Sean Hannity makes the case for NSA under Bush...

BTW: It's no more speculative now than it was then. Whistle blowers making accusations. Snowden is no more credible than any of the other whistle blowers. You just happen to agree with this one this time because it supports a preconceived belief.
I did not agree with Snowden because it matched any preconceived notion. The only reason I give any credence to his claims is because the main points have been verified.
I like the way you presume to know why I think something.
 
The 60 minutes show according to the link I saw here was just another claim.
Well, that was pretty dismissive. What do you have that is substantive?

What do you think my confirmation bias is?
That's simple, you disagree with my premise but it is a premise that is easily demonstrative. That doesn't fit with your bias so you dismiss it. Never mind it's documented. We know when 60 minutes released there report. The thing is that you feel you have safety in ad hominem. That you can attack all of the news stories as just more claims. I find that intellectually dishonest and a blatant attempt at cherry picking.

My whole point here is that based upon what was known as fact before Obama was elected and what is known now someone could have agreed with the NSA program and now be against it without being hypocritical.
The ACLU has been consistently against the NSA for very compelling arguments. Many liberals including TYT, Rachel Maddow, Sam Seder and others have consistently railed against the patriot act and the NSA.

Tell me of a conservative organization that was opposed to the NSA during the Bush admin? See, that's the problem, the left has been pretty consisten against the NSA. Idiots like Hannity have refused to listen to them. Now that the shoe is on the other foot suddenly they see the light.

Forgive me if I find them idiotic hypocrites or useful idiots. I thin useful idiot is the best I could give them. The Bush admin thought they cold pull a fast one and they relied on useful idiots like Hannity and O'Reilly and Limbaugh to carry their water. Never mind Orwell and the many liberals who were screaming in their faces to wake up and they refused.

Now that you have finally woken up are you willing to objectively look at the facts of the NSA or is your bias to strong and you are forced, by your ego, to engage in special pleading in order to defend Bush, Cheney, et al?
 
Apparently, for political reasons it seems, you have decided to willfully remain ignorant of the history readily available concerning the NSA.

Carry on with your ignorance.

ETA: Ref the avatar.... just wondered if you were equally ignorant about that as you are about the NSA.

RayG

The part I liked best was when you said that Snowden's evidence, including his release of top secret orders confirming the extent of the surveillance was old information you've known for years. That is amazing!

And his claim that Obama expanded the surveillance program?

Old news! That is fantastic!

Ya see, ray knew about the fact that Obama increased the scope of the surveillance program, old news.

That is easily the best argument I have ever seen in support of the claim that Obama increased the scope of the surveillance program. It isn't that he did not do that, it is that ray knew about it for years!

Fantastic!
 
I like the way you presume to know why I think something.
eeyore, I like you, I really do, but this really isn't a controversy. We have evidence, facts, that the NSA has been spying on Americans for decades. Nothing has changed. The NSA might have increased it's activities but that has absolutely nothing to do with Bush, Clinton or Obama.

Stop trying, like the rest of the GOP, to tie this to Obama. There is just too much evidence to play that game. I promise you that in the end you will lose. The NSA has been spying on Americans for decades. They have been wiping their ass with the Constitution for decades. Republicans only give a damn because now they have been drawn into the cross hairs.

Being a Republican doesn't make you special. It's just as wrong to spy on Democrats as it is Republicans. At the end of the day you only have special pleading.

Make up your mind, is spying on American people a good thing or a bad thing? If you say bad thing then I'm afraid, sans special pleading, it's a CIA thing that long predates Obama.

How about a little intellectual honesty and a little less confirmation bias?
 
Well, that was pretty dismissive. What do you have that is substantive?

That's simple, you disagree with my premise but it is a premise that is easily demonstrative. That doesn't fit with your bias so you dismiss it. Never mind it's documented. We know when 60 minutes released there report. The thing is that you feel you have safety in ad hominem. That you can attack all of the news stories as just more claims. I find that intellectually dishonest and a blatant attempt at cherry picking.

The ACLU has been consistently against the NSA for very compelling arguments. Many liberals including TYT, Rachel Maddow, Sam Seder and others have consistently railed against the patriot act and the NSA.

Tell me of a conservative organization that was opposed to the NSA during the Bush admin? See, that's the problem, the left has been pretty consisten against the NSA. Idiots like Hannity have refused to listen to them. Now that the shoe is on the other foot suddenly they see the light.

Forgive me if I find them idiotic hypocrites or useful idiots. I thin useful idiot is the best I could give them. The Bush admin thought they cold pull a fast one and they relied on useful idiots like Hannity and O'Reilly and Limbaugh to carry their water. Never mind Orwell and the many liberals who were screaming in their faces to wake up and they refused.

Now that you have finally woken up are you willing to objectively look at the facts of the NSA or is your bias to strong and you are forced, by your ego, to engage in special pleading in order to defend Bush, Cheney, et al?

Can you point out to me where the claims in the 60 minute piece were more than someone claiming something.

Show me where I was defending Bush and Cheney collection of data.
 
"PRISM" SURVEILLANCE PROGRAM

The Washington Post said the surveillance program involving firms including Microsoft, Skype and YouTube, code-named PRISM and established under Republican President George W. Bush in 2007, had seen "exponential growth" under the Democratic Obama administration.

I learned today that this was old news. Huh, go figure
 
Can you point out to me where the claims in the 60 minute piece were more than someone claiming something.
Can you show me where Snowden or anyone else is doing more than claiming something? I've already made this point and shouldn't have to make it again. Snowden is no more credible than past whistle blowers. So tell me why I should pay attention to Snowden and not the past whistle blowers? I'm guessing it has something to do with special pleading, am I right?

Prove me wrong?
 
I don't think you answered what you think my bias is.
Your bias is clear, you are in favor of Bush et al and against Obama.

I think that is easily established. You don't care that the NSA was wiping their ass with the constitution. But as soon as the CIA does it under Obama suddenly you care.

I find that morally inconsistent and intellectually dishonest to say the least.
 
But I'm sure you'll take all the people attacking me to task, right? Hello?

Hello yourself. Yes, if I see that sort of personalization I will. In the back-and-forth of spirited argument it's easy to get frustrated and fall into making personal digs. It's so pervasive on the Internet that some people may not realize they're doing it. It invites responses in kind and as a result substantive conversation suffers as posters become more focused on each other than on the topic.

ETA: Scrolling through the beginning of this thread, my perception is that you started the personal digs with the "Captain Tu Quoque" remark. Maybe you meant it as a term of endearment. I don't like it when others respond kind, either. It's not why I come here.
 
Last edited:
Can you show me where Snowden or anyone else is doing more than claiming something? I've already made this point and shouldn't have to make it again. Snowden is no more credible than past whistle blowers. So tell me why I should pay attention to Snowden and not the past whistle blowers? I'm guessing it has something to do with special pleading, am I right?

Prove me wrong?

Haven't members of congress and i believe the President verified the mass collection of data after the court order was released?

Up until now the administrations have always denied it.
 
Hi: Just checking in on to get the latest views on Hannity's hypocrisy. But maybe I was mistaken and that discussion is in some other thread. I'll look some more, but I could've sworn it was right here.
 
Your bias is clear, you are in favor of Bush et al and against Obama.

I think that is easily established. You don't care that the NSA was wiping their ass with the constitution. But as soon as the CIA does it under Obama suddenly you care.

I find that morally inconsistent and intellectually dishonest to say the least.

Where have I implied it was ok under President Bush but not under President Obama? It certainly is not my position.

I have said I was not really in favor of the program under president Bush.
I have not said I felt it was terrible under president Obama.
 
eeyore, I like you, I really do, but this really isn't a controversy. We have evidence, facts, that the NSA has been spying on Americans for decades. Nothing has changed. The NSA might have increased it's activities but that has absolutely nothing to do with Bush, Clinton or Obama.

Stop trying, like the rest of the GOP, to tie this to Obama. There is just too much evidence to play that game. I promise you that in the end you will lose. The NSA has been spying on Americans for decades. They have been wiping their ass with the Constitution for decades. Republicans only give a damn because now they have been drawn into the cross hairs.

Being a Republican doesn't make you special. It's just as wrong to spy on Democrats as it is Republicans. At the end of the day you only have special pleading.

Make up your mind, is spying on American people a good thing or a bad thing? If you say bad thing then I'm afraid, sans special pleading, it's a CIA thing that long predates Obama.

How about a little intellectual honesty and a little less confirmation bias?
I have to assume you have not been reading this thread and you have been ascribing beliefs and opinions to me that you have found between the lines or in posts from others.

Is there a tool for me to read all the posts someone has made in a thread?
 
Last edited:
Is there a tool for me to read all the posts someone has made in a thread?
Yes, in the bar at the top of the thread on the right site is a pull down menu for "Search This Thread". In that, there is a link for "Advanced Search". Click on that and there is an option to search posts in this thread from a specific user.
 
Hi: Just checking in on to get the latest views on Hannity's hypocrisy. But maybe I was mistaken and that discussion is in some other thread. I'll look some more, but I could've sworn it was right here.


No post can be a demonstration of Hannity's hypocrisy, although no doubt there are posts which discuss or negate this possibility, and still others whose structure might correspond to Hannity's hypocrisy.
 
Haven't members of congress and i believe the President verified the mass collection of data after the court order was released?

Up until now the administrations have always denied it.

Where have I implied it was ok under President Bush but not under President Obama? It certainly is not my position.

I have said I was not really in favor of the program under president Bush.
I have not said I felt it was terrible under president Obama.

I have to assume you have not been reading this thread and you have been ascribing beliefs and opinions to me that you have found between the lines or in posts from others.

Is there a tool for me to read all the posts someone has made in a thread?
I apologize for any false assumptions. I've no idea what your point in this thread is. The NSA has been spying on Americans for a long time and many, many people have been trying to get the American people to wake up and see it. Now suddenly everyone is concerned and Hannity is losing his mind that this is even happening when he spent years berating those who were trying to get him to open his eyes.

Do you have a point?
 
I apologize for any false assumptions. I've no idea what your point in this thread is. The NSA has been spying on Americans for a long time and many, many people have been trying to get the American people to wake up and see it. Now suddenly everyone is concerned and Hannity is losing his mind that this is even happening when he spent years berating those who were trying to get him to open his eyes.

Do you have a point?

Do you? Maybe Hannity is losing his mind because the surveillance program involving firms including Microsoft, Skype and YouTube, code-named PRISM and had seen "exponential growth" under the Democratic Obama administration.
 
I think this thread has gone a bit off the rails. If the question (and I don't want to put words in RandFan's mouth) is "Is Sean Hannity a dishonest, bloviating hypocrite?", then put me down for a "yes."

If folks are interested in discussing what laws got passed when, and how those laws contributed to the increase in intelligence-gathering activities - which I suggest is a more trenchant way of addressing whose "fault" this mess is - I have started another thread in this same forum for that purpose.
 
No post can be a demonstration of Hannity's hypocrisy, although no doubt there are posts which discuss or negate this possibility, and still others whose structure might correspond to Hannity's hypocrisy.
I tend to avoid absolutes. At best we can make probabilistic statements about people's motives and beliefs. I'm willing to say it's possible that Hannity is not a hypocrite but I think that unlikely. If he isn't a hypocrite then he is a lazy and incompetent. Of course, if the Daily Show can uncover the truth then so can Hannity. And by now he has heard about his controversy. He can address it anytime he likes or, he can hypocritically ignore it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom