a very common fallacy in which one attempts to defend oneself or another from criticism by turning the critique back against the accuser. This is a classic Red Herring since whether the accuser is guilty of the same, or a similar, wrong is irrelevant to the truth of the original charge. However, as a diversionary tactic, Tu Quoque can be very effective, since the accuser is put on the defensive, and frequently feels compelled to defend against the accusation.
I accuse Hannity of hypocrisy. You want to put me on the defensive and change the subject of the thread.

The premise of the thread is: Sean Hannity is a hypocrite. Now, that is either true or it is not. If true it doesn't make anything that Obama has done the right thing. Nothing Hannity has said or done can excuse any wrong doing on the part of Obama.
 
Oh dear, I thought the OP was posting something, anything, that had to do with "USA Politics."

Instead it is just and only silly name calling.

I had not realized that.

So on the Graham's hierarchy, we are at the bottom rung?

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/7c/Graham's_Hierarchy_of_Disagreement.svg

Oh dear... say, RandFan, do you think Hannity is an "asshat" too?

Solid thread, RandFan. Solid.
This is not an attempt to establish a definite proposition (logically valid argument). It's just rhetoric. Do you have something substantive or is being snarky and attacking me the only play you have? Sport?
 
This is not an attempt to establish a definite proposition (logically valid argument). It's just rhetoric. Do you have something substantive or is being snarky and attacking me the only play you have? Sport?

I'd just let it go. You've made your point clear and continuing this is, as I think we all know, unproductive.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom