Sean Hannity makes the case for NSA under Bush...

I don't believe this is true for one momemnt. Hell, there have been movies made (Enemy of the State). I don't think anyone who has watched the news (60 minutes report) or is at all cognizant of the controversy over the NSA has a single ounce of shock. I honestly don't. I remember listening to Rush Limbaugh during the Clinton administration urging people to use certain words in our emails or no cell phones to **** with the NSA.

So I honestly don't know if your bias made you ignore what was well known or if you are just now in denial. At any point others have provided significant evidence of what was known a long time ago by other whistle blowers. You have only argued by assertion. That's fine. You are entitled to an opinion but it's in the face of a mountain of evidence to the contrary.

BTW: It's no more speculative now than it was then. Whistle blowers making accusations. Snowden is no more credible than any of the other whistle blowers. You just happen to agree with this one this time because it supports a preconceived belief.

One last thing, that the media is interested in a story doesn't validate the story or invalidate claims made during the Bush administration. That's a fallacious line of argument. It fits your preconceived bias so you offer it ad hoc. I utterly dismiss it. If the fallacious nature of the argument isn't enough for you then let me say that it is NOT my perception of the facts. So, if you are trying to be compelling I think you are failing. Do you have something substantive? Something more than "he said, he said" or, hey, the media is suddenly interested in shark attacks or Jodi Arias as if media interest has any importance whatsoever.
Well if there was movie made or if Rush said it about President Clinton that is proof.
 
Well if there was movie made or if Rush said it about President Clinton that is proof.
And your evidence? I'm not trying to convince you of anything. You are the one making a case based on personal observation. I countered with mine.

Do you have something substantive?
 
And your evidence? I'm not trying to convince you of anything. You are the one making a case based on personal observation. I countered with mine.

Do you have something substantive?

I have seen nothing substantive that there was ever any real knowledge of this type of program to anywhere the extent that has been admitted now. I have seen speculation articles. There were denials in front of a senate committee.


Before disclosures, Bush and Obama administrations long denied widespread NSA data trawling
http://articles.washingtonpost.com/...03_1_government-surveillance-u-s-citizens-nsa
 

I have no problem understanding how NSA stepped up surveillance following 9/11. That evidence is out there for public consumption, and I have provided links to some of that evidence.

Where do you see evidence that programs have increased considerably under Obama?

Snowden is basically repeating the accusations a number of others have already brought forward (Mark Klein, for example). It's hardly anything new. 'Metadata' isn't a new term. Bamford mentions how NSA uses Narus equipment to record digital communication data as 'metadata' in the book he published back in 2008 (page 191). He also gives extensive information about Booz Allen, and other subcontractor companies.

Here's an interview Bamford did on C-SPAN a number of years ago:

http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/281780-1#

None of what he's saying is news to those that have been paying attention.

Why do you consider it so revealing now, when this information has been available to the public for years?

I have seen nothing substantive that there was ever any real knowledge of this type of program to anywhere the extent that has been admitted now.

Just because ~you~ are uninformed about this type of information, doesn't mean everyone else is. Sounds like you have a lot of reading to catch up on.

RayG
 
I have no problem understanding how NSA stepped up surveillance following 9/11. That evidence is out there for public consumption, and I have provided links to some of that evidence.

Where do you see evidence that programs have increased considerably under Obama?

Snowden is basically repeating the accusations a number of others have already brought forward (Mark Klein, for example). It's hardly anything new. 'Metadata' isn't a new term. Bamford mentions how NSA uses Narus equipment to record digital communication data as 'metadata' in the book he published back in 2008 (page 191). He also gives extensive information about Booz Allen, and other subcontractor companies.

Here's an interview Bamford did on C-SPAN a number of years ago:

http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/281780-1#

None of what he's saying is news to those that have been paying attention.

Why do you consider it so revealing now, when this information has been available to the public for years?



Just because ~you~ are uninformed about this type of information, doesn't mean everyone else is. Sounds like you have a lot of reading to catch up on.

RayG

Wow, that is one hell of a lot of words to say that the surveillance increased under Obama.

I guess you already knew that the surveillance increased under Obama.

I'm not sure why you were asking that I show that the surveillance increased under Obama, when you already knew that the surveillance increased under Obama.

I'll admit, I was uniformed that the surveillance increased under Obama. Why didn't you tell us the the surveillance increased under Obama, it would have saved a ton of posts regarding the fact that the surveillance increased under Obama.

Thanks for confirming that the surveillance increased under Obama.

So dumb! I should have know that the surveillance increased under Obama!

/the funny thing is that your link was from 2008. Huh.
 
Last edited:
Simply providing some evidence would suffice for me. Chant away if you wish, but it won't make old news more interesting.

Just curious, but do you know what that thing is in my avatar?

RayG
 
Simply providing some evidence would suffice for me. Chant away if you wish, but it won't make old news more interesting.

Just curious, but do you know what that thing is in my avatar?

RayG

Just go ahead and read the link I posted tonight in this very thread, about this very subject.

I'm guessing the thing in your avatar is some sort of time machine where someone went back in time and sat for an interview in October of 2008 and talked about how Barack Obama would increase the NSA surveillance?
 
Face palm. I really don't understand you people.

You want evidence to support the hypothetical? That doesn't make sense, now does it?

You want evidence to support the fact that Snowden said yesterday that the surveillance expanded under Obama which is what kicked this entire discussion off?

DONE!

http://www.cnn.com/2013/06/17/politics/nsa-leaks/index.html

Thanks for sticking your nose in to show "special pleading."

Oh cripes, no wonder you didn't see it! It was a whole other page.

I linked it here.

Maybe you'll read it unlike the last guy, huh?
 
Are there nominations for 'Most Ironically Appropriate Avatar'?
 
I have seen nothing substantive that there was ever any real knowledge of this type of program to anywhere the extent that has been admitted now. I have seen speculation articles. There were denials in front of a senate committee.
A man hears what he wants to hear. There is a hell of a lot of evidence that you are waving your hands out and sticking your fingers in your ears over. Hell, there was even a 60 minutes story. but I guess it's hear no evil see no evil, right? You hear what you want to hear.

Before disclosures, Bush and Obama administrations long denied widespread NSA data trawling
Bush said there was WMD in Iraq, do you really trust either? Seriously? I sure as hell don't. The more you respond the more it looks like confirmation bias.
 
Just go ahead and read the link I posted tonight in this very thread, about this very subject.

Ah yes, the link to a story wherein Snowden claims security programs were expanded, but his evidence is nothing more than regurgitated information some of us have known about for years.

I'm guessing the thing in your avatar is some sort of time machine where someone went back in time and sat for an interview in October of 2008 and talked about how Barack Obama would increase the NSA surveillance?
Yeah, didn't think you did. Your lack of knowledge doesn't make your argument stronger.

RayG
 
Ah yes, the link to a story wherein Snowden claims security programs were expanded, but his evidence is nothing more than regurgitated information some of us have known about for years.

Yeah, didn't think you did. Your lack of knowledge doesn't make your argument stronger.

RayG

Snowden's evidence is based on stuff you've known for years? You've known for years that Obama increased the surveillance? Wow! That is amazing!

You know what doesn't make an argument stronger? When we are talking about what the Obama administration has done, and you post a book published in 2008.

/I do like the smug suggestion that putting a picture of an old cipher machine makes you an expert or something, though! Lolz
 
Last edited:
Still no evidence. And 16.5, do you agree that the NSA was a bad idea? Yes or no? Do you have evidence that Obama expanded the program? Yes or no?

Oh, I forgot, you don't answer questions. My bad. You are only here to make accusations and refuse to support them, right?

In other words, you are not good for much when it comes to a discussion as you have zero evidence. You are just making empty accusations. IOW: Worthless.

If someone other than 16.5 has any evidence it would be appreciated, and productive. As it is we just have 16.5 engaging in speculation and unfounded claims.
 
Is there anyone that can demonstrate that the IRS or CIA or FBI or any organization was operating under the direct orders of Obama? Yes? No? Speculation?

Thought so.
 
Snowden's evidence is based on stuff you've known for years? You've known for years that Obama increased the surveillance? Wow! That is amazing!

You know what doesn't make an argument stronger? When we are talking about what the Obama administration has done, and you post a book published in 2008.

Apparently, for political reasons it seems, you have decided to willfully remain ignorant of the history readily available concerning the NSA.

Carry on with your ignorance.

ETA: Ref the avatar.... just wondered if you were equally ignorant about that as you are about the NSA.

RayG
 
Last edited:
Apparently, for political reasons it seems, you have decided to willfully remain ignorant of the history readily available concerning the NSA.

Carry on with your ignorance.

RayG
Any evidence for your claims 16.5 or are you without shame? You attack the Obama administration with zero evidence against a mountain of evidence that the CIA and IRS acted autonomously and were doing under Obama what they were basically doing under Bush.

Feel free to attack Obama but realize that if you fail to condemn Bush for the same acts you are a hypocrite of the highest order. After that it's fair game for people to dismiss you for dishonesty. The facts are not in dispute. Your special pleading is not in dispute.

What is becoming quite clear is your partisan ship and special pleading. You attack Obama without any evidence while ignoring the evidence for the Bush admin's failure.

Thank you. :)
 
A man hears what he wants to hear. There is a hell of a lot of evidence that you are waving your hands out and sticking your fingers in your ears over. Hell, there was even a 60 minutes story. but I guess it's hear no evil see no evil, right? You hear what you want to hear.

Bush said there was WMD in Iraq, do you really trust either? Seriously? I sure as hell don't. The more you respond the more it looks like confirmation bias.

The 60 minutes show according to the link I saw here was just another claim.

What do you think my confirmation bias is? My whole point here is that based upon what was known as fact before Obama was elected and what is known now someone could have agreed with the NSA program and now be against it without being hypocritical.
 
16.5 said:
Typical randfan thread, distract, dodge, evade.
Why do you do this personal crap?
Why is it 16.5 that I answer your questions and you distract, dodge and evade mine?

Project much?

I'm happy to stand toe to toe with you responding to your questions. I'm certain, given your dishonest history, you are not ready to stand toe to toe with me answering my questions.

Prove me wrong. Take me up on my challenge. I'll debate you and respond to your questions. I predict you will not be able to respond to mine because your position is pure and utter BS.

So, how about it? Care to respond mano a mano and see who is in fact willing to respond to questions and who is scared to respond to questions?

Let me know.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom